We might have won Mafia X had we dealt with lurkers more consequently.
Printable View
We might have won Mafia X had we dealt with lurkers more consequently.
Ask TwilightBlade. It was a joke about him, after all.Quote:
Originally Posted by Andres
If I was mafia trying to appear as town I'd sit on my hands and vote randomly like I usually do. Whenever I actually try to play the game, all I get is a vote or three. It's a wonder I'm trying at all.Quote:
Originally Posted by Captain Blackadder
1-5 is exactly what I'd expect of Andres, but really, why so much interest on me?Quote:
Originally Posted by Andres
Fluffy but more discreet. I'm real surprised no one actually quoted this before, due to Warman's penchant for hiding in plain sight.Quote:
Originally Posted by ELITEOFKWARMAN88GINGERBREADMAN
Speaking out of experience, I'm inclined to agree. vote: FluffyQuote:
Originally Posted by Romanic
A thin case is slightly better than no case (and yes I realize the situational irony). First "case" is just a shouting match going nowhere, so I'm going to wait on glyphz and see what he does before I change my vote.Quote:
Originally Posted by Romanic
The main reason I quoted this post is so I can say that I'm actually not going to spam it up like I usually do during this game.
Vote:Double A
Meanie :clown:.
Vote: glyphz
nothing major, but his previous posts adds up.
Wait, since when did a FoS warrant a OMGUS vote? Wouldn't it be an OMGUS FoS?Quote:
Originally Posted by ELITEOFKWARMAN88GINGERBREADMAN
Reducing spam can´t hurt Vote: Fluffy
vote: Fluffy
Alive fluffiniess is still suspicious.
This makes me angry. Does anyone actually care about catching scum?
I love these "well I don't want to make a case against anyone" lynches. I mean, it's not like anyone is going to try and stop it, so fluffy's an easy target.Quote:
Originally Posted by Zack
I think they're all seduced by Romanic's sexy assertiveness. Plus maybe a mafia or two.
You can tell me why; it's my case.Quote:
glyphz's case is thin, and I'm waiting for him to react, before saying why I disagree.
You're committing the common error of showing a lack of foresightedness. Fluffy:Quote:
Originally Posted by Zack
a) Has just as much a chance of being scum as anyone else, and since no real cases have jumped out this round he is an equally valid option anyway,
b) Is impossible to analyze in the endgame, when the chances of lynching a mafioso are significantly higher due to percentage
Getting rid of him now will save us all a lot of trouble in the rounds where we're more likely to catch a mafioso anyway. Since, as I pointed out in A, there aren't any real other cases going on, I fail to see why the Fluffy lynch today is an issue (aside from the fact that the bandwagon is picking up steam, but there's nothing you can do about that).
Because he's the best damn mafia player we have.Quote:
I fail to see why the Fluffy lynch today is an issue (aside from the fact that the bandwagon is picking up steam, but there's nothing you can do about that).
Quote:
Originally Posted by Double A
You confuse me. :balloon2:
:bow:Quote:
Originally Posted by ELITEOFKWARMAN88GINGERBREADMAN
:bow:
vote: glyphz
1) I like Renata's case on him at this point.
2) Metagame vendetta (joking)
3) I agree with fluffy's well thought out analysis of the harmfulness of text walls in the act of mafia hunting. It would be a shame to waste the most scholarly mind of Babylon.
And I'll give you 4) a reason to unvote, which is that you're not likely to succeed at lynching glyphz in fluffy's place. Voting for a second candidate that won't be lynched if fluffy is anyway, and not being clear whether you really want to save fluffy or just get said other guy is not helpful. It does allow for a scum to be on any bandwagon today and go "I told you so" no matter what fluffy is in the end though. If we're going to randomly lynch someone who is probably a townie solely to rouse up better posting then I agree fluffy is the right call for benefitting future town efforts, and I'd unvote and vote fluffy before one of the other two. So it's just not a good reason to condemn someone else only because they are not fluffy. The only way you'd gain traction is if you find some fluffy voters and convince them to unvote and I'm giving another incentive to imagine that still won't work.
This day has simply been disappointing discussion wise with the ridiculous bandwagons that took off not based on real evidence. Even though I get we couldn't expect anything more revealed new from axeguy or other roles, we've had very little discussion on whether people now believe that GE was a townie or mafia, which should be absolutely huge in deciding people's votes but isn't.
Of course, we do have enough total people not voting for fluffy that it's a shame the fluffy lynch is winning anyway, but the chances of getting everyone on a decent bandwagon now are slim, and if there was a chance, I'd obviously prefer to go for the still scummy TLD.
An interesting reaction considering I have not been involved in private communication with you :inquisitive:Quote:
Originally Posted by TheLastDays
Something note worthy too, much akin to GE trying to subtly nudge the voting direction elsewhere, except in your case, a bit more blatant.Quote:
Originally Posted by Zack
My vote stays.
For all those voting Fluffy and claiming "foresightedness" (GH), you ignored this:
1. Voting fluffy possibly allows scum to just hide in the woodwork with an easy reason to latch on (annoying, memes, spammy, blah)
2. Wouldn't eliminating more scum suspects now make the decision easier for the final round?
a) You say that eliminating fluffy now will make it easier in the final round to guess who the scum is, but the fact of the matter is that by your very counter-productive action, you've essentially forced a lynch because now even if fluffy isn't scum, you've made him lynch bait, and he's going to survive longer anyway even if he wasn't scum
b) Eliminating more suspects now (like TLD) rather than pursuing fluffy (who possibly could have been killed) would have been more efficient in making better decisions in the final round, which was your motivation for voting fluffy.
I concede reason 2a can be taken as encouraging fluffy's lynch, but that is not my intention.
There must really be a lack of leads this day...At the time I began writing that post, the lead on the G_E wagon dropped from 6 (Romanic's tally post post #380) to 3, including a couple of unvotes. The focus of the last posts were going away from G_E (check it out), and I saw that as a bad sign, hence the message style.Quote:
Originally Posted by Renata
As for the reason? I was not convinced of his civilian reveal. Not after surviving an attack. And not after hinting that he has something to disclose regarding that matter, and acting unsure how to do it. I also did not agree w/ his reasoning, for delaying the truth of his nature, saying it was for the sake of generating discussion, I thought it only had us running in circles trying to guess what transpired or what he was.
You could have made your point w/o the need of referencing yourself. Revealing, while under no suspicion/pressure, just makes me think you're suspicious.Quote:
Originally Posted by Zack
Vote: Zack
unvote: atpg; vote: glyphz
So I'm being lynched because I'm unhelpful?
................
Really, is that the best you can come up with?
I never play these games with the intention to hunt down mafia;
quite frankly, enough (too many, in my opinion) players
delve into dissecting every single post.
Me, I really don't give a damn, and I vote for who I want, when I want,
or when I know a player has been outed (no thanks to me) as mafia.
If there weren't so many bandwagons to jump on, or
I would always choose randomly, or I would choose Chaotix!
Now that I am done with my speech, I will now post
everyone's reaction to this.
https://i1110.photobucket.com/albums.../coolstory.png
And then I will commenced to be lynched.
And the spam will continue, as it always will.
CUZ YOU CAN'T STOP TROLLS
HURR DURR
Oh, and Vote: Chaotix
bleh.
http://i53.tinypic.com/1zpl4p5.jpg
Very proud of that btw - my original creation!
Agreed there. FOS: Zack
As for my actual vote, as much as it is impossible now for any payer to overtake the bandwagon that has been erupted around fluffymonster, would go to Vote: TheLastDays. Here is why.
1. He seemed almost entirely certain that the winged woman was either a vig or a serial killer, but not mafia, in day 1. Only way that I know for anybody to be certain about anything in day 1 is if he or she is a mafia.
2. Further investigations have shown that he is reluctant to share opinions about the game with other people. This has, in my experience, mostly been a non-town behavior.
3. He's jumped into two bandwagons already to save his own skin. While it may just be a sign of a panicking townie, the behavior is also a characteristic of a mafia.
It's not much, but it is better than the one in fluffy.
POSSIBLE CHANCE TO AVOID DEATH?
YES PLEASE
Unvote; Vote: TheLastDays
Current tally:
7 Fluffy (Chaotix, Romanic, jh, GH, TLD,khazar, soulblade)
6 glyphz (Renata, dcmort, W_e, ironside, w&f, yaro)
6 TheLastDays (DIY, Believer, Earthling, Seon, fluffy, riedquat)
4 Double A (Andres, Capt Blackadder, DE, eliteking)
1 Romanic (zack)
1 zack (glyphz)
LE GASP
TIE FTW
Unvote;Vote: glyphz
Stop it, fluffy, you are making me want to vote for you :p
Nah. Don't like ties. Too indecisive.
Unvote, Vote: glyphz
Ignore this
Aw, I want TLD to get lynched. Make it happen people. :whip:
I WILL NOT.Quote:
Originally Posted by Chaotix
THIS POST WAS OBVIOUSLY CLAIMING
HIS SCUMMINESS TO THE WORLD.
HAY!Quote:
Originally Posted by Tratorix
...............
Will you give me a cookie?
Quiet you, before I change my mind.Quote:
Originally Posted by Thefluffyone93
It's not every day I save myscummemebuddy from the lynch.
glyphz is very likely not mafia, if he was he'd have had other teammates defending him more at this point and that's besides the fact there's no real case on him here.
Chaotix I guess is excused for changing votes because he was one of the first to vote for fluffy and not a bandwagonner, so he's not exactly being a hypocrite. Nevertheless I said I'd disagree with this vote swing and as my suspect is not getting lynched I will
Unvote; vote: fluffy
We'll see what any stragglers think and there's glyphz's own vote of course too.
Are you kidding me? God Emperor was crucified for failing to reveal quickly, and for bungling the situation in general.Quote:
Originally Posted by glyphz
How was that suspicious in any way?
Why shouldn't I reveal myself? I'm vanilla, I don't have anything to hide from anyone.
Consecutive posts by fluff w/o a meme... I must be dreaming
I thought you wanted to lynch TLD? Why glyphz over him?Quote:
Originally Posted by Earthling
https://i1110.photobucket.com/albums...g?t=1312602469Quote:
Originally Posted by glyphz
^^
I love this guy.
We don't have the votes. As I already said, between the other candidates for killing a random townie, I agree people gave the correct reason that fluffy is the best lynch, as the most distracting suspect who won't be of benefit or useful to analyze later.
Fluffy is the greatest player of all time. OF ALL TIME!
Pretty sure their are enough votes. Plus the vote is currently tied, which is not good. Thank you for answering my question clearly, even though I said glyphz when I meant fluffy. :bow:Quote:
Originally Posted by Earthling
Oh phooey.Quote:
Originally Posted by Earthling
The town can do fine without my help.
So there's no need to kill me!
...............................
Wait, I don't think I made my case any better.....
https://i1110.photobucket.com/albums...g?t=1312602891
https://i1110.photobucket.com/albums...f?t=1312603077Quote:
Originally Posted by Visorslash
FLUFFY! VOTE TLD!
YOU KNOW YOU WANT TO!
WHUTS THE TALLY?!?Quote:
Originally Posted by Seon
I NEED TO KNOW THE TALLY!!!
HALP!
Fluffy- 7
Glyphz- 8
TLD-4
A bunch of people who don't matter- votes
Goodbye glyphz. :bow:
Note: tally may be wrong. Follow it at your own risk.
Tally is negative 3 to potato
This man is a geniusQuote:
Originally Posted by Yaropolk
1 Hour, 16 Minutes, 55 Seconds to go. Ish.
Vote: TheFluffyOne
I love you, but I must KILL you!
.........Quote:
Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy
You make me want to cry, Pizza.
What have I ever done to you?
Oh wait...........
Yeah, I guess you can do that.
Woah, I have been away. When I voted for Fluffy, it was Fluffy 5, others less....
There's a whole other page.... it's like a.... a.... anotherworld.
Thats not good, you tied the vote! :shocked:Quote:
Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy
Are ya? Hmmmmmm?Quote:
Originally Posted by Zack
Are ya, really?
:stare:
If I claim that I'm vanilla townie as well, are you gonna believe me, & take my word for it?
Doubt it.
So why should I believe you then?
Quote:
Originally Posted by Tratorix
EEEEK TIES ARE EVIL
unvote, vote: Somebody
*cough* whuzzat?
LE GASP
INDEED THEY ARE PIZZA.
OMG THIS IS MAKING BE BI-POLAR
I LOVE FLUFFY KITTENS COVERED IN SPIKES.
Not yet. :bow:Quote:
Originally Posted by Tratorix
Welcome to the party, 'pizzaQuote:
Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy
You're the other option for today, aren't you?Quote:
Originally Posted by glyphz
Ok tell me, which one of you should I vote for and why.
Vote for Glyphz.
People are voting for me because I'm useless.Quote:
Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy
Which is quite a big surprise for me, because I thought everybody already knew that and were fine with it!
YOU FORGOT TO SAY WHYQuote:
Originally Posted by Visorslash
vote: Visorslash
Because it'll keep me alive?Quote:
Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy
Oh wait....you want to kill me....
I DID. MY REASONING WAS
.
I HAVE SOME MORE REASONING!
Fluffy is a lynch out of frustration. Glyphz is the guy who should be lynched.
Granted, some of that frustration might have been caused by my memes, butQuote:
Originally Posted by Visorslash
https://i1110.photobucket.com/albums...g?t=1312605600
Yeah but if you're going to sign up for games, you have to try occasionally. Or else you're potential scum, and no help to the townie side.Quote:
Originally Posted by Thefluffyone93
Not that I care, being mafia and all.
unvote, vote: Fluffy
I was the one who killed Reenk Roink. I did it with the rusty chainsaw, in the conservatory, and I was wearing a dress at the time.
Also, glyphz is my home boy. Nobody touches him, in that way, but me.
Okay, let's dial down on the spam a little bit.
I like them. They're a nice change.
ATPG, do you play a game to win, or to have fun?
Pizza be trolling this game.
Who said that? I've killed men for less. :stare:
Right now, playing for fun. But still showing up to vote. No idea what I'm doing but firing blindly is better than being a lurker.Quote:
ATPG, do you play a game to win, or to have fun?
Yep. I got the wagon, but am unwillingly fighting fluff for the right to ride it one-way to the gallows...Quote:
Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy
Only gone through the thread once, so I dont have any ammunition w/ someone's name on it...
If I were to borrow someone else's case I'd go w/ DoubleA, TheLastDays, or Zack.
Try?Quote:
Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy
Where's the fun in that?
I see no fun in dissecting every single post, trying to
see which is the scummiest.
Nah, I let the Random Gods roll their dice, or vote Chaotix!
I prefer to keep guessing; let people who want to have their heads hurt actually
try.
And isn't firing blindly exactly what Fluffy is doing? And he is showing up to vote, if I recall correctly.Quote:
Right now, playing for fun. But still showing up to vote. No idea what I'm doing but firing blindly is better than being a lurker.
I approve, even if it causes my death.Quote:
Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy
TROLL TIL THE END.
(AND SOME TIME AFTER AS WELL!)
What's your point? I gotta kills me somebody.Quote:
Originally Posted by Visorslash
You don't have to dissect every single post to play this game.Quote:
Try?
Where's the fun in that?
I see no fun in dissecting every single post, trying to
see which is the scummiest.
Nah, I let the Random Gods roll their dice, or vote Chaotix!
I prefer to keep guessing; let people who want to have their heads hurt actually
try.
So make it glyphz.Quote:
What's your point? I gotta kills me somebody.
Purty Please?Quote:
Originally Posted by Visorslash
You can always kill me tomorrow!
No, I have no idea what the arguments are.
I would be really ticked off if I spent all round trying to get somebody killed and then somebody like a pizza guy came in and herp derped all over the thread and voted down my case.
You guys know what's going on, I'll defer.
Unvote, vote: GeneralHankerchief
For acting like a moderator
This, I like.Quote:
Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy
Herp Derp ftw.
I'll sum up the case.Quote:
Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy
Thefluffyone93: Is Thefluffyone93.
glyphz: Andres thought a post he made was scummy.
That has been the extent of discussion this round. Also TLD and Believer each wrote an essay on why the other is guilty, that no one actually read.