Dethy mini mafia! [Concluded]

[atheotes]

i would be wary of anyone who waits to see others' results before posting their own

[Beskar]

Well, technically speaking, no one should withhold results and being quite honest, they would only be caught out obviously trying to do that, and end of the day, if they are a mafia/non-investigator, whatever answer (innocent or guilty) is the wrong answer and just get discovered anyway.

On that note, I propose the town take up a policy of "No Lynch". According to write-up, the killer only has a chance to kill and if we start lynching fellow investigators, we get screwed fast. We need 3 investigators alive to quickly deduct who it is. That means, we can have one detective and the mysterious role probably can die too. That gives us 3 nights which should be enough time to find our Mafia.

[Askthepizzaguy]

In the previous Dethy mafia, we lynched someone and we won the game outright on the first round.

[Iskander 3.1]

Ok guys 3 more hours, get your orders in please!

[Iskander 3.1]

T-minus one more hour...

[Iskander 3.1]

Night 1 concluded, write-up coming shortly...

[Iskander 3.1]

Night 1 Results

Iskander found a joke in the backroom that was so funny it caused him to fall out of bed. "ROFL!" he narrated. That was pretty much the only interesting thing that happened that night. In the morning he gathered his friends around so the group could discuss their investigations.

Dead (0/6)

Lynched (0/6)

Alive (6/6)
Cultured Drizzt fan
atheotes
Beskar
A Very Super Market
Ask the Pizza Guy
Tratorix

Begin Day 1
Vote!

Due to the weekend I will extend Day 1 until Saturday 10:00 pm PST (that's in roughly 34 hours).

[Cultured Drizzt fan]

I looked up what a dethy mafia is, sooooooo Vote: no lynch

[A Very Super Market]

Geez, all I saw was Iskander's "time-left" announcement, before I had to head out for an appointment, so I think I may have ruined to the town's strategy. Then again, we need at least two nights before we can root out the paranoid cop, so it might work out anyways.

I investigated ATPG and got a guilty result.

[Beskar]

You was meant to investigate Atheotos with me. (I got guilty)...

That means you need to investigate him tonight and I investigate Pizzaguy, so we can compare the results (hence why we do it in twos). Idea being, the pair investigate two different people, then the pairs investigate some one together which another pair investigated. With this, we basically have the idea of who is who, thus can do the process of weeding out the mafia.

[A Very Super Market]

Alright, let's not lynch then. More investigative targets will help root out the proper people.

Vote: No lynch

[Askthepizzaguy]

I investigated CDF and got an innocent result.

vote: No Lynch

[atheotes]

no kills during the night? interesting. did someone forget to send instructions? anyways it should work very well for us.

Vote: No Lynch

[Askthepizzaguy]

I don't think we can assume that it is all good. I'll check activity to see if we can actually chalk things up to that.

ATPG
Beskar
Atheotes
CDF
Tratorix
AVSM

All 6 players were active last night.

[atheotes]

the last post tratorix made was abt 25 hrs ago...

[Beskar]

CDF and Atheotos, what results did you get?

[Askthepizzaguy]

the last post tratorix made was abt 25 hrs ago...

He posted on the forums Yesterday, 15:36 (GMT-5:00)

That means he was active during the proper time frame. He was not inactive.

[atheotes]

CDF and Atheotos, what results did you get?

Both of us posted yesterday itself.

CDF on Beskar - Innocent
Atheotes on Beskar - Guilty

[Tratorix]

I investigated CDF and found him innocent.

[Tratorix]

Oh and Vote: No lynch

[Beskar]

Both of us posted yesterday itself.

CDF on Beskar - Innocent
Atheotes on Beskar - Guilty

oh, my apologises.

[Beskar]

Just realised, I might be able to work out who is who tomorrow (small degree of error, but enough to do a possible lynch). I need everyone to do this night order tonight.

AVSM - investigate Atheotos
Beskar - investigate Pizzaguy
Pair 1 investigate AVSM
Pair 3 investigate Traitrox

Statistically, this would mean everyone has one real investigation on them, to be able to do a lynch next turn, might require a little guess work, but it might just be possible. I don't want to reveal too much away just now (since the Mafia might know how I will work this out, and could mess up the chance) but if I feel I can put forwarda case tomorrow, I will answer all then.

Oh and Vote: No Lynch

[Tratorix]

Just realised, I might be able to work out who is who tomorrow (small degree of error, but enough to do a possible lynch). I need everyone to do this night order tonight.

AVSM - investigate Atheotos
Beskar - investigate Pizzaguy
Pair 1 investigate AVSM
Pair 3 investigate Traitrox

Statistically, this would mean everyone has one real investigation on them, to be able to do a lynch next turn, might require a little guess work, but it might just be possible. I don't want to reveal too much away just now (since the Mafia might know how I will work this out, and could mess up the chance) but if I feel I can put forwarda case tomorrow, I will answer all then.

Oh and Vote: No Lynch

Your plan has me investigating myself...

[Askthepizzaguy]

Did it again.

It's Tratorix, not Traitorix.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Your plan has me investigating myself...

I think Beskar went offline. Might as well switch with someone from pair one. Go for AVSM if you like.

To be honest there seem to be holes in this plan because it does not take into account the 6th role. How does everyone end up cleared? What if always innocent and always guilty investigate the same person?

[Tratorix]

I think Beskar went offline. Might as well switch with someone from pair one. Go for AVSM if you like.

To be honest there seem to be holes in this plan because it does not take into account the 6th role. How does everyone end up cleared? What if always innocent and always guilty investigate the same person?

Well, we've still got some time, since the day phase is 24 hours, so we can see if we can find a better investigation plan by then.

[Askthepizzaguy]

I'm open to suggestions. I think it is better if one person doesn't end up directing all the action anyway.

[Beskar]

Oops, my apologises. Pair 1 and Pair 3 swap.

AVSM - investigate Atheotos
Beskar - investigate Pizzaguy
Pair 3 investigate AVSM
Pair 1 investigate Traitrox

[Beskar]

Anyway, trust me, I have it all shushed out, and yes, it even accounts for role 6. You will see.

[Tratorix]

Night 1 Results

Pair 1
Atheotes investigates Beskar: Guilty
CDF investigates Beskar: Innocent

Pair 2
Beskar investigates Atheotes: Innocent
AVSM investigates the wrong person, ATPG: Guilty

Pair 3

Tratorix investigates CDF: Innocent
ATPG investigates CDF: Innocent

Beskar, why must you mispell my name even after you've been corrected?