I loved the game setup, Methos! It was extremely interesting imho, if a bit hard on the innocents, as ATPG suggests.

I must say, early on I was quite sure that ATPG was "The Cop" because he seemed to avoid the kill of him at nights. Also, arresting people instead of killing them would be typical of ATPG.

However, my last day talk with ATPG revealed to me that he was indeed a common thief (but also made it impossible for me to redirect his vote to Secura, who I realized was the Cop by then, since I acted scummy as ).

The reason I picked this approach to the last day was that my PM indicates "mafia" victory, which I take is the same as Secura's PM does. So I figured I'd win even if I died (albeit a less impressive win than if the cop died or if I survived).

Methos, I know this game was hard on the innocents but you should consider providing the mafia with a brief summary of the common thief goals. It was impossible to guess the Ringleader one.