Choose Your Own Adventure Mafia [Concluded]

[BSmith]

With still 19 people alive and two kills per Night (Where one of them is guaranteed to be ATPG)? If I were the Mafia partner, I'd be fricking stupid if I were to kill off a mafia partner. Making as much lemonade as possible would involve me trying to keep my partner alive as long as possible so he could kill as many as possible before dieing, especially since I don't have any suspicion on me. The stupidest thing one can do in this situation is exactly kill a mafia partner who was not established in any way as being mafioso. Willingly incriminating him would a pretty stupid decision.

Again – normally, yes, but the write-up mistake was a game changer. Let’s not pretend it wasn’t.

This is what I love about you. How you like to assume everything to fit into your zionist-masonic-illuminati far-fetched conspiracies. What if the scum team didn't know beforehand? What if there was no discussion with the team and it was just Arjos decision? What if there isn't even a scum team and mafiosi are unaware of each others identities (Like on the Pirate Ninja Robot Zombie game)? What if the other mafioso(s) just decided to try and lynch somebody else instead of stupidly voting for their fellow mafioso and sticking through it, regardless of the very real possibility of just switching one vote and lynching someone else?

First off… I am a freemason. So no need for the conspiracies.

Second – should we not hypothesize here? Should we not brainstorm and talk out possibilities? Should we just let the scum coordinate in peace and let them kill us off one by one? What is your strategy here?

And I was the Robot in the other game. I am pretty familiar with how that was set up. This game feels different to me.

But nope. The obvious thing to do, with little less than twenty people still alive, vote for your Mafioso colleague, using a reasoning that is not widely accepted, and maintain the vote even when there is a dead townie telling you to spare him, and no actual scumminess of the mafioso to levarage the town into supporting the lynch.

If I was vaguely smart and was mafioso and had the intention of bussing a colleague, in this situation, I'd much rather have abstained for the tie, and if Arjos died, I could blame TinCow for my decision, while if he lived, then my team would continue with one extra member.

Given the reality of the situation this is a very likely decision. Let’s not dismiss it out of hand.

Nah, I remember very well. It was a game where we could vote to give items to someone still playing. Midway into the game, you had the most outlandish conspiracies and on how I was part of the Mafia, and how you tried to make everything make sense even though you had already failed to predict things that had happened in the game, and by some points, you were completely discredited, but still kept rambling on and on, much to my delight. Even when I took the time to counter your arguments, you'd usually say that me arguing with you ultimately proved that I was trying hard to discredit you and that it only meant that I was even more suspicious. I remember it because it was the only occasion where I used that video I now post to you. I also vaguely remember saying that by the end, when the roles were revealed, you'd eat your own words. I can't remember how the game ended, but I remember I was a regular townie in that game, so I hope you did indeed took time to eat your own words.

I don’t remember the game either, but it could have been me. I wish I was always right, but I’ll let my record be my witness.

And you do seem a little sensitive to the attention…