Pirate Ship Mafia [Concluded]

[Splitpersonality]

I'm sure the captain has someone of use, if ye're looking fer a roleblocker.

It just wouldn't be a large mafia game without one, haha.


Sadly, I be not knowin the name of this man, the captain himself may just know of one though...

[Tratorix]

Yarr, I recommend the lynching of Cultured Drizzt Fan.

[Beefy187]

Dead

Guess its better being killed rather then lynch yaar?
Good luck mateys!

[pevergreen]

Unvote: Andres

Fine.

Why should we lynch CDF?

Why? Because it'd be fun!

Vote: CDF


edit: To tha cap'n. You sent me who i was going to work with at 4am local time. I got to a computer about 55 minutes after the phase ended. 4 hours earlier...

[CountArach]

Andres is as close to a confirmed innocent as we are likely to find at this point I feel beyond invesitgation powers, which are probably best applied to someone else. Were I in his position, I could see why fleeing would be an attractive option. Not entirely sure who we should be going for though...

[miotas]

Huh? You sayin somefin CA? Wa? Aye, Andres is guilty you say? Rightyo.

Vote: Andres

[Andres]

Andres wouldn't be trying to escape if he were either Maven or British. Rather, he would be dedicated to killing us, and that entails staying on board. There is absolutely no way Andres is scum right now, or else this is was very complicated scheme to pull off.

Here is what I suggest. If Andres has any sense in him, he will leave tonight. The mafia will not try to kill him because he is a wasted kill. They may try to recruit him, however, since he is for now basically a confirmed innocent. If Andres has not left the ship in two phases, there is a good chance he's been converted and he should be lynched. Otherwise, he can't have too much gold and he's a waste of a lynch now if he was only going to leave later. Let's lynch someone with some actual suspicion on them.

I'm not going to abandon ship now that I'm as good as confirmed innocent, thank you very much.

vote Andres. I think he's innocent

Brilliant reasoning for your vote.

Really, this belongs in the category of "most funny mafia quotes"

Hmm, I'm thinking if he is a maven, he has all of sigurd's gold, plus any gold from any kills he's done and the gold for voting and being active, and recruiting before game. Could be as high as 250.

We'll attack him again tonight

Ridiculous and you know it.

Huh? You sayin somefin CA? Wa? Aye, Andres is guilty you say? Rightyo.

Vote: Andres

No, CA said I'm as good as innocent.

Maybe I should indeed abandon this ship; it's a madhouse floating on the water.

"Hey, that guy over there is innocent! Get him!"

[pevergreen]

Makes sense in this game. We are pirates.

[Subotan]

Nice to see that GH followed my advice and replaced the word "omen" with "bloodbath"

[Jolt]

Unvote: Andres

Fine.

Why should we lynch CDF?

Why? Because it'd be fun!

Vote: CDF


edit: To tha cap'n. You sent me who i was going to work with at 4am local time. I got to a computer about 55 minutes after the phase ended. 4 hours earlier...

This is the reason I'm voting for pevergreen.

Vote: pevergreen

[Subotan]

Andres is as close to a confirmed innocent as we are likely to find at this point I feel beyond invesitgation powers, which are probably best applied to someone else. Were I in his position, I could see why fleeing would be an attractive option. Not entirely sure who we should be going for though...

Doesn't matter. If we wait long enough, one of them will slip up, and we'll have someone to lynch.

Oh my, looks like Pevergreen's foot is hovering very close to that banana.

[Cultured Drizzt fan]

Yarr, I recommend the lynching of Cultured Drizzt Fan.

Can you explain why? I am kind of pressed for time right now soooo.......

What I want to know is how I am scum when we have both been in the same protection group the entire game. Especially considering we got the protection money for last night, so it was successful.


edit: OhhHHH Tratorix is dead?

ugghhhh. not a good day.

[Askthepizzaguy]

I got protection money, and one of the members of my group didn't even send in his orders.

As such, it is no proof of innocence. That being said, I don't see a case against anyone yet, and... well, my saucy wench has me swabbin' the decks here at our cabin, so I have some work to do. Yarrr....

Vote: Abstain

[Death is yonder]

Vote: Abstain

Don't have much free time lately, but it appears that people are voting for Andres because he tried to leave the ship contrary to what Maven/British would be doing at this point of time?

Also, it appears that LG was innocent...

[TinCow]

Yarr, I recommend the lynching of Cultured Drizzt Fan.

This is very interesting and needs to be pursued. This type of post immediately after someone dies usually means that the deader had info that they hadn't released before they died.

Vote: CDF

What reason would Tratorix have for suspecting you?

Andres is as close to a confirmed innocent as we are likely to find at this point I feel beyond invesitgation powers, which are probably best applied to someone else. Were I in his position, I could see why fleeing would be an attractive option. Not entirely sure who we should be going for though...

Wrong, Andres is as close to confirmed guilty as we are likely to find. Eager to vig kill, defended Sigurd vociferously, and then tried to flee with his cash ON NIGHT 3. I find it very doubtful that Andres would quit the game at this stage if he was a townie. He would know he had nowhere near enough gold to win as a townie, and he's not a quitter. Andres was fleeing as an attempt to win... which means Maven.

I recommend Andres be vig killed and CA be investigated.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Wrong, Andres is as close to confirmed guilty as we are likely to find. Eager to vig kill, defended Sigurd vociferously, and then tried to flee with his cash ON NIGHT 3. I find it very doubtful that Andres would quit the game at this stage if he was a townie. He would know he had nowhere near enough gold to win as a townie, and he's not a quitter. Andres was fleeing as an attempt to win... which means Maven.

I recommend Andres be vig killed and CA be investigated.

If this is the theory, then the correct move would seem to be lynching Andres, not chancing things on a vigilante kill. It is entirely possible that he might make it off the ship before the vigilante kill takes effect.

And if he is the most likely suspect, then perhaps the order should be reversed, a lynch on Andres and a vigilante kill on CDF. Or perhaps, investigating the man.

[Andres]

Wrong, Andres is as close to confirmed guilty as we are likely to find.

Then you should vote me, instead of CDF. I managed to survive an attack last night, so if you have two suspects, then the one able to survive a vig kill should be lynched, don't you think?

[Seamus Fermanagh]

...I think you have been really suspicious, so suspicious in fact that i almost sort of don't think a mafia would be that open. Then again you may be resigning yourself to the fact that you cannot lie low because you are such a well known player and you would eventually come up so you are building alibis now. Like i said i would not vote for you right now but you are acting rather suspicious...

I believe that's all covered under rule #1. By-the-by, Sasaki would be doing the same regardless of role -- I've yet to see another player so evenly suspicious regardless of role -- it's par of his charm.

Now...

Avast wi' your bickerin' you two! There be little enough time for sleep as it is. Pipe down and get below.

[Andres]

Besides, not only was I trying to abandon the ship and defending myself from an attack, I was also being blocked last night:

You were making preparations to abandon ship, when suddenly you felt a tap on the shoulder.

"Going so soon?" a beautiful woman said, smiling sweetly. You mumble out a response. Drat, all your experience with women happened while drunk. You have no idea how to deal with them when you're sober.

She's just so beautiful though, you can't resist and spend the night together. As the sun is about to rise, you bolt up awake, realizing what time it is. You try to abandon ship, but it's too late in the night and you are attacked. You manage to survive but all hope of abandoning ship for the night is gone.

In the confusion, it takes some time for you to notice that you have several pieces of treasure missing from your stash.

Gold count: 130

Mind you, last night, there have been quite some attacks, hmm...?

All of this while I certainly was not busy with scummy activities.

How much more evidence of my innocence do you need?

Can we now please stop this ridiculous focusing on me and look at other suspects?

[DisgruntledGoat]

Besides, not only was I trying to abandon the ship and defending myself from an attack, I was also being blocked last night:



Mind you, last night, there have been quite some attacks, hmm...?

All of this while I certainly was not busy with scummy activities.

How much more evidence of my innocence do you need?

Can we now please stop this ridiculous focusing on me and look at other suspects?

Beefy was attacked by 2 people (seen in a previous night attack on taka), Iskander by 4 and Tratorix by 1. You were attacked by a 4 as well. 4 = vig group. So two attacks can be disregarded as being British or maven. Reading the write up for Tratorix I have a tough time believing that he was attacked by the British spies or maven crew members. Its completely different from anything in the write ups previously. On night 2, there was a second group of 2 men that attacked atheotes in a standard fashion. So based on that either the British or the mavens were not killing last night. So no, you trying to escape and the number of attacks does not provide any evidence of your innocence. In fact, the write up points more to you being guilty.

[Andres]

That does it. Enough is enough. I give up.

This feels like talking to a wall or having to explain why an orange is not an apple.

[TinCow]

If this is the theory, then the correct move would seem to be lynching Andres, not chancing things on a vigilante kill. It is entirely possible that he might make it off the ship before the vigilante kill takes effect.

And if he is the most likely suspect, then perhaps the order should be reversed, a lynch on Andres and a vigilante kill on CDF. Or perhaps, investigating the man.

Probably, but there's plenty of time in the day phase so far. Pressure on CDF could produce more information, while voting for Andres now will likely just result in an unproductive bandwagon phase.

[edit]Andres' night result is interesting. Looks like we might have a roleblocking thief onboard.

[Andres]

Probably, but there's plenty of time in the day phase so far. Pressure on CDF could produce more information, while voting for Andres now will likely just result in an unproductive bandwagon phase.

No, by all means, let this nonsense end here and now. Lynch me.

Vote : mutiny
Vote : Abstain

[Beskar]

I feel sorry for Andres, he is under the typical "let's just focus on Beskar for no reason" game-style.

Also: If any townies want to give gold to some one not british or those other crewpersons people I keep doing the name wrong, I am always free to accept.

[DisgruntledGoat]

That does it. Enough is enough. I give up.

This feels like talking to a wall or having to explain why an orange is not an apple.

Oh I see when someone points out the fallacy of your statement its misdirected, unfair and wrong. Well soooooooorrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrry. What were you doing on night 2 again and can anyone account for your actions that night.

[CountArach]

Vote: Reenk

Not his usual hilariously spammy self.

[Beskar]

Vote:Reenk Roink

Good enough reason as another, Reenk Roink, what have YOU been up to?

[Andres]

Oh I see when someone points out the fallacy of your statement its misdirected, unfair and wrong. Well soooooooorrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrry. What were you doing on night 2 again and can anyone account for your actions that night.

I sent in orders to protect YLC with Sasaki and AVSM.

Sasaki sent in the same order, but AVSM replied that he was already doing something else.

We still received our gold, so all was well

[DisgruntledGoat]

So technically you didn't do anything that night and were inactive.

[White_eyes:D]

Vote: CDF Why would Tratorix want you lynched? he is not the type to point fingers, unless there is a really GOOD reason (Case in point...Capo 3)