Quote Originally Posted by PVC
Either you can't read or you are deliberately trolling. Nowhere have I said, "Ghandi is in Hell" nor have I said, "you have to be a Christian to be moral".
The former was just me making a point. The latter, however, was implied in your earlier posts.

Quote Originally Posted by Philipvs Vallindervs Calicvla View Post
I repeated several times that penitence was the key issue, not necessarily a belief in the Christian God, or the Christ.
Penitence to whom? Jesus? And who says you need to do penitence to be moral?

Quote Originally Posted by PVC
However, I also gave a nmber of reasons why Ghandi might not be a paragon of light, and why just because he seemed holy to some people he was not automatically a baromater for goodness or worthiness.
And I gave you several reasons why none of those examples apply, to which you declined to reply.

Quote Originally Posted by PVC
Now, you can either listen to what the Christians in this thread are actually telling you about their beliefs, or you can stop harrassing us; but the way you are going is pointless.
I am. You're the first one to actually reply.

Quote Originally Posted by Meneldil
Wasn't Gandhi firmly opposed to a republican democracy that would have offered the same rights to Muslims and Hindus? My impression was that he was no found of Muslims at all, and never planed to have them play any meaningful role in an independant India.

Edit: That is a genuine question, I'm not trying to make a point or something. I've always thought that Gandhi had a darkside to him, and that the whole Gandhi-fanboyism was stupid. I'm willing to be proved wrong.
Not as far as I know. He was an anarchist much in the same mold as Tolstoy, really. I've never heard this charge, though, so I could be wrong.