Large Simpsons Mafia Game- The Treehouse of Horror [Concluded]

[Captain Blackadder]

VOTE GH

That kind of anti town saving your own skin on the deadline annoys me and at least to me reaks of scumminess.

[GeneralHankerchief]

VOTE GH

That kind of anti town saving your own skin on the deadline annoys me and at least to me reaks of scumminess.

'scuse me for sticking with my guns. Like you wouldn't do the exact same thing if you were in my position.

Vote: Captain Blackadder

How about using some good reasoning for once in this game?

[Greyblades]

Um... could someone please provide a tally?

[GeneralHankerchief]

Okay people, look. I'm not this bad of a player. Look at Inishmore, when I was mafia and I didn't get a single vote on me until the last round I was alive.

All I did was jump into an existing argument between two people and got burned for it. The same thing happened to Chicago Soiree, and I got put on the lynch list for it before I was kindly offed by the mafia before the town got a chance.

Now ask yourself which is better pro-town behavior: Questioning everything so as to get a better read on things, or sitting back, going with the flow, and ensuring that you look clean while the rest of the town continues to die?

[Sasaki Kojiro]

Okay people, look. I'm not this bad of a player. Look at Inishmore, when I was mafia and I didn't get a single vote on me until the last round I was alive.

Ah, but we lynched pevergreen round 1 and he was mafia. How many votes did he get in Inishmore? QED

Now ask yourself which is better pro-town behavior: Questioning everything so as to get a better read on things, or sitting back, going with the flow, and ensuring that you look clean while the rest of the town continues to die?

[GeneralHankerchief]

It may be a strawman, but it doesn't affect the fact that I'm right.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

It may be a strawman, but it doesn't affect the fact that I'm right.

So the argument you're making here is that bread and butter pickles are better than dill? That's nonsense my friend. You can't deny that I'm right to say that dill pickles are better.

[Reenk Roink]

How about using some good reasoning for once in this game?

How 'bout defining "good reasoning" and then demonstrating how it leads to more "productive" lynches more than "not good reasoning"?

[PershsNhpios]

(Sorry for being inactive, 'R.L.' has been hectic.)

I don't agree with lynching either Boudica or GH, and I don't at all understand why more players are believing that others will take their 'instincts' seriously.
I will start from a few pages back and work my way towards a vote.

[Chaotix]

How 'bout defining "good reasoning" and then demonstrating how it leads to more "productive" lynches more than "not good reasoning"?

A little bitter, perhaps?

Anyway, I think we should open up our lynch options a bit more.

Vote: LittleGrizzly

This should create a three-way tie.

[PershsNhpios]

I have been over the posts of the three candidates and contrary to what I expected, I found that I dislike GH's tendencies the most.
But this vote is probably note final.

Vote: GeneralHankerchief

GH - 5 (Ichigo, WE, Beefy, Boudica, CB, Glenn)
Boudica - 4 (Khazaar, Fixiwee, LG, shlin28)
LG - 4 (Jolt, TM, Quintus, Chaotix)
Ichigo - 1 (ED)
CB - 1 (GH)
Thermal Mercury - 1 (AggonyDuck)

Abstaining - 1 (taka)

[Northnovas]

I am trying to follow this but there is no instinct. Since Luanne has been gone I can't think straight. I think I am going to cry.....


Vote: Abstain

[A Very Super Market]

LG seems a bit more suspicious, so I think I'll actually make the tie happen

Vote: LG

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

GH - 5 (Ichigo, WE, Beefy, Boudica, CB, Glenn)
LG - 5 (Jolt, TM, Quintus, Chaotix, AVSM)
Boudica - 4 (Khazaar, Fixiwee, LG, shlin28)
Ichigo - 1 (ED)
CB - 1 (GH)
Thermal Mercury - 1 (AggonyDuck)

Abstaining - 1 (taka)

[Reenk Roink]

A little bitter, perhaps?

Anyway, I think we should open up our lynch options a bit more.

Vote: LittleGrizzly

This should create a three-way tie.

Well yes, of course.

But that's not the reason for the question. GH seems to be hiding a blatant retaliation vote on Blackadder as "reasoned" and to be honest, I don't blame him. Many of the town have too much faith in "reason" and see retaliation as something bad. Priorities out of whack in my view.

[seireikhaan]

I would heavily advise the town KEEP this tied up. A LOT.

[Jolt]

Why would you? Just curious.

[Diana Abnoba]

Well hidely-ho good neighbors of Springfield. Not sure I understand why the vote is going the way it is. I don't think any of the 3 main choices (tie), are a good pick. Smithers (Reenk) was found to have lied about being detective, so to me Boudica is not a good choice. GH and LG were just questioning that very thing, and for this (their opinion) they are on the rope (lynch) also. I really don't know who to vote for, must do some more checking to see if anyone else stands out.

Vote: Abstain for now.