The Prometheus: Large Mafia Game [Concluded]

[Reenk Roink]

Ok, I'm pretty sure Mithrandir is just roleplaying. He's roleplaying an aloof and contradictory person, but he's roleplaying. He wouldn't be a good lynch, don't pull a pevergreen on him.

I've never really been suspicious of seireikhaan before (I'm really not sure on any of the "new guys" relative to myself) but how is this guy still alive? I recall that several times he was about to be lynched and then the next day I see someone else was. Skimming some recent posts, he does seem to want to live a lot, but so did some other townies...

I don't know why anyone is suspicious of Ichigo. Same with Seamus Fermanagh. Twlightblade on the other hand...

It's time the start thinking about putting the pressure on Peasant Phill and Alexander the Pretty Good. Both are usually lurkers anyway, but hey, they've survived this far...

White_eyes:D is an enigma to me. He's actually the one who has dictated the game the most (maybe Chaotix27) and yet his demeanor is so innocent. There are better suspects than him right now but if he's alive two rounds from now, be sure to watch him...

[White_eyes:D]

Ok, I'm pretty sure Mithrandir is just roleplaying. He's roleplaying an aloof and contradictory person, but he's roleplaying. He wouldn't be a good lynch, don't pull a pevergreen on him.

I've never really been suspicious of seireikhaan before (I'm really not sure on any of the "new guys" relative to myself) but how is this guy still alive? I recall that several times he was about to be lynched and then the next day I see someone else was. Skimming some recent posts, he does seem to want to live a lot, but so did some other townies...

I don't know why anyone is suspicious of Ichigo. Same with Seamus Fermanagh. Twlightblade on the other hand...

It's time the start thinking about putting the pressure on Peasant Phill and Alexander the Pretty Good. Both are usually lurkers anyway, but hey, they've survived this far...

White_eyes:D is an enigma to me. He's actually the one who has dictated the game the most (maybe Chaotix27) and yet his demeanor is so innocent. There are better suspects than him right now but if he's alive two rounds from now, be sure to watch him...

True, I helped lynch two innocent townies.....(one, because he kinda went all green cult peace and said I was a mafia or the other way around) I am still a little confused on why Chaotix did what he did..... (two, because Aries bad jokes really sucked and even the dead guys said to not let up on him.....so I didn't ) but yeah, at any time I will get bandwagoned for all the innoccent townies I helped lynch.....

[Chaotix]

I'm still unsure of why I did what I did, too!
I mean, if you think about it, all I did was waste a lynch! Can't believe I actually believed all of ATPG's BS.

[Askthepizzaguy]

OOC analysis-

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

I'm still unsure of why I did what I did, too!
I mean, if you think about it, all I did was waste a lynch! Can't believe I actually believed all of ATPG's BS.

*Sigh*

As much as I enjoy the fact that I contributed in some small way to town's eventual defeat, I fear that my style will kill me off early in subsequent mafia games, and no one will ever trust me or look for hidden clues in my writing ever again, which is 90% of the fun for me. I've deliberately ruined my reputation for this game. Mafia had better at least win.

*sighs* not another Chaotix please....YLC you just got FoS for talking about hippie-based crap....1 and 2 MIGHT be true but 3 is worthless....because Pizza guy being a Pro-town role? (then why kill shlin?) Just ignore all of Pizza guys posts....he only wants to confuse you....He is VERY tricky....and only wants his side to win by any means necessary

You would do well to at least look for clues in my posts, even if you consider everything I say to be a lie. YLC is right about one thing; you guys are too quick to dismiss me and my methods. I hope it works out for you, but a missed opportunity is a missed opportunity regardless.

I'd love to see town lose, but it's ever more delicious when I put the solution in front of you. That's my signature style.

[Askthepizzaguy]

A reproduced copy of a message from the cult leader is found-

My children,

Continue to spread the truth and bring more into our ranks. Our attempts to cure the plague vermin have been successful so far; while some obstacles remain, our victory is assured. Remember, that even when all seems lost to darkness, the dawn is coming. Though we currently hide in the shadows, we are preparing to reveal ourselves to the locusts, and when we do, it will be in the form of a brilliant flame which consumes all. Though I must use another in order to communicate with you now, I remain aware of my surroundings. I have claimed his mind and he speaks for me. Follow his orders as you would for me. I would recommend a former adversary for our next conversion.

Dawn is coming. Prepare to open the eyes of every rat that still sleeps in the slumber of ignorance.

[Chaotix]

What Reenk has is either very clear evidence or a very well written lie. Know that it's certainly not impossible or even too difficult for a mafia to fake a bunch of write-ups like that.

That said, if Reenk was lying, he would only be lynched the next day, and pretty much screw himself over. Thus I believe he's innocent, and I retract all of my suspicions on him. I realise why he had to act shady like he did, now.

As far as white eyes' point, he's right too. Either him or YLC has to be lynched next round. No mafia would have voted for pizzaguy in a lynch that close between him and me.

However, there may be mafia who were converted after my lynch. Don't overlook that.

Good luck guys, let's take 'em down!

[Crazed Rabbit]

Lynch write up later today. Khaan has been lynched.

Sorry, but I'm really busy yesterday and today.

CR

[Thermal]

bad jokes really sucked

i wasnt joking! besides, do you always lynch people that fail in being funny? your excuses to lynch are very poor

[Crazed Rabbit]

Captain's note:
The round will be delayed because I have ~2 hours or less to write 4 pages (double spaced) of an econ report on the Great Depression. I should have it up in less than 12 hours. If I'm still awake.

CR

[White_eyes:D]

i wasnt joking! besides, do you always lynch people that fail in being funny? your excuses to lynch are very poor

Well then your play style REALLY sucks then.... at least Chaotix knew he messed up but you seem to think some how you didn't....

[Thermal]

Well then your play style REALLY sucks then.... at least Chaotix knew he messed up but you seem to think some how you didn't....

bad townie dont suck, you can irritate other townies and if they decide to lynch you then i can taunt them and say they've blundered there chances on innocence

[ULC]

I'd like to voice something that has bothered me from the beginning, yet was never able to put words to it.

If the ecofreaks are able to convert, then why kill? Killing eliminates a possible convert, and incites said dead townie to become angry at them. A converted townie helps with voting and increase numbers, allowing the mafia to achieve their goal FASTER.

To me, this means several things -

The mafia either may only recruit so many,
The mafia actually lacks the ability to convert,
The mafia only has a chance to convert, where as they are guaranteed the elimination of a townie by killing them,
The mafia are highly experienced players, and are weeding out possible townie who would be bad for conversion based upon their lack of experience and susceptibility to being exposed, and expsoing those they associate with,
The mafia is highly inexperienced, and hasn't thought analytically about their position.

Also, reading through Pizzaguy's posts, I have come to a handful of conclusion, although I admit RR beat me to most of them.

1 - Do not bother trying to tell innocence from the write ups, where dealing with a cult like behavior who believe in something higher then themselves. As far as they are concerned, they will win, and that any sacrifice they make is better for the whole, thus they will be just as willing to be cyro-ed as town would.
2 - The words "Order, Balance, Harmony" continue to crop up in Pizzaguy's writings. Why? From what I gather, they hold significant importance. No other words are as repeated, for little or no reason, as these are. Pizzaguy is one to try to imbed clues, even if it is detrimental to his own side, in his writing.

3 - Also, as noted by Seamus and Reenk, Pizzaguy's tone changed significantly midway through the game. This leads me to believe he is a convert, and could have possibly been a protown role, which would explain his rather...revealing lynching. Thus, a thorough reading of Pizzaguy's posts, just before and just after, may reveal much information...if the town is willing to work for it.

[White_eyes:D]

I'd like to voice something that has bothered me from the beginning, yet was never able to put words to it.

If the ecofreaks are able to convert, then why kill? Killing eliminates a possible convert, and incites said dead townie to become angry at them. A converted townie helps with voting and increase numbers, allowing the mafia to achieve their goal FASTER.

To me, this means several things -

The mafia either may only recruit so many,
The mafia actually lacks the ability to convert,
The mafia only has a chance to convert, where as they are guaranteed the elimination of a townie by killing them,
The mafia are highly experienced players, and are weeding out possible townie who would be bad for conversion based upon their lack of experience and susceptibility to being exposed, and expsoing those they associate with,
The mafia is highly inexperienced, and hasn't thought analytically about their position.

Also, reading through Pizzaguy's posts, I have come to a handful of conclusion, although I admit RR beat me to most of them.

1 - Do not bother trying to tell innocence from the write ups, where dealing with a cult like behavior who believe in something higher then themselves. As far as they are concerned, they will win, and that any sacrifice they make is better for the whole, thus they will be just as willing to be cyro-ed as town would.
2 - The words "Order, Balance, Harmony" continue to crop up in Pizzaguy's writings. Why? From what I gather, they hold significant importance. No other words are as repeated, for little or no reason, as these are. Pizzaguy is one to try to imbed clues, even if it is detrimental to his own side, in his writing.

3 - Also, as noted by Seamus and Reenk, Pizzaguy's tone changed significantly midway through the game. This leads me to believe he is a convert, and could have possibly been a protown role, which would explain his rather...revealing lynching. Thus, a thorough reading of Pizzaguy's posts, just before and just after, may reveal much information...if the town is willing to work for it.

*sighs* not another Chaotix please....YLC you just got FoS for talking about hippie-based crap....1 and 2 MIGHT be true but 3 is worthless....because Pizza guy being a Pro-town role? (then why kill shlin?) Just ignore all of Pizza guys posts....he only wants to confuse you....He is VERY tricky....and only wants his side to win by any means necessary