Quote Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy View Post
The formatting is tricky. I'm unsure how to parse it.

I read all of Slaan's posts up until almost end of day 1 again. What I remember is that he had a very banter-y, slow start, made a comment about Logic to the tune of he didn't really agree with what I was accusing Logic of, I remember the passive aggression at Cuth post, and I remember that he hard bussed Logic and then named 4 other suspects, none were GH or Zack even though he had them in his mild scummy pile earlier than that post.

After that, GH and Zack outed themselves so any content after D1 is not alignment indicative.
OK, just by the 24 hours here's a condensed view that might reflect the harshest interpretation of Slaan (easier to give a charitable interpretation of later content, which you did):

0. Slaan recently is affirming the principle that we shouldn't even be seeing multi-scum sussing or distancing in D1 given the Logic threat. My own position is that we should expect controlled distancing, especially after halfway into D1. So keep in mind that this is a bit less than the first half of D1.
1. In opening posts Slaan talks about only playing with GH and Fred out of this group, some chance of reading. Cuth and Manasi were in mashes, but not enough familiarity to read with confidence. Slaan now has Cuth and Fred in upper half of POE. If you're going by the long-term significance route.
2. Slaan almost entirely banters for 16 posts, mostly w/ Zack and Winston, then Logic arrives at the tail end to begin his first round, including getting sussed by Pizza. GH welcome-votes Slaan, and Logic expresses relief that GH didn't do that when it was Logic's first ORG game.
3. Kage votes Slaan as a joke and Manasi thinks Slaan is uncomfortable and scummy. Zack soft-challenges her and Kage. Logic says Kage's vote on Slaan is lazy and begins the voting and other interactions between the two. Logic says Slaan is not scum, Kage asks why, etc.
4. Slaan returns, jokes about lynching Pizza, Winston and DP chuckle sensibly about it, and later Logic attacks Winston as having PIS wrt Pizza (Winston also a bit earlier questioned his own first town read on Slaan).
5. Vote Csargo for discussing OMGUS with Zack in a weird way, and wants to lynch Kage as a joke over skins.
6. Possible buddying with Winston and DP.
7. Slaan gives a big reads post, considers Logic, Zack, and GH in nullish and jokey ways. Zack now finds "DP, Fred, and Slaan are the only people I feel good about saying they're above null."
7. Kage feels no scumminess from Slaan now but wonders why Logic doesn't want to become involved in thread. Slaan counters that Logic is involved in thread, and confident that he can become town for Kage ("easy hurdle").
8. Slaan reads Zack true town after wallposts and other friendly interactions. GH says Slaan and Fred are down a tier but he can't really explain it; Zack disagrees only on Slaan.
9.
Quote Originally Posted by Slaan
Everyone note it down: If GH mislynches me kill GH :)

Pizza, don't go full volcano, we have 45 hours and I'm taking this slow.