The fight for Inishmore [Concluded]

**Reenk Roink** · 03-27-2009, 17:02

Originally Posted by Sasaki Kojiro

What percentage chance do you think reenk has of getting into hot water over the writeup?

6.27%

On one last note, it frankly smacks of elitism to say that only such and such a person with such and such education, intelligence, whatever would be able to produce such and such writeup. I don't know how any one can infer much about intelligence or education from Mafia games and internet posts.

I am of the opinion, that while there are some really good writers here, that almost everyone here who is a native speaker and old enough to have used the language a lot will be capable of writing up even the best write ups. I am of the opinion that most people can change their writing at will to whatever they want it to be.

I think the entire enterprise of write up analysis with regards to syntax or diction or style is just not worthwhile. All of these things are easily changeable.

Write up analysis with regard to theme is a little better, but again, only in certain contexts (we don't even know if pevergreen is writing most of the write ups or not) and also can be easily masked by just about anyone.

EDIT: Not you too YLC! I need someone to take up my banner.

**ULC** · 03-27-2009, 17:10

Then your sense of equality does not apply to me Reenk, because I am not capable of it. I cannot change my writing style at all, because of how I think of the words. My thought process, not the thoughts themselves, cannot change, or are extremely hard to change. So in essence, allow me to refine my post slightly - There is a slight chance that someone else is writing it because they want to go to either A) extreme effort to frame you, or B) extreme effort to win, both of which are pointless in my eyes, and I am not one of those capable of doing so.

Also, please continue to ignore the rest of my statements and invalidate my emotional status. It makes me feel like Sasaki.

**ULC** · 03-27-2009, 17:23

Originally Posted by Reenk Roink

EDIT: Not you too YLC! I need someone to take up my banner.

Why should I take up anyone's banner but my own? Why should I champion another player at all? I am not part of nay team, I am and have always worked alone, always doing what a group should be doing, as a single person.

Every one is suspect, there is no reason to champion anyone unless you have something to lose - I've already lost everything, and therefore have nothing more to lose. I have nothing to lose, I have no need to champion anyone.

This includes you Reenk, and anyone else I so

well choose. Unlike Sasaki, I am bitter, biting, and sarcastic without the humor. I am insane and cruel without being fun like you. I am emotional and rational without the logical side of ATPG. I follow people along like Seamus, but am never as insightful or to the point.

So Reenk, before asking me to pick up your flag without justification, where the

is my flag? Where is my banner, where is my champion?

**Askthepizzaguy** · 03-27-2009, 17:46

I knew it. I just knew, waking up, I would be the only vote on Reenk. Reenk could show up, declare that he wanted out of the game, post his actual mafia role pm, vote for himself, and you guys would think it was just Reenk being Reenk. It is possible, given his amazing skills, his ability to survive, that the English Godfather could choose him to be a henchman, you know.

But, since Reenk is getting a pass to survive the game, and it seems likely to me he's a henchman, not the Godfather, I say it's time we lynched a Godfather.

unvote,
vote: Yoyoma1910

In my estimation, Yoyoma, you are no townie. And Reenk is trying to pull of the big distraction to cover your butt, since you haven't posted here since the 23rd. And you voted for seireikhaan when he was an easy target, and Reenk (though I agree with Reenk) back when he was an easier target as well.

Lots of jokes, but no substance. Just trying to increase your post count, I'd suspect. You were here all yesterday, the 25th, and the 24th, and no posts here? Avoiding this thread, are we?

Spoiler Alert, click show to read:

Reenk, you may well be a henchman, and well done. But I'm only interested in hitting the godfather. Since we're obviously not lynching you, let's take a shot at not only wiping out you, but your entire family.

**ULC** · 03-27-2009, 17:49

Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy

I knew it. I just knew, waking up, I would be the only vote on Reenk. Reenk could show up, declare that he wanted out of the game, post his actual mafia role pm, vote for himself, and you guys would think it was just Reenk being Reenk. It is possible, given his amazing skills, his ability to survive, that the English Godfather could choose him to be a henchman, you know.

But, since Reenk is getting a pass to survive the game, and it seems likely to me he's a henchman, not the Godfather, I say it's time we lynched a Godfather.

unvote,
vote: Yoyoma1910

In my estimation, Yoyoma, you are no townie. And Reenk is trying to pull of the big distraction to cover your butt, since you haven't posted here since the 23rd. And you voted for seireikhaan when he was an easy target, and Reenk (though I agree with Reenk) back when he was an easier target as well.

Lots of jokes, but no substance. Just trying to increase your post count, I'd suspect. You were here all yesterday, the 25th, and the 24th, and no posts here? Avoiding this thread, are we?

Spoiler Alert, click show to read:

Reenk, you may well be a henchman, and well done. But I'm only interested in hitting the godfather. Since we're obviously not lynching you, let's take a shot at not only wiping out you, but your entire family.

Way to acknowledge the premise of my theory, without actually acknowledging me for it.

**Askthepizzaguy** · 03-27-2009, 17:51

Originally Posted by YLC

Way to acknowledge the premise of my theory, without actually acknowledging me for it.

I didn't read your posts. I woke up and checked the vote tally to see if anyone, anywhere, anyhow, would ever vote for Reenk, even when a good case was made on him. They didn't.

Forgive me, YLC, but I do have my own brain and my own thoughts, and sometimes they are similar to yours without actually being yours.

**ULC** · 03-27-2009, 17:58

Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy

I didn't read your posts. I woke up and checked the vote tally to see if anyone, anywhere, anyhow, would ever vote for Reenk, even when a good case was made on him. They didn't.

Forgive me, YLC, but I do have my own brain and my own thoughts, and sometimes they are similar to yours without actually being yours.

Or vice-versa. For some odd reason I tend to wait until the next page to read your posts sometimes.

**Reenk Roink** · 03-27-2009, 18:04

Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy

I didn't read your posts. I woke up and checked the vote tally to see if anyone, anywhere, anyhow, would ever vote for Reenk, even when a good case was made on him. They didn't.

Forgive me, YLC, but I do have my own brain and my own thoughts, and sometimes they are similar to yours without actually being yours.

Your case wasn't really good Atpg. I already replied to it. Although you have really tried hard for the past couple games to hammer home a theory that I "get away" with things, perhaps the reason the town leaves me alone is because there is no good evidence against me?

I know you think there is, but that is because you made the case.

**Askthepizzaguy** · 03-27-2009, 18:08

It was a good case. The writing style is nearly identical to yours, the tone is "upturned nose", the content, vocabulary, and literary references are those easily found by someone of your caliber.

The sad part is, I can actually pay you a compliment Reenk, and you still find ways to belittle my efforts. I consider that in-game, though, so I of course forgive you and shrug it off as best I can. But I see now how you were able to make it through Prometheus by yourself. You are indestructible.

**Andres** · 03-27-2009, 18:38

Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy

I have a disagreement with your reasoning; in this game, the mafia families seem to be only killing once per night. A henchman dies, it is no big deal. If Sasaki and LittleGrizzly exposed themselves trying to save a henchman, it would make little sense. However, mafia games rarely make sense, so I suppose even though I disagree, anyone's opinion is valid here.

And White_Eyes, the writing style itself is completely different, as is the tone, in your examples.

This doesn't sound like the usual ATPG to me.

Also, basing votes on the write-ups is usually not a good idea. And you're a more than decent writer yourself, ATPG.