The Revenge of Inishmore! [Concluded]

[Thermal]

You know this is WIFOM, Thermal and it isn't going to wash; it certainly looks like a setup, but this could be the response you want people to think, no? "Why would Thermal kill the person accusing him? Mafia wouldn't draw attention to themselves like that"... and so the town looks elsewhere, right?

Your attitude-laden responses really don't do you any favours in regards to the game, because you're only making yourself look shiftier. You can refute claims with a completely rational approach without resorting to sarcasm and such... it might actually help people believe your case.

The issue being that I'm not sure what I'm supposed to be refuting.

[Csargo]

Unvote:Yaropolk, Vote: YLC

You guys should really start voting YLC. Much better choice than TM.

[Secura]

Unvote:Yaropolk, Vote: YLC

You guys should really start voting YLC. Much better choice than TM.

What makes YLC a good lynch choice?

[Csargo]

What makes YLC a good lynch choice?

How would he know that Renata was a reviver? She would have had to of revealed that to him, but she obviously wouldn't do that with the amount of suspicion that has been on him. Smells fishy to me.

@Csargo: Good lord, why? If he knew who the reviver was all this time, then I don't think so.

"I am not a clever man"

you know what I'm talking about, also because I hate freedom

[Splitpersonality]

How would he know that Renata was a reviver? She would have had to of revealed that to him, but she obviously wouldn't do that with the amount of suspicion that has been on him. Smells fishy to me.

Aren't private reveals not allowed in this game or am I confusing it with another game?

or are you implying what i think you are?

[Secura]

How would he know that Renata was a reviver? She would have had to of revealed that to him, but she obviously wouldn't do that with the amount of suspicion that has been on him. Smells fishy to me.

What if Renata wasn't one of those people that thought he was suspicious and did reveal to him, though? It's a possibility.

[Csargo]

What if Renata wasn't one of those people that thought he was suspicious and did reveal to him, though? It's a possibility.

Thermal's right.

You may not reveal in private. You may not, in private, discuss, allude to, hint or in any way attempt to convince a person/party that you have a certain ability or role.

Good lynch is good.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Interesting, the rules do state that private reveals aren't allowed. How does one gain knowledge of who the reviver is?

[Diamondeye]

I'd like an explanation as to why Diamond Eye is voting me, he seems to have a very good reason, so I'd like to hear it.

Okay
You're the guy sending the most scummy vibes in the game.

In which case, fos: diamondeye & captain blackadder

Mind if I ask, what's the deal with me, besides semi-activity?

Vote: Diamondeye - forgot to vote, too busy not sending in kill orders.

Ugh, you figured me out!
No, wait, I'm busy in all the three games - and the two NESes - I'm playing. Not working.

You fool, she is dead, and you just admited to it.

Why is it everyone agrees with this?
Read Renata's death, and then read Thermal's post.
To me, it looks as if Thermal is saying something like this; "If I could kill someone now, it'd be RR". Focus on 1: IF, and 2: It'd be RR. Not Renata. Even if he could kill Renata, he'd be an idiot to crosspost a post that said "if I could kill..." with the writeup of his target dying.

People need to regain their senses, leave Thermal alone and vote: YLC.
I know I'm siding with the prime suspect. I know what light it puts me in. I'm just doing what I can that we don't waste this lynch...

[ULC]

Okay
You're the guy sending the most scummy vibes in the game.


Why is it everyone agrees with this?
Read Renata's death, and then read Thermal's post.
To me, it looks as if Thermal is saying something like this; "If I could kill someone now, it'd be RR". Focus on 1: IF, and 2: It'd be RR. Not Renata. Even if he could kill Renata, he'd be an idiot to crosspost a post that said "if I could kill..." with the writeup of his target dying.

People need to regain their senses, leave Thermal alone and vote: YLC.
I know I'm siding with the prime suspect. I know what light it puts me in. I'm just doing what I can that we don't waste this lynch...

Name what I am doing wrong, and that qoute is sarcasm BTW (don't skim) and the second part is simply reading his statement wrong, as if he said "That was what happens when you mess with me". I'm sorry if I get enraged at watching the town's resurrector die.

[Joooray]

Man this is confusing. From what I can gather, TM seems to be a decent lynch. And mind you, TM, I have read the whole thread till this point.
I don't think the suspicions about YLC are justified. Though I don't think he is necessarily pro-town, the manson role could be rather neutral, it seems he has sided with the town at this point.

Also about the tie business, why would the killer out himself? Also I don't think it's possible to protect someone during the day, which I think has been suggested.

I can't say much about the other suspects, so that leaves me with Vote: Thermal Mercury.

[Secura]

The issue being that I'm not sure what I'm supposed to be refuting.

Well, I would hazard a guess at the accusation that you killed Renata.

[Thermal]

Well, I would hazard a guess at the accusation that you killed Renata.

To which I denied.