The fight for Inishmore [Concluded]

[Seamus Fermanagh]

Maired, we may have to take this outside.....

pever, you have a lyrical prose style. taka's demise was oddly "genteel."

[F.C is the bees knees]

>:( i wanted seamus to die. :(
i just got £230 for my birthday

[pevergreen]

Maired, we may have to take this outside.....

pever, you have a lyrical prose style. taka's demise was oddly "genteel."

Since it came up, I do not write the kills. I only edit them slightly to take into account other roles.

the first one was changed quite a bit, but the second just had a minor change at the end.

[Beefy187]

Sif they kill taka... His such a nice bloke

[Andres]

Vote : F.C is the bees knees

[Yoyoma1910]

Donney decided to leave Mcdoogals right then and there, and make sure he got patched up. Brendan just looked around sadly, and decided to leave his card anyway, but now it said Two Blind Mice.

Sounds like A Very Supper Market was the IRA mafia boss.

It would make sense as well, from the early write ups.

[Reenk Roink]

Just 2 fyi's:

1) I made an example of taka (also thought he was a bad guy)
2) Will be lurking this round to avoid suspicion

[Jolt]

Just 2 fyi's:

1) I made an example of Jolt (also thought he was a bad guy)
2) Will be lurking this round to avoid suspicion

One question. Why did you think I was a bad guy? Any reason?

[GeneralHankerchief]

Vote: Ares

[Greyblades]

This is the first game I have played in which I've been able to vote 3 days in a row...

[Yoyoma1910]

This is the first game I have played in which I've been able to vote 3 days in a row...

Is that a good sign or a bad sign... hmm...

[A Very Super Market]

I was not! Quite obviously, I was the serial killer, since the write-up clearly mentions me as leading a

"Splinter group off of the IRA"

Also, no one has sent me a PM yet, and Maireed and Oswald were clearly active last night.

[Greyblades]

Is that a good sign or a bad sign... hmm...

Meh its not that bad... I was lynched on one, But! I was only blocked from voting for half of the other... pity it was closed due to ares being late posting writeups... yeah maybe it is a bad sign.

[LittleGrizzly]

Vote ATPGood

Needs to catch up in posting with his similarly named .orger!

[F.C is the bees knees]

Vote andres

[ULC]

Vote:Seamus

[Askthepizzaguy]

Sounds like A Very Supper Market was the IRA mafia boss. It would make sense as well, from the early write ups.

Well it does sound like there are only two of them, but if Super Market was an IRA mafia boss, that would have made him their Godfather. From the first post on the thread:

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

However, due to the inspiration this game comes from, as well as the epic games of Silver Rusher and Seamus, this game also uses the Godfather mechanic. If the "Godfather" is lynched or killed that "mafia family" will cease to exist, the remaining players, if any, attempt to flee the island and drown.

Therefore AVSM could not have been their Godfather.

vote: Alexander the Pretty Good

He's been doing such an excellent job blending in, I forgot he was even playing. Needs to talk more, I agree with LG.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Just 2 fyi's:

1) I made an example of taka (also thought he was a bad guy)
2) Will be lurking this round to avoid suspicion

Ok you first said you made an example of Jolt, but then you quickly changed it to Taka. You're admitting or insinuating you have a role, and that role is to murder people. WHY did you murder Taka? If Taka was telling the truth to me yesterday, then I believe we are all royally boned.

He wanted me to help him find someone called Davey I believe (deleted all my PMs, but I saved them as text) and said that if he could not find Davey, and he died, some kind of massive serial killer would run loose. I knew it had to either be a deception (in which case, he'd be confirmed as mafia) or the truth (in which case, we needed to protect him) and in either case, we had time to determine which was which.

If you killed Taka, Reenk, please explain why. From the writeup it looks like he's confirmed innocent because he had no name from the play, something that according to the host, all protowns and mafia have. Now I suppose it is a moot point who Davey is. Of course Taka could have been lying to me, but I still felt it warranted tossing him a bone for one measly round so I could either help him out and/or interrogate him a little more before he died.

If you killed Taka, you're admitting that you're Oswald, who killed Padraic. And Oswald, apparently from the FIRST murder writeup, is from one of the two mafia families.

From the N1 murder writeup:

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Padraic left his house with the intention of going to the pub. After walking for two or three minutes along the lane, he was tempted, by the pleasantness of the evening, to go into the park. The weather was not often fine enough to allow for a walk in the park, and Padriac was pleased with the opportunity. The grounds of the park were tolerably extensive; and, like every other park of some degree of importance, it had its open shrubbery, and closer wood walk; a road of smooth gravel, winding round a plantation, led to the front; the lawn was dotted over with timber; the path itself was under the guardianship of the fir, the mountain-ash, and the acacia, and a thick screen of them altogether, interspersed with tall poplars, shut out the noise of the street.

As he walked, he passed and was pleasantly greeted by the village postman, and pitied him for the neglect of abilities which education might have rendered so respectable; for he saw, with tenderness of feeling, the thorough want of delicacy, of rectitude, and integrity of mind, which his attentions, his assiduities, his flatteries in passing betrayed; and he realized he could have no lasting satisfaction in the company of a person who joined insincerity with ignorance; and whose want of instruction prevented their meeting in conversation on terms of equality.

With such thoughts occupying his mind, AVSM was oblivious to Oswald walking behind him.

Having heard the shot, the postman came on the run, only to find AVSM in his death throes, gasping desperately as black blood from the gash in his midsection spilled out onto the path. Within minutes he was dead.

unvote: Alexander the Pretty Good
vote: Reenk Roink

Explain why you aren't the top lynch candidate this round for admitting to two murders. Or do you have a type of confessor role that admits to crimes you did not cause? If you do not get lynched this round, you should be investigated.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

I'd pegged Seamus as mafia (his posting was off to me and he's a logical choice for grunt) and was planning on making my case on him. Any powers come with your role Seamus?

Vote:Seamus

"Donney" can hardly be guilty.

>:( i wanted seamus to die. :(

Too bad you missed him last night?

Vote:FC is the bees knees

I think the defense of "lol I don't what I'm doing" is scummy in a "if I was mafia I would be worried about your accusation but since I typed lol I'm obviously not and therefore innocent" way. WE says he acts different than he does at twc as well. Some of the other things he says (like quoted above) seem to fit a "but I wouldn't say this if I was mafia!" pattern. On the whole it reminds me of a playstyle I've seen mafia use before.

To add to the FC case:

Vote: taka for abstaining aka chickening out and his name is the only one i can remember

Clearly bogus reason. I believe this is his only post of day one.

Vote Taka because i feel like it plus i'm good at guessing.

i.e. no reason

unvote taka
vote ATPG
because you are sticking up for taka

bad reason

Vote LittleGrizzly Because he dosen't like lynching.

Night vote.

eh? what is fos plus i forgot it was night, how i am supposed to analysis when there is nothing to analysis, i can't analysis how people normaly play because i don't know no one . Plus i like trying to be funny. white_eyes your get gonna get lynched >:( unvote:littlegrizzly
Actually i am going to kill both of you
lol you make it sound like i know what i am doing.

Threatens to kill seamus and white_eyes.

No i won't...

When avsm asks oswald and mairead to pm him.


Then today he says he is sorry that seamus didn't die.

I have to retract my previous reason for voting him...this seems to genuinely be mafia I style play. I actually believe he is mairead, tried to kill seamus like he threatened to, refused to send avsm his pm and is sorry seamus didn't die. He genuinely doesn't seem to care much about the game or remaining hidden.

If this isn't true then he's at best no good as a townie.

[F.C is the bees knees]

I'd pegged Seamus as mafia (his posting was off to me and he's a logical choice for grunt) and was planning on making my case on him. Any powers come with your role Seamus?



"Donney" can hardly be guilty.



Too bad you missed him last night?

Vote:FC is the bees knees

I think the defense of "lol I don't what I'm doing" is scummy in a "if I was mafia I would be worried about your accusation but since I typed lol I'm obviously not and therefore innocent" way. WE says he acts different than he does at twc as well. Some of the other things he says (like quoted above) seem to fit a "but I wouldn't say this if I was mafia!" pattern. On the whole it reminds me of a playstyle I've seen mafia use before.

what chance does that give me?
White_eyes doesn't know how i play he has only played one game with me and started moaning on day 1 because people was voting him.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

Ok you first said you made an example of Jolt, but then you quickly changed it to Taka. You're admitting or insinuating you have a role, and that role is to murder people. WHY did you murder Taka? If Taka was telling the truth to me yesterday, then I believe we are all royally boned.

He wanted me to help him find someone called Davey I believe (deleted all my PMs, but I saved them as text) and said that if he could not find Davey, and he died, some kind of massive serial killer would run loose. I knew it had to either be a deception (in which case, he'd be confirmed as mafia) or the truth (in which case, we needed to protect him) and in either case, we had time to determine which was which.

Pever said above that he added a to second kill (something about a cat running away) so this story might check out. How many people did taka tell? Did you try to pursuade anyone privately to vote for reenk instead of taka?

Don't agree with your case on reenk btw.

[ULC]

And neither do I

FoS: Pizzaguy

For that nifty PM you sent me

Also, you have a bit of a lyrical prose style ATPG - I've seen to much of your writing not to notice it.

Grr...keep end up editing my own post. Sasaki, I am not familiar with the "Donney" role, explain please.

[Askthepizzaguy]

@Sasaki

I will say right now, I contacted no one regarding the Davey thing. I wanted to wait until morning phase, and I wanted to also discuss with Taka the proper method of finding Davey; I would simply have posted in the thread "Someone is looking for Davey, it's not me, but if you want to find him, I can tell you who he is, otherwise you can remain anonymous."

But, I wanted to make sure Taka was OK with that plan, and I didn't want to reveal that someone was looking for Davey during a night phase when it could affect the kills. Gotta read the other replies now.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

And neither do I

FoS: Pizzaguy

For that nifty PM you sent me

Also, you have a bit of a lyrical prose style ATPG - I've seen to much of your writing not to notice it.

Grr...keep end up editing my own post. Sasaki, I am not familiar with the "Donney" role, explain please.

It's in the earlier write ups, davey runs over the cat and donney yells at him about it and then calls padraic.

btw, what did pizzaguy pm you?

@Sasaki

I will say right now, I contacted no one regarding the Davey thing.

Well that's a null lead then. Unless taka told someone else.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Taka and I had a PM exchange yesterday which I'd like to reveal, but I can't until Taka comes back and allows me to post it. I believe Reenk is admitting to something perhaps he didn't do, which means we need to question him. Otherwise he is Oswald, who killed twice already.

Would you be willing to pressure vote Reenk? And what do you think of Seamus, he obviously has a role; it says he is Donney. Do you think that's a mafia role? I'll vote for Seamus if he is.

Maidred is another single role - another SK most likely.

Not sure as to Donney's status, but since the odds that we would be lynching a protown roles versus a mafia role are 1/3, I'd go with lynching known roles - Seamus and Reenk must both die.

I would ask that they both reveal their role pms and have them claim protown. The real protowns can then come forward and call them LIARS. What do you think? Pressure vote, not massive bandwagon, is the safest route, yes?

That all depends on your alignement status really. To easy for someone to quickly kill the protown roles once it's in the open - 2 possible mafia for what, 2/3rds of our protown? with 4 mafioso left? No...

This is what I said.

[GeneralHankerchief]

Actually, wait a sec. Ares plays over at TWC too, right? Can anybody tell me if he's active as usual over there?

[Askthepizzaguy]

No, he's not. A game he is hosting has been stagnating for days.

[GeneralHankerchief]

All right, let's try somebody else.

Unvote: Ares
Vote: Psychonaut

2 posts, and I know for a fact he's active on other parts of the forum.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

Would you be willing to pressure vote Reenk? And what do you think of Seamus, he obviously has a role; it says he is Donney. Do you think that's a mafia role? I'll vote for Seamus if he is.

You indicated before that you've read a lot about the play, is my assumption that donney is a good guy off base?

[Greyblades]

No, he's not. A game he is hosting has been stagnating for days.

It seems to be a trend of his.

Vote: Reenk Roink
Rule 60: Keep your lies consistent.