Pirate Ship Mafia [Concluded]

[TinCow]

I can always resign from playing if need be.

To be clear, from my perspective this is entirely an in-game issue. Nothing I say has anything to do with your behavior in other games. To use the popular phrase: this is business, it's not personal. I hope you can understand that.

[pevergreen]

To be clear, from my perspective this is entirely an in-game issue. Nothing I say has anything to do with your behavior in other games.

As for me, kind of the same.

Its an entirely mafia related issue, outside of that, you're a stand up bloke.

Two reasons why you shouldn't resign:

1) I'm dead
2) I'm one person.

If you enjoy it, keep playing. I'd hate to think I caused someone to stop playing the game.

[Louis VI the Fat]

There is no pro-town group.
There are no attack/protect combo's to find out who's real.
The game mechanics don't inform protectors whether the other protectors showed up.
The write-ups don't even mention how many protectors there were when a player is attacked.

And:
Investigations take three rounds. It is impossible for the detectives in the town to figure out who has what role.

This means:
The officers aren't holding anything back - there simply isn't any information.
This game is played on gut feeling. (This is how Rabbit sniffed Sigurd out!)
This is Pirate roleplay galore for those with a sense of fun and some creativity!



Also:
Tincow is deluding the town. Here's the deal, I figured it out. See my post on the previous page:

Andres is anti-First Mate.
Tincow is anti-QM.

Simple as that. One needs to disregard everything Andres wrote about me, and what Tincow wrote about Pizza. I do believe both Andres and Tincow to be pro-town. This is the only explanation for the erratic behaviour of both.


Lastly:

unvote: AVSM
vote: Reenk Roink
His name aliterates. Very Eton. Very English.

[Askthepizzaguy]

unvote, vote: Sasaki

My magic crystal ball suggests that Sasaki is British. And no, I have no investigation results or damning evidence to point that out. It is my impression of the man alone.

[pevergreen]

Interesting premise. I never considered there being an anti-role role.

However, we are being told, by yourself that x is innocent.

"What about CR" we say. Innocent, you lot say.

And Louis has been investigated and found to be a townie.

By the mystical town aligned investigator who revealed to, no doubt at that point, an uncleared player, who looks to be cleared by more products of the initial clearing.

What I want is the detective to jump up and say who they are. Then we can either believe them, follow them and protect them, put them in captain, or if found to be false, lynch them.

Its not hard. Why are you critical to our success CR? You arent. We should get this investigator in there.

Or is it you?

I know you were pegging sigurd without trying to reveal you had investigated him (or on your behalf)

edit: ATPG: I believe he may be as well.

[Cultured Drizzt fan]

So now we want to get rid of Sasaki? I mean we have known that he has been killing townies for almost the whole game but now we are choosing to act on it?

Frankly that seems strange to me, but who am I to argue? I was for lynching Sasaki before and I still am now. He has been getting away with what he is doing for far to long.

Vote: sasaki

[Louis VI the Fat]

What I want is the detectives to jump up and say who they are.

I think our supernatural creature with the enchanted bunderbuss killed us a pommy.

[Askthepizzaguy]

CDF-

To be clear, "we" do not want to get rid of Sasaki. I am voting based on what I believe. And I wasn't suggested by Crazed Rabbit or Louis to vote for him either. I am choosing to rely on the "gut" which so many others rely on.

[Splitpersonality]

Vote: Abstain

I have no idea who the :dasiy: to vote for anymore :(

[pevergreen]

I think our supernatural creature with the enchanted bunderbuss killed us a pommy.

As per rules for the dead, I can't say anything on this matter.

However, I urge you to look back over my last posts.

[Askthepizzaguy]

mavergreen is right, we should focus on the British.

[Splitpersonality]

Askthebritishguy is right, we can't let people infiltrate our ranks and poison our minds.

[Cultured Drizzt fan]

CDF-

To be clear, "we" do not want to get rid of Sasaki. I am voting based on what I believe. And I wasn't suggested by Crazed Rabbit or Louis to vote for him either. I am choosing to rely on the "gut" which so many others rely on.

Thats fine, Personally after what sasaki has done I think he deserves a lynch.

The funny thing is he has gotten away with it. He organized hits on townies and the rest of us just said "ohh he can't be mafia, just let him have his fun". even if he is not mafia he is not helping the town out.


but I may just be living in the past, .

[pevergreen]

"mavengreen"

I like that.

[Splitpersonality]

"ohh he can't be mafia, just let him have his fun". even if he is not mafia he is not helping the town out.

Am I right in believing we already lynched someone who wasn't actively killing townies, over someone who has?

Just wondering if I'm right about that, I think I might be.

[Louis VI the Fat]

pevergreen the last maven? But he is claimed to have been part of the vig team against Pizza, on the night of a maven kill?

I know mavergreen hints at being maven:

What you all should do is stop focusing on who the maven are. In my opinion, (since I can't reveal facts) the maven are no longer a problem as of last night.

Was pevergreen part of the vig group, or was that a lie?

[pevergreen]

pevergreen the last maven? But he is claimed to have been part of the vig team against Pizza, on the night of a maven kill?

I know mavergreen hints at being maven:


Was pevergreen part of the vig group, or was that a lie?

Looking purely at the writeup, the attack failed. There was four people though.

Anyway, I may need to be quiet to avoid breaking any rules here.

[White_eyes:D]

That's why the "Protect group" AVSM was in, is SO scummy sounding....

pevergreen can't be the last "Maven"...

[Louis VI the Fat]

Looking purely at the writeup, the attack failed. There was four people though.

Anyway, I may need to be quiet to avoid breaking any rules here.

Meh. I can't work it out. But I want to know so I'll put a pressure vote on the people who do know and can tell:

unvote: Reenk
vote: Sasaki

[pevergreen]

Results don't show who you worked with.

[a completely inoffensive name]

Can someone give a tally? I am confused on where everybody stands.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Some have suggested if I step down as quartermaster and leave the ship, things would be better.

If the Captain dismisses me as QM then I shall take my leave.

[Chaotix]

Now, you see, if Yaropolk was a smart mafioso, he would put his vote right here, once the bandwagon was already established and his post would be undistinguishable from any of the others:

Lynching Kojiro-San is always a safe bet! Vote Sasaki

But instead, he made the mistake of blatantly jumping on the bandwagon way before there was a bandwagon. Does that seem to anyone else like a miscalculated scum move?

Sasaki's gotta go... we should keep an eye on Yaropolk afterwards.

[a completely inoffensive name]

That's why the "Protect group" AVSM was in, is SO scummy sounding....

pevergreen can't be the last "Maven"...

Do you like making assertions with no evidence but just your feelings?

[White_eyes:D]

Do you like making assertions with no evidence but just your feelings?

Why do you think no one listens? and anyone who does is Scum?

I can't talk or hint about it...but GH wouldn't let pevergreen's hinting stand, if it were true
(I was even told to stop....)

[pevergreen]

Why do you think no one listens? and anyone who does is Scum?

I can't talk or hint about it...but GH wouldn't let pevergreen's hinting stand, if it were true
(I was even told to stop....)

I've asked GH and he said he was monitoring the thread.

I'm 100% trying to stay within the rules.

[KukriKhan]

What, no one offering to buy or sell votes yet? By now, it's tradition, harrrr.

vote: Tin Cow

I've never seen him be so obstinate. Something is up.

[White_eyes:D]

I've asked GH and he said he was monitoring the thread.

I'm 100% trying to stay within the rules.

He was VERY NICE to you then....

And yes, I use evidence....what have you come up with ACIN??(Other then comic relief?)

[pevergreen]

What, no one offering to buy or sell votes yet? By now, it's tradition, harrrr.

vote: Tin Cow

I've never seen him be so obstinate. Something is up.

YLC bowed out, then I was losing money waaay too fast.

[Louis VI the Fat]

Some have suggested if I step down as quartermaster and leave the ship, things would be better.

No.

Tincow maybe has lost track of the fine line between attacking the role, and attacking the person playing the role. Too much is too much. This is a game. We are not here for character assassination.

You are a great force for this town, and one hell of a funny player to work with.