South Park: Imaginationland [Concluded]

[ULC]

Vote: Joooray

I am inclined to go after the lurkers right now due to the lack of a kill.

[Winston Hughes]

vote: Death is yonder

Snarf

[Diamondeye]

Well yes, that is what I am accusing you for.. It doesn't sit well with me when people change their vote 10 minutes before deadline-- Although you make it sound absurd that I would believe you would cause a mess like that as a mafia, it's the exact same reason you use when voting for me :) - So I fail to see why you would use such an argument in your defense, when such reason is good enough for your offense.

The difference is that mine was an elaborate action to skew the tally; as I said, I hadn't seen the extra vote on CB, and I though I was effectively giving JHT the death kiss; if he was mafia, I'm sure it would provoke one of his scum buddies to try and save him (although voting CB would've been better than voting me, in that case).
You on the other hand reacted on it as I expected a potential scumpartner would have done. That's why I'm voting you. I can understand why people are voting me, but it's still a wrong move.

Snarf

What.

[Winston Hughes]

What.

Snarf

[johnhughthom]

The difference is that mine was an elaborate action to skew the tally; as I said, I hadn't seen the extra vote on CB, and I though I was effectively giving JHT the death kiss; if he was mafia, I'm sure it would provoke one of his scum buddies to try and save him (although voting CB would've been better than voting me, in that case).
You on the other hand reacted on it as I expected a potential scumpartner would have done. That's why I'm voting you. I can understand why people are voting me, but it's still a wrong move.

What.

Exactly.

[classical_hero]

I am inclined to go after the lurkers right now due to the lack of a kill.

Do we have any role blockers in this game? That could explain the lack of the other kill, but so does this, but there still was a kill so at least one mafia was active, so we should try for him first, I think.

[autolycus]

The reason why I want to lynch an inactive, classical_hero, is not so much about the possibility of them being mafia, but more, strange as it sounds, to prevent the mafia from killing them. Since this is a game where scum aren't revealed on death, the only people we know are innocent are those the mafia kills. I'd like to make sure the mafia can't keep telling us "the person who isn't talking is innocent so you can trust his lack of advice." If we lynch inactives, then the mafia a) has to stay active themselves, giving us a record to analyze, and b) has to kill more active people, who can then help us identify the mafia later in the game with us knowing they're innocent.

[woad&fangs]

vote: Jooray due to lack of kill.
Dang it! I wanted to vote Jesus! Looks like I'll have to settle for Aslan whenever I find him.
:hurls thunderbolts in a fit of rage:

[God Emperor]

The difference is that mine was an elaborate action to skew the tally; as I said, I hadn't seen the extra vote on CB, and I though I was effectively giving JHT the death kiss; if he was mafia, I'm sure it would provoke one of his scum buddies to try and save him (although voting CB would've been better than voting me, in that case).
You on the other hand reacted on it as I expected a potential scumpartner would have done. That's why I'm voting you. I can understand why people are voting me, but it's still a wrong move.

Your reasons doesn't sit well with me at all.. however to be fair with you, I don't know how to feel right now; your actions reminds me of those in council of villiant that just shifted their vote from Tincow to survive, which we spoke a bit about.
The case on Joooray is well spotted... As I think all save Joooray has been actively online, I think we are down to a 50% chance of him being scum.. which is ofc a very high percentage chance. However imo chances are equally good that Johnhughthom was scum - In which case, Diamondeye was really lucky.. Viewing the number of active people that happily join that bandwagon might suggest that it was JHT who was scum.. This is ofc just speculations, but worth a thought imo..
Anyway the best choice for today is to Vote: Joooray

[Diamondeye]

I like Autolycus' reasons for lynching inactives

[God Emperor]

I see Iforgot to unvote. . Unvote; Vote: Joooray

[robbiecon]

Well, ok the reason for only one kill last night may be:

1.) One of the mafiats weren't active, and that mafiat may have been in charge of a kill order, so it didn't go through.
2.) One of the targets was protected.
3.) One of the mafia were roleblocked.

Now, the most possible is that one mafiat wasn't actve, and as others have noted, Joooray hasn't been active.

Therefore Vote: Joooray

[classical_hero]

The reason why I want to lynch an inactive, classical_hero, is not so much about the possibility of them being mafia, but more, strange as it sounds, to prevent the mafia from killing them. Since this is a game where scum aren't revealed on death, the only people we know are innocent are those the mafia kills. I'd like to make sure the mafia can't keep telling us "the person who isn't talking is innocent so you can trust his lack of advice." If we lynch inactives, then the mafia a) has to stay active themselves, giving us a record to analyze, and b) has to kill more active people, who can then help us identify the mafia later in the game with us knowing they're innocent.

Fair enough, even though it does sound crazy. We are killing them to prove they are innocent, but i do understand what you are about.

So with that in mind I unvote, vote:Jooray

[Khazaar]

I think the last minute voteswitch (es) were unneccesary VOTE: Diamondeye

[Askthepizzaguy]

Your reasons doesn't sit well with me at all.. however to be fair with you, I don't know how to feel right now; your actions reminds me of those in council of villiant that just shifted their vote from Tincow to survive, which we spoke a bit about.
The case on Joooray is well spotted... As I think all save Joooray has been actively online, I think we are down to a 50% chance of him being scum.. which is ofc a very high percentage chance. However imo chances are equally good that Johnhughthom was scum - In which case, Diamondeye was really lucky.. Viewing the number of active people that happily join that bandwagon might suggest that it was JHT who was scum.. This is ofc just speculations, but worth a thought imo..
Anyway the best choice for today is to Vote: Joooray

This was the last vote before the 24 hour deadline. Apologies for being asleep.

Tallying now.



Joooray: Auto, DIY, YLC, woad,
DE: Classical, GE [did not unvote]
GE: DE
DIY: Winston

[Askthepizzaguy]

Darth Vader: Bring the prisoner to me....


Morpheus: We are all in a prison. A prison of the mind. DO YOU BELIEVE ALL OF THIS..... is real? Take the blue pill, you stay in Imaginationland. Take the red pill, and....

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Morpheus' head hit the stone floor of Castle Sunshine. The rest of him hit the floor a second later. Darth Vader's glowing red saber was held menacingly above the body.

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Darth Vader: You take the blue saber, you stay in Jedi land. You take the red saber.... and kill someone. The rest of you, get to your quarters and try to stay alive. Your attempts at survival continue to amuse me.



Alive: [14/17]

Diamondeye
Sprig
Seon
God Emperor
classical_hero
Khazaar
Death is yonder
Captain Blackadder
Winston Hughes
Secura
Robbiecon
woad&fangs
YLC
Autolycus


Dead: [3/17]

Johnhughthom- Popeye
Warman- Jesus
Joooray- Morpheus



24 hours to send in your actions.

[Diamondeye]

Whoever Vader is, he's awesomesauce.

[Secura]

Ugh, haven't been feeling well all day, dozed off and woke up far too late to vote. -_-'

Despite the general consensus, I believe that the missing kill from the previous night phase wasn't a case of an inactive mafia, but a ploy designed to have us throw lynches away on inactive townspeople; lynching lurkers/inactives is always going to end up with easy bandwagons for mafia to hide in, and here we have six people voting for him (two late votes, though).

I don't really have a suspect as of yet, but I'd definitely start in that list of six people and I would probably have voted for woad&fangs again; gut feeling.

[Askthepizzaguy]

That night, the good creatures of Imaginationland went to sleep.


However, one man was up the whole night, pacing around.


Al Gore: "I know he's here.... I just know it! WHERE ARE YOU MANBEARPIG??? I will curse you if you kill even one more defenseless child!"

Al Gore tore off his shoes and looked inside them.

Al Gore: "I know you're in there! I've got you completely surrounded!"


Suddenly, a furry creature popped out of his shoe, startling him.


Al Gore: "Gahhhh! Manbearpig! I knew it was you!"

Unknown: "Relax, mister! I'm not Manbearpig!"

Al Gore: "You don't fool me that easily! Stay back, or I will use my awesome Goring powers on you!"

Unknown: "Goring? Gee that sounds awfully painful!"

Al Gore: "Just listen to the sound of my voice.... listen closely.... it's super important! I'm cereal!"

Unknown: "That's okay, I really just came to congratulate you. It turns out, they finally finished recounting the ballots, and you've become the REAL President of the United States!"

Al Gore: "Really? I always knew this day would come."

Unknown: "Only in your imagination...."

Al Gore: "No.... no that's not true.... that's impossible!"

Unknown: "Search your feelings, you know it to be true."

Al Gore: "I just can't live with myself anymore.... good-bye, cruel Manbearpig-filled world!"

Captain Blackadder- Al Gore

Much later on, a woman was flying around in the sky, in her invisible plane. She spotted something large and furry in the forest, yelling for help. She landed her aircraft and had some trouble exiting the plane. Where was the door handle?

Come on, it's gotta be around here somewhere.

I think it's more to the left.... no, lower. Lower.

What do you mean it's locked? Look for the keys. Oh yeah, right, they're invisible too. You can't open the locked door from the inside? What kind of crazy design is that? You're saying you can't get out of the plane? Oh for the love of crumbs.

*Game host draws a door on the plane.*

There. Next time, try flying in a visible plane.

Too bad your clothes are visible. But I digress.


Wonder Woman: "I'm here, woodland creature! I will rescue you from the bear trap!"

Unknown: "I haven't eaten in forever! Please help me...."

Wonder Woman: "I can collect some nuts and berries for you."

Unknown: "But I can't just eat nuts and berries! I'm starving! I need something more substantial!"

Wonder Woman: "What do you want to eat?"

Unknown: "Crispy chicken breast and a couple of drumsticks. But I ain't got no chicken...."

Wonder Woman: "EEEEEK!!!"

Secura- Wonder Woman

Darth Vader: "There were more remains found last night. Don't fail me again."



Alive: [12/17]

Diamondeye
Sprig
Seon
God Emperor
classical_hero
Khazaar
Death is yonder
Winston Hughes
Robbiecon
woad&fangs
YLC
Autolycus


Dead: [5/17]

Johnhughthom- Popeye
Warman- Jesus
Joooray- Morpheus
Captain Blackadder- Al Gore
Secura- Wonder Woman





24 hours to discuss and vote.

[autolycus]

Alright, Secura and Captain Blackadder, step up and give us your confirmed-townie wisdom!
I could see the case for eliminating another inactive, but if we haven't hit a scum yet, we've only got two more shots.
Therefore, I'm going to vote:YLC His reasoning for voting jooray was weak, and it was joining a bandwagon.

[Seon]

Lololol

Reading through the thread now. Will report when done so.

[robbiecon]

The thread isn't that long Seon to go over.

But I'm not interested in looking at you yet.

Now YLC may have killed off Captain Blackadder as he voted for YLc on day 1, and perhaps he was worried that CB would return to vote for him.

However YLC was on the Joooray bandwagon reasonably early, and I have a feeling that Morpheus may be mafia. (At least I feel it more likely than Popeye as mafia)

Now moving on, classical_hero came in with a very late vote change. Perhaps he wanted to blend in on the lynch wagon, seeing as Joooray was a gonner anyway. It's a regular move to come in and vote for a mafia buddy if he's going down.

For this reason I'll vote: classical_hero

[Seon]

Ah yes Robbie, I have gone through all the posts made by everyone, analyzed all their hidden intents, examined all the kills, made a chart, compared many of the players to characters from Edgar Allen Poe Novel, and came up with nothing in particular, but I think I am still going to vote for Vote: Diamondeye. Because if he's not guilty, I am going to burn my hands.

[autolycus]

Atpg, do cover roles stay intact on death?
Robbiecon, I'm assuming cover roles stay intact on death, since scum are not revealed on death. Therefore, conclusions based on what character anyone came up when lynched are founded on sand.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Cover roles stay intact on death.

[robbiecon]

Good point autolycus, I didn't consider that perhaps the dead scum are revealed as their cover roles. I assumed it would be purely for claiming purposes.

But remember there was no picture for Morpheus in the write up.

[Askthepizzaguy]

But remember there was no picture for Morpheus in the write up.

That's an oversight on my part.

[robbiecon]

That's an oversight on my part.

This looks like the face of pure evil.

[johnhughthom]

This looks like the face of pure evil.

Nah, evil is much more decisive looking.

[Secura]

I still think woad is a good lynch.