The fight for Inishmore [Concluded]

[Askthepizzaguy]

You indicated before that you've read a lot about the play, is my assumption that donney is a good guy off base?

Actually, I never saw the play; all the info I have is based off of whatever I could get off of wikipedia's page for the Lieutenant of Inishmore, plus the data we have in-thread here. Beefy said pevergreen actually wrote the wikipedia article, so, I'd start there. I have no idea if Donney is innocent, but I am leaning that way if the mafia/serial killers are trying to take him out, and someone defended him.

[Seamus Fermanagh]

I'd pegged Seamus as mafia (his posting was off to me and he's a logical choice for grunt) and was planning on making my case on him. Any powers come with your role Seamus?

Yes.

Too bad you missed him last night?

Vote:FC is the bees knees

I think the defense of "lol I don't what I'm doing" is scummy in a "if I was mafia I would be worried about your accusation but since I typed lol I'm obviously not and therefore innocent" way. WE says he acts different than he does at twc as well. Some of the other things he says (like quoted above) seem to fit a "but I wouldn't say this if I was mafia!" pattern. On the whole it reminds me of a playstyle I've seen mafia use before.

I'd already been gnawing at him a bit prior to votes opening for today based on WE's comments. Based on me being targeted AND the points you rightly make, I'll second your

Vote: F.C is the bees knees


IC



Donney walked into the Lucky Star, a white bandage covering his recent wound. He walked purposefully toward the back corner where Mairead sat quietly.

"Rest easy, Mairead," said Donney. "I've come to apoligize."

Mairead relaxed a little, but only a little.

"A few of the others told me you only pinked me as a distraction. I'm after thinking they were right. I should have known that Brendan was only asking questions to set me up. I'd have been dead soon enough if you hadn't tossed a spanner into the works."

Mairead nodded her acknowledgement.

"I'll be damned if I'll shout 'Brilliant' over your choice of how to help me out though. You only pinked me sure enough, but it'll be stinging and sore for weeks to come." Donney paused, the faintest of grins slipping onto his face, "but I do thank you."

Donney turned to face the other patrons.

"I know Paddy was a bad one," he said. "None here knows that better. Still, he was my son and I did love him -- nearly as much as I feared him. It's only I and the bean sidhe will keen over him, and that's true enough. But it's these trice-damned 'Troubles' that'll take us ALL to an early grave if we don't end the efforts of both those cursed Saxons AND those of our own who glory in killing. They're hiding in plain sight, so if one of you notices something that doesn't fit, sing out and we'll all have a chance to work on finding them...before they 'find' us."

Donney walked to the bar, downed the slow-poured Guinness the barman'd automatically drawn for him when he entered in one slow pull, and then turned and walked off into the afternoon sun.

[Askthepizzaguy]

I'd be willing to take my vote off of Reenk, but I'd like to know what he is up to. If this is in-character roleplaying, I'd understand, but he's still doing self-incriminating stuff. If he's forced to do so by his role, perhaps he could favor us with a thumbs up? Otherwise, he's a better lynch than Seamus, who is a confirmed role that if we decided were guilty somehow we could lynch later. Plus it seems he's got a defender who can simply defend again at night.

Why do you think Reenk is not a good lynch, Sasaki? I'm aware it's his typical style, but it's the same even if he were mafia, so it's not a defense. I'm just looking to hear your reasoning.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Wait a second... YLC, why did you just assume Mairead is a serial killer? He's obviously a doctor or something from the writeup if he saved Seamus.

[GeneralHankerchief]

Wait, I thought Mairead shot Seamus in the arm.

[A Very Super Market]

My role states that I don't need to kill Maireed.

Maybe a hint...

[Seamus Fermanagh]

Wait, I thought Mairead shot Seamus in the arm.

I initially thought the same, pever' corrected me. Yes, she shot me, but to prevent my death, not cause it.

[ULC]

Wait a second... YLC, why did you just assume Mairead is a serial killer? He's obviously a doctor or something from the writeup if he saved Seamus.

I blame myself for skimming the write up, and honestly thinking it was Mairead who tried to kill Donney -

[Askthepizzaguy]

That would make her a doctor type role. Definitely no serial killer. For now, we have to peg Seamus as Donney and Mairead as our anonymous doctor/defender who could also be innocent.

[GeneralHankerchief]

We really need TinCow here to keep track of who's who. So far all I can glean is that Oswald is a bad guy, Seamus is Donney (exact specifics unknown), and Mairead can protect people.

Although Seamus refusing to take Sasaki's bait is a point in his favor. I think a mafioso/neutral role would be more apt to play up his role's pro-town aspects.

[ULC]

Sorry, but I am suspicious of any roles at this point - I'll wait for the night phase to see what happens.

Someone have a tally?

[Askthepizzaguy]

Oswald appears to be one of the mafioso, and Brendan appears to be the other. From the two murder attempts per night, I think we have our two mafioso who are killing. Brendan and Oswald appear to be henchmen.

Post 219:

3 Mafia (IRA)
3 Mafia (English)
3 Pro Town
2 other roles.

No suicide roles.

The 2 other roles could be serial killers or neutrals which involve the cat side story. One I believe could be a serial killer due to Taka's warning. Taka could have been the other one, but he didn't have a named role. Since there are two kills per night, if we do have a serial killer, he's not murdering. Taka suggested that this killer would start murdering after he (Taka) died, and plenty. I would like Taka to elaborate on what he suggested if he can, whenever he gets in.

[Seamus Fermanagh]

So far, we've got (deceased in bold):

Donney (Seamus) -- role specifics not published

Mairead (unknown) -- probable doctor, other particulars unknown

Padraic (AVSM) -- serial killer

Brendan (unknown) -- lead IRA wetworker

Oswald (unknown) -- killer (presumably lead English wetworker)

Davey (unknown) -- killed Paddy's cat in prequel, sought by Jolt? (pizza's post)

Any other names I've missed?

[Askthepizzaguy]

I believe he was sought by Taka, did I miss something about Jolt? And aren't we sure Jolt didn't have a role, due to his murder and lack of a name? Then again, if that's the case, Taka had no role either, and I am confused.


for convenience, here is a link to murder night one:
https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showp...&postcount=328
And murder night two:
https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showp...&postcount=480

[ULC]

So far, we've got (deceased in bold):

Donney (Seamus) -- role specifics not published

Mairead (unknown) -- probable doctor, other particulars unknown

Padraic (AVSM) -- serial killer

Brendan (unknown) -- lead IRA wetworker

Oswald (unknown) -- killer (presumably lead English wetworker)

Davey (unknown) -- killed Paddy's cat in prequel, sought by Jolt? (pizza's post)

Any other names I've missed?

Sought by taka actually.

However, taka was mentioned as taka, not as a named role. That whole situation needs taking a look at to me...

[Askthepizzaguy]

Get out of my brain, YLC!!!

[Diana Abnoba]

Maired, we may have to take this outside.....:beadyeye

Seamus when you take her outside you may want to kiss her, she did save your life. You only got a flesh wound.

[White_eyes:D]

Vote:F.C is the bees knees Pizzaguy.....Reenk is just being Reenk... If he was guilty he would not self-incrimate himself. *Check Godfather 3*.....how did he getaway with that stuff???

[ULC]

Get out of my brain, YLC!!!

I am not in your brain...I am...somewhere else...

Maybe I am simply a better looking clone of you

[Askthepizzaguy]

How... DARE... you! I'll have you know I am a handsome fellow. Check me out.

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

And if you're my clone, you'd better thank me for the genes I sent you. Do they fit?

[ULC]

How... DARE... you! I'll have you know I am a handsome fellow. Check me out.

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

And if you're my clone, you'd better thank me for the genes I sent you. Do they fit?

Considering my physique? No, definitely not. I had to sow my own, and it seems I only managed to nab some stuff for this thing called a brain not many people use. If few people use it, it must be worthless - I've been jipped.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Okay, Okay, White_eyes and everyone else, maybe it's not Reenk. I am just curious about why he'd do this, is all. Not that much of a stretch to wonder about that is it?

I'll keep my vote on him for now, and read up on this FC is the bees knees case.

edit-
Sasaki makes excellent points. I'll do a tally and see whether or not he needs more pressure votes.

[GeneralHankerchief]

Frankly I don't think taka had a role. While confirmation bias keeps me from being certain, so far all the players with roles have been named, and it's been proven that this is also the case if they are nightkilled.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Sorry I just got bogged down with something. Can someone else do a tally please.

[F.C is the bees knees]

COOL I AM GOING TO DIE........................................ unvote:whoever i voted for and VOTE FC goodbye.

[Askthepizzaguy]

No, no no. You don't do that. Even I'd be willing to at least answer questions while voting for myself. So you should stick around and respond to the points that have been made against you.

[Seamus Fermanagh]

Seamus when you take her outside you may want to kiss her, she did save your life. You only got a flesh wound.

I apologized. Skipped the kiss as OOC she's more likely to be a hairy y chromosome type given the player pool.


EDIT:

Okay, I misread the jolt taka thing, thanks for the correction.


FCBK:

Do not go gently into that good night. If you are town, then fight for all you are worth as you know you are innocent. If you are mafia, then fight for all you are worth as you know you are one of the few.

[F.C is the bees knees]

I rather not... i rather celebrate my birthday.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Uhhh.... you may want to reword that, FC.

Tradition around here is that you get lynched on your birthday, it seems. I can name at least two examples of that.

[LittleGrizzly]

Ohh its F.C's birthday, i may just have to chang my vote to F.C now!!

We lynched seamus on his bday i think... whose the other ?