Pirate Ship Mafia [Concluded]

[Sasaki Kojiro]

Who gave you this information, and why? It seems odd to me that you always end up at the center of every town group.

I don't see why multiple power roles would be revealed to someone recruitable...especially an obvious recruiting target.

[TinCow]

I don't see why multiple power roles would be revealed to someone recruitable...especially an obvious recruiting target.

The only way this could be known is if ATPG has been investigated. Since he's already putting himself out in the limelight, I think these results should be posted or conveyed to us in some manner. ATPG's statements are pretty blatantly asking for recruitment. Since he's not in a position that prevents him from being recruited, this is of concern to me. If he's been investigated and found to be non-scum and non-recruitable, great... but we need to know that.

[Askthepizzaguy]

The only way this could be known is if ATPG has been investigated. Since he's already putting himself out in the limelight, I think these results should be posted or conveyed to us in some manner. ATPG's statements are pretty blatantly asking for recruitment. Since he's not in a position that prevents him from being recruited, this is of concern to me. If he's been investigated and found to be non-scum and non-recruitable, great... but we need to know that.

I have been already fully investigated as recruitable and non-scum.

Predictable.

[TinCow]

I have been already fully investigated as recruitable and non-scum.

Predictable.

You do realize you're making a very strong argument for your own lynching. Why are you doing this?

[Askthepizzaguy]

You do realize you're making a very strong argument for your own lynching. Why are you doing this?

So the town doesn't LOSE!

look, I want to win the game, right? I'm a townie. I win if the town wins. I want the town to win.

White Eyes blabs that I know sensitive information, enough such that I'm thinking of abandoning ship so you don't have to waste a lynch on me, since I can't become an officer (all slots are filled)

Now, I have to die. Or else the mafia recruits me. And then what?

I want to win the game, right? I blab all my info and pray they can win. You have to kill me.

[TinCow]

So the town doesn't LOSE!

look, I want to win the game, right? I'm a townie. I win if the town wins. I want the town to win.

White Eyes blabs that I know sensitive information, enough such that I'm thinking of abandoning ship so you don't have to waste a lynch on me, since I can't become an officer (all slots are filled)

Now, I have to die. Or else the mafia recruits me. And then what?

I want to win the game, right? I blab all my info and pray they can win.

You never once considered winning by aiding the mafia if you were recruited? Presumably you would greatly aid any mafia family that recruited you, even if you died shortly after that. That would put that mafia family (and thus you as well) in a good position to win the game.

You're honestly saying that you've never considered any method of winning other than being pure pro-town, even after learning that you were recruitable?

[Askthepizzaguy]

You never once considered winning by aiding the mafia if you were recruited? Presumably you would greatly aid any mafia family that recruited you, even if you died shortly after that. That would put that mafia family (and thus you as well) in a good position to win the game. You're honestly saying that you've never considered any method of winning other than being pure pro-town, even after learning that you were recruitable?

Sorry, that would require me to do a number of things I don't want to do in this game, such as hard work and backstabbing. I just wanted to roleplay Smilin' Sam and sing shanties.

That's all. I didn't ask for people to reveal their power roles to me. And if I ever want to organize a pro-town group again, I'm not going to betray all the people who confided in me. What was that Sasaki said in capo.... forget the exact quote but basically the idea is your trustworthiness affects how you can play the game. If you want to be at the center of pro-town groups or be recruited by mafia, etc, you can't be backstabbing your own teammates every game.

And maybe, just maybe, it isn't in my personality to be a townie and play for the mafia, trying to cut down the town's chances while I am on their team. I leave that up to other, more notorious players.

And yes, I did consider my options for helping a mafia family win. But when I got all those power roles handed to me on a silver platter, I realized that the town stood a better chance of winning. And I also knew I'd be investigated and proven loyal, and perhaps, just perhaps, made an officer and really kicked some mafia tail. That's always fun for me, regardless of role.

I was mafia recently at CFC and my team went down in flames right away. But before I died, I figured out who one of the rival mafia were and got the town to kill him off. That's what I do... because I like killing mafia.

[White_eyes:D]

White Eyes blabs that I know sensitive information, enough such that I'm thinking of abandoning ship so you don't have to waste a lynch on me, since I can't become an officer (all slots are filled).

It was your fault as well

Why is it totally my fault?? I had my back to the corner, you know that

If I hadn't said anything I would have been lynched, because I choose a bad night to leave your groups...

[Andres]

You do realize you're making a very strong argument for your own lynching. Why are you doing this?

How about who ever pulls the strings behind the scenes stops sending information on recruitable townies? And those with pro-town roles, please do not reveal yourselves to recruitable townies!

I understand that ATPG is recruitable and knows the names of people with a pro-town role.

Not much of a choice left


Unvote ; Vote : ATPG

Unvote : Mutiny

[Askthepizzaguy]

At least don't waste the round though. Double lynch me with another suspect.

I'll put the finishing vote on myself to make sure it's a double.

[naut]

Well that has blown the wind out of my sails. Well, not really I just always wanted to say that. ATPG why would you have to join the mafia? Wouldn't a recruit-able thingy be optional? Or are you being shanghaied by top hat wielding Englishmen?

[Askthepizzaguy]

Well that has blown the wind out of my sails. Well, not really I just always wanted to say that. ATPG why would you have to join the mafia? Wouldn't a recruit-able thingy be optional? Or are you being shanghaied by top hat wielding Englishmen?

I believe it is mandatory in this game. You get recruited, you join. No options.

[White_eyes:D]

Isn't there an obvious write-up when someone gets recruited??