Mafia VIII: Return of the Recommencement of the Revenge of the Mafia [Concluded]

[Privateerkev]

And that's unfortunately where you're wrong. This is quite fortunate for the town, because we can simply tune him out and leave him be. Why do the mafia a favor and kill someone whom we're quite sure is a regular(even if unhelpful) townsperson. Anytime you can get a near confirmation of innocence, its good because you can turn the lynch to someone who might actually be a mafioso.

If you have a better target, I'd like to hear it. And I'm not convinced yet by the arguments against Tiberius.

Pever distracted the town and tried to throw suspicion on Kag, who might very well be innocent. We should let him live because?

Though I still keep wondering why your fighting this so hard...

[Craterus]

Though I still keep wondering why your fighting this so hard...

Why are you?

Even you don't think pever is mafia so why lynch him? The aim is to lynch the mafia so there's little point in lynching someone who is believed to be innocent. Thus, may as well lynch another possibly-more-helpful, but possibly mafia, 'townie'.

[FactionHeir]

PK the Grand Inquisitor
You happy with khaan and my answers now or you want to continue to grill us and let some others get away with killing townies?
Those that don't reply to you are probably a lot more scummy.

[Privateerkev]

Tiberius blatantly ignored previous data given in two different posts to lodge a quick vote before soon disappearing into the background again to lurk. Further condemning, he completely mischaracterized CR's vote in an attempt to justify his own vote. What part of that do you not feel is scummy?

Btw, I could say that you're trying awfully hard to make sure pever DOES get lynched. The pendulum swings both ways.

If you don't know CR, he does come off as guilty at first. He fooled me in Taormina. I see Tiberius as just lurking right now. Go after him if he doesn't get WoG'd.

As for me, go ahead and swing that pendulum back if you think it will help you. Pever seems to be doing a good enough job getting Pever lynched. I'm now turning my sights on those who are trying to protect him and enable poor townie behavior.

PK the Grand Inquisitor
You happy with khaan and my answers now or you want to continue to grill us and let some others get away with killing townies?
Those that don't reply to you are probably a lot more scummy.

No I'm not happy. Both of you tripped off my radar. As for those who don't reply, we'll go after them soon enough when they don't get WoG'd.

Talking and analysis help the town. Letting this place stay quiet does not help the town.

[FactionHeir]

No I'm not happy. Both of you tripped off my radar. As for those who don't reply, we'll go after them soon enough when they don't get WoG'd.

Talking and analysis help the town. Letting this place stay quiet does not help the town.

Tune your radar then.
As I said, there is no point is pursuing false leads which allow the true suspects to hide under the pretense of conversation going on.

And remember that GH said that just posting in the thread without voting abstain counts as abstain and won't get you WoGed.

[Privateerkev]

Tune your radar then.

Sorry, you'll have to do better than short, light, and fluffy comments to convince me your innocent.

As I said, there is no point is pursuing false leads which allow the true suspects to hide under the pretense of conversation going on.

And remember that GH said that just posting in the thread without voting abstain counts as abstain and won't get you WoGed.

Why are you so convinced they are false? Why do you seem to fear conversation? If your a townie, you would welcome discussion. You would welcome analysis and opinion.

Your attempts to solve "Da'General's Code" could just be an attempt to appear like your helping when your really not.

[FactionHeir]

Sorry, you'll have to do better than short, light, and fluffy comments to convince me your innocent.
Why are you so convinced they are false? Why do you seem to fear conversation? If your a townie, you would welcome discussion. You would welcome analysis and opinion.

Your attempts to solve "Da'General's Code" could just be an attempt to appear like your helping when your really not.

Nice try in getting some uncertainty into other people's minds with nagging questions, but they don't work. There is a limit to how much discussion is welcome and how much starts to harm the town.
That limit in my opinion has been exceeded.

I certainly do welcome analysis and opinion, but you must direct such works properly rather than analyze where there is nothing more to analyze.

[shlin28]

Damn... that means I wasted 10 minutes thinking about my theory over nothing...

Unvote: Ichigo

[Craterus]

If you don't know CR, he does come off as guilty at first. He fooled me in Taormina. I see Tiberius as just lurking right now. Go after him if he doesn't get WoG'd.

As for me, go ahead and swing that pendulum back if you think it will help you. Pever seems to be doing a good enough job getting Pever lynched. I'm now turning my sights on those who are trying to protect him and enable poor townie behavior.



No I'm not happy. Both of you tripped off my radar. As for those who don't reply, we'll go after them soon enough when they don't get WoG'd.

Talking and analysis help the town. Letting this place stay quiet does not help the town.

I've named my suspects and, as it stands, none of them have done anything to convince me otherwise. You can look back for it though.

[Privateerkev]

Why are you?

Even you don't think pever is mafia so why lynch him? The aim is to lynch the mafia so there's little point in lynching someone who is believed to be innocent. Thus, may as well lynch another possibly-more-helpful, but possibly mafia, 'townie'.

Because I'm trying to figure out why khaan is going so hard-corp on Tiberius but he gives Pever a total pass. At least be consistent...

And again, if there is a better choice than pever, than name it. Otherwise, cull the unhelpful townies from the group.

[seireikhaan]

Tiberius blatantly ignored previous data given in two different posts to lodge a quick vote before soon disappearing into the background again to lurk. Further condemning, he completely mischaracterized CR's vote in an attempt to justify his own vote. What part of that do you not feel is scummy?

Btw, I could say that you're trying awfully hard to make sure pever DOES get lynched. The pendulum swings both ways.

[Tratorix]

Tiberius blatantly ignored previous data given in two different posts to lodge a quick vote before soon disappearing into the background again to lurk. Further condemning, he completely mischaracterized CR's vote in an attempt to justify his own vote. What part of that do you not feel is scummy?

Tiberius acts like this in almost every game i've seen him in. He pops up about once per round and puts up either a random or bandwagon vote. I pretty much just tune him out, even though it seems scummy. I believe the only time i've seen him as mafia, he was trying to be active and helpful.