French Revolution Mafia [Concluded]

[NotACop]

no one around it seems. you can have some music

[Dp101]

Dp101 - dislike the #245 read on Jabbz "Jabbz feels really stilted but that's normal for him". Weird to notice someone seems stilted, wanting to address it, and then nullifying it by saying it's normal for someone. Why mention it at all then?
+ #281 "I want to call this scummy, but I know that Jabbz is perfectly capable of being this awkward as town." while he quotes a bad post from Jabbz where Jabbz unvotes and complains about actually having to find a real vote now.
It does look good that he voted Jabbz at last minutes of d1 EOD over Manasi, so that makes me hesitate a bit. But Jabbz seemed like someone struggling to look towny, so wouldn't be surprised of bussing.
So I'll vote Dp101. Not all sure on this, fwiw - but

The 245 post was made because I wanted to avoid a potential mislynch, as I had not seen anything alignment indicative in his play so far and I've played with him more than the majority of people here. Sure, in the end, it was the wrong move, but I felt that I had to say something at that juncture as I had just seen him get mislynched D1 on another site after behaving in a similar pattern. Same goes for 281, that kind of half-joking self deprecating style of post is well within his town range, and I again felt I needed to note for others that a post like that did not mean that he had to be scum. Do you have any other questions?

[Manasi]

Aw dude I love that song.

[Manasi]

Aw dude I love that song.

This is probs my fav by them.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gWBG1j_flrg

[El Barto]

Nothing more to say, have you?

Non, Choxorn, mon cher, je n'ai rien plus que dir.

He seemed more than willing to see El Barto or Snerk dead.

I disagree with this. The former part at least.

I'm thinking this part is genuine. El Barto hasn't cleared himself by his own merits, but it's looking pretty good that he's not a royalist anyway.

With this post I increase my total postcount by 50% (not even you can do that) so I'm giving you a lot of material to analyse.

Nac hasn't posted this phase, everyone said it was a good vote, but no one has joined me. Hmmmmm.

vote: NotACop

[Manasi]

Non, Choxorn, mon cher, je n'ai rien plus que dir.

I disagree with this. The former part at least.

With this post I increase my total postcount by 50% (not even you can do that) so I'm giving you a lot of material to analyse.

vote: NotACop

Well this is funny, isn't it?

NAC just posted a lot above. What do you think of that?

[GeneralHankerchief]

I voted NAC @ GeneralHankerchief.

Got it, added to my spreadsheet. Next tally will include it.

@Choxorn 1:00 PM GMT-4

There was a post Zack edited several hours ago, it checks out.

Think that's everything, tag me if something else is pressing.

[El Barto]

Well this is funny, isn't it?

NAC just posted a lot above. What do you think of that?

Posts such as #661? Complete fluff. Clutters the thread.

[Dp101]

Posts such as #661? Complete fluff. Clutters the thread.

What about 657, with a case on me?

[El Barto]

He ‘clarifies’ it saying that it's the ‘more fun’ option, which takes any seriousness out of it.

[Zack]

It just feels like the comment about how brutal it is towards the royalists is something that scum is more likely to say compared to town. Or rather, phrasing it as brutality rather than as something to be celebrated. I know I've made similar tonal slips in the past as mafia.

I mean, it is nice indeed to have gotten so many mafia so far, but the problem is that it doesn't seem to really lead anywhere afterwards. When mafia die so early, combined with the faction setup, the amount of spew you can get out of them is minimal at best.

I'm annoyed not because I think lurker lynches are bad, but because... I dunno. I feel that in a game where the ordinary D1 mislynch went off, we would have a lot more options for trying to find scum by trying to figure out who caused the mislynch. However, when the D1 lynch is good, instead of a bunch of potential scumpoints all we get are some cleared townies, which means that there are few high-profile people to try and hunt, so we are forced to go for those who didn't push as hard, if that makes sense at all.

[Zack]

Posts such as #661? Complete fluff. Clutters the thread.

Could you possibly answer this more disingenuously?

[Zack]

like, you're going to just cherry-pick that one post and completely ignore the huge post where he reads the entire game?

he's done a HELL of a lot more than you

[Zack]

Vote: El Barto

[Manasi]

Vote: El Barto

tfw you voted for this guy right after posting the question to him but you forgot to post it so now it'll seem like you're literally always sheeping zack.

[Zack]

tfw you voted for this guy right after posting the question to him but you forgot to post it so now it'll seem like you're literally always sheeping zack.

[NotACop]

The 245 post was made because I wanted to avoid a potential mislynch, as I had not seen anything alignment indicative in his play so far and I've played with him more than the majority of people here. Sure, in the end, it was the wrong move, but I felt that I had to say something at that juncture as I had just seen him get mislynched D1 on another site after behaving in a similar pattern. Same goes for 281, that kind of half-joking self deprecating style of post is well within his town range, and I again felt I needed to note for others that a post like that did not mean that he had to be scum. Do you have any other questions?

those weren't questions, was simply stating my reasoning.
seeing el barto's way of jumping on my wagon right now and his response when asked into opinion of my case post makes me feel he'd be a fine lynch.
vote: el barto

He ‘clarifies’ it saying that it's the ‘more fun’ option, which takes any seriousness out of it.

this is a non-answer to what he thinks of my post. he just comments that my case doesn't look serious, not what it means for his impression of my alignment.

[Manasi]

don't u fuckin post that picture to me how dare you

[autolycus]

I'd like to see unvote, vote: Sooh go on the record. I'll check again in the morning, and assuming Sooh's taken a position, I'll make a decision among the likely candidates at that time.

[El Barto]

Could you possibly answer this more disingenuously?

Are you daring me?

[NotACop]

This is probs my fav by them.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gWBG1j_flrg

that one is solid too! mostly just those two songs I've been listening to from them

[Zack]

don't u fuckin post that picture to me how dare you

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

[Arakhor]

Because you don't think he's scummy, or because you don't want to lynch your faction mate?

Well, I already said that he was being Lurky McLurkyson and that it would be bad for him to die today, so no, I don't want to lurk a fellow faction member if I can help it, but no, I have no view on his scumminess as he's done almost at all.

As for Barto, he's often cagey and unhelpful and gets mislynched because of it, but this is particularly unhelpful of him.

[Arakhor]

Phone posting is really terrible at the Org.

[El Barto]

You're posting from a phone?

unvote

FishFingerOfSuspicion: Arakhor

[Arakhor]

When I'm not on the PC, yes.

[El Barto]

[GeneralHankerchief]

Tally as of post 687. Please inform me of any errors.

NotACop: 3 | Csargo (615), Manasi (625), Arakhor (647)
autolycus: 2 | Renata (518), Csargo (593)
Arakhor: 2 | Dp101 (532), ATPG (577)
Sooh: 2 | Snerk (628), autolycus (679)
El Barto: 2 | Zack (674), NotACop (677)

Round ends:

1:00 PM EDT, not EST. 1:00 PM GMT -4, not -5. Stupid daylight savings.

[seireikhaan]

Hello again everyone, and welcome back to day two of "The Joys of Lynching". Last time we nabbed ourselves a royalist, an excellent start. I'm going to go ahead this round and Vote: Dp101. Now, I've played my share as mafia in the past, and especially with results on death, I can tell you that DP's vote at the end of the day doesn't look great to me. Some might call it a sealing vote for a royalist, but to me, that looks like a good old fashioned, meaningless late bus to try and give some cover.

[Zack]

Hello again everyone, and welcome back to day two of "The Joys of Lynching". Last time we nabbed ourselves a royalist, an excellent start. I'm going to go ahead this round and Vote: Dp101. Now, I've played my share as mafia in the past, and especially with results on death, I can tell you that DP's vote at the end of the day doesn't look great to me. Some might call it a sealing vote for a royalist, but to me, that looks like a good old fashioned, meaningless late bus to try and give some cover.

It does seem weird given his earlier comments on Jabbz that NAC pointed out (numerous instances of "awkward but town" or something to that effect). I also wonder if Dp might be a bit jumpy about d1 wolf wagons after the recent game.