what's the vc rn?
Printable View
what's the vc rn?
@Gemma what about my play today reads as powerwolfy to you?
i'd like you to unpack that and explain it out a bit pls, cause it kinda feels like a random pot shot, so im curious what the thoughts are behind it
Vote: Dolby :pop2:
@Sunbae so unfortunatley the tldr of why i tr grr is: meta. i've played with him a fair amount and he's pretty stilted and frozen as a wolf. the stream of consciousness and overexplaining and relative highposting here is all pretty far out of his scumrange, and there's a tonal purity he just really hasnt been able to replicate well as scum before.
I can pull up posts and walk through them if you need me to, but, everyone who is familiar with grr is towncoring him, so, that's p significant here
(also this post at eod just felt very loltown) #1205
Hmm, I'm with ender on this one. Like here you're saying it was easy to anticipate the Syn wagon popping up in real time (bleh, missing eods is hard cause you dont get the actual feels of what was going on) but even still monts actions are not really doing anything against it right? Like, he's not ignoring it and hoping it doesn't happen because he talks about it, he's not dissuading from the wagon because he's calling it the pure, if he's anticipating it like you said he's not getting on early for credit nor staying off other wagons entirely, I just don't see an agenda here and think it makes more sense as villager uninformed eod posting
Maple (2) Ladd, Dolby
Nebjiamn (2) Gemma, Wisdom
Enderwiggin (1) Nebjiamn
Jan (1) Theknightsofneeee
Raskolnikov (1) Enderwiggin
Sunbae (1) Grr
Dolby (1) Didistetter
Not voting (10) Insomnia, Arctic, Maple, Jan, dyachei, ColonelLubriderm, Raskolnikov, Vanta Black, Sunbae, Montmorency
?
but that's exactly what he did tho
he unvoted rask as syn wagon was regaining traction, and then stayed unvoted.
Mont's entire VH from D1:
Montmorency votes Raskolnikov p#1170 ?4
Montmorency unvotes Raskolnikov p#1187 ?3
thats it.
he made rask top wagon, and then when people took issue with it and pushed elsewhere, he just hopped off and didn't push anything
i truly dont see how that reads as uninformed villy
wats the good word friends
Let me try rephrase cause I think that didn't get explained properly:
I interpreted your post as saying it was easy to anticipate that the Syn wagon was going to happen so we should not give any credit for the syn wagon is pure post Mont made. I was saying if Mont was anticipating that it was going to happen like you suggested he didn't really do anything to get credit for it by getting on early and didn't just avoid other wagons entirely. He hopped on Rask and then hopped off. I just don't think you can dismiss positive points (basically calling the Syn wagon best) because you think it was easy to anticipate while also not pointing out that if he DID anticipate it then he didn't really do anything about it you know? Is this one of those things that makes sense in my head and not in text? I feel like it might be
Kinda vibing with Jans judgement post hmmm
Think I already commented on this in my Syn ISO post but I just think this post isn't partnered with Wisdom
Feeling more confident that Rask is town, when I read Syn's ISO I felt that the way he was going after Rask felt like he wasn't in a wolf
I have other reasons to townread grr but those reasons are just "I read their posts, I think it's a villager". I think this take is lol but I kinda am amused by it
yeah rask is town
so this is one of Maple's first reads. I just don't like it, I feel that grr has had micro towny moments already. I feel like grr looks like a pushable person to a wolf despite that
except for the Arctic take I love this post a lot, particularly calling grr a lock villa. I think that it isn't hard to do that but I think wolves aren't inclined to do that
maybe slightly towny reaction to Syn's read list but I might be reaching with this
I like this a lot actually since I think that Dya was up to this point a bit above null and yeah idk I just like it
This is so town. I think that this is not the angle a wolf chooses to go here since it risks just burning some people to them
I think this but also imma be real this is 100% bc I vibe with the read
NOOOOOOOOOO you were doing so good
I dislike this bc if there's bad reasons, even if he is right, that's kinda just more likely to be a wolf faking a read imo
want to question why a third of these are here but w/e I'll do it later
Arctic I feel like you aren't Abominating this game :(. Like IH just feels v and I feel like it should be kinda recognizable? I am also not getting the abomination solving vibes from you
ok actually my problem with these is different and we will see if it stays like that, but Arctic isn't putting anything out in this section of posts, he's just asking for more elaboration of TRs, which, fair, but I also think just isn't the best look
Ok nvm I love this post, this basically summerizes the entirity of my thoughts on Maple v grr, and correctly calls out why Maple's posts just don't feel good at this point in the game.This is the right read for the right reasons at this point in the thread (even if I'm not sure if Arctic has read up to Maple somewhat backing off the right at this point)
hmmm, disagree with WHY he's townreading IH though I also gotta to admit that I'm townreading IH for reasons that may be connected to that and maybe IH is posting more because he is not wolf (simply speaking, I believe that IH believes what he's posting, he is putting off a vibe that he is trying to solve in his own way). Not gonna comment on the Benneh and Dya stuff bc I am not backreading or anything that isn't on the same page, quoted, or directly connected to Syn.
If the parts about Rask didn't exist in the section about his Syn read I'd be townreading it because it correctly calls out Syn's reads list as frankly insane and says that the townreads on Syn are weak... but sheeps Rask anyway. I don't think it's the worst, I think the read is mildly towny, but in either direction it gives Arctic wiggle room which detracts from how I feel about him. I do think at this moment that he is more likely town though
maybe towny bc this is such an insane thing to say
god I think that outside Syn this list is pure even though I don't really have a ladd take but I hate that he correctly calls out why Syn shouldn't be townread, then just sheeps Rask anyway
there are things I like and dislike about this list, mostly like
I think that townreading Rask while not caring about his Syn "godread", especially if Rask is town, is somethign that wolves are going to avoid doing, I think the only thing I really dislike is Maple up which I don't really see, and Ender/Knights in the same tier. I would like more elaboration from Dya on why Ender is always a wolf to them and I'm gonna be keeping an eye on that since, I do sus Ender to but I don't think that that has been reflected much in their previous posts
think this post in general is towny and the two bolded lines are less likely to come from a wolf
I gotta leave now, full solve to come later
Stett, this parts harder for me so can you help?
If the syn wagon was pretty easy to anticipate, do you think any of the voters (especially early ones) were busses?
@Wisdom
why did you have syn as a lower tier villa yesterday?
ender, if i said "but i didnt even vote you" was a shitpost with a tinge of truth (aka, trying to be funny and silly in the way i said "idk why youre so focused on me about it i just made a read and moved on i wasnt pushing") that apparently didnt land well would that feel less weird for you
i hope the wolves arent something like benneh/maple/wisdom cause id be playing very bad if it was
Pls to have confirmed that posting a readlist is a waste of time.
I like how IH is shrugging at me and my reads. True story
"maybe towny cause this is an insane thing to say" got a real life belly laugh from me
love manti posts
Peeformative, wish I could thanks my typos
@Raskolnikov btw so far I have both of them as town
Your clears are fine. (from your pov)
your poe is meh. (having both knights and myself in your immediate poe is wrong but you know that yourself. manti as poe is fine but also the easiest person to put in there at any point of the game)
your nullpile is huge.
your third wisdom take needs explaining because I think I would be the one shading in the conversation and not wisdom.
bop is villa.
grr is villa
vanta is ~likely villa. (I get overall similar vibes to last game where I wasted an action on Vanta to clear her name)
idk anymore, I haven't even had a chance to really rethink my reads list today. i do think rask looks villagery today so im not interested in voting there. I might cop out and vote montmorency because like...what's he doing?
feels like everyone else is seeing things differently than I am spew wise and Idk if I'm the problem or not so I've just been watching people chat.
i still think jan is villa
Premise: there are four wolves left
inno children(0 wolves)
vanta
stet
villas(0-1 wolves but lean towards 0)
insomnia
arctic
grr
villagy (0-1 wolves lean towards 0 but not as far as above)
sunbae
dya
village side of /shrug(0-1 wolf)
maple*
knights
/shrug(1-2 wolves)
montmore
neb
jan**
rasko**
ender
wolf side of /shrug(1-3 wolves)
ladd
dolby
gemma
wisdom
*Spoiler Alert, click show to read:
**Spoiler Alert, click show to read:
***Spoiler Alert, click show to read:
like going into yesterday's elim, i had ladd, rask, and jan all as villa and I think i'm probably wrong on just 1 of them. If I am, it's ladd.
Whoever made that one post about thinking it's reasonably likely that Mont is a villager, that post seemed good.
Maybe I'm biased, but I'm not particularly a fan of dolly's catchup so far.
The people I want to see more from more or less haven't given much more yet which is annoying so I'm just gonna give it till I'm on my computer.
if yall aint a fan of my catchup vote me then
Pretty sure I had him as upper tier PoE but it might depend on when you're talking about.
I tend to read Syn through his mood and he was way too happy/jokey which I read as wolfy. But that burned me last game and he didn't really give me anything else to read him on. Rask reads Syn better than me though (or so I thought, at least) and he town cleared Syn, which I at some point thought made Syn town regardless of Rask's alignment.
I wasn't able to word it properly since I'm on phone so I hope it makes sense. @ColonelLubriderm
I agree with the first 3 tiers in varying degrees. (all of them I have at least as village lean)
I have gemma higher but not confident enough to try and convince anyone of it.
I vibed with her I don't bus reaction towards me. Not because I don't think she busses in general, but because I think she thinks she would not bus in that situation. Again ~vibes.
ok sunbae here goes
I think you're being too lenient with ben. yes, he's playing differently and he's been absent. I have him as basically null for it, i'm not sure how you can have him so high. I agree on insom, stett, and bop
I think there's a chance of gemma or grr being a wolf. I think there could be 2 wolves here and 2 wolves in your last category. I dont think jan/rask/ladd are all wolves together. I think there's at least 1 villa and probably really 2. i dont really know what to do with vanta but I got slight v vibes there
and ender I suck at reading. it's possible, and I think interactions look bad for him.
grr seems to be doing a lot of work but I'll be honest, I'm having a hard time with his posts because there's too much going on in them and I'm not really sure if he believes all of what he's saying
How about we just yeet all wall posters and multi quoters?
Do you think it's possible that I've taken my normal approach to benneh (one where I read him mostly based on whether or not he's showing attempts to position himself for the future) and applied it to a game that isn't normal (appears to be very busy)? So I'm reading a lack of long term approach as villagery but it really just means he's just not been available at all?
@Arctic sup?
@Raskolnikov you're a butt <3 Stop talking about yourself as if you're a rational and not predictable person :3
rephrase: not "not available" but more just less available than usual (he has been participating and making reads so that came out wrong)
have i ever explicitly told you that you're delightful to play with wisdom?
i dont think anyone has been unfun fwiw
same, this game has been really enjoyable for me
Ah that's how I phrased it, makes sense!
Yeah right now I'd say...
Top town
Colonel
Jan
Rask
Leaning town
Ender
Ladd
Probably also town
Arctic
Dya
Insomnia
Stett
Null
Benneh
Knights
Maple
Monte (I still can't recall 1 post from him and always forgets he exists)
Sunbae
Wolf lean
Dolby
Gemma
Vanta
Ok read Monte's iso he's still null.
Vote: Gemma
why tf is everyone fuckign wolfreading me
rask viable wagon
syn viable wagon
he says rask should die first for his read on syn. that's a read that both spews rask villager and syn wolf if jan is a wolf. do you agree with this premise?
and all im saying is that a wolf would recognize the really poor positioning and it'd be a tough progression to pull off with TMI
Decided to skip to the first Syn vote since what I've been doing has clearly not been serving me well. I did a quick skim of the page immediately prior and I don't think that Syn becoming as big of a EOD wagon was really visible, but I think Syn was pretty clearly in danger the moment Newcomb said he was a good vote and Stett got on him
I like this vote a lot
fine vote, think this guy is town anyway. Given what Newcomb said earlier, this might as well have been the vote that put Syn at three (largest counterwagon) anyway
I think that the thought to call out Syn missing from a readslist (even though he isn't) is towny and shows the there is a level of realness to Bop's sus
I like this only bc it ties syn with the lead wagon gemma
Not quoting them but so far I like Arctic's posts in this stretch, I find them generally agreeable... except for his Syn read
so get on Syn then. I also don't get how the post itself is villagery
this is towny
tracking
I've seen talk of Monty's EOD, rn I think this is a fine Monty post and only leaves him room to vote Gemma
aight here's the thing
If I ignore the Syn townread I still don't like this beyond, well, he's putting people in front of Syn, but more importantly Ithink his theory doesn't come from a villa
Despite Wisdom's townread of Syn, I feel like two interactions from Syn's direction towards Wisdom just weren't w/w, the stronger one being the one where Syn calls out Wisdom for wanting to mason with Jan. I just don't feel like that's a post that w!Syn is inclined to make if with Wisdom and Jan is v, wolf Syn can bus but if he's a wolf he's going to raise his teammates over others while keeping them in whatever tier feels appropriate for them. tbf I think that Syn hadn't posted in a while by this point but still.
Jan hasn't said much about Rask beforehand so maybe a weird push but ugh
if this continues well its a good look for arctic
I gotta read if Jan liked Gemma ugh
tbh I think this is fine for Monty
meaningful vote for keeping Syn in contention, good
I think w Arctic doesn't say this if Rask v because it risks trapping him on Syn
I like this but also context that he's lead wagon
ok looks like his Rask read was stronger than I thought, still think the sentiment is villa
gonna call this towny
I'd have to read Monty's ISO deeper and it doesn't look good that he's unvoting without anyone getting on Rask but I think I'm fine with it? kinda an admission that he isn't fully informed on the game state which is kinda villa. I think if a wolf he just keeps his vote on Rask probably, rather than Abrograte all responsibility with a teammate in danger
think this is towny given other options existed
boom
hate this
I think the sequence isn't that great since idk how Arcitc would vote if it was sheep/knights/gemma as CW but I'm fine iwth it
anyone but Syn huh
lmao
kinda don't like that Monty didn't vote but it's like, w/e. I think there's a good chance that he was to disconnected from the game to feel like he could place down a good vote.
I feel like if Jan is town more people would have tried to exploit his Rask push to get on Rask but at the same time at EOD the CWs were nowehre near consolidated. Bopolis doesn't count to me in that fwiw
@didistetter
Inclined to change my mind on Raskol, probs not gonna shield/care about them anymore.
Like I get that you didnt like the read I outed on you it would probably annoy me too and it might even annoy me so much I vote or kill them for it (god knows Nanook has vigged me once for annoying him lmao, and so has Cobalt :D (damn im really annoying now that i think about it lmaoooo)), but the fact that you're not even considering that a take that looks surface level so annoying to you might actually come more likely from a villager becuz why wouldnt a wolf find a singular better reason to vote someone is somewhat starting to get unbelievable, becuz this is not your first mafia game.
By the way "this person is treating me in good faith so they are likely a wolf" is, in some variation (maybe not exactly like that idk don't wanna misrepresent them but Newcomb surely has made readslist where he said people who are to be the most reasonable about him and telling him how they are considering etc. are the most likely wolves, I can probably bring the receipts if anyone seriously questions this LOL), a read that I have seen a lot of veterans apply. it's also rand accurate btw. becuz hey, wolves like to look good. but hey im happy to have ladd tell me he never made a read like this before :curtain:
I tend to not be as slick about it as others but like you dont get to treat me worse than other mafia players just because I am expressing my thoughts in a less palpatable manner when i am basically talking about the same things others do.
dya i had as gut town all game, not because they were super towny but everything they said i was like "yeah town-dya would say this".
except that one post where i definitely had an out of body experience and i'm irked people still havent told me if its like, a normal take for them or anything because I genuinely don't know.
@grr i dont care about what Newcomb said about it. Put on my shoes for a second: I give Manti a try and attempt to follow up his process. I get what he is saying before you, think about it, conclude its NaI for both of you (re Maple the fact its what remains mostly, together with his 6 word posts about sheep is actually AI for me).
Then u proceed to wolfread me for it? Like wtf. So do what u want with it, but try charitabke if villa smh.
@Jan: thoughts on Dolby willing to make us D2 dome? Fwiw i dont like it. Like narrow vision or smtg. A lot of slots remains to be discussed etc etc
I honestly dont really get why u feel so strongly about it
If all i read was eod, jan would look bad iyam
He defended syn and is clearly not spewed wolf so id say it worked
I just read eod again and what i find strange is how much jan suddenly cares once syn becomes a wagon, like he was pretty chill until the syn wagon and then he goes "ham"
@Wisdom why dolby so low? Why gemma?
Maybe i am out of the loop but i thought dolby catch up was fine - tho i dont get your jan read and why that jan post doesnt come from a villagrr. Can you elaborate on that?
Can people explain what they dislike?
I dislike that we already talked about us for quite a while and basically took a break for now to look at other people.
And the moment he gets some heat he directs the attention to us.
I don't believe in domes this early into the game(unless there is mech).
There is a world in which you are a wolf, but we are far away from a sure fire 1on1.