Daggers in the Night [Concluded]

**Askthepizzaguy** · 05-25-2010, 22:45

Originally Posted by The Stranger

so... we got a mafia?

vote:beskar

Who are your top 3 suspects, TS?

**Diana Abnoba** · 05-25-2010, 23:01

Yes, I agree. Everyone please post (or you can PM me) with your top 3 suspects.

**atheotes** · 05-25-2010, 23:09

I am glad the town is looking into all possibilities and not confining the drop in kills = i was mafia. After seeing the write up i thought i will have to struggle to get the idea through but i underestimated the players here.

It is a bold move by the mafia. Curious to see how they move forward.

i understand i dont have much credibility right now...but...

I see it as good for the town that there was only one kill. Either they have to keep up the ruse or the lost kill becomes a waste.
The people who will stand to gain the most from this WIFOM will need to be pressured.
the 2 times i played as mafia with Beskar - Netherworld and Shakespearean mafia - he voted for me just to keep us his behavior and more importantly as a distancing tactic. Please get Beskar to talk more - there is nothing to lose by applying pressure.
Same goes for Kage, whose activity has dropped since he came under suspicion.

I am not sure if i am throwing additional WIFOM at the town, but that is not my intention.

**Sasaki Kojiro** · 05-25-2010, 23:16

Kage's activity drop is no big deal. I can see a townie not wanting to keep up with the thread + those long stylized posts. His dropping out is not suspicious.

ps: beskar is equally likely to go for the only 1 kill based on "atheotes is always guilty".

**atheotes** · 05-25-2010, 23:20

Originally Posted by Sasaki Kojiro

Kage's activity drop is no big deal. I can see a townie not wanting to keep up with the thread + those long stylized posts. His dropping out is not suspicious.

ps: beskar is equally likely to go for the only 1 kill based on "atheotes is always guilty".

Kage dropped out when people questioned him why he was not accusing anyone (not hunting for mafia)...thats y i think it is suspicious

**Beefy187** · 05-25-2010, 23:20

ATPG+ Renata (Maybe Diana or Flax...Or Beskar even)
Tincow+ Scienter (Beskar?)

Beskar could fit anywhere.

**TheFlax** · 05-25-2010, 23:24

Originally Posted by Beefy187

ATPG+ Renata (Maybe Diana or Flax...Or Beskar even)
Tincow+ Scienter (Beskar?)

Beskar could fit anywhere.

Your suspecting someone who has been dead for roughly 6 rounds? Beefy dear, what's up with that? Also, what's your obsession with Beskar in this game? Every other round you either vote for him or push for his death.

**Renata** · 05-25-2010, 23:28

Do tell us who you think is guilty, then, atheotes. May as well multiply the WIFOM a bit more, since we're already swimming in it.

You say you were concerned when you saw the write-up. Not, when Diana denied a successful protection.

I'm not sure if I should be questioning a dead person like this, but really:

**atheotes** · 05-25-2010, 23:37

Originally Posted by Renata

Do tell us who you think is guilty, then, atheotes. May as well multiply the WIFOM a bit more, since we're already swimming in it.

You say you were concerned when you saw the write-up. Not, when Diana denied a successful protection.

I'm not sure if I should be questioning a dead person like this, but really:

Did we not discuss the possibility of the mafia intentionally dropping a kill? As soon as i read the write up thats what came to my mind along with the fact that i will not have any credibility. the possibility of a successful protection came only as an after thought and it was quashed very soon because Diana had already posted that info when i was reading the writeup.

**Beefy187** · 05-26-2010, 00:16

Originally Posted by TheFlax

Your suspecting someone who has been dead for roughly 6 rounds? Beefy dear, what's up with that? Also, what's your obsession with Beskar in this game? Every other round you either vote for him or push for his death.

Then again, I forgot that each henchmen get a kill... So if one of them dies, kills drops to one?

Ok then maybe not ATPG, unless atheotes theory is correct.

I still suspect Renata though.

**Niklas** · 05-26-2010, 00:32

Avenge me - kill TinCow!

**atheotes** · 05-25-2010, 23:27

Beefy - i am not considering ATPG to be mafia because the possiblity for that is: He has to be the Ancient One - in which case, the secret role in the game is that of the Ancient coming back to life after getting lynched. I dont know if anyone can understand what i just said

what i am trying to say is: the game is set up such that the Ancient one has to be dead before he/she can truly come back to live forever. And that is the special role in the game.

That is far fetched by any standards. hence i am willing to believe ATPG is town.

**The Stranger** · 05-26-2010, 09:08

Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy

Who are your top 3 suspects, TS?

hmm

beskar and tincow and pevergreen (even if he is not guilty, he has to die)

i think renata is suscpicious too.

other than that i believe beefy and diana to be innocent