Pirate Ship Mafia [Concluded]

**Tratorix** · 10-08-2009, 15:47

Originally Posted by DisgruntledGoat

Well you certainly helped by placing a somewhat random vote Diana.... Glass houses tincow. Glass houses.

FoS: Tincow

Why? You seem to care just a little too much about the way the lynch was handled. Trying to exude innocence? Have a reason to be mad that Jolt is now gone? I don't know yet. But you have my vote come the next day phase.

Darn townies always trying to make us find and lynch actual suspects.

**Sasaki Kojiro** · 10-08-2009, 16:12

Bad logic is really hard to argue with...how do you convince someone of something that should be obvious?

LG--strong evidence of him starting the game with a group of affiliated players, and of him having something to hide. And in fact as has now been revealed, he started the game with a group of affiliated players, and had something to hide. Lynch on that basis everytime, no question.
Jolt--all evidence pointed towards him being a townie.
ANYONE else--approximately 10% chance of being mafia. Louis, I showed before that mathematically it is to the towns advantage to randomly vig kill people. That's kind of mean though. But nothing wrong with vigging or lynching suspects, you aren't going to vote no lynch are you?

**DisgruntledGoat** · 10-08-2009, 16:16

Originally Posted by Tratorix

Darn townies always trying to make us find and lynch actual suspects.

My point is, why is he criticizing the lynch when he offered nothing of an alternative. Except for a half hearted vote on Diana after she voted for Jolt. It reeks of someone that is trying to show how much of a townie he is. "HEY! I highly disapprove of this lynch. It was lazy and bad for the town but I didn't offer any alternative and in fact participated in the laziness by voting randomly for Diana. But I DISAPPROVE! And that means I'm nothing but an able seamen." Doesn't fly with me. Sorry.

**Sasaki Kojiro** · 10-08-2009, 16:19

Originally Posted by DisgruntledGoat

My point is, why is he criticizing the lynch when he offered nothing of an alternative. Except for a half hearted vote on Diana after she voted for Jolt. It reeks of someone that is trying to show how much of a townie he is. "HEY! I highly disapprove of this lynch. It was lazy and bad for the town but I didn't offer any alternative and in fact participated in the laziness by voting randomly for Diana. But I DISAPPROVE! And that means I'm nothing but an able seamen." Doesn't fly with me. Sorry.

No it's basic math. 10 % > 1%. A bad lynch is worse than a random lynch.

**TinCow** · 10-08-2009, 16:20

Originally Posted by DisgruntledGoat

My point is, why is he criticizing the lynch when he offered nothing of an alternative. Except for a half hearted vote on Diana after she voted for Jolt. It reeks of someone that is trying to show how much of a townie he is. "HEY! I highly disapprove of this lynch. It was lazy and bad for the town but I didn't offer any alternative and in fact participated in the laziness by voting randomly for Diana. But I DISAPPROVE! And that means I'm nothing but an able seamen." Doesn't fly with me. Sorry.

Did you bother reading any of the other 13 posts I made that day before that point, when I was trying to get information out of CDF, ATPG, and Reenk? Sorry for putting effort into getting information out of people. I'll try harder to just vote as ATPG says without comment from now on.

**DisgruntledGoat** · 10-08-2009, 17:30

Originally Posted by TinCow

Did you bother reading any of the other 13 posts I made that day before that point, when I was trying to get information out of CDF, ATPG, and Reenk? Sorry for putting effort into getting information out of people. I'll try harder to just vote as ATPG says without comment from now on.

What a wonderful side step to the right. How 'bout instead of complaining about the lynch offers and claiming you've been doing your part and making token posts you offer up something substantial. You disliked the way the lynch was headed and yet instead of offering someone else, or even abstaining you vote for Diana. Which you will claim was a "pressure vote" to get her talking. Do you know what scum do? They put pressure votes on people to look like they are participating especially when they want to avoid being associated with a bandwagon.

**White_eyes:D** · 10-08-2009, 17:34

Originally Posted by DisgruntledGoat

They put pressure votes on people to look like they are participating especially when they want to avoid being associated with a bandwagon.

To be fair....that was an easy bandwagon to slip into.....

Most Mafia have no qualms about slipping into a monster bandwagon like that....perhaps there are other signs?

Because I doubt TinCow is Mafia because of that...

And if he is....He is nothing like the Mafia player I seen in Netherworld...

**Crazed Rabbit** · 10-08-2009, 17:46

This ship will be run as the captain says it will be.

And I be the captain!

We will not be followin' any man and votin' based on his whims. That be no way to run a ship.

We will investigate and lynch those we find to be guilty. But I don't think lynching a man who wanted to betray us, and was helping our enemies even before that, is a very bad choice.

So I be askin ye all; who should we investigate?

CR

**Andres** · 10-08-2009, 17:55

Originally Posted by Crazed Rabbit

This ship will be run as the captain says it will be.

And I be the captain!

We will not be followin' any man and votin' based on his whims. That be no way to run a ship.

We will investigate and lynch those we find to be guilty. But I don't think lynching a man who wanted to betray us, and was helping our enemies even before that, is a very bad choice.

So I be askin ye all; who should we investigate?

CR

Joooray, pevergreen and CDF.

And in case it hasn't been done yet: Louis.

**TinCow** · 10-08-2009, 17:44

Originally Posted by DisgruntledGoat

What a wonderful side step to the right. How 'bout instead of complaining about the lynch offers and claiming you've been doing your part and making token posts you offer up something substantial. You disliked the way the lynch was headed and yet instead of offering someone else, or even abstaining you vote for Diana. Which you will claim was a "pressure vote" to get her talking. Do you know what scum do? They put pressure votes on people to look like they are participating especially when they want to avoid being associated with a bandwagon.

I fully admit that by the time I made my vote on Diana, I was too frustrated with the situation to try and create a solid case against someone else. By that point I believed that no matter what I said, the Jolt vote was going to succeed. I felt (and still feel) that there were almost certainly mafioso hiding in that bandwagon. I picked Diana because I wanted to vote for a bandwagoner to express my frustration and because I felt voting for her specifically would be the most likely way to get a reaction out of ATPG.