Mafia VIII: Return of the Recommencement of the Revenge of the Mafia [Concluded]

[Privateerkev]

I'm torn on LG.

On one hand, he seems to be posting more than in Taormina. Which seems a little suspicious.

On the other, his posts almost seem too argumentative to be mafia. The back and forth about math just seems out of character for someone who is trying to hide amongst the crowd.

So he is either trying to be more involved in this game in order to be a helpful townie, or it is because he's trying hard to "not" act like the stereotypical mafia.

Right now, I would lean towards the former.

[Ferret]

Eh I thought Shlin told me Craterus was already dead. Man I am bad at this game, oh well

vote:Ichigo

for not allowing himself to belong to ferrets :P

[seireikhaan]

Vote: Elite Ferret

For that ludicrous 3rd vote on the PK bandwagon last round. Also, for still being goofy after the first round of voting.


EDIT:

Tally:

FactionHeir 1(Woad&Fangs)
Seamus: 1(Kagemusha)
Makaikhaan: 1(FactionHeir)
LittleGrizzly: 1(Shlin28)
Ichigo: 1(Elite Ferret)
Elite Ferret: 1(makaikhaan)
Sasaki: 1(Ichigo)

[Csargo]

Vote:Sasaki again...

[Privateerkev]

For that ludicrous 3rd vote on the PK bandwagon last round. Also, for still being goofy after the first round of voting.

EF is acting very different from Taormina. In Taormina, where he was a Townie, he basically made short, yet thoughtful posts semi-often. (about once a day phase)

Vote:Sasaki again...

Ok, I can understand doing it the first turn every game for laughs. But again? What exactly has Sasaki done this game to have you paying attention to him for more than your usual customary turn?

[Beefy187]

This might have been said before but...

Can mafia kill two players if they are down to one players?
Sorry if this has been said. I got no time to go through all post just yet..

[GeneralHankerchief]

Yes.

Two players will be killed on every night.

[pevergreen]

Vote: Beefy

You know that beefy. I know you know that.

And on top of all of that, why are you not getting ready for our soccer match?

[Sarathos]

Look into EF guys.
He did a pointless FoS on Craterus. Plus, throwing suspicion on someone you know will be killed is a well know WIFOM.

Why? As he said he was just having some fun. I do stuff like that all that time (and a lot worse) and I always get wrongfully lynched.

I am going to Vote:Shlin
You were one of only three talking in the last night phase. You FOSed EF for FOSing Craterus and then Craterus dies. A set up to make EF looke guilty perhaps....?

This might have been said before but...
Can mafia kill two players if they are down to one players?
Sorry if this has been said. I got no time to go through all post just yet..

Beefy, you have been on the .Org longer than me, ago you are more experienced, and even I know this so of course you would. Plus I am pretty sure you have done it when you have been mafia, whats gives?

And on top of all of that, why are you not getting ready for our soccer match?

The question is, are you?

[Tratorix]

I think EF is rather suspicious. I don't recall him ever being this silly in any previous games. Seems like he's trying very hard to seem nonchalant about everything.

[Privateerkev]

I think EF is rather suspicious. I don't recall him ever being this silly in any previous games. Seems like he's trying very hard to seem nonchalant about everything.

Exactly. Where Sarathos does it all the time, I have never seen EF quite like this. Even in the throne room. It's almost like he is going out of his way to be "goofy".

Go through his posts in order.

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14

[Csargo]

Ok, I can understand doing it the first turn every game for laughs. But again? What exactly has Sasaki done this game to have you paying attention to him for more than your usual customary turn?

A typical vice of American politics is the avoidance of saying anything real on real issues.

[Crazed Rabbit]

vote: Kagemusha

He well knows, since winning GH's first mafia, of the history of the mafia games. Some of that included a person drowning after being weighted down with osmium. He also knows that GH adds a lot of his own storytelling to the descriptions.

The reasoning for the vote on Seamus seems very thrown together, more of a fake attempt at good reasoning than a genuine assessment. I would expect better logic from someone like him.

CR

[Beefy187]

Vote: Beefy

You know that beefy. I know you know that.

And on top of all of that, why are you not getting ready for our soccer match?

Im just checking. Am I not allowed to check anymore? My parents always told me to check even its the most obvious thing.. Besides if I was a mafia I wouldnt even have to ask that...

And im was already ready, destination is like 20 minutes away and post was made like 1 hour before the game fool!

Vote: EF

While I dont completely trust PK, he does seem to be the safest bet for now.

[Ferret]

Sure lynch away I'm not much use to the town anyway. I don't think I've ever done anything useful in any game that I've been a townie...

[shlin28]

FoS EF for FoSing a dead guy...

I FoSed EF because he FoSed PK, never did I FoS EF because he FoSed Craterus...

So Sarathos' reason for voting me is null and void

[Gaius Scribonius Curio]

Vote:FactionHeir

I'm in a bit of a hurry and won't have a chance to explain properly, for now but will be back tomorrow morning my time to explain further if necessary.
Basically he the one of the standouts in my book at the moment, but I don't remember exactly why right now and don't have enough time to go searching.

Apologies and will be back tomorrow.

[LittleGrizzly]

On the other, his posts almost seem too argumentative to be mafia. The back and forth about math just seems out of character for someone who is trying to hide amongst the crowd.


Want to watch out for those chatty people eh ?

the math thing was just my fingers typing quicker than my brain thinks, halfed the nine then just added 10 for some reason.... anyway the whole odds thing is a bit of a pointless sidetrack, i was just trying to explain my vote for sasaki..... im not sure who to vote for now...

im going to go for EF just because of the PK bandwagon....

Vote EliteFerret

[Ferret]

What about the rest of the people on the PK bandwagon...besides I left it before the end as I didn't think it was worth lynching him.

[LittleGrizzly]

On the hand i don't think your all that guilty... on the other hand no-one wants a vote on them so i can't change it because of that, well its partially your fault pk's dead...

[KukriKhan]

Don't know about the rest, but georgeman51 signed up for LotR last week and then disappeared off the face of the earth. I suspect he's one of those Org n00bs who signs up for games and then never returns to the forums.

OK, so he's WoG-bait then. The rest of the non-participants?

Didn't vote: 5 (Mithrandir, Lord Winter, Quintus.J.Cicero, georgeman51, Joe Monks)

Gotta dash to the day-job, so I'll throw a vote out there:

vote: Mithrandir

I've not ever seen him sign up to a project, then ignore it. Hughly suspicious.

[naut]

Christ I'm confused already. So many players playing strangely. I really have to give this some thought first.

I really do hate to jump on a bandwagon (actually no I do, its good fun )

I'm gonna FOS: FactionHeir, getting some bad vibes.

[FactionHeir]

Everyone seems to have bad vibes about me and I'm not even wearing those rags the greenies do

[Seamus Fermanagh]

Vote: Elite Ferret

You were too savvy in Capo to make this "choppy" performance seem believeable.

Lynch away? Too cute.

[Ferret]

Goodbye sweet world

And LG: it was PK's fault he was lynched, no one elses.

[TinCow]

It's pretty thin on the ground all around, but a bit less thin around Elite Ferret. PK is correct about his posting style. The only thing that makes me doubt it is that I don't see any posts which would be consistent with a mafioso partner trying to save him. He's probably not mafia, but I don't see anyone else who looks more incriminating at this point.

Vote: Elite Ferret

[anelious phyros]

Is there still room?

[GeneralHankerchief]

Is there still room?

Sorry, signups have been closed.

Check the Mafia Hosting Queue (stickied in the Gameroom) for games that still need players. There should always be at least one, and if not, then one will be starting soon.

[anelious phyros]

Thanks

[Joe Monks]

As I am not Mafia I better post quick