Random-ice-cream-flavoured friends of the friends [Concluded]

[El Barto]

You guys are making a huge mistake.

scumscumscum is the real enemy here.
You seem to know everything about the scum… your knowledge is too detailed. I call Perfect Information Syndrome. vote: Chaotix

[BSmith]

That makes sense. I've just been going with my gut and my gut said Choxorn earlier in the game. He vociferously put me off, but then we didn't catch any scum. I can't help but want him to be scum, becuase he blipped my scumdar earlier, but I have no clue as to whether or not any of you are smoothing the way to victory. I don't think there's a roleblocker or there would have been a reveal by now.

I thought that Lazy was a rather Resourceful Fellow and had more than gut to go on. My vote will stay on Riedquat, but I think we need to lynch both him and choxorn.

[Riedquat]

You may not have played a lot of games with Double A, but I know you have read many a game played here, Mr Riedquat. I doubt you are unfamiliar with his playstyle.

Or nonplayingstyle, as it were.

Is not the same thing john, you can read a lot but nothing compares to the experience of playing, of course I can recognize certain things from some notable players but not much from the bulk of not so noticeable others. Your style I've learned by experience before I never noticed it so well.


Well I continue to object to your characterization of it as an idiotic plan. After all, it's currently winning the game.

Further, Chaotix knows all about Double A, we've been playing mafia together for what, five years now. If you're scum, the idea need not have come from you directly.

You seem really bummed about being suspected.

Ok, you are undecided, its me or chaotix the designer? Or I designed something with the information I lack or I followed the dead guy plan, which I keep finding idiotic, missing 3 kills? How many are we? Five? pff...

I'm bummed at this situation repeating over and over, first people saying I'm panicking when I'm not and then reaching the end game to get misslynched because I'm middle scummy or not scummy but lynched anyway. :shrug:

[Darth Feather]

scumscumscum is the real enemy here.

Is that your new name?
I can't even recognise Jht's name in it.

[Chaotix]

Is that your new name?
I can't even recognise Jht's name in it.

And yet you still knew exactly who I was talking about...

My master plan has come to fruition! johnhughthom can now be referred to as scumscumscum and everyone will know who I am referring to. MUAHAHAHAHAHAHA!

[Darth Feather]

And yet you still knew exactly who I was talking about...

My master plan has come to fruition! johnhughthom can now be referred to as scumscumscum and everyone will know who I am referring to. MUAHAHAHAHAHAHA!

Not everybody has Force knowledge as I have, I just felt who you meant.

[Ferret]

Apologies for my absence, I've been heavily involved with the Milton Keynes Marathon. At least my vote wasn't missing.

I really don't think Riedquat is mafia, he was instrumental in the lynching of Chaotix and I really can't believe he would miss three kills in a game that he has been active in.

BSmith is still my top suspect, he attempted to save B_Ray early on, steered clear of the Chaotix lynch and has been laying low for the majority of the game.

[johnhughthom]

I also think BSmith is likely scum. The whole forgetting malarkey is just distracting belly button fluff.

[Makrell]

KILL RIEDQUAT

i tell you

trust me on this one

[El Barto]

As always, we keeps a running tally, mateys:
kumquat: BSmith1068; johnhughthom; Double AAnd we runs before it. Cheers!

[Choxorn]

I thought BSmith was town for the longest time after that vote on edse, but now I'm not sure. I've never known him to act anything like this as a mafia, but I don't doubt that he could totally come up with something this brilliant if he was mafia.

And I'm just not sure about Riedquat. Pizza's argument is entirely logical, and since I know I'm townie, that means I should be voting for him. But he just doesn't give off any mafia vibes to me.

[johnhughthom]

I'll make the first move.

unvote; Vote: BSmith

[Askthepizzaguy]

Okay. Let's compromise.

Lynch Reidquat or BSmith today, lynch the other tomorrow.

I'll give choxorn a miss. I need to narrow it down anyway, and I feel Ried was more incriminated.

I also think BSmith's performance was flawless if scum. Kudos to him.

[Choxorn]

Very true. If BSmith is scum, he probably deserves to win at this point.

At the same time, I still can't shake the feeling that he's scum, and he honestly seems like the scummiest person alive at this point.

Vote: BSmith

[BSmith]

Wow. I wish I was as awesome as I would have to be to pull something like this off, but really guys I am (or was, anyway) just a vanilla townie up until this morning.

Pizza asked why I had reasons to dig into Lazy’s opinion. Well. Here they are. This is the end game and I don’t see too much risk in sharing this.

Last night was the first night I received a result PM. It seems that “the man who was found dead” had a bag of goodies on him. I apparently was the closest to him, found this bag and hid it from the others.

The items in the bag let me do one of two things. Guard someone at night, or watch them and see who does stuff to them. Pretty powerful things that if used right could really aid in catching scum.

I am assuming that Lazy was this Resourceful Fellow who owned the bag, which is why I was pinged by his fairly strong statement that Choxorn was guilty. I was hoping by alluding to this in thread that the previous owner (or owners?) of the bag would see it and hint back at me. If Lazy had watched choxorn visit someone, then we probably had our man. That doesn’t seem to be the case though given his response to my questions.

I would have liked to have kept this a little more quiet, and let me do my thing and try to catch this scumbag, but this consistent pressure on me (while it has kept me alive) is getting somewhat tiresome and I’d really rather not be killed today. Not just because this is the end game and we don’t have many more chances, but because of this new ability I have. It would be a shame to waste it.

But wait – now that I have come out with this, what’s stopping the scumbag from just killing me? Well, it turns out that I can use this on myself. So you’ll just have to risk attacking me and having your kill fail, or take your chances that I am not watching your target. Ball’s in your court. But please don’t lynch me.


KILL RIEDQUAT

i tell you

trust me on this one

I can’t help but look at this post in a different light as well. My vote stays on Riedquat for now. If he is innocent then tomorrow I’d look at choxorn. I don’t think AA is our man. He is usually completely AWOL when he misses orders, and he has been posting. It is too much of a stretch to think that Chaotix has been posting his scumbuddy’s name all game. Kudos to them if that is indeed the case.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Meh.

I don't really believe the wacky role-passing role you're describing. It's quite literally a "magic bag."

That said, it takes serious cojones to invent such an implausible thing. Again, if you're scum, BSmith, you're playing a game I admire.

If I were alive I'd vote for Reidquat to give you one last chance for a solve.

[Chaotix]

:bounce:

[Askthepizzaguy]

:bounce:

Not one of your wittier retorts.

[Chaotix]

Not one of your wittier retorts.

~;p

[Double A]

Okay, Pizza's right, a magic bag is just exceptionally silly. unvote, vote: BS

[Askthepizzaguy]

Okay, Pizza's right, a magic bag is just exceptionally silly. unvote, vote: BS

Pizza is right about something, simply because he's said everything that can be said.

That's the secret of successful politicians: take every position so you can claim to be against all bad ideas and for all good ideas.

[Makrell]

I can’t help but look at this post in a different light as well. My vote stays on Riedquat for now. If he is innocent then tomorrow I’d look at choxorn. I don’t think AA is our man. He is usually completely AWOL when he misses orders, and he has been posting. It is too much of a stretch to think that Chaotix has been posting his scumbuddy’s name all game. Kudos to them if that is indeed the case.

i wouldnt really trust me

[Chaotix]

I don't know man.

What if the bag didn't have random things in it, but perhaps... random ice-cream flavors?

Then I'd believe it. I mean, I still have no idea what the name of this game even means.

[Askthepizzaguy]

I don't know man.

What if the bag didn't have random things in it, but perhaps... random ice-cream flavors?

Then I'd believe it. I mean, I still have no idea what the name of this game even means.

Means could be vanilla, could be not vanilla. But leaning 95% vanilla at bare minimum, with no flip that reveals a power role.

I don't understand how the magic bag moves from person to person. That's odd to say the least.

Anyway. I can live with Reidquat and BSmith dying, though he's not my first choice.

[Double A]

I honestly don't see the allure of vanilla. Everyone just ends up putting chocolate on it anyway, though to be perfectly fair, Hershey's does taste better than most varieties of ice cream chocolate. I still get Dippin Dots whenever I can, though.


Pizza is right about something, simply because he's said everything that can be said.

That's the secret of successful politicians: take every position so you can claim to be against all bad ideas and for all good ideas.

I'm in favor of more betterness, less worseness myself.

[Choxorn]

BSmith's magic bag sounds completely ridiculous.

And yet, it doesn't sound like the sort of thing even he could come up with, because it's that totally ridiculous. What mafia in his right mind would invent something that silly? I'm sure there's some easier way he could convince me or john to vote for Riedquat. Unless that's just what he wants us to think...

And Riedquat has made way too little effort to save himself. He should be calling for someone's head, mine, BSmith's, or hell, john or Double A's, just so long as it's anyone but himself. Yet he's not even voting, and he's not trying at all to convince us of anyone's scumminess, just that he isn't going to pull this kind of thing off.

Riedquat cares way too little about this to possibly be the last mafia, and yet BSmith is acting way too ballsy. Double A has, as BSmith pointed out, been a little bit active despite the missing kills, so it's not like he hasn't been around to send in orders. And if he was mafia, why the hell would he not kill to frame himself? That doesn't make any sense at all. And if john is mafia, then he and Chaotix both have evidently stolen ATPG's Diamond Balls.

I just don't know what to do anymore. Whoever the last mafia is, you have played very, very well.

Then of course there's the other option that there's been more than one remaining mafia this whole time, in which case we are right well :daisy:ed.

[Darth Feather]

Wow. I wish I was as awesome as I would have to be to pull something like this off, but really guys I am (or was, anyway) just a vanilla townie up until this morning.

Pizza asked why I had reasons to dig into Lazy’s opinion. Well. Here they are. This is the end game and I don’t see too much risk in sharing this.

Last night was the first night I received a result PM. It seems that “the man who was found dead” had a bag of goodies on him. I apparently was the closest to him, found this bag and hid it from the others.

The items in the bag let me do one of two things. Guard someone at night, or watch them and see who does stuff to them. Pretty powerful things that if used right could really aid in catching scum.

I am assuming that Lazy was this Resourceful Fellow who owned the bag, which is why I was pinged by his fairly strong statement that Choxorn was guilty. I was hoping by alluding to this in thread that the previous owner (or owners?) of the bag would see it and hint back at me. If Lazy had watched choxorn visit someone, then we probably had our man. That doesn’t seem to be the case though given his response to my questions.

I would have liked to have kept this a little more quiet, and let me do my thing and try to catch this scumbag, but this consistent pressure on me (while it has kept me alive) is getting somewhat tiresome and I’d really rather not be killed today. Not just because this is the end game and we don’t have many more chances, but because of this new ability I have. It would be a shame to waste it.

But wait – now that I have come out with this, what’s stopping the scumbag from just killing me? Well, it turns out that I can use this on myself. So you’ll just have to risk attacking me and having your kill fail, or take your chances that I am not watching your target. Ball’s in your court. But please don’t lynch me.



I can’t help but look at this post in a different light as well. My vote stays on Riedquat for now. If he is innocent then tomorrow I’d look at choxorn. I don’t think AA is our man. He is usually completely AWOL when he misses orders, and he has been posting. It is too much of a stretch to think that Chaotix has been posting his scumbuddy’s name all game. Kudos to them if that is indeed the case.

I actually do believe it. It is like the crazy kind of role El Barto would invent.

EDIT: and even if Lazy were the previous owner, he would not have been able to tell it, because he cannot give any new info in thread.

[Darth Feather]

I just want to say I have a strong feeling BSmith is not lying and is completely innocent. The previous owner of the bag can't step forward due to the non-giving new info after death.

[LazyMcCrow]

I don't think BSmith is a good lynch. The 'magic bag' seems like the likeliest explaination for the non-kill nights.

[Darth Feather]

BSmith is a very, very bad lynch. The bag got to be real. Who died recently:

LazyMcCrow
Elite Ferret
Darth Feather

One of these must have dropped the bag, or am I wrong? At least, that is what I can deduce from BSimth's post

[Ferret]

Because no mafia player has ever made a false reveal just as they are about to be lynched...

Having said that I know from previous games that BSmith doesn't like to lie, even when he's scum.

Lynch him anyway, if his crazy story is true then the bag will just go to someone else tomorrow.

[LazyMcCrow]

Maybe BSmith IS scum and also got the bag. From my experience, BSmith is certainly a man with a back up plan when he's scum, but his recent posts seem townie to me.

[B-Wing]

I don't understand how the magic bag moves from person to person. That's odd to say the least.

It was obviously planted at the crime scene by the murderer - a red herring, no mas. I probably shouldn't have told you that...

Note to self: that's another good idea for future mafia games.

[BSmith]

I don't understand how the magic bag moves from person to person. That's odd to say the least.

My guess is that it goes to a random townie in the event of the holders death. It would be too OP if it went to a scumbag.


BSmith's magic bag sounds completely ridiculous.

And yet, it doesn't sound like the sort of thing even he could come up with, because it's that totally ridiculous. What mafia in his right mind would invent something that silly? I'm sure there's some easier way he could convince me or john to vote for Riedquat.

This. There is NO way I’d come up with a cockamamie story like this if my life was on the line. I have been playing this game for over 2 years now and I have never seen a mechanic like this. I’d pick something much more believable.


I actually do believe it. It is like the crazy kind of role El Barto would invent.

EDIT: and even if Lazy were the previous owner, he would not have been able to tell it, because he cannot give any new info in thread.

Now to read between the lines, because DF is right that dead townies can’t give new information. But they can post in a way that gets their point across a little less directly. I have made enough information public for them to hide behind.



I don't think BSmith is a good lynch. The 'magic bag' seems like the likeliest explaination for the non-kill nights.

This is the most direct quote I think is possible from the most likely person to have had the bag before me. An opinion that given the context can confirm my story. If he had said “I don’t know what you are talking about” then it would be a different story.


I just want to say I have a strong feeling BSmith is not lying and is completely innocent. The previous owner of the bag can't step forward due to the non-giving new info after death.


BSmith is a very, very bad lynch. The bag got to be real. Who died recently:

LazyMcCrow
Elite Ferret
Darth Feather

One of these must have dropped the bag, or am I wrong? At least, that is what I can deduce from BSimth's post

My theory – DF had the bag first, and when he died it went to Lazy. Notice how he is being adamant that I am a bad lynch, and also includes himself in his list of who might have had the bag? Why do that if you don’t know anything about it? These statements of support are as direct as can be given by a dead townie in this situation.


i wouldnt really trust me

This is Makrell telling me that he never had the bag, and there isn’t anything behind his push for Riedquat’s lynch.


Having said that I know from previous games that BSmith doesn't like to lie, even when he's scum.

This is a dead true read on me. Impressive since we haven’t played all that many games together, let alone where we were both scum (or you were GM) to pick up on this. I don’t like to lie, even in a game where it is expected and even encouraged.

[BSmith]

My gut's telling me we should unvote; vote JHT and then choxorn.

[johnhughthom]

My gut is telling me you are getting desperate.

[BSmith]

Look closely at who is pushing for my lynch. The best way for the scum to get rid of me is to lynch me. Killing me is going to be much harder.

We have at least two confirmed townies vouching for my story. Think about that.

The scum need to lynch me, and lynch me now. I am too big a threat to their win.

[Askthepizzaguy]

I still say get Riedquat.

[Riedquat]

I only come to apologize for my lack of participation, terribly busy these last couple of days, everybody is sick and I'm under a ton of paperwork, my top suspect keeps being Bsmith, but now I just need to read all from my last post as I don't know what is going on.

[Askthepizzaguy]

I only come to apologize for my lack of participation, terribly busy these last couple of days, everybody is sick and I'm under a ton of paperwork, my top suspect keeps being Bsmith, but now I just need to read all from my last post as I don't know what is going on.

Reidquat is either a cleverly "hidden in plain sight by jumping on the random bandwagon" scum or the ever-increasing in popularity "What the ____ is going on?" townie. Either way I want to lynch him.

[El Barto]

Tally
BSmith: johnhughthom; choxorn; Double A
johnhughthom: BSmith

not voting: Riedquat.

Eight hours remaining for the lynch!

[BSmith]

Come on people. Lynching me is a very bad idea. Let's not be stupid in the end game.

[Darth Feather]

Come on people. Lynching me is a very bad idea. Let's not be stupid in the end game.

Listen to B. He is, and has been completely right in all his posts.

[Makrell]

mystery bag

[BSmith]

Listen to B. He is, and has been completely right in all his posts.

Thank you. There is now absolutely zero reason to be voting me. Let's go after the actual scum here, ok?

[LazyMcCrow]

Thank you. There is now absolutely zero reason to be voting me. Let's go after the actual scum here, ok?

I hope I'm not stepping on protocol here by stating that all the posts he made since BSmith 'revealed' make me think he is town, and also that he probably thinks I'm cleverer than I actually am. :bow:

[johnhughthom]

Unvote

I'll not be taking part in the game any longer, replace me if you wish, El Takewer

[LazyMcCrow]

Unvote

I'll not be taking part in the game any longer, replace me if you wish, El Takewer

How come?

[BSmith]

What? Why?

[Riedquat]

Uff... thought I wasn't going to reach in time!


Reidquat is either a cleverly "hidden in plain sight by jumping on the random bandwagon" scum or the ever-increasing in popularity "What the ____ is going on?" townie. Either way I want to lynch him.

Well.. I was going to say I am neither of those but with the recent events...

Last time I checked yesterday I had a couple votes on me, now I've none and everybody is voting Bsmith except him is voting jht who just...


Unvote

I'll not be taking part in the game any longer, replace me if you wish, El Takewer


What? Why?

+1 What the :daisy: is going on? :inquisitive:

I was going to say my top suspect keep being Bsmith but he is the only suspect I have, I know nothing of john or Double A and choxorn is out of the list from the start.

Well I go with Vote: Bsmith

[BSmith]

unvote; vote: Riedquat..

Seriously. Everyone else better be scum, or I'll be sorely disappointed. I don't know how much clearer it could have been that my story was legit.

Scums won this game. We lost. Well played as I still have no effing idea who you are. Unless it is all of you.

[El Barto]

Day Twelve
Yet again, a townie was lynched.

BSmith: choxorn; Double A; Riedquat (3)
johnhughthom: BSmith (1)

Not voting: johnhughthom (1)
BSmith was town!

Living
Double A
Riedquat
choxorn
townhughthom

Dead
robbiecon, town, killed Night One.
B_Ray, Mafia, lynched Day Two.
edse, town, killed Night Two.
Jarema, town, lynched Day Three.
rickinator9, town, killed Night Three.
Chaotix, Mafia, lynched Day Four.
Major Robert Dump, town, killed Night Four.
Montmorency, town, lynched Day Five.
Visorslash, town, lynched Day Six.
Diana Abnoba, town, killed Night Six.
Askthepizzaguyman, town, lynched Day Seven.
Darth Feather, town, killed Night Seven.
Ishmael, town, lynched Day Eight.
Seon, town, lynched Day Nine.
Makrell, town, lynched Day Ten.
Elite Ferret, town, killed Night Ten.
Ibn-Khaldun, town, lynched Day Eleven.
LazyMcCrow, town, killed Night Eleven.
BSmith, town, lynched Day Twelve.

It is now Night Twelve, which will last for 24 hours.
Time remaining: .

[BSmith]

Lynch or lose tomorrow if there is only one left. If there are two the game is over.

Good job in making the bag useless tonight. It could have saved a kill, or better yet found the killer.

:soapbox:

[Askthepizzaguy]

And that's game, since john is dropping out.

Good game scumbags. If it was Reidquat, I told you so...... eventually.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Double A <--- swears he'd send in orders when active, doesn't seem like Chatoix would bus his final partner by pointing fingers at him deliberately with no-kills
Riedquat
choxorn
townhughthom <---- not this guy for obvious reasons


That leaves the two people who threw Chaotix under the bus, as I mentioned, and the guy who doth protest too much and also tied the vote, be Reidquat.

Now then, since the game is "continuing" anyone else want to give their final guesses?

[BSmith]

choxorn.

[Choxorn]

Riedquat.

[Askthepizzaguy]

I'd be happy losing to choxorn. played a better game than the rest of us.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Riedquat.

No really.... u think?

[Choxorn]

I'd be happy losing a game to me, too, but I'm not the scum you're looking for, because I'm a 100% vanilla townie.

[Riedquat]

:no: I am not mafia!! And I know I'm going to be lynched tomorrow not matter what and it is like a bloody deja vu repeating over and over...

[Ishmael]

My guess is jht. I've been suspicious of him all game, and his 'dropping out' is clearly just a cunning ploy.

(alternately, I may be voicing this suspicion as it won't actually count for anything, and in the unlikely event that I'm correct I get to act smug).

[LazyMcCrow]

No idea. My guts still rumble..."Choxxxorrrnnngngnngn"

[Chaotix]

It's obviously scumscumscum.

[Makrell]

townfakescum it is

[El Barto]

New tally, with spam, baked beans, egg, spam and spam:

Oh, no tally. Heh-heh.

[El Barto]

NIGHT TWELVE (Endgame)

The four remaining people decided to stay up all night, playing Card Wars. They reasoned that, if all were awake, none could suddenly kill one of the others because the other two would prevent it. jht, formerly known as townhughthom, johnhughthom, and occasionally confused with a Frenchman called le Comte du Chatoix, didn't really fancy playing. In fact, kumquat nearly got dangerous and told him to play, or else. But, just as when Double A and Riedquat (his and choxorn's opponents) were about to win, jht suddenly flooped the pig. And then, Double A lost it. Really, really lost it. Not just the game, mind you, but everything. He upended the table, then took out a knife, and stabbed wildly. Kumquat didn't really try to stop him, and Choxorn noticed, even though he'd been watching Double A all evening with the aid of some items from some mysterious bag. Just as Choxorn started moving forward to try and stop Double A with a soda syphon loaded with rock salt, Riedquat made an incredibly fast motion -like this! HAI-YAA!- and tripped him. choxorn and his bag fell down the trapdoor and out of the treehouse, hitting the ground with a dry thud.
*dry thud sound effect*
Double A started practising different maniacal laughs, while Riedquat went down below to fetch the mysterious bag. I, Takhisis, 'El Barto' the Renewer, can swear that I saw with my own eyes how the bag (that really wasn't supposed to be magical, but, if enough people believe in magic, things can become magical) rose in the air, and then vanished in a puff of smoke. Riedqat didn't really mind, as the main goal was complete, and went back up the ladder. And so I set into the sunset, while my wizard eyes allowed me to see some ghosts arguing, and betting whom among the town leaders would be the first to flip out at discovering that the lack of kills was accidental…

johnhughthom was town!
Choxorn was town!
Living
Double A
Riedquat

Dead
robbiecon, town, killed Night One.
B_Ray, Mafia, lynched Day Two.
edse, town, killed Night Two.
Jarema, town, lynched Day Three.
rickinator9, town, killed Night Three.
Chaotix, Mafia, lynched Day Four.
Major Robert Dump, town, killed Night Four.
Montmorency, town, lynched Day Five.
Visorslash, town, lynched Day Six.
Diana Abnoba, town, killed Night Six.
Askthepizzaguyman, town, lynched Day Seven.
Darth Feather, town, killed Night Seven.
Ishmael, town, lynched Day Eight.
Seon, town, lynched Day Nine.
Makrell, town, lynched Day Ten.
Elite Ferret, town, killed Night Ten.
Ibn-Khaldun, town, lynched Day Eleven.
LazyMcCrow, town, killed Night Eleven.
BSmith, town, lynched Day Twelve.
johnhughthom, town, killed Night Twelve.


MAFIA VICTORY

Congratulations to Double A and Riedquat (the living Mafia) and the remaining mafia, B-Ray and Chaotix.
I hope everyone enjoyed it.

[El Barto]

A message from the mafia:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qFtaCLDLrMg

And now the history of the game:Night One
robbiecon killed
no other actions.

Day Two
B_Ray lynched

Night Two
Chaotix kills edse, disembowels him with a rusty spoon.

Day Three
Jarema lynched

Night Three
rickinator9 killed.

Day Four
Chaotix lynched.

Night Four
Major Robert Dump killed.

Day Five
Montmorency lynched.

Night Five
riedquat killed (converted).

Day Six
Visorslash lynched.

Night Six
Diana killed.

Day Seven
Pizza lynched.

Night Seven
Darth Feather watches LazyMcCrow
Darth Feather killed--> stuff goes to Lazy McCrow:

It would seem that the man who was found dead had a bag with assorted items which you, being the nearest person, managed to hide before anyone else realised it was there.

Congratulations! It is 'a large paper bag with a corkscrew, some bandages, a gallon of lye, a ping-pong ball, a package of rock salt, a soda syphon and a few other items that no one who's ever watched MacGyver wouldn't know how to use.'

Every Night Phase you might choose to target another player, you can either Guard that player, preventing them from becoming killed if they are indeed attacked, or watch that player and see if anyone else targets them.

You can't use the abilities more than three nights in the whole game in all (limited supplies, man!), and, since you've never actually done these things, it takes you a little time to gear up your McGyver-y antics. So you can't use the same ability two nights in a row. If I were you, I'd use them sparingly.
It must have belonged to soem Resourceful Fellow. Use it well.

Day Eight
Ishmael lynched.

Night Eight
No kill.

Day Nine
Seon lynched.

Night Nine
…er, no kill?

day Ten
Makrell killed.

Night Ten
Elite Ferret killed

Day Eleven
Ibn-Khaldun lynched.

Night Eleven
LazyMCCrow jht LazyMcCrow killed. --> stuff goes to BSmith
It would seem that the man who was found dead had a bag with assorted items which you, being the nearest person, managed to hide before anyone else realised it was there.

Congratulations! It is 'a large paper bag with a corkscrew, some bandages, a gallon of lye, a ping-pong ball, a package of rock salt, a soda syphon and a few other items that no one who's ever watched MacGyver wouldn't know how to use.'

Every Night Phase you might choose to target another player, you can either Guard that player, preventing them from becoming killed if they are indeed attacked, or watch that player and see if anyone else targets them.

You can't use the abilities more than three nights in the whole game in all (limited supplies, man!), and, since you've never actually done these things, it takes you a little time to gear up your McGyver-y antics. So you can't use the same ability two nights in a row. If I were you, I'd use them sparingly.
It must have belonged to soem Resourceful Fellow. Use it well.

Day Twelve
BSmith lynched --> stuff goes to choxorn.
It would seem that the man who was lynched had a bag with assorted items which you, being the nearest person, managed to hide before anyone else realised it was there.

Congratulations! It is 'a large paper bag with a corkscrew, some bandages, a gallon of lye, a ping-pong ball, a package of rock salt, a soda syphon and a few other items that no one who's ever watched MacGyver wouldn't know how to use.'

Every Night Phase you might choose to target another player, you can either Guard that player, preventing them from becoming killed if they are indeed attacked, or watch that player and see if anyone else targets them.

You can't use the abilities more than three nights in the whole game in all (limited supplies, man!), and, since you've never actually done these things, it takes you a little time to gear up your McGyver-y antics. So you can't use the same ability two nights in a row. If I were you, I'd use them sparingly.
It must have belonged to soem Resourceful Fellow. Use it well.

Night Twelve
Choxorn watches Double A --> result: no targets.
The mafia kill jht and win the game.

[El Barto]

A carbon copy of the text file describing the setup:


Mafia: Chaotix, Double A, B_Ray
You are the friends of the friends. You have one team kill at night. May luck be on your side, for the hearts of all good townsfolk and burghers are certainly not.

(yes, you may start a team QT if you wish, send me the address).

widow: kumquat
You are The Widow. Your Husband was a mafioso, until he was betrayed to the police who killed him while attempting to escape. Now you wish to continue his good work, but have no idea who his remainign companions are or who to trust. One thing is sure: you're liable to be captured and killed if the filthy townsfolk ever know about you.

VC: The Mafia win.

(will become SK if all others have been killed and she is still alive)

Pentiti: Diana, Robert
You are a Pentito, a former Mafioso who has turned in evidence against them and is now keeping a low profile hoping to hide from the Mafia. The people still think you are a criminal (or would if they found out your real name) and the only way to clear your name would be to have the still unrepentant portions of the Mafia kill you, which wouldn't be exactly convenient.

Jack-of-all-trades: Darth Feather
You are A Resourceful Fellow. You have a large paper bag with a corkscrew, some bandages, a gallon of lye, a ping-pong ball, a package of rock salt, a soda syphon and a few other items that no one who's ever watched MacGyver wouldn't know how to use.
Every Night Phase you might choose to target another player, you can either Guard that player, preventing them from becoming killed if they are indeed attacked, or watch that player and see if anyone else targets them.

You can't use the abilities more than three nights in the whole game in all (limited supplies, man!), and, since you've never actually done these things, it takes you a little time to gear up your McGyver-y antics. So you can't use the same ability two nights in a row. If I were you, I'd use them sparingly.

And of course, yes, you're a townilicious townsfolk.

bag of all trades to be reassigned if DF dies.

^I was really peeved that the bag wasn't used until the very last night, and then it didn't have any effect.
^^I didn't tell Robert and Diana anything about each other
^^^The mafia didn't know about the widow until, as you can see in the post above, they tried to kill riedquat and suddenly found they had a new teammate. Heh-heh. Surprises for everyone.

That's all, folks!

-El Barto

[Double A]

We were surprised as you all probably are now when Ried became mafia. He said he was mafia all game long, and I was pretty damn impressed with him for being so townie we tried to kill him.

By the way, the second time there was no kill, I sent orders to kill Warman, thinking he and Elite Ferret were the same person. The night after we all just kind of herp derped up.

Half truths are fun.

[Riedquat]

When I contributed in Chaotix lynching I was sure he was townie, scummy of course but townie! That unfortunate accident made possible to form my perfect townie cover! Perfect to everybody except for Atpg... :rolleyes:

The no killing plan was idiotic!! :laugh4:

[Double A]

Oh, and here's the QT.
http://www.quicktopic.com/50/H/cgQKQiHrRkPD

[El Barto]

Hey, everyone else is invited to post as well!

[Double A]

It's Friday night, I bet a third of the players are off doing things and another third are sleeping.

It's that other third you gotta watch.

[Diana Abnoba]

Four mafia total ~:shock:. Town was screwed rounds ago and didn't even know it :wall: :laugh4:. Well played mafia :applause: Congrats on your win.

Thanks El Barto for hosting. :bow:

[Askthepizzaguy]

Told ya Reidquat was guilty.

[Choxorn]

I'm not sure what I was expecting. Riedquat's role? Nope. Not at all.

And I agree with Takhibartoreva about the bag. Would have been pretty helpful to the town if it had been used more than once, although it did have limited uses and Darth Feather had no way to know that it would go to someone else still with full uses if he died.

[Darth Feather]

It would have been a waste if I used it early on I wouldn't have gotten a thing out of it. Once I was quite sure about some people being town, I was going to start watching LazyMcCrow, riedquat (I didn't realize he was scum), Choxorn and Elite Ferret.

I died before they did. :sad:

Thanks for hosting, El Barto. It was fun.

[Double A]

Told ya Reidquat was guilty.

You were right about so many things but subsequently dropped them because you thought there were only three mafia (or at least that's the impression I got). You had me sweating for the entire game. I definitely had fun trying to outwit you but it was really damn hard. Good game, Pizzaman.

And that goes for you other townies, too.

[Makrell]

good game me likesi

[Askthepizzaguy]

You were right about so many things but subsequently dropped them because you thought there were only three mafia (or at least that's the impression I got). You had me sweating for the entire game. I definitely had fun trying to outwit you but it was really damn hard. Good game, Pizzaman.

And that goes for you other townies, too.

Good game for you as well. Didn't know there were other roles. Felt 4 scums versus all vanilla would have been OP, so I aimed for whoever I thought was the scummiest at the time.

If Reidquat died and flipped scum it would have been a bad day for ya. But luckily for you, they stopped listening to me after I punished Ishmael for having the gall to replace in.

[Darth Feather]

We should have killed DoubleA or Riedquat yesterday and not BSmith.
That gave the mafia victory.

That and some confusing, yet great mafia play.

[Choxorn]

Yeah, I was thinking that too, and I would have probably changed my vote if I hadn't been busy or if I'd expected more than one mafia left.

[Ferret]

By the way, the second time there was no kill, I sent orders to kill Warman, thinking he and Elite Ferret were the same person.

I have never been more insulted in my life :clown:

Thanks for hosting El Barto.

The town started so well I thought we might absolutely nail it, not so much in the end...

[johnhughthom]

Very well played, scummers. I would never have guessed it was Riedquat and AA. :2thumbsup:

[LazyMcCrow]

gg and thanks for hosting. LOVE the roles you used. My scumdar was way off. Well played mafia :bow:

[Riedquat]

If Reidquat died and flipped scum it would have been a bad day for ya. But luckily for you, they stopped listening to me after I punished Ishmael for having the gall to replace in.

And we were preparing us for that scenery, town listened to you but decided Choxorn was more scummy than me... :sweatdrop:



I have never been more insulted in my life :clown:

Elite Ferret Warman88andalotofstuffmore :laugh4: I would be insulted too!



We should have killed DoubleA or Riedquat yesterday and not BSmith.
That gave the mafia victory.

That and some confusing, yet great mafia play.

With one of us killed earlier it was going to be a rough end for sure.

Good game everybody! And Bartito, thanks for hosting! Any day I will invite you with a complete "Menu Rosarino" :eyebrows:

[Makrell]

is el barto and trewa the renewer the same?

zomg

[Double A]

I have never been more insulted in my life :clown:

Sorry about that. :sweatdrop: I was seriously wondering why Warman actually made a contributing post, though.


The town started so well I thought we might absolutely nail it, not so much in the end...

You might've if I hadn't been in Arizona the first few phases, though Ried would've had more time, more kills, and no partner to try to save.

[Choxorn]

is el barto and trewa the renewer the same?

zomg

Yeah, he's the same. He's also Takhisis on CFC.

[Makrell]

wow

mind is blown,

also people should use a similar theme across websites, for example fishtheme

[B-Wing]

Congratulations to my team mates, and good game to everyone! Entertaining game, thoroughly enjoyable to keep up with, despite being the first person lynched.

I thought this was a very interesting concept, El Barto, gracious host, and I thank you for your work. The bag of goodies is a cool alternative to power roles, and the fact that it passes on to a new player whenever its carrier dies is a nice way of ensuring balance. I like it a lot.

Would the Pentitos have flipped mafia if they had been lynched instead of murdered?

[Ishmael]

Nicely played mafia. Honestly, I never really suspected either of the surviving scum - I would have called for the lynch of either of the townies before either of the mafioso :laugh4:. Great job.

[El Barto]

Thanks for all the compliments! Seems that the crazuy setup worked out fien after all. And, compliments to you lot, because you actuallly played. Our KotOR game last year half-fell apart because of inactivity on both sides.

On Chaotix's antics: I allowed it because it was fair since I was also allowing Pizza, Diana, etc. to continue issuing opinions.

I'm not sure what I was expecting. Riedquat's role? Nope. Not at all.
Hah! I threw in a few cool roles and left it to the players to see if they figured out some things.

And I agree with Takhibartoreva about the bag. Would have been pretty helpful to the town if it had been used more than once, although it did have limited uses and Darth Feather had no way to know that it would go to someone else still with full uses if he died.

It would have been a waste if I used it early on I wouldn't have gotten a thing out of it. Once I was quite sure about some people being town, I was going to start watching LazyMcCrow, riedquat (I didn't realize he was scum), Choxorn and Elite Ferret.

I died before they did. :sad:
Well, it was intended for people to try and use it. You never thought of giving it away either.

Good game everybody! And Bartito, thanks for hosting! Any day I will invite you with a complete "Menu Rosarino" :eyebrows:
Why on earth would I, of all people, want to have cat meat?


is el barto and trewa the renewer the same?

zomgYeah, he's the same. He's also Takhisis on CFC.
And I have many other usernames you might have stumbled upon without noticing… I'm EVERYWHERE.

I thought this was a very interesting concept, El Barto, gracious host, and I thank you for your work. The bag of goodies is a cool alternative to power roles, and the fact that it passes on to a new player whenever its carrier dies is a nice way of ensuring balance. I like it a lot.
The point of this was to have a jack-of-all-trades (without things that were pointless, like tracking, because the only other one out there would be the mafia killing, and with four mafias, this'd be too difficult to nail as there wasn't even a designated killer), and so the town would always have a power role, until the very end, but a rather limited one.

Would the Pentitos have flipped mafia if they had been lynched instead of murdered?Awww yeah man! This might have given the mafia a clue about Riedquat, but it never happened.

[Choxorn]

Note to self: Everywhere is one of Takhisis's usernames on... some site.

[Ibn-Khaldun]

This was a good game.

[El Barto]

Well the thread title still says it's in play but the game's over. Who's hosting next?