There is indications of both a Fire guy and a Black Ooze guy, we might be looking at two possible killers, not simply one.
I think the cult is telling the truth about their alignment themselves, none of their dead members have ever turned up as being scum in the write-ups and the ones they accused of being scum have turned up as scum. Apparently Askthepizzaguy, Andres (first time), Death is Yonder and others who have been killed were all cultists. All their write-ups have indicated of them actually being town. According to them as well, recruited members retain their normal victory conditions (getting rid of the mafia), it is sort of a "recruited pro town network" as it were.
People they have failed was Renata and Andres (second time), both of these turned up as scum in the write-ups. With what Classical_Hero being a 'god' and was recruited, in comparison to Chaotix, that casts a big figure on Chaotix's true alignment.
Since the cult is looking for Angra Mainyu as well, Chaotix wouldn't obviously be him and Chaotix has claimed to be some one else. All in short - There is a very strong possibility Chaotix is not town aligned and scum of some sort.
As for cults? Bring on the cult overlord, the worst that could happen is that I get night killed before I end up recruited into the winning side if the cult truly are not town aligned.
Bookmarks