With Great Sacrifice [Concluded]

[BSmith]

I need to correct an inconsistency here:

Oh and actually there is one other reason that I believe edse is innocent. Yesterday he switched off of White_eyes onto you, BSmith. When he did that the vote was tied at 2 on you and himself, but since the vote on edse hadn't changed while the vote on you went from 1 to 2 that put edse as the vote that reached 2 first and therefore if day ended the one to be lynched. Why would edse switch his vote in a manner that put him at risk? That's actually one of the reasons I switched off of WHite_eyes at that time. I was sure that Lazy and edse were innocent. I thought that either you or White_eyes were the last killer. So I switched onto you to protect him even though of the two f you I suspected White_Eyes most. Something you eventually took advantage of by bargaining us all to move to White_eyes.

Edse switched off of me to White_Eyes only after I came off of him. The count was 3-2 against me when Edse posted this:

If you change your vote to White_eyes I can do so as well. I don't want to risk my own life however so one more vote would be needed.

I switched off of Edse to White_Eyes making it 3 for me, 1 for edse and 1 for White Eyes. You and Edse then followed making it 3 for White Eyes and 1 for me in the end.

Edse was never in danger with his vote switch, and in fact voted for White Eyes only after both you and me voted for him. I never bargained you all to move to White Eyes. I responded to edse’s offer and you both followed.

2) I guess I've already addressed this, but after that post you quoted I've never voted for edse because I felt he was innocent based on the things I mentioned above. And again he sent me that msg after the post you are highlighting. So at the time of the post I was still really suspicious of him.

If you thought that edse was innocent, then why the statement about neither one of us “engendering a lot of villager vibes”? That statement was today, and not earlier when it would make sense to hedge your bets in letting on that you thought he was innocent.

3) I don't remember saying it so many times. I DO remember saying it today. Mostly because I was specifically claiming that I was the pure one. I mean how else do you claim your role?

You claimed it twice in this game. Post #87 and the one today. And here is another inconsistency. In this quote you are saying that you ARE the pure one. Earlier today you said you are not:

If I'm the pure sacrifice, I don't know it. I never received a PM giving me any role. It's probably a red herring at this point.

Which one is it?

I mean wow. As far as last stands go this is pretty awesome. I mean I cultivated you? The only problem with your whole argument is that I already believe edse is innocent. Something I've been pretty careful to avoid mentioning because I wanted whoever was the killer to think I still suspected him. I mean unless edse actually is the killer, in which case, HE"S the one that played the masterful game. But I'm feeling really confident in my vote on you. I was really hoping that if White_eyes wasn't the killer that I would survive the night for just this reason. So yes as you say you kill off the unknown vote. You couldn't know if I would vote for edse, but you knew for damn sure that Lazy would vote for you. If I were the killer I would have killed edse. Lazy was voting for you all of yesterday and he would have voted for you again today. Based on your own argument, I would have been better off killing edse.

Two things: Killing Lazy would be such an obvious tell that I wouldn’t do it. Second, it is such an obvious tell that it would be a good kill for someone else to make so they could frame me. It wouldn’t be too hard as I was already a suspect (and seems to be working today as well).

Man, its an awesome attack, awesome last stand but in the end it was either you or White_eyes for me and I've got you in the end.

You may well have me, but if I am wrong here and you are indeed the other innocent one, then you will be sorely disappointed with the loss when edse kills you tonight and wins this game.

One of you two is the last killer. Both of you have played well, and either one of you deserve to win this game. But mark my words. I am one of the innocent ones here.