Mafia v. Cult [Concluded]

[Jarema]

vote: Isaikhaan

[GeneralHankerchief]

vote: Isaikhaan

Why?

[Visor]

Why?

I am not exactly against the vote. I wanted to vote Khaan earlier today and I can't even explain why.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Page 3 stuff

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

vote: Isaikhaan

Null but could be cult hunting

I don't think you're going to get much out of Jarema.

FWIW, I think he would post more than that in that post if he was mafia/cult, he would feel the need to give a reason. I feel like he is probably town.

Null maybe

Vote: GH for forcing.

Seems fine

I don't even know what to do with this game, but seeing as it's mafia vs cult I'm probably going to have to reevalute every read on every new day anyway, so it feels more like a YOLO game. At least until we get down to the last few players.

Vote: Zack

Get back in here.

She hates cult games. Maybe more than me. I believe this post.

Hmmm....I'm actually not a fan of the fact that Zack is still quoting old games. It was a fun gag on day one, but I thin we ought to dig into the game a little more now, and that stuff is more confusing and filler-y than it's worth.

Vote: Zack

Why Pelican is a cult read and not a town read. He may not be mafia but I doubt he's town.

Then care to present a read, a case, etc...yada yada yada (excuse my cynicism towards this kind of prompting, I find it a bit tedious but necessary in some cases, such as today, when things are moving at a glacial pace)

I'd say it's null, but it's a better thing to post for scum then town, since scum has more reasons to keep up appearances of activity without posting any real content, and endearing themselves to the good humor of their fellow players. I disregard it on day one, and usually in subsequent days unless I have significant other evidence to go with it, since that kind of stuff can also be posted by anyone in the spirit of camaraderie and fun, but it's a starting point at least.

You'll have to link back for the nested quotes.

This is kind of the same behavior I exhibited in that Middle Earth game when I was scum. Point out the glacial pace and talk about the difficulties in solving the game. It's great filler and it matches what scum probably think town is feeling.

Unvote: Golden
Vote: Al Sips

Well he turned out to be cult. Not even sure why I quoted this. He was probably town when this happened but *shrug*

I really don't think Zack is mafia.

vote:ATPG for counterwagon.

I think this is actually townie. I can't explain why. It matches how I feel landlubber approaches me in these games. Unlike most players he's willing to get rid of me early at the drop of a hat, no reason needed except he doesn't want to lynch others.

It's thin and it could be wrong but my gut says it's right.

Not sure if that's the site culture thing, but .Org Zack feels scummier than CFC Zack based on the tone. Probably it was not a good idea to sign for 2 games on the different sites at the same time. I think the only game I played here (ROTSC) had a lot of outside players, so it's not representative of the site culture.

I want more Pizza, so not voting him.
Raith seems indecisive enough to be town.
Visor seems town: clearing townies, voting around, even though he's claiming conversion powers.
GH is scumhunting, good.

Need to read up on the rest.

Vote: Zack

Scum. EZ

On general tone. I was just reading ISO's on CFC, then switched here and felt the contrast. You are more reasonable, helpful and solvey there, and more fluffy and careless here. ALL CAPS and stuff. Calling out GH for the forced post was good, though.

Jarema seems a bit wordy than in ROTSC, but less wordy than in the CFC game where he was town nevertheless. I really don't like his meta, that is actually forcing him to be a lurker when town. I'd like to encourage him to post more.

Choxorn had like a single non-fluff post, voting GH for forcing. Might be a joke, might be lazy or opportunistic. Slight scum.

Sooh as well has a single YOLO vote. Slight scum.

Kennigit feels good, solvey.

I don't buy this. Al Sips is being tryhard here. It's pretense, no one else in the game including the usual suspects for doing so are trying hard.

Look at how townie I am

Nope.

Town:
Visorslash
GeneralHankerchief

Slight town:
Askthepizzaguy
Raith Kemmler
Pelican, pushing for serious game
Kennigit

Neutral:
Jarema
landlubber, votes ATPG over Zack. Making choices is good.
seireikhaan. If he voted Kennigit just for his GH vote, that'd be null. The additional point he makes about his scumdar - not sure. Neutral to very slight scum lean.

Slight scum:
Zack
Choxorn
Sooh
Cuthillius, voted Scarlett and votes Visor without a reason

Unresolved:
Golden1Knight
Csargo
Zain
SeveringViper

The last group needs to post more.

Blue- revealed town or later became cult
Green- town imo
Red- mafia imo
Purple- cult leader imo

Landlubber and Csargo are mild town leans and not starting cult. Could be cult convert at best.

It's possible Severtheotes is cult or mafia but I think it's just an abandony townie.

Scum ranking:

1. Al Sipsclar
2. Pelican
3. Jarema

Town ranking:

1. landlubber
2. Sooh
3. Visor

My reaction to Al Sips post at the bottom is what I want people to read after I die. Or now, preferably.

I do think this one is quite solving because of Al's posts, if you read any of these this is the one to read.