Pirate Ship Mafia [Concluded]

[Cultured Drizzt fan]

I didn't vote.....

um Vote: Double A. I am going with the officers. Trying to write a lynch writeup now, so don't feel like thinking.

[Tratorix]

Makes me wonder if he's the last maven and a different maven attacked cent1 on night one to provide an alibi for CDF.

[Beefy187]

Vote: Mutiny

Someone told me to

[Crazed Rabbit]

I didn't vote.....
I am going with the officers. Trying to write a lynch writeup now, so don't feel like thinking.

Double A is confirmed not to be either of the killers.

CR

[Cultured Drizzt fan]

Ok geez. Tin cow is still an officer ain't he? Thought he knew something about what was going on.

if you think I am maven then just kill me already No need to go passive aggressive.

[TinCow]

Double A is confirmed not to be either of the killers.

CR

Um... how? Last I heard he was your top suspect. Even Louis thought Double A was the best choice and that was after he was dead. You're now hiding info from both of us?

[a completely inoffensive name]

I always had a weakness for the lookers....

EDIT: Why am I doing anything anymore in this game? I have no credibility and no gold anymore, so **** it, Imma just lurk and post troll comments for the rest of the game.

[Captain Blackadder]

The currently living (at least One of whom is a bad guy):

a completely inoffensive name
A Very Super Market
A1 Unit
Captain Blackadder
Centurion1
Crazed Rabbit
Cultured Drizzt Fan
Death is Yonder
Double A
KukriKhan
Lord Winter
miotas
Reenk Roink
Seamus Fermanagh
shlin28
slashandburn
spL1tp3r50naL1ty
Subotan
taka
TinCow
White_eyes:D
Yaropolk

Captain calls for discussion, but not bandwagon, on taka. All I can contribute on him is that he doesn't say much in-thread, until his name comes up - then he's johnny-on-the-spot with an excuse. We went through this exercise a couple of day phases ago with taka, and atPizzag "cleared" him, and Captain stopped a bandwagon on him (IIRC).

Seamus F does a fine job of staying in-character, but has only contributed 14 posts to the effort in this thread. Very unusual play for him.

I don't know Captain Blackadder very well, but he seems to be laying low as well, with a mere 11 posts here. Busy elsewhere, like a mafia forum?

For pressure (and because, if he's on our side, he could be very helpful with analysis):

vote: Seamus

Yeah that was because I was mafia in the inventor game and I was concentrating on that. In games like this where they are huge and I am a simple seaman I don't particuly post very much since there are so many people that I can't get a good read on anyone. However I will try and post more.

[Splitpersonality]

I always had a weakness for the lookers....

EDIT: Why am I doing anything anymore in this game? I have no credibility and no gold anymore, so **** it, Imma just lurk and post troll comments for the rest of the game.

According to sources, you have about 180 gold, that is certainly not "no gold"

;)

I think you're quite credible ACIN <3

[a completely inoffensive name]

According to sources, you have about 180 gold, that is certainly not "no gold"

;)

I think you're quite credible ACIN <3

I used to have 200+ and was hoping to have the most at the end of the game.

And thanks, its good to know there are those that still listen. :)

[Splitpersonality]

I have no reason to mistrust you, from the little information I've been given at least.

:D

[Louis VI the Fat]

Um... how? Last I heard he was your top suspect. Even Louis thought Double A was the best choice and that was after he was dead. You're now hiding info from both of us?

I was suspicious of Double A indeed. I am however going over today's information that has led me to now think Double A is not scum.


ACIN - you have not lost your credibility. You paying me off with ten gold each turn provided you with lots of credibility and little credit indeed but You are not on the (rapidly shrinking) shortlist of suspects.

[a completely inoffensive name]

I was suspicious of Double A indeed. I am however going over today's information that has led me to now think Double A is not scum.


ACIN - you have not lost your credibility. You paying me off with ten gold each turn provided you with lots of credibility and little credit indeed but You are not on the (rapidly shrinking) shortlist of suspects.

I never paid you anything, I don't know why you have that on there and crossed through.

But thanks about my credibility, it just seems like this last guy is really entrenched to be an average townie. I want someone to be straightforward though, was i role blocked?

[Louis VI the Fat]

This thread is perhaps not my audience for my humour.


* wipes rotten tomatoes off face, gets coat *

[a completely inoffensive name]

Oh there i go again, still in serious business mode.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Only the dead have a sense of humor.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

Vote:Mutiny

I don't find the current captain deserving...

I do agree with what was said earlier (I think by pizza?) about the dead not bolding their votes. It makes it tough for the game host and for the other living players as well.

I'll vote for lynch when I finish going back through the thread, have a lead on something.

[Crazed Rabbit]

EDIT: A reminder, Sasaki, you are dead as well, so kindly unbold your vote

Hmm. My mind towards towards CDF more and more.

He had a successful protection on night one, but not since then.

Almost everyone else has had a successful protection on a night when the maven solo killer was operating, or a confirmed role or confirmed in some other action.

Perhaps he can suggest a better choice, though.

I want someone to be straightforward though, was i role blocked?

Yes.

CR

[Death is yonder]

Vote: Abstain

And an FoS on LordWinter for your sudden decline in activity as opposed to your early game, your last post may have been 4 days ago but you were last online 18 hours ago, stop lurking

[Cultured Drizzt fan]

EDIT: A reminder, Sasaki, you are dead as well, so kindly unbold your vote

Hmm. My mind towards towards CDF more and more.

He had a successful protection on night one, but not since then.

Almost everyone else has had a successful protection on a night when the maven solo killer was operating, or a confirmed role or confirmed in some other action.

Perhaps he can suggest a better choice, though.



Yes.

CR

I don't even care. I have had no successful protections because the targets you chose for me have not been attacked. Is that my fault?


for god sake just lynch me or Vig me, don't ask me who I think is the last maven, cause I have no idea.

[a completely inoffensive name]

Yes.

CR

Why?

[Crazed Rabbit]

I suspected you guys might be attacking someone who I didn't want attacked.

for god sake just lynch me or Vig me, don't ask me who I think is the last maven, cause I have no idea.

Well that is the whole point of the game - if you have no suspects why not read a bit of the thread and see if you come upon one?

CR

[TinCow]

I was suspicious of Double A indeed. I am however going over today's information that has led me to now think Double A is not scum.

Well, that was enlightening.

I suppose I'll toe the line yet again though. I wouldn't want CR to get all paranoid or anything and think I'm scum because I don't agree with everything he says.

Unvote; Vote: CDF

[Centurion1]

i trust cdf. I think we should wait one more turn before making any judgments like that cr

[a completely inoffensive name]

I suspected you guys might be attacking someone who I didn't want attacked.

CR

I don't take kindly to authority shutting me down.

Vote: mutiny

[Cultured Drizzt fan]

I suspected you guys might be attacking someone who I didn't want attacked.



Well that is the whole point of the game - if you have no suspects why not read a bit of the thread and see if you come upon one?

CR

Dude I am trying to juggle a IH, one small mafia, one Small game I am hosting, a PBM, trying to figure out a way to get a NEW PBM going, Plus Battle Royale. And of course real life. I read the thread, bu I hardly have any time to analyze it.

I had a good enough run early on and helped you find a watchstander, so if I die I will die knowing I helped the town. if you want to go ahead and put me out of my misery. I get to say I told you so however. as is my right

No hard feelings though, I get how trying to organize the whole ship would be tough. You need suspects and frankly, I always look scummy.

[Louis VI the Fat]

I don't take kindly to authority shutting me down.

Vote: mutiny

Mate, we are trying to clear you, lest your horseman group suspect you of not having sending in orders. Only three of you showed up, so the others will want to know what happened. And before they start pointing fingers at you, we clear it up.

That is, we have been on your side this whole day.

[a completely inoffensive name]

Mate, we are trying to clear you, lest your horseman group suspect you of not having sending in orders. Only three of you showed up, so the others will want to know what happened. And before they start pointing fingers at you, we clear it up.

That is, we have been on your side this whole day.

No need to get all cranky. (And would you please be so kind to give me a polite answer to my PM? It's just a game. )

I made a deal with the F.H. that since I have been supporting them they would help me kill Reenk. I supported him then he posts a secret message from me publicly meant to truly see if he was good or not. I will be honest, I wanted to get him as a matter of revenge not because I thought he was mafia. I should not have been role blocked though.

[Centurion1]

ACIN you really tried to base a kill off revenge in a game like this. Thats sort of scummy.......

[Crazed Rabbit]

I made a deal with the F.H. that since I have been supporting them they would help me kill Reenk.

Supporting them? Are you not one of them?

I should not have been role blocked though.

You go to kill a likely watchstander based on a personal vendetta and you say you should not have been role blocked?

CR