Pirate Ship Mafia [Concluded]

[TinCow]

If this is the theory, then the correct move would seem to be lynching Andres, not chancing things on a vigilante kill. It is entirely possible that he might make it off the ship before the vigilante kill takes effect.

And if he is the most likely suspect, then perhaps the order should be reversed, a lynch on Andres and a vigilante kill on CDF. Or perhaps, investigating the man.

Probably, but there's plenty of time in the day phase so far. Pressure on CDF could produce more information, while voting for Andres now will likely just result in an unproductive bandwagon phase.

[edit]Andres' night result is interesting. Looks like we might have a roleblocking thief onboard.