The Brothel - Large Mafia Game [Concluded]

[Ferret]

Vote:Beefy
He seems to be acting pro-town. But he is acting too pro-town for him to be a real townie....

How is it possible to act too pro town for a townie? Beefy is trying to help, would you rather he he voted for townies eh puritan?

vote:cronos

[Sigurd]

I have no reason to doubt GH's claim.
However I am not guilty and neither will I be if being investigated again.

That Beefy now repeats my question to shlin, without seeming to acknowledge that it has been answered, speaks of not really paying attention to what is going on.
It could mean he is innocent. But his so far pro-townieness with good replies speaks of a player reading the game thoroughly.
But this last statement blows his cover and instead puts him in the informed minority. His pro-towniness is a result of knowing what is going on and he don't really need to pay close attention to what is going on.
That is what I think, and if he is a prostitute then I am full of crap.

vote:Beefy

[Omanes Alexandrapolites]

Day IV Conclusion
As the sun set and the day concluded, it was discovered by a narrow margin that Beefy187 was to be lynched. The people of the brothel eventually decided to burn him to death. He was tied to pole in the brothels courtyard, and old twigs and bits of wood were thrown around the pole's base. As the kindling wood was lit, and the logs began to smoke, Beefy murmured unaudible words under his breath which continued as the flames engulfed him.

****

Beefy187 has been lynched!

Tally:
Beefy187 – 3 (shlin28, Cronos Impera, Sigurd Fafnesbane)

Sigurd Fafnesbane – 2 (GeneralHankerchief, makaikhaan)
Cronos Impera – 2 (Beefy187, Elite Ferret)

Elite Ferret – 1 (Craterus)

Night IV begins. All orders must be in by 20:00 (GMT+1) on Sunday the 20th of July. This is a total of 24-hrs.

Alive (10):
Andres
Caius
Craterus
Cronos Impera
Elite Ferret
GeneralHankerchief
Ichigo (joined D2 - replaced anelious phyros)
makaikhaan
shlin28
Sigurd Fafnesbane

Lynched (3):
pevergreen (D1) (formerly peverpink)
FactionHeir (D2)
Quintus.J.Cicero (D3)
Beefy187 (D4)

Killed (5):
El Diablo (N1)
Tratorix (N2)
Rythmic (N2)
TevashSzat (N3)
Crazed Rabbit (N3)

WoGed (0):

Suicided (1):
anelious phyros (D2) (replaced with Ichigo)

[Omanes Alexandrapolites]

Night IV Conclusion
shlin28 was eating a supper of dry bread dipped in some sort of broth. shlin couldn't sleep, and felt that a little nutrition would maybe help him accompish this. He was sat with his back towards the door while he consumed the food which was a foolish mistake to make.

From behind him, a single man approached. Dagger drawn, ready to attack shlin's neck. Within the space of a few seconds, shlin was a bloody heap on the flaw with numerous stab wounds all over his corpse. The attacker smiled a smile filled with pure evil, but, before leaving, he took a larger serrated knife from his pockets, and used it to cut off shlin's leg.

****

shlin28 has been killed!

Day V begins! This day shall conclude at approximately 19:00 (GMT+1) on Tuesday the 22nd of July. This is a total of around about 48 hours.

Alive (9):
Andres
Caius
Craterus
Cronos Impera
Elite Ferret
GeneralHankerchief
Ichigo (joined D2 - replaced anelious phyros)
makaikhaan
Sigurd Fafnesbane

Lynched (4):
pevergreen (D1) (formerly peverpink)
FactionHeir (D2)
Quintus.J.Cicero (D3)
Beefy187 (D4)

Killed (6):
El Diablo (N1)
Tratorix (N2)
Rythmic (N2)
TevashSzat (N3)
Crazed Rabbit (N3)
shlin28 (N4)

WoGed (0):

Suicided (1):
anelious phyros (D2) (replaced with Ichigo)

[Craterus]

vote: Sigurd

Firstly, the unclear detective result, seems a bit risky to leave him alive if GH won't be back to give the follow up result.

Secondly, I thought Beefy was innocent. I still can't really see the case against him but Sigurd put on the lynch vote (despite thinking he may be innocent? Why not Cronos, Sigurd? He's seemed much more suspicious for the whole game.)

Thirdly, he was sending PM's earlier in the game (to Andres, I think). I'm not sure I like this, I don't think I've ever felt the need to send private messages except when mafia in Capo. Could be completely innocent things but I don't see why it couldn't be posted in the main thread if everybody involved is innocent.

[Quintus.JC]

So only 1 kill this night, seems to be the serial killer.

[Cronos Impera]

I guess the serial killer is dead.This is the first night only one player bites the dust so Beefy's death either destroyed the mafia or eradicated the serial killer.

[seireikhaan]

Do we know how many puritans there are at the moment? Sigurd sent me a PM saying cronos must survive so they could both be mafia, or both be prostitutes...

But I doubt Sigurd would expose himself like that so I'm gonna take his advice and

vote:khaan

ATTENTION!!!

I am the real detective! I gave my previous results, as well as my role PM to General Hankerchief after I found him to be innocent on night one. I have once again investigated Sigurd Fafnesbane, and I have achieved a guilty result on him. And we can see that clearly, Sigurd did not want Cronos to be lynched, which tells us that Cronos must be guilty as well.

Vote: Sigurd Fafnesbane

Tally:

Sigurd Fafnesbane- 2(Khaan, Craterus)

[Cronos Impera]

That is a trick Makaikhaan.
Usually a mafioso claims to be the detective so he diverts attention from the party he tries to protect and direct the mob into lynching the townies.
That is Sasaki's tactic...it's a masquarade (khaan hasn't revealed his PM)
So.
Vote: Khaan
For pretending to be GH. This is an excellent move for him.


Tally:

Sigurd Fafnesbane- 2(Khaan, Craterus)

makaikhaan - 1 (Cronos Impera)

[seireikhaan]

That is a trick Makaikhaan.
Usually a mafioso claims to be the detective so he diverts attention from the party he tries to protect and direct the mob into lynching the townies.
That is Sasaki's tactic...it's a masquarade (khaan hasn't revealed his PM)
So.
Vote: Khaan
For pretending to be GH. This is an excellent move for him.


Tally:

Sigurd Fafnesbane- 2(Khaan, Craterus)

makaikhaan - 1 (Cronos Impera)

Ha. Nice try, but this just confirms your guilt. Why wouldn't I have revealed the role PM? No offense, but duh! Its already been revealed by GH, for everyone to see. It would be the epitome of redundancy to do it again, and if I had, Sigurd would certainly have accused me of being a fake anyways, of copying the PM from the thread. And if you had read GH's post, you would have noticed that he in fact challenged the mafia(aka you and Sigurd) to kill him, as it would be a wasted target. He, unlike Sigurd, was not bluffing.

[Craterus]

Adds up with what I said too.

Vote for Sigurd people.

[Csargo]

Interesting... Vote: Khaan

[seireikhaan]

Interesting... Vote: Khaan

Pray tell as to why your vote, Strawberry?

[Ferret]

Well I was suspicious of that first PM, might as well

vote:Sigurd

[FactionHeir]

Doubtful that khaan is the detective. Afaik private reveals are usually forbidden in games, so how would GH get khaan's full role PM? And even if it were true, how can we be sure he didn't fake a role PM?

[seireikhaan]

FactionHeir, private reveals are only banned if the host states so; many games have allowed them. Furthermore, there wasn't any problem with giving GH the role PM; I did it when I revealed. If you read the rules, there is no such ban on private reveals, or even sharing role PM's.
As for a fake; I guess that's up to everyone else's judgement as to whether or not I could have faked it.

[Craterus]

It's interesting that you've revealed after GH has gone. I guess you were waiting for the morning but... who knows. I believe you for now.

[seireikhaan]

It's interesting that you've revealed after GH has gone. I guess you were waiting for the morning but... who knows. I believe you for now.

Well yes, of course. The results GH had given were all the results I'd had until this night phase was over. Furthermore, if I'd revealed before the night was over, I would not only have not had any new info to show, I would have likely been killed as well. That would have been extremely counter productive.

[Crazed Rabbit]

ATTENTION!!!

I am the real detective! I gave my previous results, as well as my role PM to General Hankerchief after I found him to be innocent on night one. I have once again investigated Sigurd Fafnesbane, and I have achieved a guilty result on him. And we can see that clearly, Sigurd did not want Cronos to be lynched, which tells us that Cronos must be guilty as well.

Vote: Sigurd Fafnesbane

Tally:

Sigurd Fafnesbane- 2(Khaan, Craterus)

You lie. Lynch khaan, he is mafia.

I was killed in the night, but I was protected by two people. That can only mean one thing.

And so I know khaan to be a liar who must be lynched.

CR

[Caius]

Wait wait. If GH SAID that he was detective, why is he alive?

vote:khaan
What if khaan(confirmed mafia) and GH are the mafiosi?

[seireikhaan]

You lie. Lynch khaan, he is mafia.

I was killed in the night, but I was protected by two people. That can only mean one thing.

And so I know khaan to be a liar who must be lynched.

CR

If the town actually lynches its own detective, it deserves to lose. Hard.

BTW, I fail to see how your death means I am a liar.

[seireikhaan]

Wait wait. If GH SAID that he was detective, why is he alive?

vote:khaan
What if khaan(confirmed mafia) and GH are the mafiosi?

Caius, GH isn't the detective. He revealed proxy to help make sure I wasn't killed so I could keep investigating. It would work if the town would actually figure this out and pull its head out of its

[Crazed Rabbit]

BTW, I fail to see how your death means I am a liar.

I know you are lying, and I am proven innocent. So you should be lynched.

CR

[Beefy187]

You got 9 men left and 1 kill each night. So the best move would be to trust Khaan least for couple nights until you make your decision. Not that hard if you all stay active.

The worst move is to let the mafias allow to lynch the real detective.

Am I wrong?

[Caius]

If the town actually lynches its own detective, it deserves to lose. Hard.

BTW, I fail to see how your death means I am a liar.

We all know you are trying to kill Sigurd because he is the most active pro-town player. Give up scum. You are tryng to kill the discussion, who was promoted all the time by Sigurd Fafnesbane. That's why you are lying. Very good try, but it was not enough, khaan the guilty.

[seireikhaan]

I know you are lying, and I am proven innocent. So you should be lynched.

CR

If you "know" I am lying, then why don't you share the evidence?

[seireikhaan]

We all know you are trying to kill Sigurd because he is the most active pro-town player. Give up scum. You are tryng to kill the discussion, who was promoted all the time by Sigurd Fafnesbane. That's why you are lying. Very good try, but it was not enough, khaan the guilty.

Yes, I am soooooo killing discussion, I only have half the posts for this last page. Sigurd is scum, trying to direct the traffic of discussion just like Sasaki did in Taormina. And now I present evidence, and you still won't believe. Me and GH both had Sigurd pegged from early on as acting scummy, hence why we've both been voting for him.

[Crazed Rabbit]

You got 9 men left and 1 kill each night. So the best move would be to trust Khaan least for couple nights until you make your decision. Not that hard if you all stay active.

The worst move is to let the mafias allow to lynch the real detective.

Am I wrong?

No, you're wrong. We know khaan is lying and he should be lynched right now.

The evidence of my innocence is that I was killed in the night, while protected by two people. That can only mean one thing.

I also know Sigurd to be innocent. I, a confirmed innocent player, am vouching for him. khaan has accused him, and so I know khaan to be lying.

CR

[seireikhaan]

No, you're wrong. We know khaan is lying and he should be lynched right now.

The evidence of my innocence is that I was killed in the night, while protected by two people. That can only mean one thing.

I also know Sigurd to be innocent. I, a confirmed innocent player, am vouching for him. khaan has accused him, and so I know khaan to be lying.

CR

CR, out with it. Just because you were killed while being with 2 other people, which, btw, gives you a 50% chance of not being killed, does not mean that you have any kind of reason or evidence against someone else. You've got nothing, and I would like it if you would stop messing with the town. I would also enjoy hearing your story of why you vouch for Sigurd's innocence.

[Andres]

CR, out with it. Just because you were killed while being with 2 other people, which, btw, gives you a 50% chance of not being killed, does not mean that you have any kind of reason or evidence against someone else. You've got nothing, and I would like it if you would stop messing with the town. I would also enjoy hearing your story of why you vouch for Sigurd's innocence.

Where you involved in a protection during the night CR was killed?