Monty, you're making no sense. The bear-skin guy is the guy who has "conquered his fear" who is clearly pizza and clearly attacked Ishmael. The guy with the mace seems highly unlikely to be the same. You're lying, and there's only one response for that.
Oh, I see it. I've got it wrong.

Then who is my attacker? Single townies both attacked and protected me on the same night? Ridiculous.

If Pizza is indeed Riedquat's killer and Ishmael's attacker, then we sort of have to lynch him. Vote: ATPG