Star Fox- Lylat Wars [Concluded]

[Secura]

I would have some validation of some sort by Romanic.

What is Romanic allowed to reveal as a dead player though?

The rules state the following:

Do not reveal information that is not publicly available after you die. Your actions during the night phases, other people's actions, your role, your role PM, communications from the game host, even things you heard as a rumor privately... don't talk about them, don't confirm them when others say them. If you speak after death, you may only refer to IN-THREAD information.

Seems as though validation from Romanic might not be permitted, though I guess the call is ultimately up to the host; Double A claimed Slippy though, so should be able to chip in with the yes/no we require to be certain.

[Beskar]

Seems as though validation from Romanic might not be permitted, though I guess the call is ultimately up to the host; Double A claimed Slippy though, so should be able to chip in with the yes/no we require to be certain.

Previous phase or so, the whole "if Beefy Pinman is a good lynch candidate or not", was permitted. Neither confirms or denies, just gives us an opinion from a Star Fox player we trust.

[Beefy187]

Who ever scanned me, speak up. Because IIRC the Star Fox member with the investigation ability scanned someone else.
Reason why I didn't say that my ability is one time thing is because by not saying it, I thought the mafia might hesitate attacking the star fox team as long as I live.

[johnhughthom]

You're not getting another StarFox member out in the open that easily.

[wideyedwanderer]

Who ever scanned me, speak up. Because IIRC the Star Fox member with the investigation ability scanned someone else.
Reason why I didn't say that my ability is one time thing is because by not saying it, I thought the mafia might hesitate attacking the star fox team as long as I live.

Beefy, this sounds like rubish to me. I'm sticking with my vote on Khazaar for today, but tomorrow...

[Renata]

StarFox can scan for recruitable members of the Star Fox team, I never played the games so I'm going with the others that Rob 64 would definitely be in the game as a member of the Star Fox faction. He was protected and scanned last night, a protection which would have gone on Falco.

I don't get it. Like, at all. Can you start over from the beginning?

[Joooray]

Well, finally there are some interesting candidates to choose from. I have a feeling that both of them are worthy of a lynch, but at this point Khazaar already has enough votes.
So I shall Vote: Beefy considering that he should belong to the inner circle of the Star Fox team and thus it seems odd that there is an accusation like this.

Than again, why is this just now coming up, john?

[Beefy187]

You're not getting another StarFox member out in the open that easily.

Because I already have a contact in the Star Fox team, and his said nothing about me not being RoB64.

[seireikhaan]

Vote: Jooray

[Frozen In Ice]

I think I'm gunna wait and see how this Beefy situtation develops before I accuse anyone.

[Beskar]

I don't get it. Like, at all. Can you start over from the beginning?

Fox can recruit roles like Katt Monroe, this includes other like Slippy, Falco, etc, to rejion his faction. For story reasons, the team is split up into two. Due to distance or something or the other.

If Beefy is indeed Rob64 as he claimed, therefore, Fox should be able to recruit him into the faction officially, thus, joins their quicktopic etc.

Fox scanned Beefy, but he wasn't recruitable. This means he is not a Star Fox team member (which Rob64 actually is). Which means Beefy is a town or a mafia falsely claiming. (Obviously, could be Star Wolf too, but he isn't one of us)

[Askthepizzaguy]

I mean, all they have to do is PM me and go "Hello Beskar" just to attract my attention.

No.... that's no different from such and such just plain old revealing to you privately.

That's adding one step: "If I say hello, that means I am revealing to you privately." that's a rule workaround and against the spirit of the game.

I will WOG whoever tries that.

[Joooray]

Vote: Jooray

That's very nice of you, may I ask why I deserve this honour?

[Beskar]

I apologise, removed.

Though didn't stop you laughing at my desperation on MSN.

[Romanic]

I think we should lynch Beefy! I'm allowed to say that without giving any details.

[very busy today, don't wait for another reply]

[Cultured Drizzt fan]

Vote: Beefy


Because Falco says so.

[seireikhaan]

Mkay

Unvote: Joooray
Vote: Beefy

'Cuz the good guy told me so.

[miotas]

Unvote, Vote: Beefy

[Secura]

I think we should lynch Beefy! I'm allowed to say that without giving any details.

unvote, vote: Beefy187

S'all we needed to know, really.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Actually I have a better solution;

I'm afraid there's been way too much tightrope walking between legal and illegal private communications.

It isn't being used how I intended; which is that normal, basic townies could share opinions about suspects. That's about all you're really allowed to do. Code words and hints and near-reveals and not-reveals but implied reveals..... it's all illegal.


So, it's all done.

Private communication, outside of a host-sanctioned quicktopic, is now ILLEGAL. All forms of it, regarding this game.


I'm afraid I've had more objections to past near-illegal actions, and the only reason they weren't illegal is because I didn't do my job and define the rules well enough. This is my mistake.

In consolation, two sides have made this mistake, and two sides nearly got WOG'ed for it. You're even. It is done. No more private communications at all outside of the quicktopic.

edited into the first post, and will appear in every writeup just to make sure.

[pevergreen]

Vote: Beefy

[Skooma Addict]

Beefy you lying ******!!!! How dare you claim to have revived Falco and then say it was only a one time deal when he died again. You are not Rob 64 and you deserve to go.

Unvote, Vote:Beefy

I had a feeling but was afraid to go balls out on him without anything other then a hunch. His behavior was the same as a previous game I played with him were he was scum and I found it odd that after finding out he was a revival role the mafia went after Falco...again. I was going to wait and see if he survived this following night before voting him since that would mean something is seriously wrong somewhere, but between him and khazaar I do indeed feel he is the better choice. Unvote: Vote Beefy

If he is scum, he deserves a medal for putting his proverbial cojones on the table like that.

Rob64 is a kind of like the R2D2 of starfox. It's possible that all Fox members have a survive 1 night kill power or something to that extent explaining why falco came back and also explaining why no one came forward to dispute Beefy's claim. Someone said earlier that there doesn't necessarily have to be a human controlled Rob64. Think it was Jooorey.

This should be interesting.

[Choxorn]

Unvote, Vote: Beefy187

Because he obviously isn't Rob64.

[Seon]

I think it's time for Beefy to reveal that he actually is the Aparoid Queen and start scaring the daylights out of people.

[Beefy187]

Unvote, Vote: Beefy187

Because he obviously isn't Rob64.

I think it's time for Beefy to reveal that he actually is the Aparoid Queen and start scaring the daylights out of people.

I just might Seon.. I just might :D
I will Vote: Beefy
In hope of me being the Big Bad which I know RoB64 isn't.
And I hope ATPG is doing the "you thought you were goodie but your a baddie!" trick.

Also I know someone scanned Khaan last night and his not neutral.
Whether if thats good or bad... I don't know.

[Krill]

vote: Beefy

[ArpeggiateTHIS]

I cannot wait to tell everybody "I told you so" on this.

[Nightbringer]

hmm, i still am not sure about beefy, i would like to hear the result of the scan before i kill off a possible innocent. im not convinced of kazaar either though so ill just have to wait and see, hopefully i dont miss the vote.
vote: abstain

[hell_hound]

I am so very confused :(

Surely if Falco had a reason for us to kill Beefy surely he would have told us last turn...

[ArpeggiateTHIS]

I am so very confused :(

Surely if Falco had a reason for us to kill Beefy surely he would have told us last turn...

Precisely. So don't vote Beefy.