View Full Version : Small Mafia Game Pratia III
Darth Feather
12-01-2013, 15:20
Define PG. (Newbie, sorry) :help:
Personal Goal
crossroad
12-01-2013, 15:25
Personal Goal
Thanks DF! :happy2:
Personal Goal
Meaning the may have a goal to kill certain individuals, or have a goal to be the last female in the group(lol)
Riedquat
12-01-2013, 16:18
Everyone knows my name is Brett. Seems fair to me! :idea2:
Hayden Matthews (edse) stood over Aaron Anduin (autolycus) as he slept. Bloodlust grew evermore in the man's heart as he stared down at the only remaining descendant of Areos Anduin. Aaron was not on the list provided to him by his superiors, he had no real reason to kill him, but this man's vendetta for the eradication of the Mobilian people was shallow by comparison to his desire to wipe out the Anduin name.
He stooped down over the boy, contemplating the cruelest way he could kill him quietly. After deciding a hand over his mouth and a knife through the eye would suffice, he noticed a small stream of light creeping up towards them. He looked at the wall and noticed a small crack and the hint of the sunrise.
His orders were to eliminate the “potential threats” and hand the rest over to the army on the seventh morning. He looked back at Aaron, sleeping peacefully, knowing full well that if he didn’t leave now he could get caught in the crossfire. Anger rose, he did not get the chance he wanted. He wanted to watch Aaron die, torture him, feel his agony and bask in it. The man bent down and whispered in the boy’s ear, “You will suffer. I promise. My brothers are here.”
Pratia was upon Mobile once again, initiated by an explosion sending the large steel doors of the outpost flying. The massacre had begun…
Fair?
Fair?
Michael will probably save Aaron to last. That's at least what I would do :rolleyes:
Darth Feather
12-01-2013, 18:27
Michael will probably save Aaron to last. That's at least what I would do :rolleyes:
So you were michael and you are coming back from beyond the grave.
Murdered a pregnant woman! For shame!!! :whip:
Come now, that's too far. I convinced the town to murder her, by a fair vote. It was much more amusing to let you all have the stain of guilt on your souls.
crossroad
12-01-2013, 23:23
Come now, that's too far. I convinced the town to murder her, by a fair vote. It was much more amusing to let you all have the stain of guilt on your souls.
Well played, mafia scum, well played. :bow:
The Sixth Night
Tension was heavy in the camp as they lie down for the night. If Kassy Garnett was really pregnant, then yesterday's lynching was more. It was also a murder of an unborn child, and most were not okay with that.
At this point though, most were convinced their problems were solved, and that tomorrow morning eleven pairs of eyes would open. Unfortunately they were wrong.
Night fell and as usual Michael and his partner took the shift...
"Why?" His follower asked.
"Because I was reckless..." Michael replied, solemnly. "I never got your name?"
His follower turned, and paused before saying, "Owen... Owen Thatcher."
They shook hands, and Owen went off with Michael's knife toward Margaret McGill (Riedquat). He stooped over her body under the watchful eye of his mentor, and hesitated at the sight of her face. He froze, came to, looked around at the faces beneath him, and finally shoved the knife into her neck severing the spinal cord. She died instantly, and Owen returned to Michael.
Michael nodded his head, "You're ready."
Day Phase 7 has begun!
Time Remaining:
crossroad
12-02-2013, 01:25
Vote: Ishmael
vote: abstain
That's confirmation, if nothing else is.
Vote: Ishamel
Vote: End day early
Chief Pappy
12-02-2013, 01:32
Vote:Ishmael
Good play, desperation false reveal, brilliant.
That's confirmation, if nothing else is.
I would have thought my earlier gloating over Lux's death would have been confirmation enough.
Vote:Ishmael
Good play, desperation false reveal, brilliant.
:bow:
I would have thought my earlier gloating over Lux's death would have been confirmation enough.
:bow:
Are you Michael or Owen?
Are you Michael or Owen?
I'm afraid you'll have to wait until the end of this day phase to find out. I probably shouldn't be posting at all - I'm the sort of person who slips up and gives information away accidentally.
I'm afraid you'll have to wait until the end of this day phase to find out. I probably shouldn't be posting at all - I'm the sort of person who slips up and gives information away accidentally.
Who is your scum partner and what does he do?
Who is your scum partner and what does he do?
:laugh4:
Accidentally, I said.
:laugh4:
Accidentally, I said.
11353
Anyway, we're one (scum) down. I'd like to look at those that supported Ishamel (besides myself obviously, I was completely fooled. Pity you don't play for NSW then Ishmael :laugh4:)
Riedquat
12-02-2013, 02:12
Now my sprit is one with Ryan Cavanaugh! We will hunt you down scum!
Just lets hope there isnt any mechanich involved like the time we choose to lynch edse in the previous game...
Zain is gearing it up for Pratia IV. When you all vote out Michael (Ishmael) he'll still have this Owen character for the next game. Oh the brilliance of it all. :laugh4: Unless of course you have to find Owen too, now that he's graduated from observer to Killer.... The student has become the master. :sweatdrop:
Mechanics that mess with the lynch are HEAVILY ANNOYING.
In any case, rereading the thread for scums.
Mechanics that mess with the lynch are HEAVILY ANNOYING.
In any case, rereading the thread for scums.
Lesson learned last time, not to be repeated :bow:
Lesson learned last time, not to be repeated :bow:
Cheers, good to know.
Obviously Visorslash is the other scum.
That entire conversation between the two of them was scripted.
Obviously Visorslash is the other scum.
That entire conversation between the two of them was scripted.
I'm far too lazy to script anything. Ask any of my scum partners ever.
I think its more likely that Owen Mitchell doesnt exist and that Chaotix is scum.
I'm far too lazy to script anything. Ask any of my scum partners ever.
I think its more likely that Owen Mitchell doesnt exist and that Chaotix is scum.
Eh, I meant more like lightly scripted.
Like Jersey Shore scripted.
Like in your little quicktopic Ishmael was like, "Okay I'm going to make it obvious that I'm scum and then you're going to call me out on it to make you look innocent."
And then that's more or less what happened, but it's not like you knew exactly what you were going to say beforehand.
I think Owen Mitchell definitely exists, otherwise he wouldn't be in the write-up. I don't think that is his real name, neither do I think Michael is using his real name in his cover role. Because if they were, this game would be too easy.
Eh, I meant more like lightly scripted.
Like Jersey Shore scripted.
Like in your little quicktopic Ishmael was like, "Okay I'm going to make it obvious that I'm scum and then you're going to call me out on it to make you look innocent."
And then that's more or less what happened, but it's not like you knew exactly what you were going to say beforehand.
I think Owen Mitchell definitely exists, otherwise he wouldn't be in the write-up. I don't think that is his real name, neither do I think Michael is using his real name in his cover role. Because if they were, this game would be too easy.
Yes, because I hard defend Ishmael for two days straight? Why would I out myself like that?
Besides, I'm not in the original group.
Riedquat
12-02-2013, 03:26
Riedquat (Killed) scanned so far:
Ferret
I-K
rickinator9
Lux
All guilty
Ferret (Lynched) tie breaker, never got to use his ability
rickinator9 (killed) scanned:
DF
Riedquat
Crys (replaced by chaotix)
Lux
All innocent
I-K protected:
Makrell unsuccessful by passive power
Ishmael
rickinator
Lux
-
Ishmael attacked:
Makrell
Chief Pappy (from the first group)
Blocked by Lux
Rickinator9
?
Lux (miss-lynched) blocked:
Bsmith
Makrell
Ishmael
Visorlash
Makrell Pasive power:
-indestructible at night shown in the write up
-indestructible at night (here blocked by two different blockers)
-indestructible at night
-indestructible at night
Minion Owen actions:
Makrell by write up and again unsuccessful by passive power
A mosquito and failed
Scratched his nose or possible usage of minion power against Lux
Scratched his nose or possible usage of minion power against Lux
Attacked and killed an extenuated woman while sleeping after a wild party with the true men of town, perhaps jealous he never got invited! :laugh4:
Riedquat
12-02-2013, 03:39
I'm far too lazy to script anything. Ask any of my scum partners ever.
I think its more likely that Owen Mitchell doesnt exist and that Chaotix is scum.
Aaron Anduin exist, he was mentioned in the write ups, several times. And nobody else claimed to be him. Aaron can't be the minion.
I think Owen Mitchell definitely exists, otherwise he wouldn't be in the write-up. I don't think that is his real name, neither do I think Michael is using his real name in his cover role. Because if they were, this game would be too easy.
If Owen exist or is an invented name is irrelevant, Michael exist and is an invented name by Hayden Mathews, this is his real name! And Ishmael claimed to be a woman... Ann I don't know what if he is Michael/Hayden he has three names! Irrelevant!
Yes, because I hard defend Ishmael for two days straight? Why would I out myself like that?
Besides, I'm not in the original group.
First part is exactly what Chaotix thinks about the script. Second part self explain why he (Visor) can't be the minion, who got recruited from the start.
For once, stop barking at each other, both have their own quote of scummy statements but obviously both are wrong!:bow:
dcmort93
12-02-2013, 03:53
I don't think anything more than Vote: Ishmael needs to be said
Riedquat
12-02-2013, 04:01
I don't think anything more than Vote: Ishmael needs to be said
That is the important part, but a lot more needs to be said! Is your role male or female? For you, who can be the minion?
Edit:
Living players from original group:
BSmith
crys/Chaotix (scanned as innocent, claimed Aaron Anduin, male)
Darth Feather (scanned as innocent, claimed female)
dcmort93
Ibn-Khaldun (doctor and female by self claim)
Makrell (Passive power, attacked by both killers first night)
Ishmael (dead man talking)
:rolleyes: One of these is the minion!
Darth Feather
12-02-2013, 09:25
That's a no-brainer: Vote: Ishmael
But maybe we should be thinking about who the second evil guy is. I would guess BSmith due to lurekerism.
That's a no-brainer: Vote: Ishmael
But maybe we should be thinking about who the second evil guy is. I would guess BSmith due to lurekerism.
I dont think i have ever seen a nonlurking bssmith, but the rule of lurkers is that they always show up when mentioned.
BSmith
My general participation in this game has been pretty poor, but that has mainly been due to a ton of RL stuff going on last week (I moved and had Thanksgiving). This is one of the first times I have been at a keyboard in over a week. That said, I am back to a more normal schedule now, so I should be much more active going forward.
My name is Noah Andrews, and naturally I am a male.
I think it goes without saying that we need to vote: Ishmael today.
Riedquat
12-02-2013, 15:31
That's a no-brainer: Vote: Ishmael
But maybe we should be thinking about who the second evil guy is. I would guess BSmith due to lurekerism.
First probable, BSmith and dcmort, but there is a slim possibility it is someone who already claimed but not confirmed by a third party, Makrell and I-K, with the pertinent doubts every one can have, by last you and Chaotix, both cleared by scan, the most unlikely case of course.
I dont think i have ever seen a nonlurking bssmith, but the rule of lurkers is that they always show up when mentioned.
BSmith
Oh, I saw him in active mode and remember a good reasoning form him in form of wall of text... very very scummy! :P
Ghostly vote: Ishmael
Vote is unanimous against Ishmael aside from Ibn-Khaldun who hasn't voted yet and Ishmael himself. If I-K votes soon we will end the round early.
Ibn-Khaldun
Ibn-Khaldun
12-02-2013, 15:41
Vote: Ishmael
Like if there is another option?!
Well okay then! I'll post the write-up once I get a chance to actually write it
The Seventh Day
Aaron Anduin was the first to wake up this morning and did his usual morning routine. He walked up to the stream they had been following and took a drink, taking in the morning smell. It truly was beautiful, however he missed his family. He missed his friends. He missed the bakery next door and the smell of fresh bread in the mornings. He missed the old man who sold trinkets and candy, Mr. Olney.
He heard a panic behind him, and yet again a body was found in their camp. Margaret McGill, self proclaimed detective and investigator, as paranoid as ever.
His anger surged, he was fed up with all of it. All of the lies and deception, the killings. He clenched his fists and his teeth and walked straight up to their "fearless leader" Michael Engels.
Michael was standing over the body as Charlie checked her pulse when Aaron's forceful push sent him off balance and onto his back. "You did this!" Aaron raged as he stood over him.
Bret, a larger man with broad shoulders and big hands held Aaron back while Michael got up. "What are you doing, kid??"
Aaron didn't back down, "You're the murderer! We trusted you Michael! We trusted you!"
"Woah, woah, calm down. Sounds like Kassy yesterday, can't keep in your guilt boy?"
Aaron tried to tear from Bret's grip but did not succeed, "Don't you all see it?" He looked at the others, aside from himself and Michael were five men and three women. "He's been the one accusing from the beginning, saying he's "seen them" but why didn't he ever stop them? Yesterday he murdered a woman who said she was pregnant without blinking an eye. Does that sound like a leader to you? Does that sound like a man you want to follow?"
Bret let Aaron go, stunned by what the boy was saying. Aaron approached Michael, real close, "Admit it."
Michael's face contorted, for the first time he didn't have control. He pulled out his knife and so did many of the members of the group, all backing Aaron.
Michael smiled, "No. I'm not "Michael Engels". My name is Hayden Matthews (Ishmael), Prater special forces and assassin." The entire group gasped, time stopped for a moment. All eyes were on the man they had known as Michael, now admitting to being the famed enemy of Mobile.
Charlie spoke up, "You were attacked by the assassin in the Outpost. Weren't you?"
Michael aka Hayden responded, "I knew your man Ripley Tasker would save me. I knew he was capable."
The evil in his eyes was startling, he gazed at Aaron. "They told you I killed your father. They lied. Your father is Isaac Throckmorton, General of the Prater army."
He took the knife and shoved it deep into his temple, his body dropped to the ground and died within seconds.
Aaron, stunned, walked up to his body. What Hayden had said, was it true? No, it can't be...
"He's a liar." Aaron responded. "We'll be at the coast by nightfall, let's go."
The reign of Hayden Matthews is over, but now another threat looms amongst them...
Night Phase 7 has begun! PM me asap!
Time Remaining:
rickinator9
12-02-2013, 20:49
Finally that Talker filth has been killed.
dcmort93
12-02-2013, 21:01
For the record my name is Tristan Toft, a male. If you want my ability I will give it to you privately however. I have to keep some secrets ya know
Riedquat
12-02-2013, 21:44
For the record my name is Tristan Toft, a male. If you want my ability I will give it to you privately however. I have to keep some secrets ya know
Private communication is not allowed! ;)
Riedquat
12-02-2013, 21:53
"They told you I killed your father. They lied. Your father is Isaac Throckmorton, General of the Prater army."
So.. he is Aaron Throckmorton? :dizzy2:
Darth Feather
12-02-2013, 22:01
For the record my name is Tristan Toft, a male. If you want my ability I will give it to you privately however. I have to keep some secrets ya know
That's not quite a good move as town. Scum will know you have a good pro-town ability.
names will not work now that michael is dead anyhow, we dont know the name of michaels accomplice(if someone does please share)
"Because I was reckless..." Michael replied, solemnly. "I never got your name?"
His follower turned, and paused before saying, "Owen... Owen Thatcher."
Makrell, you do know their names, Michael (Ishmael) and Owen (???) , males.
Edit: quote from Night phase six, post #509.
dcmort93
12-02-2013, 23:39
That's not quite a good move as town. Scum will know you have a good pro-town ability.
But at the same time if I reveal my ability they know exactly what it is and can counter act it as necessary
Makrell, you do know their names, Michael (Ishmael) and Owen (???) , males.
Edit: quote from Night phase six, post #509.
my fault
Then i am roosevelt gardener
Owen is going to have a cover name as well. I doubt the names will be helpful.
We can try to force reveal everyone's names if you want, it might be worthwhile. Most likely there will be no Owen.
I also find it hard to believe that only a male role name could be this mafioso. It's a serious oversight if nearly half the players can be cleared (especially with name mention in the write-ups) just by being female.
Owen is going to have a cover name as well. I doubt the names will be helpful.
We can try to force reveal everyone's names if you want, it might be worthwhile. Most likely there will be no Owen.
I also find it hard to believe that only a male role name could be this mafioso. It's a serious oversight if nearly half the players can be cleared (especially with name mention in the write-ups) just by being female.
Oh like Owen Schimdt? but yes cearing the females is silly. (although i think most of the females are dead(more fodder for my femaledestroyer theory))
11359
My general participation in this game has been pretty poor, but that has mainly been due to a ton of RL stuff going on last week (I moved and had Thanksgiving). This is one of the first times I have been at a keyboard in over a week. That said, I am back to a more normal schedule now, so I should be much more active going forward.
But you have the time to post to me in the org minecraft thread twice? Have you strayed away form the group? To KILL!!!!
26.11. Welcome! We need a harbor and by extension some more ships. Once you get in the game let me know if there is anything you need.
28.11. Not sure offhand. There is free stuff in the noob hotel just east of the spawn. Other chests in town (by the town hall) have building materials that can be used for town improvements.
crossroad
12-03-2013, 14:52
So.. he is Aaron Throckmorton? :dizzy2:
A hint for Pratia IV ?!
Owen is going to have a cover name as well. I doubt the names will be helpful.
We can try to force reveal everyone's names if you want, it might be worthwhile. Most likely there will be no Owen.
I also find it hard to believe that only a male role name could be this mafioso. It's a serious oversight if nearly half the players can be cleared (especially with name mention in the write-ups) just by being female.
Is there a way to truly force reveal? If so, let's do it!
But you have the time to post to me in the org minecraft thread twice? Have you strayed away form the group? To KILL!!!!
I never said I was not online. I just didn’t have the time to dedicate to a lot of posting in this (or any other game I am in). I have posted at least once a game day here, as I don’t think I missed any votes. I’ve just been spread really thin.
Take a look at any of the other games I am in (here and at CFC) and you’ll see a similar pattern.
This is not a “lets lurk because I am scum and that is what I do as scum” kind of thing.
Chief Pappy
12-03-2013, 17:53
The scum is part of the original group, we know that for sure.
He will attack a member of the new group so as to not raise his own chances of being discovered.
Doctor's, if you chose to protect a member of the old group, I beckon you to change your orders to someone in the new group!
Riedquat
12-03-2013, 18:40
The scum is part of the original group, we know that for sure.
He will attack a member of the new group so as to not raise his own chances of being discovered.
Doctor's, if you chose to protect a member of the old group, I beckon you to change your orders to someone in the new group!
At some point he will need to dispatch the people of the old group too... Doctors should be protecting themselves!
Zain
C'mon, I want to lynch some scum. :tongue:
crossroad
12-04-2013, 03:50
Zain
C'mon, I want to lynch some scum. :tongue:
He must be attending to some important official Host duties!
:washing: :music: :holiday: :couch: :date: :tredmil: :painting:
Riedquat
12-04-2013, 13:16
:quiet:~:confused:
The Seventh Night
The campfire crackled under the watchful eye of Owen Thatcher, along with Charlie who volunteered to cover the watch in Michael's stead. Heart thumping, knowing exactly what he needed to do, Owen was wide awake.
Charlie leaned over, "You got this?"
"What?" Owen asked, confused.
"I need to take a piss, I'll be right back."
Owen, unsure of what he was going to do, finally saw the light, the hope he needed to pull off the murder. "Sure."
Charlie walked away, behind a tree in the forest. He went far in, further than Owen was expecting. Perfect, he thought.
Owen, who could tell all of the other members were asleep, quickly pulled out his knife and approached the big guy Bret (crossroad) who had joined them just a few days ago. Without much hesitation, but with a sweaty forehead and palms, Owen stabbed the knife deep into Bret's temple, killing him instantly.
He returned to his place on the log next to the fire. After some time, Charlie returned. "Nature called." He said again in jest.
Owen meditated on what just happened, his nerves were on fire, heart beating profusely. He had succeeded though on a thin line. How did Michael do this so calmly?
Day Phase 8 has begun!
Time Remaining:
Riedquat
12-04-2013, 19:29
Now! Who were doing what with who? Charlie! Who were on the watch with you? :P
Chief Pappy
12-04-2013, 20:36
:shrug: Zain likes to mention the named characters. I think he's trying not to expose player's names this game so to avoid the reveal problem in Pratia 2...
Darth Feather
12-04-2013, 20:50
:shrug: Zain likes to mention the named characters. I think he's trying not to expose player's names this game so to avoid the reveal problem in Pratia 2...
But Chaotix has most likely lynch immunity. I mean, he is Aaron Anduin.
Vote: BSmith Even though lurker as town you lurk as scum as well. (IIRC someone said on CFC you lurked you to a mafiavictory again.) Also, Zain doesn't like lurkers.
Chief Pappy
12-04-2013, 22:36
Also, Zain doesn't like lurkers.
Judging by the amount (or lack thereof) of discussion these past few days, I'd say we're all lurking... :shame:
Riedquat
12-05-2013, 00:24
Judging by the amount (or lack thereof) of discussion these past few days, I'd say we're all lurking... :shame:
Talk for yourself I've Troll mode turned on! But a bit tired of answering my own questions, that is true.
Now you the living go back and look for who never wanted to put a vote on Ishmael, exclude the dead and the new group, we can't analyse Ishmael's votes because he almost always voted Lux.
crossroad
12-05-2013, 02:09
Sad. :sad:
Really not sure what your line is there Chaotix. I'm obviously not Owen, I've claimed Leigha which Chief can confirm. I cannot be Owen both genitally and physically and the fact I wasn't even in the game when Owen happened.
Aaron-Owen are sorta similar.
I'm busy doing a lot of writing and mowing lately so I'll go back and do some rereading on what happened with the Lux-Ishmael debacle later tonight. I'm certain we should be able to find some solid proof of the scum, or at least narrow it down.
and the fact I wasn't even in the game when Owen happened.
Expound on this?
I don't consider your cover name or gender any form of proof of innocence, as I mentioned earlier. The last part I don't understand.
Expound on this?
I don't consider your cover name or gender any form of proof of innocence, as I mentioned earlier. The last part I don't understand.
Go read the write ups. Crossroad, chief pappy v2 and myself were not in the game when the minion was in the game. We literally can't be scum (original)
Expound on this?
I don't consider your cover name or gender any form of proof of innocence, as I mentioned earlier. The last part I don't understand.
they are a cult or something, but not praters.
Vote: bssmith
Care to share your name?
Go read the write ups. Crossroad, chief pappy v2 and myself were not in the game when the minion was in the game. We literally can't be scum (original)
Well... you could be scum.
But you are not Owen.
Unvote, Vote: BSmith
Riedquat
12-05-2013, 13:36
Chaotix... I'm angered, I explained before why Visor couldn't be Owen, from town nobody differed of my humble opinion but you keep ignoring everything I've said, it is so difficult to understand what I've said? And I can't be Owen because he killed me! Visor or Chief Pappy can't be Owen because Owen existed from first day while them didn't.
Now, tell us about your father Aaron, how was it? I mean, your mother was Anduin's wife? Or she wasn't even your mother and you are a kidnapped child from Pratia raised as mobilian?
If town doesn't talk and BSmith is not our guy we will be in serious trouble soon! Now, talk! :stare:
Riedquat (Killed) scanned so far:
Ferret
I-K
rickinator9
Lux
All guilty
Ferret (Lynched) tie breaker, never got to use his ability
rickinator9 (killed) scanned:
DF
Riedquat
Crys (replaced by chaotix)
Lux
All innocent
I-K protected:
Makrell unsuccessful by passive power
Ishmael
rickinator
Lux
-
Darth feather
Ishmael attacked:
Makrell
Chief Pappy (from the first group)
Blocked by Lux
Rickinator9
?
Lux (miss-lynched) blocked:
Bsmith
Makrell
Ishmael
Visorlash
Makrell Pasive power:
-indestructible at night shown in the write up
-indestructible at night (here blocked by two different blockers)
-indestructible at night
-indestructible at night
Minion Owen actions:
Makrell by write up and again unsuccessful by passive power
A mosquito and failed
Scratched his nose or possible usage of minion power against Lux
Scratched his nose or possible usage of minion power against Lux
Attacked and killed an extenuated woman while sleeping after a wild party with the true men of town, perhaps jealous he never got invited! :laugh4:
Dudes, seeing as youve all revealed there is no reason not to reveal whom you targeted, if someone blocked Bssmith for example he should be cleared.
@ibn-khalduin
And i have no idea what all youve other got for powers, except you have them, do what you deem wise. But would like to know some info from the new guys, one of you gotta be a detective or doctor i think. (unless both are cult)
IK is a doctor.
I'm vanilla.
What's this cult thing you keep rambling about?
Riedquat
12-05-2013, 14:29
Dudes, seeing as youve all revealed there is no reason not to reveal whom you targeted, if someone blocked Bssmith for example he should be cleared.
@ibn-khalduin
And i have no idea what all youve other got for powers, except you have them, do what you deem wise. But would like to know some info from the new guys, one of you gotta be a detective or doctor i think. (unless both are cult)
Agree but... first BSmith need to say everything he knows, everything, the more he delays his reveal less chances he has to get away from the lynch...
I wonder what powers the rest of you have, gender scanner could be a really handy one at present...
Agree but... first BSmith need to say everything he knows, everything, the more he delays his reveal less chances he has to get away from the lynch...
I wonder what powers the rest of you have, gender scanner could be a really handy one at present...
Gender scanner should really be available to everyone... but this is a mafia game, where everyone is almost completely blind.
Ibn-Khaldun
12-05-2013, 15:36
Dudes, seeing as youve all revealed there is no reason not to reveal whom you targeted, if someone blocked Bssmith for example he should be cleared.
@ibn-khalduin
And i have no idea what all youve other got for powers, except you have them, do what you deem wise. But would like to know some info from the new guys, one of you gotta be a detective or doctor i think. (unless both are cult)
I protected Darth Feather last night.
IK is a doctor.
I'm vanilla.
What's this cult thing you keep rambling about?
I think it has been established that noone is vanilla in this game, so either you are hiding something, or you have some kind of dormant power you dont know about, you might have clues about it though in your pm.
the cult is the possibility that the new guys are a third party, plotting in the shadows.
Zain said it would end bad for us, then three new guys, so far they dont seem to be original mafia, but i bet atleast one of you is a third party.
I think it has been established that noone is vanilla in this game, so either you are hiding something, or you have some kind of dormant power you dont know about, you might have clues about it though in your pm.
the cult is the possibility that the new guys are a third party, plotting in the shadows.
Zain said it would end bad for us, then three new guys, so far they dont seem to be original mafia, but i bet atleast one of you is a third party.
I'm vanilla deal with it.
IK your protections are sounding very suspect right about now.
Why would you not protect either crossroad or myself...
Vote: bssmith
Care to share your name?
I already did?
My name is Noah Andrews, and naturally I am a male.
Dudes, seeing as youve all revealed there is no reason not to reveal whom you targeted, if someone blocked Bssmith for example he should be cleared.
Lux blocked me back on N1…
I am going to vote: chaotix today. He seems to be intentionally misconstruing things.
Vote: abstain
Too many scumbags in this game.
Chaotix, what can you do?
Vote Tally:
BSmith: 3 (DF, Makrell, Chaotix)
Chaotix: 1 (BSmith)
Abstain: 1 (Visorslash)
Non-voting: Ibn-Khaldun dcmort93 Chief Pappy
Riedquat
12-05-2013, 17:03
Lux blocked me back on N1…
I am going to vote: chaotix today. He seems to be intentionally misconstruing things.
Umm.. you are right... but voting Chaotix isn't very productive, it is like the exact thing he is doing...
I'm vanilla deal with it.
IK your protections are sounding very suspect right about now.
Why would you not protect either crossroad or myself...
More suspicious than believing you are vanilla? You must be kidding! If you don't have an ability, invent it!
Vote: abstain
Too many scumbags in this game.
Chaotix, what can you do?
As Aaron Anduin with nothing else than write-ups and the attention call to himself, I guess another doctor!
Now be a good townie and stop being so scummy!
Chief Pappy
12-05-2013, 17:25
Here's my synopsis.
Myself and Visorslash and clear from being Owen. Our names have been announced via writeup as Charlie and Leigha.
BSmith - Typically a lurker, especially up til recently, justified reason. Seems less scummy than others at this point but still concerns me.
Chaotix - Obviously distracted, claimed Aaron Anduin. Doesn't clear him but for now removes him from my sites regardless of how strange his arguments may seem. No offense meant.
Darth Feather - Fairly active, doesn't stir up much trouble. Claimed doctor and no one has questioned him thus far. Innocent? Probably
dcmort93 - Lurker. No information on his ability. Innocent? I don't think so.
Ibn-Khaldun - Less active than DF, same feeling. Claimed doctor and no one has questioned him so far. Innocent? Also, probably
Makrell - Strange comments about his ability, about how it's "failed" although he's supposedly impervious to mafia scum. Innocent? I don't think so either...
Scumminess gauge:
MOST - dcmort93 & Makrell
Maybe - BSmith & Chaotix
least - Darth Feather & Ibn-Khaldun
Everybody is aiming for BSmith but he's not my prime suspect. For now, because of the vagueness of his ability, I'm going to
Vote: Makrell
Chief Pappy
12-05-2013, 17:48
Also, because Ishmael was mafia, only blocks on him seem to mean anything. He's dead and Owen has taken over. All blocks prior to Michael's death are now worthless.
Riedquat's scans dont mean anything either...
Rickinator's could mean something though, let's see who he scanned.
DF - Proclaimed doctor, as I said above, innocent by my standards.
Riedquat - Dead, innocent.
Crys (replaced by chaotix) - Aaron Anduin, innocent.
Lux - Roleblocker, innocent.
So this leaves us with BSmith, dcmort93, Ibn-Khaldun, and Makrell who haven't been scanned as "innocent"
Of the list the red flags go up against all but Ibn who like I said has claimed doctor and hasn't caused any fuss.
dcmort and Makrell have been very vague about their role or at least confused me enough, BSmith same story but he's been characteristically inactive.
Zain this game is so involved, I feel like I'm truly there and the paranoia is real. Well done! Excellent game series!
Ibn-Khaldun
12-05-2013, 18:06
I'm vanilla deal with it.
IK your protections are sounding very suspect right about now.
Why would you not protect either crossroad or myself...
Because you and crossroad were in the new group and like people have mentioned there might be a scum/mafia/bad guy in the new group.
Vote Tally:
BSmith: 3 (DF, Makrell, Chaotix)
Chaotix: 1 (BSmith)
Abstain: 1 (Visorslash)
Non-voting: @Ibn-Khaldun (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/member.php?u=25845) @dcmort93 (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/member.php?u=33565) @Chief Pappy (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/member.php?u=98228)
Vote: dcmort93
I guess he could be Owen. He claimed to be Tristan Toft, male, but this could be just a cover. He is not inactive and always comes to vote but then disappears again. Typical lurker-mafia.
I am quite wary of us having two claimed doctors who have not been targeted by the mafia and do not seem to have actually protected anyone from dying.
As Chief Pappy mentioned, having been blocked early in the game means nothing. Ishmael was doing all of the killing. Nobody is cleared from Owen by virtue of being blocked unless it was on a night that Owen killed.
Nobody is cleared from being Owen by their name or gender. He should have a cover role and if not, these things can be faked.
The new group are cleared from being Owen but not from being anti-town. They are not a priority and should be left alone unless this game continues after Owen's death.
---
As for my role:
My role PM does not mention anything about my parents besides the fact that Areos Anduin was pretty famous.
My special ability is that my votes count for double.
I am entirely expendable.
Riedquat
12-05-2013, 18:36
I... forgot? Missed? Where DF claimed doctor? :dizzy2: Please somebody enlighten me!!
Chief Pappy
12-05-2013, 19:14
:study::book2:
My name is Crystal Perreault. I am not sure wether I am male or female. (What kind of name is that, Crystal?)
:inquisitive:~:confused:
This is the only reveal he's given, where did the idea of him being a doctor come from??
edit:
I must've misunderstood something from Makrell's list... :shame:
Who are you, DF?!
Darth Feather
12-05-2013, 19:42
Darth Feather - Fairly active, doesn't stir up much trouble. Claimed doctor and no one has questioned him thus far. Innocent? Probably
Scumminess gauge:
MOST - dcmort93 & Makrell
Maybe - BSmith & Chaotix
least - Darth Feather & Ibn-Khaldun
What post did I claim doctor? I mean I am a doctor but it seems like a lucky guess. ~:confused:
Ibn-Khaldun
12-05-2013, 20:18
If Darth Feather did not claim being a doctor before then how did CP know it?!
Chief Pappy
12-05-2013, 20:31
What post did I claim doctor? I mean I am a doctor but it seems like a lucky guess. ~:confused:
If Darth Feather did not claim being a doctor before then how did CP know it?!
Cat's out of the bag... My role is of an investigator but it's considered a "Psychic" so instead of getting an alignment result I get a role result.
First night we joined (Night 4, edse was lynched the next day) I didn't get to use it but then the next night (when rickinator was murdered) I investigated Ishmael and got the "mafia" role result. I fought hard to take him down but Lux was lost instead... The next night, the one when Riedquat was murdered I investigated Darth Feather and he came out as "doctor". We lynched Ishmael that next day, thankfully, and last night I ended up choosing to investigate Crossroad but he was murdered anyway. Crossroad was a "vanilla townie".
I didn't want to reveal because I knew my role was very powerful and didn't want to become a huge target. Apologies to Darth Feather for revealing his secret too, since he was probably keeping it a secret for the same reasons.
dcmort93
12-05-2013, 20:38
Seeing as how most people have claimed their roles I may as well. I'm a bodyguard and I can protect people, but there is a bit of a catch thus why I haven't used my ability yet. Now however things aren't so hit or miss so I can start protecting people, however how long that lasts depends.
Darth Feather
12-05-2013, 21:13
But wait. Isn't the game essentially broken if two doctors exist and only one scum? I mean, we could protect each other every night, becoming invincible masons. As the scum have only one member we can outvote them anyway. I would like our role-scanner to scan Ibn-Khaldun.
I didn't want to reveal because I knew my role was very powerful and didn't want to become a huge target. Apologies to Darth Feather for revealing his secret too, since he was probably keeping it a secret for the same reasons.
It would have been out sooner or later anyway. I couldn't hide forever. People were growing suspicious of my silence about my role. (I think)
Riedquat
12-06-2013, 01:02
:pleased: Not so fast friends! Something is off, I mean really off!
Everybody has a role... I don't know if it was here or in the Pratia II game, but Zain said everyone was going to get a role...
So who is or was role-less?
Autolycus? We will never know. Edse, same. BSmith, not telling, mentioning or referring to it. Visor, well... you know, just one of the new comers is backupping (sp?) him, with the just deceased crossroad, also a newcomer... I don't buy it, to me every single one of us got a role! At this moment this is not very important but lets keep in mind an interesting thing. Why Chief Pappy scanned one of themselves? We all, are tired of pointing out Owen is from the original group, what do you gain as townie scanning one of the newcomers, absolutely nothing!
DF, do you care to tell us your protections so far?
We went from 60-80 posts in a day phase to less than half!
I believe since it was a short round and the main suspect was lynched, you all need another day. Interesting information has presented itself and I would like for everyone to have a chance to react.
24 hour extension!
Time Remaining:
If you view the thread in the Forum Default setting, every 30th post is on top of the page.
Double post for the timer to be visible on the new page.
edit:
Fail... :gah2:
If you view the thread in the Forum Default setting, every 30th post is on top of the page.
Double post for the timer to be visible on the new page.
Time Remaining:
Double post...
:wall::wall::wall:
Teh Interwebz...
Riedquat
12-06-2013, 01:27
BSmith Unknown
Chief Pappy (2nd role) psychic investigator New Comer
crys Chaotix (Replacement) Double voter
Darth Feather Doctor
dcmort93 Bodyguard
Ibn-Khaldun Doctor
Makrell Indestructible
Visorslash Vanilla New Comer
Dead Players: (9/17)
autolycus - D2 Unknown
Ferret - D3 Tie breaker
Chief Pappy - N3 Drunk man
edse - D5 Unknown
rickinator9 - N5 Investigator
Lux - D6 Blocker
Riedquat - N6 Paranoid Investigator
Ishmael - D7 Hayden Mathews
crossroad - N7 Vanilla New Comer
Come on, lie to us! With this heavy role game, two of the newcomers are vanilla? Really?
Riedquat
12-06-2013, 01:30
Double post...
:wall::wall::wall:
Teh Interwebz...
:laugh4: More like quadruple! But thanks for the extension!
Riedquat
12-06-2013, 01:44
But wait. Isn't the game essentially broken if two doctors exist and only one scum? I mean, we could protect each other every night, becoming invincible masons. As the scum have only one member we can outvote them anyway. I would like our role-scanner to scan Ibn-Khaldun.
Why to protect each other if you can protect yourself? Also, it didn't worked very well in the previous game and we had 3 doctors... Also, have you just discovered you are a doctor or what? you never pointed a finger against I-K... another oddity, Chieff Pappy scanned you, again, instead of scanning someone who never got scanned...
Chief Pappy's scan is different from the other scans, like he mentioned. He is a role investigator, not an alignment investigator, although apparently he also gets results for players when "mafia" is their role.
There is (in general) no need to be so suspicious of night actions. Most players send their night actions without coordinating or checking what other players have done. It is not sinister, it's just ignorance.
What we ought to be looking at is players' relations to Ishmael. Anybody who voted for Lux on the day Lux got lynched instead of Ishmael should be suspect.
EDIT: Also, unless there is some caveat to our two doctors' protections, and there is only one kill per night, yes we have a way to win without fail and the game is broken. I suspect someone is lying or hasn't revealed an extra aspect of their protection ability.
Unvote: Vote Dcmort
from the roles the bodyguard and double voter are the easiest to fake. (+mine)
Also, i ask that chaotix use his ability today, meaning vote for the person one behind. and break the tie :)
Riedquat (Killed) scanned so far:
Ferret
I-K
rickinator9
Lux
All guilty
Ferret (Lynched) tie breaker, never got to use his ability
rickinator9 (killed) scanned:
DF
Riedquat
Crys (replaced by chaotix)
Lux
All innocent
I-K protected:
Makrell unsuccessful by passive power
Ishmael
rickinator
Lux
-
Darth feather
Ishmael attacked:
Makrell
Chief Pappy (from the first group)
Blocked by Lux
Rickinator9
?
Lux (miss-lynched) blocked:
Bsmith
Makrell
Ishmael
Visorlash
Makrell Pasive power:
-indestructible at night shown in the write up
-indestructible at night (here blocked by two different blockers)
-indestructible at night
-indestructible at night
Minion Owen actions:
Makrell by write up and again unsuccessful by passive power
A mosquito and failed
Scratched his nose or possible usage of minion power against Lux
Scratched his nose or possible usage of minion power against Lux
Attacked and killed an extenuated woman while sleeping after a wild party with the true men of town, perhaps jealous he never got invited! :laugh4:
Chief pappy Investegator
5- Ishmael - mafia
6- DF - Doctor
7- Corssroad - vaNILLa townie
Darth Feather
Night 1: Protected Chief Pappy
Night 2: Forgot to send in orders
Night 3: Protected Crys
Night 4: Protected rickinator
Night 5: Protected Riedquat
Night 6: Don't remember at all. I think I protected Visor but I am not sure
Night 7: Protected Chaotix I think
Darth Feather
care to share your results?
Darth Feather
12-06-2013, 10:00
Night 1: Protected Chief Pappy
Night 2: Forgot to send in orders
Night 3: Protected Crys
Night 4: Protected rickinator
Night 5: Protected Riedquat
Night 6: Don't remember at all. I think I protected Visor but I am not sure
Night 7: Protected Chaotix I think
(I should remember to keep notes in the future.)
you seem to be one night to early for every protection lol :P
Darth Feather
12-06-2013, 10:56
you seem to be one night to early for every protection lol :P
Didn't notice that untill now. kinda tragic.
Riedquat
12-06-2013, 13:44
Night 1: Protected Chief Pappy
Night 2: Forgot to send in orders
Night 3: Protected Crys
Night 4: Protected rickinator
Night 5: Protected Riedquat
Night 6: Don't remember at all. I think I protected Visor but I am not sure
Night 7: Protected Chaotix I think
(I should remember to keep notes in the future.)
Err... That is why I created the bloody list...
But, DF I urge you to check your results pm or check with Zain and be sure of what you are saying, some things doesn't add up in that list...
Ugh. Really don't like this, feels empty, but Vote: Bsmith. Narrow the field.
Vote Tally:
BSmith: 4 (DF, Chaotix, Makrell, Visorslash)
Chaotix: 1 (BSmith)
Makrell: 1 (CP)
dcmort93: 1 (I-K)
Non-voting: dcmort93
Ibn-Khaldun
12-06-2013, 15:35
I haven't got any results PM. If I succeed protecting someone it will be shown in the write-up. I guess it's the same for DF as well. However, how could he protect CP if night 1 was the phase when edse went with his answers to those weird people? It was said that during night 1 we can't use our powers.
Huh seriously?
Unvote; Vote: DF
Riedquat
12-06-2013, 15:55
I haven't got any results PM. If I succeed protecting someone it will be shown in the write-up. I guess it's the same for DF as well. However, how could he protect CP if night 1 was the phase when edse went with his answers to those weird people? It was said that during night 1 we can't use our powers.
Right... I forgot about results, was thinking of myself but you always can check sent messages, and there is something else really odd in the actions he informed very related at what you just noted.
Didn't want to mention it before he clarifies... and still don't want to... but...
Darth Feather
12-06-2013, 16:54
Right... I forgot about results, was thinking of myself but you always can check sent messages, and there is something else really odd in the actions he informed very related at what you just noted.
Didn't want to mention it before he clarifies... and still don't want to... but...
I saw in my outbox: Night 1 action, night 3, night 4, night 5, night 6, night 7, so I figured I must have sent something night 1.
But I might have made some mistake. I asked the host whom I protected.
MAYBE I made a mistake and labelled night two as night 1. That's why I thought I forgot to send in orders. (Due to RL I was kinda chaotic.)
Riedquat
12-06-2013, 18:24
I saw in my outbox: Night 1 action, night 3, night 4, night 5, night 6, night 7, so I figured I must have sent something night 1.
But I might have made some mistake. I asked the host whom I protected.
MAYBE I made a mistake and labelled night two as night 1. That's why I thought I forgot to send in orders. (Due to RL I was kinda chaotic.)
I believe the part about night 1 actually being night 2, but there is a problem there, if night 1 was actually night 2, night 4 would be night 5, you protected rickinator the night he died? :dizzy2:
You were scanned two times, every single thing you have said has sense, also your participation on thread is exemplar but your claim is really weak and messy...
Darth Feather
12-06-2013, 18:41
I believe the part about night 1 actually being night 2, but there is a problem there, if night 1 was actually night 2, night 4 would be night 5, you protected rickinator the night he died? :dizzy2:
You were scanned two times, every single thing you have said has sense, also your participation on thread is exemplar but your claim is really weak and messy...
I asked clarification to the host. My claim IS messy. I know that.
Riedquat
12-06-2013, 19:10
I asked clarification to the host. My claim IS messy. I know that.
I know you know, I was just writing down my ghostly thoughts and explaining why you don't deserve my humble ghostly FoS :P
Also I've learned the lesson with what happened to Ferret in the last game!
Unvote, Vote: Darth Feather
Smells fishy.
Darth Feather
12-06-2013, 20:29
Ok, Something is terribly wrong with my memory. (Well I did have a rough time lately due to RL)
These were my protection actions.
Night 2 - Riedquat (Scanner)
Night 3 - crys (Kinda random)
Night 4 - rickinator9 (more usefull scanner)
Night 5 - Forgot to send in orders
Night 6 - crossroad (One of the newcombers so innocent)
Night 7 - dcmort93 (Claims Superpower)
I also figured the reasons for my protections. (My memory needed a great whipping)
Darth Feather
12-06-2013, 20:44
Wait... I have been scanned doctor, and I am in the lead for the vote? That's just ridiculous. I know I have been rather chaotic and errative lately, but come on.
Riedquat
12-06-2013, 20:58
Unvote, Vote: Darth Feather
Smells fishy.
Yes and no! With all the time DF invested playing this game, discussing and posting, if he was mafia he easily could come with a solid account of every night action. When I did the list Makrell keep updating was to keep track of my own actions that were becoming a mess in my own memory.
Also, two different investigations of him resulted, innocent and doctor... he is not a good candidate for todays lynch :no:
Riedquat
12-06-2013, 21:09
Chief Pappy's scan is different from the other scans, like he mentioned. He is a role investigator, not an alignment investigator, although apparently he also gets results for players when "mafia" is their role.
Scanned DF as doctor, the alignment scanner got innocent from DF and you...
Unvote, Vote: Darth Feather
Smells fishy.
There are things more fishy than him at present!
I start to wonder with what town you are aligned to... mobilians or pratians
I'm just not sure if I trust that his story is true.
He could have easily been faking it and just scrambled to make it sound coherent when parts of it didn't check out. Further, he might have even been clever enough to have made himself sound disorganized to seem more innocent. It's all WIFOM.
If you think somebody else is more suspicious, let me know. I don't know what BSmith has done this game either, but I am fine with lynching him.
And you have been "wondering" about my alignment since I replaced crys, based on my posting. Please get over it (:clown:), I simply post as I do because I am an expendable townie and somehow, one of the few remaining players paying any semblance of attention. I'm looking at the game through the lens of what I would have done to keep it balanced, and that means I shouldn't be able to trust that the ridiculous number of town power roles are all trustworthy.
Darth Feather
12-06-2013, 23:42
I'm just not sure if I trust that his story is true.
He could have easily been faking it and just scrambled to make it sound coherent when parts of it didn't check out. Further, he might have even been clever enough to have made himself sound disorganized to seem more innocent. It's all WIFOM.
If you think somebody else is more suspicious, let me know. I don't know what BSmith has done this game either, but I am fine with lynching him.
And you have been "wondering" about my alignment since I replaced crys, based on my posting. Please get over it (:clown:), I simply post as I do because I am an expendable townie and somehow, one of the few remaining players paying any semblance of attention. I'm looking at the game through the lens of what I would have done to keep it balanced, and that means I shouldn't be able to trust that the ridiculous number of town power roles are all trustworthy.
But how about CP's scan?
Unvote; Vote: BSmith
Chaotix still needs to die imo.
The Eighth Day
Owen Thatcher (BSmith) nervously awaited as the limp body of Bret was discovered beneath his sleeping bag. The people went into an uproar, accusing each other, cursing them, even going as far as questioning their own reality.
Owen never made a sound, he only stared down at Bret's pale body, blood pool below him. His skin grew clammy, pale white, and sweat fell from his brow. A woman next to him who had been pointing fingers wildly turned and noticed his odd behavior. "Are you okay?" She asked him.
He didn't acknowledge her, in fact, his symptoms grew. She said something and brought all of their attention on him, and when he noticed the dozen eyes on him, he cracked and started to cry.
"What's wrong with you?" Aaron Anduin asked him, already assuming the worst. Owen looked at him behind blank eyes and said nothing. "I believe we have our murderer, he's cracked."
Owen didn't fight them when they took him out away from their camp and put a knife in his throat. He died instantly, never saying a word.
Night Phase 8 has begun! PM me ASAP!
Time Remaining:
Riedquat
12-07-2013, 01:53
I'm just not sure if I trust that his story is true.
He could have easily been faking it and just scrambled to make it sound coherent when parts of it didn't check out. Further, he might have even been clever enough to have made himself sound disorganized to seem more innocent. It's all WIFOM.
It could be wifom, but I doubt it, for one side it didn't worked at all, he being in this position, and his disorganization was as mine a couple days ago, I also sent a night 1 order... the other game we had 2 town doctors and a doctor/scanner and a single killer, in this game we know we had 1 paranoid detective, 1 (legit) detective and 1 doctor?
The problem is two scans were carried on him, different in nature but still... I think you leave the cleared ones for the last lynching... and while I have heavy doubts about Chief Pappy, I can't discard rickinator's scans...
If you think somebody else is more suspicious, let me know. I don't know what BSmith has done this game either, but I am fine with lynching him.
Honestly I don't have a clue, to me better candidates are Bsmith, perhaps Dcmort.. followed by Makrell, I-k and DF, and you the last... of course Chief Pappy and Visor are good candidates but none of them is Owen so no priority at this time.
And you have been "wondering" about my alignment since I replaced crys, based on my posting.
LOL No! Its the other way around, I been a bit pushy because you are Aaron Anduin and replaced inactive Crys, and the continue barking between you and Visor is becoming tiresome and unproductive! ;)
But how about CP's scan?
What about it? He is looking for somebody special to him God knows why...
Chaotix still needs to die imo.
:rolleyes:
Edit: Doh! Zain post wasn't there when I started to write... I'm like a slug on salt!
Riedquat
12-07-2013, 02:00
The Eighth Day
Owen Thatcher (BSmith)
Thanks BSmith!! :bow:
And at the same time :elephant:
Huh, I was actually right on bsmith. sweet.
Gotta stop doubting myself.
Well done.
If this game doesn't end, you know what that means, right?
One of the living new guys is also some sort of anti-town.
Kill visorslash, seeing as the scanner was actually right about DF being a doctor.
Darth Feather
12-07-2013, 10:07
Wait. Didn't we catch the scumbag? Or is there someone else remaining? ~:confused:
Darth Feather
12-07-2013, 10:09
Kill visorslash, seeing as the scanner was actually right about DF being a doctor.
Visor dropped BSmith over the edge. I am not sure that would be a good idea.
Visor dropped BSmith over the edge. I am not sure that would be a good idea.
Why do they have to be on the same party? i guess cult or third party.
Or Chaotix have embraced his pratian side :P
Why do they have to be on the same party? i guess cult or third party.
Or Chaotix have embraced his pratian side :P
No mention of anything regarding cult/third party. Unlikely for a cult - there would be roles to stop them.
I'm obviously not scum.
I'm looking at Makrell/DC/IK at the moment for good candidates.
Darth Feather
12-07-2013, 10:58
Edit: Doesn't matter.
i would hope CP uses his ability for good, maybe checking chatoix or visor.
Riedquat
12-07-2013, 13:40
To easy,,, don't like it, Zain doesn't make things easy... Luckily with tonight's write up I guess we will get a couple clues about who we are looking for, but it is only one?
Waiting on one other order and I can do the write-up, they have 7.5 hours.
Chief Pappy
12-07-2013, 19:32
WoG the inactive scum!
Anybody else thinking Pratia 3 was easier than Pratia 2?
Is it scaring anybody else?
WoG the inactive scum!
Anybody else thinking Pratia 3 was easier than Pratia 2?
Is it scaring anybody else?
Were not in safe territory yet, we might get ambushed or worse.
Chief Pappy
12-07-2013, 20:37
Were not in safe territory yet, we might get ambushed or worse.
I wonder if we're going to get hit with another decision to make. We should've reached the coast by now...
I wonder if we're going to get hit with another decision to make. We should've reached the coast by now...
I dont think zain wants to quit hosting, maybe it ends with townie victory, with an epilogic backstory for the new mafia :P
Darth Feather
12-07-2013, 21:05
WoG the inactive scum!
Anybody else thinking Pratia 3 was easier than Pratia 2?
Is it scaring anybody else?
Nope, in pratia II we just had a brilliant scumperformance by edse with his fake suicide. If he wouldn't have done that town WOULD have won.
Last order has been received! I'll work on the write-up as I'm expecting it to be pretty entertaining!
The Eighth Night
Darkness fell on the night in which the catatonic Owen Thatcher was killed. The previous day, the infamous murderer and double agent of the Pratian society, Hayden Matthews, disguised as a man named Michael Engels, was killed as well.
The alleged Mobilian survivors, seven in numbers, four men and three women, had survived their threat. Now, approaching the historical Gulf of Mexico, they had a decision to make.
Charlie and Aaron had assumed leadership after Michael was exposed. Feet in the sand, stars overhead, Charlie spoke first, "We should head West, the Praters have less influence that way."
"How would you know that?" A woman asked him.
"They started in the East, everybody knows that." He said. He had proven himself rather resourceful with a powerful memory and the ability to read people like a book.
Aaron spoke up now, the tentativeness of immaturity quickly fading away with each passing day, "The coast is to our East and our South, we could set up our own foothold here for now, maybe even more survivors will find us."
Charlie responded, "Or we could just wait for the Prater army of hundreds to find our little pack of seven so they can stomp all over us."
Aaron looked at the other five, "We'll have a vote then, but we'll settle this in the morning... we need to rest."
~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~
Charlie enjoyed his time alone, and when he got the chance he took a stroll down the beach. Little did he know, two sets of eyes watched him.
He continued down the sandy airstrip until he was out of earshot of the small campfire, when he stopped and looked out over the dark ocean. The moon was waning, the light didn't guide him as well as before.
A figure bolted from the tree line towards him, knife in hand. Another figure from closer did the same. Charlie turned around and saw the two figures running toward him and he bolted toward the sea. He was a fantastic swimmer, and likely could out swim his assailants. He turned, once several yards out, and saw the two figures in a grapple on the ground. He watched as the armed figure stabbed to death the other, and then run into the forest.
He quickly swam back and attempted to see who his protector had been but the light was too dim. He labored and brought the body to the campfire, Tristan Toft (dcmort93) was finally identified. One member woke, gasped, and the rest followed. Blood had been spilled once more...
Day Phase 9 has begun! Please vote for the lynch AND whether you think the group should Stay or Go.
Time Remaining:
Darth Feather
12-07-2013, 22:53
So, Dcmort, any info you want to share with the town?
So, Dcmort, any info you want to share with the town?
he has claimed bodyguard already, so i assume he protected chief pappy, CP was targeted, and dcmort died protecting him.
Peace be with his memory.
But cps result should be good.
Imma: Vote:stay
moving is not the best option, staying and waiting for other survivors is good, we will see the prater army if they come in force, then run.
Vote:visorslash
although im uncertain, but i guess serial killer or something. Hope CP have light to shed.
Chief Pappy
12-07-2013, 23:04
Well gentlemen, as I mentioned earlier in the thread Makrell's odd comments about his ability(s) got me curious. Last night I investigated him (personally not thinking a member of the new group is guilty) and got this result.
Makrell: Bulletproof
That's it... Sorry guys, my scan didn't help much...
Chief Pappy
12-07-2013, 23:11
So we have...
Chief Pappy - Role Scanner
Chaotix - Double Voter
Darth Feather - Doctor (confirmed)
Ibn-Khaldun - Doctor
Makrell - Bulletproof (confirmed)
Visorslash - Vanilla Townie
Crossroad was also a vanilla townie, I believe the newbie trio were to bolster the ranks for the assistance of the town. Zain might've saw a balancing issue? Or perhaps a chance to improve the story?
Either way, I'm willing to bet Chaotix (Aaron Anduin) will be the hero in Pratia 4, so he's innocent too. That leaves Ibn-Khaldun an unconfirmed doctor (who hasn't successfully stopped a kill) and Visorslash an unconfirmed vanilla townie.
Like I said, I don't personally believe my group contained more scum, but that a vigilante of such remains.
So, Vote:Ibn-Khaldun for now.
Riedquat
12-08-2013, 05:34
Now... I believe you more Chief Pappy!
Our killer is afraid of your power, that is sure... I don't know what to think about I-K, since he revealed, he has been very cooperative and made clear some minor things only one with his role should know, like the no results about protections and other stuff...
Ghostly vote: Go west... Hawai if possible, run like a paranoid ghost were haunting you! :yes:
Living Players: (6/17)
Chief Pappy - Scanner - Probed
Chaotix - Aaron Anduin - double voter
Darth Feather - Doctor by scan - innocent by scan
Ibn-Khaldun - Doctor by self claim
Makrell - Indestructible by write up, claim and scan
Visorslash - vanilla by self claim
This is going to hurt...
Im going to stay with my vote on visorslash. he couldve waited to start with his serial killing as a tactic, i dont think IK wouldve done that. And if it is a recently awakened power i think it makes sense that a vanilla townie would get it.
Ibn-Khaldun
12-08-2013, 09:23
There are no vanilla townies in this game. I don't believe that.
Vote: Visorslash
And last night I protected Darth Feather again.
That leaves Ibn-Khaldun an unconfirmed doctor (who hasn't successfully stopped a kill)
Umm.. unless the mafia publicly announces who they are going to attack in the night it's just luck if I or anyone else manage to protect the target of mafia kill. Also, "who hasn't successfully stopped a kill" can be said about DF as well.
Darth Feather
12-08-2013, 09:43
There are no vanilla townies in this game. I don't believe that.
Vote: Visorslash
And last night I protected Darth Feather again.
Umm.. unless the mafia publicly announces who they are going to attack in the night it's just luck if I or anyone else manage to protect the target of mafia kill. Also, "who hasn't successfully stopped a kill" can be said about DF as well.
As a matter of fact, I protected you. I am also happy to Vote: Visorslash
Also: Go south. I don't think we should be waiting for the army. The write-up suggests Aaron is innocent though,or has severe schyzofrenia.
Two doctors in a game is ridiculously unbalanced.
Vote: IK
Two doctors in a game is ridiculously unbalanced.
Vote: IK
agreed, we have 3 peope that through sheer tactic cant die at night, "victory is secured". but something must be amiss though, even if i cant tell what.
agreed, we have 3 peope that through sheer tactic cant die at night, "victory is secured". but something must be amiss though, even if i cant tell what.
If I'm scum, I threw BSmith off the cliff for no reason. If I'm scum I lost myself the game.
Vote IK. He is far more likely then me to be scum. Have Chief scan me and have DF protect either himself or Chief.
Darth Feather
12-08-2013, 11:03
Two doctors in a game is ridiculously unbalanced.
Vote: IK
If I'm scum, I threw BSmith off the cliff for no reason. If I'm scum I lost myself the game.
Vote IK. He is far more likely then me to be scum. Have Chief scan me and have DF protect either himself or Chief.
Both good points: Unvote; vote: Ibn-Khaldun
Riedquat
12-08-2013, 17:32
Both good points: Unvote; vote: Ibn-Khaldun
:stare: Previous game, 3 doctors and 1 killer within 10 players...
Also there is no clue this new killer is a Pratian agent, the lynching of BSmith shouldn't be taken in consideration..
Darth Feather
12-08-2013, 18:07
:stare: Previous game, 3 doctors and 1 killer within 10 players...
Also there is no clue this new killer is a Pratian agent, the lynching of BSmith shouldn't be taken in consideration..
Well, we'll lynch IK and I will protect CP next night while he scans visor.
Chief Pappy
12-08-2013, 18:11
There are no vanilla townies in this game. I don't believe that.
Crossroad was one, confirmed by my scan.
Also, Vote:Go
Putting more distance between ourselves and the Praters sounds like the best idea right now.
Vote Tallies:
Lynch
Ibn-Khaldun: 3 (CP, Visor, DF)
Visorslash: 2 (Makrell, I-K)
Non-Voting: Chaotix
Action
Go: 3 (Visor, DF, CP)
Stay: 1 (Makrell)
Non-Voting: Chaotix Ibn-Khaldun
Time Remaining:
Crossroad was one, confirmed by my scan.
I guess he was dormant, or impervious to your scans, a full on roleinvestigator is a powerful tool afterall.
Chief Pappy
12-08-2013, 19:30
I guess he was dormant, or impervious to your scans, a full on roleinvestigator is a powerful tool afterall.
What do you mean by dormant?
What do you mean by dormant?
An ability that comes at a trigger. (maybe for example when a certain person dies, like michael)
a sleeping power basicly, i do not think there are vanilla townies.
The problem here is that our new killers have no names in the write-ups, like we are used to. We might not know if we successfully lynched scum.
I believe the 3 extra players are their own scum team, independent of the Pratians and only activated after the Pratians were finished off.
Vote: Visorslash
Chief Pappy goes tomorrow. He is the other one, right?
And I suggest we go rather than stay.
Day Phase has ended, I'll draw up the write-up soon!
Be ready for epicness :2thumbsup:
The Final Day
That morning they had agreed to go further West away from Mobile and Prater territory. All but one, a man by the name of Roosevelt Gardner (Makrell) voted in favor of this plan. They offered to leave him behind, but he opted to go with them. Aaron Anduin (Chaotix) and Charlie (Chief Pappy) tag-teamed the leadership role. The three women, Leigha (Visorslash), Kira Cooper (Ibn-Khaldun), and Crystal Perreault (Darth Feather) kept a cool countenance and assisted the group the best they could.
Crystal, Leigha, and Charlie were in favor of lynching Kira for the night's murder while the others wished for Leigha to go. In the end, with the extra influence of the young Anduin boy, the decision was made.
Leigha didn't fight when they grabbed her arms and Charlie pulled the knife to her throat. She began to speak and stunned everyone, "Pratia will consume all of you." She looked Aaron in the eye, "You're the son of the General, you're not even of Mobilian blood. Your father attacked Mobile six years ago not for it's wretched resources, or to enslave the inbred population... No, he wanted you back."
Aaron hesitated, trying hard not to be deceived.
She continued, "Areos, his brother... YOUR uncle stole you from him when he defected from the Pratian army. Your father wanted you back, until reports from Hayden came back saying how soft and loyal you had become. He decided he wanted you gone along with the rest of your sorry people."
Aaron felt fear, a different fear. "You've been watching me?"
"We have eyes everywhere. You've never been alone your entire life." She responded in a haunting manner.
Aaron looked at Charlie and nodded, and he slit her throat ending her life.
They all stood in silence, watching the body bleed out, wondering if their nightmare had ended. Aaron looked at Kira and Crystal, "I don't care what she said, you are my people." He put his hand on Charlie's shoulder, nodded, then on Roosevelt's. He raised his voice a little higher, "We're all that's left of a once thriving city, a million down to five. We have a job to do."
"What's that?" Charlie asked, relief starting to sneak into his heart.
"We have to kill them all."
Complete Town Victory
Congratulations to Darth Feather, Ibn-Khaldun, Makrell, Chaotix, and Chief Pappy!
The true conclusion to this epic story comes soon, Pratia IV will open up for sign-ups in just a few short hours. The plot-twists to come will surely leave you baffled. Sign-up on the link in my signature!
Don't really think I deserve to lose this game, but that is that.
Can't do much when the vote is based of a meta argument like that.
What were the roles?
Well played town. You all kept your heads despite a fair bit of confusion as to what was going on, much better than I would have!
And thanks for hosting Zain! I had great fun in this, despite the result.
Here's the mafia QT (http://www.quicktopic.com/50/H/hyxqqPG3MMCus), for those who are interested.
You will note that there was no 'minion power' - my claim against Lux was an (educated) guess, and it was pure coincidence that we 'blocked' the same person twice. It certainly helped my cause though :beam:.
Character Synopsis:
autolycus - Heidi Niles - "Incompetent Doctor"
Ferret - Lyndsay Chamberlain - "Director (Tiebreaker)"
Chief Pappy - 1st Role - Dorian Morris - "Town Drunk"
edse - Bev Fitzpatrick - "Odd-Night Commuter"
rickinator9 - Monte MacCoughlan - "Investigator"
Lux - Kassy Garnett - "Roleblocker"
Riedquat - Margaret McGill - "Paranoid Detective"
Ishmael - Hayden Matthews - "Mafia"
crossroad - Bret - "Insane Townie"
BSmith - Owen Thatcher - "Mafia"
dcmort93 - Tristan Toft - "Bodyguard"
Visorslash - Leigha - "Mafia"
and our survivors!
Chaotix - Aaron Anduin - "Double Voter"
Chief Pappy - 2nd Role - Charlie - "Psychic Investigator"
Darth Feather - Crystal Perreault - "Doctor"
Ibn-Khaldun - Kira Cooper - "Incompetent Doctor"
Makrell - Roosevelt Gardner - "Bulletproof"
A special thanks to EVERYBODY for playing! I especially enjoyed hosting this one, can't wait to finish it off!
Riedquat
12-09-2013, 03:33
Amazing game! Thanks Zain! :bow:
Uh, so you didn't know each other after all.. interesting!
I personally have a few issues with the balance that I can go over if you like? I could also look at P4 if you want and give you a hand with any balancing?
I enjoyed the game, liked the paranoia.
Thanks for hosting Zain.
I personally have a few issues with the balance that I can go over if you like? I could also look at P4 if you want and give you a hand with any balancing?
I enjoyed the game, liked the paranoia.
Thanks for hosting Zain.
P4 won't be as role heavy, but we need lots of players to accomplish the atmosphere I'm needing. Spread the word!
Chief Pappy
12-09-2013, 03:42
Awesome game Zain :yes:
May not can participate in Pratia IV, but I'll keep in touch :bow:
dcmort93
12-09-2013, 05:59
I definitely enjoyed this game even though my participation was not a good as it could have been. Well hosted Zain and well played everyone
Ibn-Khaldun
12-09-2013, 09:22
Yay, I survived!
Liked the game, Zain! Thanks for hosting!
rickinator9
12-09-2013, 10:10
Good game.
Don't really think I deserve to lose this game, but that is that.
Can't do much when the vote is based of a meta argument like that.
What were the roles?
"there are no townies" is not a bad argument when it is true.
i dont see why you wouldnt claim a role, you could claim naive detective or tiebreaker if needed. (or bulletproof)
but the balance was abit odd yes.
Darth Feather
12-09-2013, 16:15
Loved this game and will definitly join Pratia IV when it goes live.
"there are no townies" is not a bad argument when it is true.
i dont see why you wouldnt claim a role, you could claim naive detective or tiebreaker if needed. (or bulletproof)
but the balance was abit odd yes.
Already two detectives claimed, it'd look fishy. Already a tiebreaker claimed, it'd look fishy. Bulletproof, roleblocker, doctor, all claimed.
I also didn't know if there was a watcher or a tracker out there, so I can't take that risk.
vBulletin® v3.7.1, Copyright ©2000-2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.