I've never been poor nor living in completely desperate circumstances, so I don't know what I would do
Also, are the guys in those small boats, waving guns and jumping on board of big ships the leaders, the big fishes?
If you kill them, wouldn't the real leaders just recruit other desperate guys to try again? Guys who probably don't even know they might get killed? Or maybe the pirate leaders could just put a gun against the heads of desperate people and tell them to either take their chances or die immediately?
Somalia is not exactly a country filled with hard working, middle class citizens and just a small minority of poor and desperate people.
Plenty of recruits and plenty of opportunities to force unwilling potential recruits for a smart, rich, ruthless and hardened criminal.
Anyway, that's how I would run my pirate business (if I would be evil). I wouldn't jump on those (guarded) ships myself, I'd force a few poor chaps to do it for me and let the ransom money be transferred to my bankaccounts. As a pirate leader, I would not care about the couple of hundreds poor guys that would get shot.
Bookmarks