Results 1 to 25 of 25

Thread: Hoplite question

  1. #1
    Member Member Cyrus's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2008
    Location
    Milano ITA
    Posts
    353

    Default Hoplite question

    Why is it that such a huge error is in such a great game? i mean there are clearly better historians than me in this forum but even the lowest gread knower of greek history knows that hoplites are supposed to form a solid wall of shields in front of the enemy to provide defence for one another, why then is it that eb oplites just run like a disorderly mob in front of the enemy?


    Italians do it better! Chi dice donna dice guai. Abbi donna di te minore, se vuoi essere signore. Donne e buoi dei paesi tuoi. Fiume, grondaia e donna parlatora mandano l'uomo di casa fuora.
    And my personal favorite: "Non rimuovere il confine antico fissato dai tuoi padri". In english: "Do not remove the anchent border placed by your fathers". It looses something in the translation......

  2. #2

    Default Re: Hoplite question

    Ummm, you probably have not seen the phalanx minimod...


  3. #3
    Guest desert's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2008
    Location
    The greatest polis built by men.
    Posts
    1,120

    Default Re: Hoplite question

    TWFanatic's phalanx mod fixes that a little, but yeah, their shields should really be interlocked.

    It's just game mechanics though; what can you do?

    I haven't tested it personally, but I'd bet that the shieldwall trait in BI doesn't solve it either.

  4. #4
    EB Support Guy Senior Member XSamatan's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2008
    Posts
    1,820

    Default Re: Hoplite question

    Just one word: hardcoded

    Maybe someone with more modding experience can give you a little more detailed explanation...



    and be a little temperate with your words, written things can easy be missunderstood



    XSamatan

    1.2 fixes - Updated regularly. Latest news from 2009-02-01.
    EB FAQ --- Tech help important thread list --- Frequent issues and solutions

  5. #5
    EBII Mod Leader Member Foot's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2005
    Location
    Brighton, East Sussex, England (GMT)
    Posts
    10,736

    Default Re: Hoplite question

    Quote Originally Posted by Cyrus View Post
    Why is it that such a huge error is in such a great game? i mean there are clearly better historians than me in this forum but even the lowest gread knower of greek history knows that hoplites are supposed to form a solid wall of shields in front of the enemy to provide defence for one another, why then is it that eb oplites just run like a disorderly mob in front of the enemy?
    We have to work within the constraints of the game, and we felt that our representation was quite good. Others have disagreed and made changes accordingly.

    Foot
    EBII Mod Leader
    Hayasdan Faction Co-ordinator


  6. #6
    Symbasileus ton Rhomaioktonon Member Maion Maroneios's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Location
    Heraklion, Crete, Greece
    Posts
    2,610

    Default Re: Hoplite question

    There are several things you could do to simulate a historical hoplite phalalx. First of all, try using guard mode when fighting or guarding a position. Secondly, try TWFanatic's phalanx mini-mod, or give them the shieldwall formation if you play on BI. I've done the latter, by the way.

    Maion
    Last edited by Maion Maroneios; 11-24-2008 at 00:32.
    ~Maion

  7. #7
    Member Member Cyrus's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2008
    Location
    Milano ITA
    Posts
    353

    Default Re: Hoplite question

    Ok well first of all what i meant must not be understood as an offence or critich to the game or people who created it, just simple curiosity,i love EB exept for it's too frequent crashes......
    And secondly what are the guarding position and phalanx mini mod?
    Thirdly i have eb from rtw gold edition so should i be able to do the shield wall formation?


    Italians do it better! Chi dice donna dice guai. Abbi donna di te minore, se vuoi essere signore. Donne e buoi dei paesi tuoi. Fiume, grondaia e donna parlatora mandano l'uomo di casa fuora.
    And my personal favorite: "Non rimuovere il confine antico fissato dai tuoi padri". In english: "Do not remove the anchent border placed by your fathers". It looses something in the translation......

  8. #8
    Member Member theoldbelgian's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2008
    Location
    64,8 stadies from the east bank of the scaldis
    Posts
    177

    Default Re: Hoplite question

    guard position is the button with the shield on in the unit control panel: it makes your units fight more like a solid block
    doesn't tire them that much but they seem to fight worse, and they don't chase routing enemies anymore
    for the rtw gold: you still have to set eb in on BI just forumsearch for BI and you 'll get there
    the greatest problem with this is that your generals no longer supplies in your regions only in city's

  9. #9
    Prefect of Judea (former) Member Pontius Pilate's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2008
    Location
    The City on the Banks of the Tiber
    Posts
    267

    Default Re: Hoplite question

    Quote Originally Posted by Cyrus View Post
    Ok well first of all what i meant must not be understood as an offence or critich to the game or people who created it, just simple curiosity,i love EB exept for it's too frequent crashes......
    And secondly what are the guarding position and phalanx mini mod?
    Thirdly i have eb from rtw gold edition so should i be able to do the shield wall formation?

    no need to apologize. and yeah, as stated before, it's hardcoded into the game and not much else can be done to fix the hoplite shield wall. although the phalanx minimod helps a little bit. also the shield wall animation is only in Barbarian Invasion expansion. in my opinion I don't like the shield wall from Barbarian Invasion, it makes the unit too small in length and just isn't effective. if you want to get EB on BI anyway, just go to the unofficial EB modding projects of the forum. you must also have B. invasion installed too.
    Last edited by Pontius Pilate; 11-24-2008 at 02:19.
    SPQR SPQR

    Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

    Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 
    LS is the best! LS is the best! Come on people sing along!!

  10. #10
    Symbasileus ton Rhomaioktonon Member Maion Maroneios's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Location
    Heraklion, Crete, Greece
    Posts
    2,610

    Default Re: Hoplite question

    Quote Originally Posted by Pontius Pilate View Post
    it makes the unit too small in length and just isn't effective.
    Could you please define the first thing you said? As for their effectiveness, the shieldwall gives them bonuses in defense. Much more reliable than guard mode and more correct than the short_pike attribute, which makes units take weird angles with their spears, plus the back rows hold them in a 45 degree angle. And let us not forget the fact that the short_pike attribute makes units stick together that much, that it becomes completely unhistorical.

    Maion
    ~Maion

  11. #11
    Prefect of Judea (former) Member Pontius Pilate's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2008
    Location
    The City on the Banks of the Tiber
    Posts
    267

    Default Re: Hoplite question

    Quote Originally Posted by Maion Maroneios View Post
    Could you please define the first thing you said? As for their effectiveness, the shieldwall gives them bonuses in defense. Much more reliable than guard mode and more correct than the short_pike attribute, which makes units take weird angles with their spears, plus the back rows hold them in a 45 degree angle. And let us not forget the fact that the short_pike attribute makes units stick together that much, that it becomes completely unhistorical.

    Maion

    I don't know, maybe it's just me, but the shield wall in Barbarian Invasion just doesn't work for me. the unit's size and length reduces signifigantly and make it easier to flank, and it seems like they aren't able to fight as well in shield wall than on regular mode with guard mode on, they seem to get overwhelmed more when facing enemies. then again, maybe there is just something wrong with my tactics and the way I am using the shieldwall. and yes, I admit that short_pike attribute makes the unit take strange angles.
    SPQR SPQR

    Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

    Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 
    LS is the best! LS is the best! Come on people sing along!!

  12. #12
    Symbasileus ton Rhomaioktonon Member Maion Maroneios's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Location
    Heraklion, Crete, Greece
    Posts
    2,610

    Default Re: Hoplite question

    Quote Originally Posted by Pontius Pilate View Post
    I don't know, maybe it's just me, but the shield wall in Barbarian Invasion just doesn't work for me. the unit's size and length reduces signifigantly and make it easier to flank, and it seems like they aren't able to fight as well in shield wall than on regular mode with guard mode on, they seem to get overwhelmed more when facing enemies. then again, maybe there is just something wrong with my tactics and the way I am using the shieldwall. and yes, I admit that short_pike attribute makes the unit take strange angles.
    While it is true that shieldwall makes individuals form a very tight formation, I'm afraid what you say about them being overwhelmed is incorrect. If you want, I can run test battles for you and present the results. Hoplites with guard mode are definitely much worse than with shieldwall, as with the latter you get the pushing effect plus more aggressive stabs. With guard mode on, your guys will just stand their ground and occasionally a hoplite or two will stab at the enemy. After all, it's 'guard' mode and not normal or aggressive one.

    Maion
    ~Maion

  13. #13

    Default Re: Hoplite question

    I used shieldwall in a version of RTR and it made hoplites too hard to attack. If I remember they formed into a box with spears pointing outward. Not exactly shiltron but you couldn't flank them at all. It doesn't matter too much to me since the game's mechanics makes them get shredded by swords. It's best to focus on flanking with assault troops or heavy cavalry. Anyways I like the not quite perfect formation. It would seem robotic if they kept perfect form all the time. In the heat of battle soldiers fought to keep formation while trying to save their skin too.

  14. #14
    EB Nitpicker Member oudysseos's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2006
    Location
    Dublin, Ireland
    Posts
    3,182

    Default Re: Hoplite question

    Cyrus,

    Although it is, I suppose, a common assertion that hoplite phalanxes routinely fought with the edges of their shields interlocked like a giant Roman testudo formation, in fact this issue is hotly contested in academic circles and the evidence for technical details about hoplite combat is both very sparse and very far from unequivocal.

    The major source for the interlocked shields concept seems to be a passage from Thucydides (5.71.1) which has been commonly translated along the lines of

    All armies are alike in this: on going into action they get forced out rather on their right wing, and one and the other overlap with this their adversary's left; because fear makes each man do his best to shelter his unarmed side with the shield of the man next him on the right, thinking that the closer the shields are locked together the better will he be protected. The man primarily responsible for this is the first upon the right wing, who is always striving to withdraw from the enemy his unarmed side; and the same apprehension makes the rest follow him.
    However! Careful inspection of the greek text is very revealing. A literal translation from Garrett Fagan, Great Battles of the Ancient World, of the bold-face passage above is
    Thinking that the denser their closeness is, the better protected they are.
    There is no explicit mention of locked or touching shields in the greek at all- the Perseus website can provide excellent commentary on the greek text if you're interested.
    Anyways, 'Close' is a pretty subjective term and depends on context- if you and I were together in an elevator, and we were four or six feet apart I would not think that you were 'close' to me. But if we were standing in the middle of a football pitch, I would find six feet to be quite close (at six feet our shields would not touch).

    Furthermore, there are several passages from Xenophon in the Anabasis (1.2.17, 6.5.25) that seem to describe relatively loose formations of hoplites.

    It is true that Victor Davis Hanson has long asserted the 'locked shields' concept as if it were established fact, but Hans van Wees, for example, is critical of this position. I suggest reading Greek Warfare: Myths and Realities by the latter author.

    So maybe the 'lowest gread knower' does think that hoplites are supposed to fight in a shield wall all the time, but a going a few grades up in knowledge might give you a different perspective.

    Dogmatic assertions of any kind are, I think, inappropriate. The truth is no-one will ever ever know the precise technical details of hoplite combat. The written sources don't describe the mechanics of combat because they assumed that the majority of their readers were themselves hoplites.

    So it seems that the EB team is not so clearly guilty of such a huge error, after all. And as Foot so patiently pointed out, there are some mini-mod alternatives if you really feel strongly about this.
    Last edited by oudysseos; 11-24-2008 at 10:22.
    οἵη περ φύλλων γενεὴ τοίη δὲ καὶ ἀνδρῶν.
    Even as are the generations of leaves, such are the lives of men.
    Glaucus, son of Hippolochus, Illiad, 6.146



  15. #15
    Member Member Cyrus's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2008
    Location
    Milano ITA
    Posts
    353

    Default Re: Hoplite question

    I seem to recall in xenophon's anabasis at the battle against the kings forces ( when the brother is still alive) that the greek wing of his army beats the enemy's thanks to thei close and tight formation, anyways thukidides is interpreted also in other ways, would u give the number of that passage please i have his book here.


    Italians do it better! Chi dice donna dice guai. Abbi donna di te minore, se vuoi essere signore. Donne e buoi dei paesi tuoi. Fiume, grondaia e donna parlatora mandano l'uomo di casa fuora.
    And my personal favorite: "Non rimuovere il confine antico fissato dai tuoi padri". In english: "Do not remove the anchent border placed by your fathers". It looses something in the translation......

  16. #16
    Legatvs Member SwissBarbar's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2008
    Location
    Helvetia
    Posts
    1,905

    Default Re: Hoplite question

    Quote Originally Posted by Cyrus View Post
    Why is it that such a huge error is in such a great game? i mean there are clearly better historians than me in this forum but even the lowest gread knower of greek history knows that hoplites are supposed to form a solid wall of shields in front of the enemy to provide defence for one another, why then is it that eb oplites just run like a disorderly mob in front of the enemy?
    Imagine vanilla RTW as a strawberry. You can make it better by adding sugar and stuff. EB is the sugared, chocolate-vanilla-sauced, peach-icecream cultivated version of the strawberry , but you still cannot make a banana out of it.

    EB works with the tools V-RTW to give us and make the best they can out of it. I'm sure the know pretty well about phalanxes.
    Balloon-Count: x 15


    Many thanks to Hooahguy for this great sig.

  17. #17
    EB Nitpicker Member oudysseos's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2006
    Location
    Dublin, Ireland
    Posts
    3,182

    Default Re: Hoplite question

    Cyrus, I did in fact give you the citation: 5.71.1, i.e. book 5 chapter 71. Here is the original.

    ξυνιόντων δ᾽ ἔτι Ἆγις ὁ βασιλεὺς τοιόνδε ἐβουλεύσατο δρᾶσαι. τὰ στρατόπεδα ποιεῖ μὲν καὶ ἅπαντα τοῦτο: ἐπὶ τὰ δεξιὰ κέρατα αὐτῶν ἐν ταῖς ξυνόδοις μᾶλλον ἐξωθεῖται, καὶ περιίσχουσι κατὰ τὸ τῶν ἐναντίων εὐώνυμον ἀμφότεροι τῷ δεξιῷ, διὰ τὸ φοβουμένους προσστέλλειν τὰ γυμνὰ ἕκαστον ὡς μάλιστα τῇ τοῦ ἐν δεξιᾷ παρατεταγμένου ἀσπίδι καὶ νομίζειν τὴν πυκνότητα τῆς ξυγκλῄσεως εὐσκεπαστότατον εἶναι: καὶ ἡγεῖται μὲν τῆς αἰτίας ταύτης ὁ πρωτοστάτης τοῦ δεξιοῦ κέρως, προθυμούμενος ἐξαλλάσσειν αἰεὶ τῶν ἐναντίων τὴν ἑαυτοῦ γύμνωσιν, ἕπονται δὲ διὰ τὸν αὐτὸν φόβον καὶ οἱ ἄλλοι.

    My comment on the passages from the Anabasis would be that the Greek formations are dense compared to the Persian forces. This would be true whether you go along with Hanson or van Wees on the density of hoplite formations.

    Again, the multiplicity of interpretations of these texts only means that certainty is impossible. To me, that indicates an agnostic attitude is probably best. Rather than say that the EB team committed a huge error, one might say that they have interpreted the data in a way with which you were unfamiliar.
    οἵη περ φύλλων γενεὴ τοίη δὲ καὶ ἀνδρῶν.
    Even as are the generations of leaves, such are the lives of men.
    Glaucus, son of Hippolochus, Illiad, 6.146



  18. #18
    Member Member zooeyglass's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Location
    Oxford, England
    Posts
    245

    Default Re: Hoplite question

    Quote Originally Posted by oudysseos View Post
    Cyrus, I did in fact give you the citation: 5.71.1, i.e. book 5 chapter 71. Here is the original.

    ξυνιόντων δ᾽ ἔτι Ἆγις ὁ βασιλεὺς τοιόνδε ἐβουλεύσατο δρᾶσαι. τὰ στρατόπεδα ποιεῖ μὲν καὶ ἅπαντα τοῦτο: ἐπὶ τὰ δεξιὰ κέρατα αὐτῶν ἐν ταῖς ξυνόδοις μᾶλλον ἐξωθεῖται, καὶ περιίσχουσι κατὰ τὸ τῶν ἐναντίων εὐώνυμον ἀμφότεροι τῷ δεξιῷ, διὰ τὸ φοβουμένους προσστέλλειν τὰ γυμνὰ ἕκαστον ὡς μάλιστα τῇ τοῦ ἐν δεξιᾷ παρατεταγμένου ἀσπίδι καὶ νομίζειν τὴν πυκνότητα τῆς ξυγκλῄσεως εὐσκεπαστότατον εἶναι: καὶ ἡγεῖται μὲν τῆς αἰτίας ταύτης ὁ πρωτοστάτης τοῦ δεξιοῦ κέρως, προθυμούμενος ἐξαλλάσσειν αἰεὶ τῶν ἐναντίων τὴν ἑαυτοῦ γύμνωσιν, ἕπονται δὲ διὰ τὸν αὐτὸν φόβον καὶ οἱ ἄλλοι.

    My comment on the passages from the Anabasis would be that the Greek formations are dense compared to the Persian forces. This would be true whether you go along with Hanson or van Wees on the density of hoplite formations.

    Again, the multiplicity of interpretations of these texts only means that certainty is impossible. To me, that indicates an agnostic attitude is probably best. Rather than say that the EB team committed a huge error, one might say that they have interpreted the data in a way with which you were unfamiliar.
    hear, hear! thank you for posting the greek also, kind of you. i liked your explanation and will read a little more around it.
    inde consilivm mihi pavca de Avgvsto et extrema tradere, mox Tiberii principatum et cetera, sine ira et stvdio, qvorvm cavsas procvl habeo.

  19. #19
    Member Member Cyrus's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2008
    Location
    Milano ITA
    Posts
    353

    Default Re: Hoplite question

    Quote Originally Posted by SwissBarbar View Post
    Imagine vanilla RTW as a strawberry. You can make it better by adding sugar and stuff. EB is the sugared, chocolate-vanilla-sauced, peach-icecream cultivated version of the strawberry , but you still cannot make a banana out of it.

    EB works with the tools V-RTW to give us and make the best they can out of it. I'm sure the know pretty well about phalanxes.
    Mmmmm straberry............ "drools"
    Anyway yeah their representation is ok i'm saying however there is much room to improve so maybe in eb 2 we might see something different?
    And oudysseos sorry, i guess io missed the part where you said you wrote it anyway thanks.
    I have a few more questions regarding the matter,the early triarii, roman hoplites why were they abandoned?they seem even stronger than the late ones.....
    And were there any at cannae?
    Since i only got as far as the polibian reforms once would anyone explain when,why and how they happened? and why have i never heard of them before? from what i studied polibius was just a writer.....


    Italians do it better! Chi dice donna dice guai. Abbi donna di te minore, se vuoi essere signore. Donne e buoi dei paesi tuoi. Fiume, grondaia e donna parlatora mandano l'uomo di casa fuora.
    And my personal favorite: "Non rimuovere il confine antico fissato dai tuoi padri". In english: "Do not remove the anchent border placed by your fathers". It looses something in the translation......

  20. #20
    Vicious Celt Warlord Member Celtic_Punk's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2007
    Location
    In your kitchen, raiding your fridge!
    Posts
    1,575

    Default Re: Hoplite question

    My hoplites perform soundly thankyou.

    Put em on Guard mode, and they'll kick ass if they are not flanked. If they are flanked, or the lines change a bit so that they are not straight, and part of your unit is isolated, switch off guard mode, and you'll continue to kick ass.

    Hoplites are bomb... Dont let anyone tell you otherwise.
    'Who Dares WINS!' - SAS
    "The republic stands for truth and honour. For all that is noblest in our race. By truth and honour, principle and sacrifice alone will Ireland be free."-Liam Mellows


    Who knows? If it's a enough day we may all end up Generals!"

  21. #21
    Arrogant Ashigaru Moderator Ludens's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2003
    Posts
    9,063
    Blog Entries
    1

    Lightbulb Re: Hoplite question

    Quote Originally Posted by Cyrus View Post
    I have a few more questions regarding the matter,the early triarii, roman hoplites why were they abandoned?they seem even stronger than the late ones.....
    And were there any at cannae?
    Since i only got as far as the polibian reforms once would anyone explain when,why and how they happened? and why have i never heard of them before? from what i studied polibius was just a writer.....
    You are right that Polybius was a writer. The game uses the term Polybian military era to indicate the Roman army as described by Polybius during the second Punic war. This army was significantly better equipped than the armies of the Phyric and first Punic war (in-game called the Camillian military era).

    The term "Polybian reform" is used, for want of better alternative, to describe this transformation. It probably wasn't a real reform, but a gradual adaptation of new techniques (Celtic chainmail, Iberian swords) coupled with an increase in wealth that allowed individual Romans to better equip themselves.
    Looking for a good read? Visit the Library!

  22. #22

    Default Re: Hoplite question

    In guard mode, they're close enough to replicate that anyway.....
    Μηδεν εωρακεναι φoβερωτερον και δεινοτερον φαλλαγγος μακεδονικης

  23. #23
    Member Member Cyrus's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2008
    Location
    Milano ITA
    Posts
    353

    Default Re: Hoplite question

    Yes of course celticpunk they are fine,just saying i thought they didn't form the interlocking.....
    But yeah i agree they kick ass!!! what do you mean "your" hoplites?
    Also just off topic question how do i change my signature?
    And how did the romans get in touch with the celtic chainmail? before giulius cesar they never went further than gallia transalipina.


    Italians do it better! Chi dice donna dice guai. Abbi donna di te minore, se vuoi essere signore. Donne e buoi dei paesi tuoi. Fiume, grondaia e donna parlatora mandano l'uomo di casa fuora.
    And my personal favorite: "Non rimuovere il confine antico fissato dai tuoi padri". In english: "Do not remove the anchent border placed by your fathers". It looses something in the translation......

  24. #24
    EB Nitpicker Member oudysseos's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2006
    Location
    Dublin, Ireland
    Posts
    3,182

    Default Re: Hoplite question

    Look at the second-to-last word in your post and you've answered your own question.
    οἵη περ φύλλων γενεὴ τοίη δὲ καὶ ἀνδρῶν.
    Even as are the generations of leaves, such are the lives of men.
    Glaucus, son of Hippolochus, Illiad, 6.146



  25. #25
    Arrogant Ashigaru Moderator Ludens's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2003
    Posts
    9,063
    Blog Entries
    1

    Lightbulb Re: Hoplite question

    Quote Originally Posted by Cyrus View Post
    Also just off topic question how do i change my signature?
    At the top left of the screen is a button "User CP", click it and select "edit signature" from the left column.
    Looking for a good read? Visit the Library!

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  
Single Sign On provided by vBSSO