Pirate Ship Mafia [Concluded]

[DisgruntledGoat]

Blah apparently the serial killer didn't like me.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

Blah apparently the serial killer didn't like me.

I wonder if it's a cue'd serial killer...someone should check and see if tratorix and DG said something similar.

[Andres]

I'd like to know the names of those who protected Pizza tonight.

Maybe that person didn't take no risk at all, because killing me would make the attack on Pizza fail?

It seems to me that my killer is someone who had information on the Pizza protection and/or the vig hit on Pizza.

The write-up makes me believe the killer was in Pizza's protection group.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

Andres, it could just be GH making a transition from the attack on pizza to your death.

[Askthepizzaguy]

I'd like to know why you decided to attack me to begin with. Surely there was a more productive use of your talents?

[Andres]

Andres, it could just be GH making a transition from the attack on pizza to your death.

Nope. Two men were protecting ATPG, not the required three. Somebody gambled or somebody had intel on both the protection and the attack.

EDIT: I think the names of both the protection and the attack group should be made public.

[GeneralHankerchief]

Not commenting on this either way. Speculate away.

[Subotan]

I was protecting ACIN last night. ACIN was worried that Chaotix's vote against him was the precursor to either the mafia or that vig group of four last night paying him a "visit". He asked me to protect him in the event of an attack.

[TinCow]

I'd like to know why you decided to attack me to begin with. Surely there was a more productive use of your talents?

Not as far as I was concerned. Your antics the previous day have convinced us that you can't be trusted outside of an officer position. Well, after yesterday's vote, I don't trust you to organize the town either. Taking a shot at removing you with a vig kill seemed to me like the best way to solve the town's conundrum.

[Subotan]

Could it be that one of those who was in the protection group on ATPG was my killer?

ATPG had a 50 % chance of surviving the attack by himself, right? A ballsy mafioso would take the risk of changing orders to attack me, knowing that ATPG had a 1/2 chance of surviving and giving himself an alibi for the remainder of the game.

Is that even possible?

[Askthepizzaguy]

"You die tonight, Quartermaster," one of them responded. "We be havin' just about enough the way this ship be run, and we'd be likin' to make some changes 'round here. First demand: You, dead."

"Consider the complaint noted," Pizzaguy replied. "I be referrin' it to me staff. Expect an answer from them right about... now," he said, and several more figures rushed out from behind another door, their cutlasses raised. The vigilante group, a bit taken aback, charged forward, and the battle was on.

I'd also like to know where you get only two protectors from "several". Even a very liberal definition of several would mean more than two.

Not as far as I was concerned. Your antics the previous day have convinced us that you can't be trusted outside of an officer position. Well, after yesterday's vote, I don't trust you to organize the town either. Taking a shot at removing you with a vig kill seemed to me like the best way to solve the town's conundrum.

Yarrr... then let the Captain handle the organization, if you're not happy with my efforts. Did you really be thinkin' that I would let my life be decided by a coin toss? I know you have more productive things to be doing, and I expect that you be doing them.

At the very least, we can narrow down who isn't the long-winded serial killer. That means we've made some progress today.

[gibsonsg91921]

I have no idea who killed me. It was either random or because I was voting "present."

[KukriKhan]

So Andres, TinCow & Sasaki = 3 of the pizza attackers? Who else?

[Askthepizzaguy]

You might suspect AVSM being a fourth, as I do. But I've no proof.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

Nevermind, I suspect that our serial killer is the last maven. Once sigurd and gibson died he just started killing, yeah?

[Yaropolk]

I was protecting ACIN last night. ACIN was worried that Chaotix's vote against him was the precursor to either the mafia or that vig group of four last night paying him a "visit". He asked me to protect him in the event of an attack.

Who else was in your group who can confirm your behavior?

[Andres]

I'd also like to know where you get only two protectors from "several". Even a very liberal definition of several would mean more than two.

Sure, "several" came forward. Two real protectors and one 'protector' who cancelled the protection order he had forwarded to you and sent in an order to kill me instead.

Something about that write-up makes me believe my killer was one of those who were supposed to protect you.

Who was in that group, please? It can't be too hard to form a group that doesn't have those three in it for the next night to protect you, if you're so worried about you're own safety.

[Andres]

Nevermind, I suspect that our serial killer is the last maven. Once sigurd and gibson died he just started killing, yeah?

There was more than one solo killer last night.

Both are scum or Louis has been out killing (and of course, Louis can be scum too, I for one have not seen any evidence on his innocence).

Since our dear officers are very good at protecting themselves, they don't need to worry about being a bit more open to us.

[Subotan]

Who else was in your group who can confirm your behavior?

Miotas and AVSM

[TinCow]

Miotas and ACIN

ACIN was protecting himself?

[Yaropolk]

Sounds like you're off the hook.

ACIN and Miotas, can you confirm? GH - can you comment on whether mechanics allow one to participate in a protection group on themselves?

[GeneralHankerchief]

You can't protect yourself.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

There was more than one solo killer last night.

Both are scum or Louis has been out killing (and of course, Louis can be scum too, I for one have not seen any evidence on his innocence).

Since our dear officers are very good at protecting themselves, they don't need to worry about being a bit more open to us.

Ah yes, the tour guide killer is probably the maven, but the "unearthly glow--blunderbuss" guy is new.

Arr but andres, methinks a man scared enough to beg other pirates for protection at night isn't going to give you their names, even if one of them is a serial killer. "rest assured, the captain and I will look into the matter. Trust in your noble officers to take care of things for you" sayeth he I'm sure.


Vote:shlin

fos:yaropolk

[Subotan]

Whoops typo, that should read AVSM.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Who was in that group, please? It can't be too hard to form a group that doesn't have those three in it for the next night to protect you, if you're so worried about you're own safety.

I'll show you mine if you show me yours.

Otherwise I have no reason to divulge my protection to the very person who tried to kill me.

[Beskar]

Both are scum or Louis has been out killing (and of course, Louis can be scum too, I for one have not seen any evidence on his innocence).

I have seen it, Louis VI the Fat is 100% loyal crewmember with no corruptibilities.

Now you are swimming with the fishes, a good place for ye traitorous scum.

[Tratorix]

I have seen it, Louis VI the Fat is 100% loyal crewmember with no corruptibilities.

Now you are swimming with the fishes, a good place for ye traitorous scum.

Louis is completely incorruptible? Then why don't we switch him out of the First Officer position, since he can't be recruited?

[Askthepizzaguy]

After all that bluster about wanting to know who is protecting me, and about me being "cowardly", you fellas won't divulge the names of your vigilante group. How duplicitous.

vote: Ricera10

Your posts and voting pattern seem suspect to me.

[Yaropolk]

fos:yaropolk

Those be fighting words matey! You best sleep with your one good eye open from now on. You're a dead man walking, your parrot's a dead bird flying, and if you ever get back to land and manage to trick a wench into having your piratelings, they're dead as well. And when your kids have a pet goldfish, HE's dead!

[A1_Unit]

I was in a protection group last night. vote:shlin for lack of better suspects.