Seven Man Scrimmage 1: C4 [Concluded]

[Beskar]

I think you've upset Renata. Bad Pizza.

[Renata]

My hero! *swoons* :)

[Beskar]

If you want to be mine, I need a replacement player. Basically it is at the end of the game, but some one unfortunately has to leave and they left a big PM of their thoughts etc for anyone who wants to take over.

(Sorry for the slight hijack of the thread Diamond Eyes. I was reading your game, looks good. )

[Renata]

Ah ok. Sure, why not.

[Subotan]

EDIT: Ah , missed it.

[Askthepizzaguy]

That vote will be late.

[Thermal]

Final Tally, then:

Renata: 3
atheotes: 1
Beefy: 1
Thermal: 1
Subotan: 1

[Diamondeye]

Vote Tally:

Subotan: Thermal
Thermal: Subotan
Renata: Atheotes
ATPG: Renata
Beefy: Renata
CDf: Beefy
Atheotes: Renata

Renata is lynched with 3 votes against Beefy/Thermal/Subotan/Atheotes' 1 each...

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Renata was an ordinary townsperson!

It is now night - day comes in roughly 23 hours.
People with night abilities, send in orders please!

Player overview:
Alive (6):
ATPG
Subotan
Beefy
CDf
Thermal
Atheotes

Dead (1):
Renata (lynched day 1, townie)

[Renata]

Beefy tomorrow, pretty please.

[Askthepizzaguy]

I agree. Beefy lied... something didn't happen that he said would happen.

[Thermal]

[Cultured Drizzt fan]

I agree. Beefy lied... something didn't happen that he said would happen.

.....

[Beefy187]

Sorry I lost the game for the town
Pizza misunderstood what I told him.

And my mafia detecting skill is terrible as always
Lynch me.

[atheotes]

we lynched a townie I guess there is more going on through private conversations than in the thread.

[Thermal]

Spill the beef beefy

[Diamondeye]

The night reveals that there has been a killing! The town has lost its one and only pizza delivery guy!

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

ATPG was an ordinary townsperson!

Narrowed down to five people, you need to be spot on to have a chance now!

It is now day - night comes in roughly 24 hours.
Remember to keep votes in the standard format!
The dead can (as you noticed) talk all they want.

Player overview:

Alive (5):
Subotan
Beefy
CDf
Thermal
Atheotes

Dead (2):
Renata (lynched day 1, townie)
ATPG (killed night 1, townie)

[Askthepizzaguy]

I was bluffing. I do not want Beefy to die.

Focus your efforts elsewhere.

[Thermal]

Vote: Subotan

[Askthepizzaguy]

Thermal Mercury claimed a power role. Because no one has challenged that claim, that tells me that his claim was legitimate.

That means you've effectively proven him innocent. There are now only 3 suspects. (Subotan, CDF, atheotes)

[Cultured Drizzt fan]

Don't you mean 4 suspects? (nevermind, missed your edit. Either way how are you sure beefy is innocent? )



anyway, Vote: Atheotes for being third on the Renata Bandwagon

[Askthepizzaguy]

Well it's just a matter of this:
2 power roles remain
2 mafia remain
1 basic townie
2 power roles have claimed
no one said they were lying last round
that imcriminates everyone who isn't one of the two claimants.
that means we have a 2/3 chance of lynching a mafia today



Does everyone get this?

1. If you are a pro-town role, and you're not Beefy or Thermal, WHY DIDNT YOU CALL THEM A LIAR LAST ROUND??? We would have had a 1/3 chance of lynching a mafia last round, and if we lynched a pro-town role, we would have a 1/2 chance of lynching a mafia this round.

2. By not calling Beefy or Thermal a liar, you've proven you're either the ONE basic remaining townie, or a MAFIA SCUMBAG.

3. You've also proven Beefy and Thermal's claims are both legitimate.

[Cultured Drizzt fan]

Well it's just a matter of this:
2 power roles remain
2 mafia remain
1 basic townie
2 power roles have claimed
no one said they were lying last round
that imcriminates everyone who isn't one of the two claimants.
that means we have a 2/3 chance of lynching a mafia today



Does everyone get this?

1. If you are a pro-town role, and you're not Beefy or Thermal, WHY DIDNT YOU CALL THEM A LIAR LAST ROUND??? We would have had a 1/3 chance of lynching a mafia last round, and if we lynched a pro-town role, we would have a 1/2 chance of lynching a mafia this round.

2. By not calling Beefy or Thermal a liar, you've proven you're either the ONE basic remaining townie, or a MAFIA SCUMBAG.

3. You've also proven Beefy and Thermal's claims are both legitimate.

Ohhh.... Cool. So it does not matter if I vote subotan or atheotes, they have to both be scum?? (unless beefy is lying..... which I still think)

[Thermal]

That leaves subotan, athelotes, beefy, CDF

I'm sticking with subo

Diamondeyes, can I communicate with players outside of the thread that are dead or alive?

[Askthepizzaguy]

That's generally frowned upon (dead people), but it is the host's call.

You can talk to us in-thread, can you not?


Remember, Beefy's been proven innocent by the lack of other claims.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Ohhh.... Cool. So it does not matter if I vote subotan or atheotes, they have to both be scum?? (unless beefy is lying..... which I still think)

Beefy isn't lying.

If Beefy were lying, someone in this game would have to step forward (as this is the last round if we get this wrong) and CALL HIM A LIAR by claiming a pro-town role. All power roles MUST claim now.

Therefore, Beefy isn't lying. You, for example, are either a basic townie or a mafia scum, because you haven't claimed.

[Cultured Drizzt fan]

Beefy isn't lying.

If Beefy were lying, someone in this game would have to step forward (as this is the last round if we get this wrong) and CALL HIM A LIAR by claiming a pro-town role. All power roles MUST claim now.

Therefore, Beefy isn't lying. You, for example, are either a basic townie or a mafia scum, because you haven't claimed.

I already told you all I never got a PM. So I guess that makes me the only townie left

[Thermal]

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

I have a good feeling I'm missing school tomorrow, amazingly thick snow, it better not melt....

I don't think I should share anything given the fragile situation town is already in.

[Renata]

Hmm? There's fragile and then there's lynch or lose. This is the latter. If people don't put it on the line now, then when?

[Diamondeye]

That leaves subotan, athelotes, beefy, CDF

I'm sticking with subo

Diamondeyes, can I communicate with players outside of the thread that are dead or alive?

As ATPG said, that is generally frowned upon. Please keep it in the thread if you want to discuss this game with them. You are of course welcome to talk to them about anything else.

[Askthepizzaguy]

I don't think I should share anything given the fragile situation town is already in.

This is the last round of the game, for most intents and purposes. Spill it, or I will call you a liar.