Capo di Tutti Capi IV [Concluded]

[Craterus]

On the one hand, it's obviously Sigurd's doing. On the other, I don't understand why he left a clue in-thread.

unvote: Raskolnikov
vote: Sigurd

[Xenoneb]

Go for a four way lynch!

[Kennigit]

I pretty much missed this thread today, so I'll vote: Present. I am uneducated to form a proper lynch vote today, but still want to be annoying to tally makers while I comply to the game rules :) (as opposed to voting abstain).

[Secura]

Who said anything about the same night?

The presentation of the results in your post make it appear as such.

[Chaotix]

Unvote, Vote: Sigurd

Much better. I would rather not lynch MRD if we can avoid it, there seems to be no reason apart from a criminal scan.

TinCow has made a concise and convincing case on Sigurd, and I'd say it's better to cut off the head of the snake rather than go after Populus the Proletariat at the moment.

[fubbleskag]

TinCow's logic seems sound enough for me: Vote: Sigurd

[Crazed Rabbit]

Vote: Sigurd

Left a clue behind on the internet again, huh?



CR

[El Barto]

I don't know them. Only if I accepted I would have got in touch with them.

But you said you got an invite from someone ....with a ...name?

My point exactly.

vote: Major Robert Dump
I can't find the case against him but apparently it is a good one. The reasons for my guilty result are well known. I am going for rogue detective status.

So much scummalicious Wine in front of you!

Vote: abstain

Sorry I'm on family trip and I have limited internet access.
I couldn't read all the thread.

Beefy, you're Japanese. national stereotypes dictate you have no family trips.

I pretty much missed this thread today, so I'll vote: Present. I am uneducated to form a proper lynch vote today, but still want to be annoying to tally makers while I comply to the game rules :) (as opposed to voting abstain).

You serious?

[DaveShack]

Based on votes since last tally, I think Sigurd now has enough of a lead to require votes on someone else to keep the possibility of a multiple.
I'll vote: Chaotix to tip it back toward balance a little.

Though to be honest, I'm thinking someone is getting framed, and I have no idea which one. My guess is either the original PM is originally fake and a trap for the one who posts it, or modified but it can't be rebutted without revealing something else damaging.

The 3 day wait to identify folks after death is going to make things really interesting. And then there's all those posts to dig through to figure out which ones are evidential and which are meaningless fluff. Is there a way to download a whole thread on this forum? I know how to do it on CFC but not here. Might be interesting to do some offline analysis once it's in one big text file. Also can you pull up #posts by user and filter by user that way?

[Xehh II]

Vote: Sigurd

[GeneralHankerchief]

Is there a way to download a whole thread on this forum? I know how to do it on CFC but not here. Might be interesting to do some offline analysis once it's in one big text file. Also can you pull up #posts by user and filter by user that way?

There isn't a way to download the entire thread (that I know of), but you can check a user's posts in a particular thread from the parent forum (in this case, the Gameroom) by clicking on the number of replies the thread has. A new window should come up listing everyone who's posted in the thread and the number of posts they've made. Click on the number of posts they've made and voila. You have to do it while online though.

[Ishmael]

There isn't a way to download the entire thread (that I know of), but you can check a user's posts in a particular thread from the parent forum (in this case, the Gameroom) by clicking on the number of replies the thread has. A new window should come up listing everyone who's posted in the thread and the number of posts they've made. Click on the number of posts they've made and voila. You have to do it while online though.

Wow, I didn't realise you could do that. Thanks GH!

[Erebus]

You can by subscription actually. Just have it email you with daily updates. You'll get one big email that you can copy and paste into a text file.

[a completely inoffensive name]

Too many people in this game. Go for a 5 way tie lynch.

[naut]

Does the distinction of being a 3rd Party really matter when there are multiple, competing mafia families? What's the difference?

Why the interest?

Vote: Cecil

[naut]

Why are people voting for Sigurd? Some stupid he's a communist ploy?

I mean, at least I can understand people are voting for MRD... He's different! Not a member of the herd! Quick lynch him before he makes us look foolish!

Sigurd had success last game disguising himself as part of a different faction while being mafia didn't he?

Do you believe he would he do it again?

[scottishranger]

Vote: Sigurd Lets kill some communists ... even though I know I stated earlier that I doubt Seamus would include them again...

[Erebus]

For the record, we're not voting Sigurd because he's a communist.

We're voting him because he isn't a communist and this is obviously some sort of cover for something else, possible sinister.

[naut]

For the record, we're not voting Sigurd because he's a communist.

We're voting him because he isn't a communist and this is obviously some sort of cover for something else, possible sinister.

So what I quoted from Sasaki? Aka: "He's done it before, and he'll do it again."

Ok. At least I can understand the "logic" there.

[Craterus]

Well, a more complete summary of the case would be:

A fabricated KGB role PM was sent with an image taken from his photobucket account and he posted in-thread about recruiting for the KGB.

My theory is that Sigurd sent the PM to Populus Romanus who fell for it and signed up, or rather, assumed he'd been recruited. What doesn't add up is: 1) why Sigurd would post in-thread about it - maybe he didn't think it'd get out in the open so soon but that throwaway comment seems pretty stupid in hindsight.
2) Why Populus Romanus took credit/blame for forging the role PM - perhaps he thought he should sacrifice himself for his leader but it would have been easier for him to defect back, so to speak. He's still a townie doctor after all...

[Lewwyn]

Here's my take on this thing. First, I do not believe Seamus would have asked Sigurd to host graphics on Sigurd's photobucket account. Seamus isn't the type to use images in any official role PM anyway, and if you look at post 3, you'll see that Seamus uses imageshack when he puts images into the game. Second, I do not believe Sigurd would invent a communist faction, complete with images and role PMs, just for the lulz. He's done it for a very specific purpose. Personally, I'd wager it's an attempt to disguise an entire mafia family as a neutral faction. If you're going to lynch anyone over this thing, you should lynch Sigurd.

Best argument in the thread...

Unvote; Vote: Sigurd

[Major Robert Dump]

That's a lot of scummy packed into one sentence. I mean, just for one thing, Revengening was about as overwhelming as it gets -- much more complicated than Capo in all ways save the role changing, and you coped just fine.

unvote, vote: MRD

That game wasn't nearly as spamilicous as this one. 55 pages. Day 4?

Also, I had a desk job then

[seireikhaan]

Vote: Sigurd

No regrets.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Giant wagon on Sigurd for the obviously scummy move of pretending to be scum...

Well, this is what happens when I go to work.

[GeneralHankerchief]

I still need volunteers for vig work tonight. PM only, I'd like to have enough people signed up a couple of hours after the phase ends so everybody can get their orders in on time.

[edse]

Vote:MRD I don't have internet enough to read all this

About the communist request: I got a pm from Seamus where he said the commies wanted to recruit me and I could accept or refuse. If I accepted I would get the recruiters name, if I refused nothing. That how it works.

Edit: They can't kill me for telling, can they?

[GeneralHankerchief]

Going to sleep for the night. Still could use a name or two for the vig group. If you're not sure, PM me anyway.

[Cahoma]

Vote: Sigurd
Obvious vote is obvious.

[Diamondeye]

Unvote, Vote: MRD.

[Jarema]

Unvote; Vote: Major Robert Dump