The Prometheus: Large Mafia Game [Concluded]

[ULC]

Perfectly logical reasoning, pevergreen.

Perfectly good timing of you, now stop being a , Pizzaguy, or I won't tip you.

[Askthepizzaguy]

I resent being called a daisy. I'm telling the moderators.

[Crazed Rabbit]

The crew members went to sleep somberly that night. It seemed as though they were close to finally ridding The Prometheus of the scourge of the fanatics. But there were not many of them left, and failure would be catastrophic for all of humanity.

In the third barracks quadrant, one individual slept fitfully. Finally he sat upright and felt the urgent need to relive himself. He shook off his covers and dropped from his bunk to the floor.

As he landed, tried to avoid waking the other crewmembers sleeping in the room. Then he carefully made his way out of the room, narrowly avoiding smacking his foot on a bed leg.

As he made his way to the bathroom, his pace grew faster. The corridor lights were dimmed. As he pushed open the bathroom door, he caught his toe on the lip of the doorway and fell forward.

As Ichigo put his hands out to brace his fall, he saw a metal pipe swing over his head. He turned after he hit the floor to see a dark figure grunting as the pipe hit the doorframe, where Ichigo would have been had he not fallen, with a resounding thud and vibrated.

The figure grunted and turned to Ichigo, then raised the pipe and advanced as Ichigo scrambled away. Ichigo got up and looked around; there was no place to run in the bathroom, and the figure was rapidly advancing in the darkened room. Frantic, he saw a glint of light off the floor in front of the figure; a spot of water?

He could only hope; Ichigo dashed forward and feinted to his right. The figure matched his movement and began to swing, but then his boot slipped on the water and he fell.

Ichigo then dashed around the figure and to the doorway. He shot a quick glance back and saw the shadowy figure already getting up and coming towards him. His heart was pounding, and he knew his problems weren’t over yet. He took a deep breath and began running back to the barracks rooms. He picked up speed and dashed as closed as he dared to the walls, taking corners at dangerous speeds and nearly losing control several times. He could hear running footsteps behind him, gaining on him.

Ichigo was breathing heavily now, barely able to maintain his speed. It took all of his mental and physical effort to keep the pace up. Just a little farther, he thought, still hearing the footsteps behind him, the footsteps still gaining ground.

Finally he made the last turn, glancing off the wall and running forward, door of the barracks room in sight. As he sped down the hallway, he could no longer hear the footsteps behind him. Only as he reached the door did he dare to turn around. There was nobody behind him. He kept looking for a moment, and then collapsed, panting.
*********************************************
The Captain gathered the crew that morning, emotionless. The effort to find the attacker after Ichigo had raised the alarm had been fruitless.

“The killers still lurk among us, but one of us, or rather, we, got lucky tonight and survived. Continue what you have been doing and find the killer among us,” commanded the Captain.

The crewmembers began to talk among themselves.

Alive (7)

Ichigo
YLC
Seamus
Reenk Roink
twilightblade
Peasant Phill
Alexander The Pretty Good


Killed (6)
Lord Winter
Andres
shlin28
beefy187
Yoyoma
White Eyes

Thrown Out the Air-Lock (1)
KukriKhan

Imprisoned (9)

Rythmic
glyphz
Sigurd
Askthepizzaguy
Chaotix
Pevergreen
Aries777777
makaikhaan
Mithrandir

[Alexander the Pretty Good]

Huh, I wonder how that happened...

I'll vote when I see some more arguments or RR's results (if it's still possible or whatever).

[Sigurd]

Yes, though I posted otherwise, my real suspects this past round were Mithrandir and Peasant Phill. How stupid do you think the Reenkmaistro is divulging his exact plans in public? Just keeping you on your toes Mafia, a battle of wits is a bad deal for you.

Alright Reenkster, I know your style. Who did you really investigate this night at what was the result?

And I would really like to hear more about this comm.officer role YLC claims to have. What can you do?

[Sigurd]

I want to hear from the dead and alive.
The only restriction we have is "no communication by the dead outside this thread, no screen shots and no chatlogs".

Any other players with roles? The setup with a mafia able to convert, would be unfair if no pro-town roles were provided.

We have:
the Agent: seireikhaan - converts
a Disciple: Pizzaguy - kills
a Disciple: ?? - kills
the Deputy: Reenk Roink - investigates
the comm officer: YLC - ??

The remaining players:
Ichigo - probably innocent due to last night's attack

YLC - claims innocence with pro town role.

Seamus - unclear. Was investigated by RR but could have been converted later.

Reenk Roink - claims deputy. Most likely true.

twilightblade - on a cruise, but not WoGed yet... why??

Peasant Phill - mentions being the Janitor twice, but later no reference - converted?
He defends seireikhaan at one point in the game asking why people are voting for him.

Alexander The Pretty Good - voted out both Pizzaguy and seireikhaan.

[pevergreen]

FYI, Twilightblade's group has returned today, expect a post tomorrow, as they are apparently all tired.

[Reenk Roink]

It seems the dynamic of this game has really changed. First in CR's writeups and my investigations, the kills happened after the meetings before the crew went back to their cabins. Then my investigation of Peasant Phill showed me that I could not enter people's rooms, clearly a nerfing of my role for whatever reason. Now this rounds writeup shows an unsuccessful Mafia kill in a communal barracks room.

This may mean that the Mafia abilities have been nerfed like myself. I was never a big believer in the later conversions, but lets look at the results. The Mafia have killed 6 times. They had only 5 nighttime kill attempts available (1 failed just now) and 2 kills occured when a Mafia was lynched. Very low kill rate if you ask me...

Off tangent to Sigurd: I can't believe you caught that pevergreen reference. That was wholly unintentional and subconscious, I had to read it again to realize I had made a pretty strong indirect claim there. Once again you were the one to find these types of posts... must be why you are the best. Although I still don't realize why you didn't notice me as the hobo with my blatant posts in Gotta have more Mafia, must be because we were all noobs then.

[Crazed Rabbit]

I'm not sure*, but TB may have to vote in this day phase (which may or may not coincide with the real day in Australia) to survive (and not be thrown out the airlock).

*I haven't checked right now.

CR

[White_eyes:D]

I think YLC is the final Mafia *ducks to avoid tables and chairs being thrown* I mean he NOW claims to have a role, which then Pizza Guy comes outta nowhere and defends YLC. I ask you, why would he defend him now? I had TONS of posts before this, why jump on something I just noticed? and YLC is being VERY silent on the matter*Scum alert* but it is up to you...

[Seamus Fermanagh]

Ichigo and Reenk need to exchange thoughts and PMs. All others are potentially tainted (I haven't been converted, but can offer no definitive proof.

5 Remain: YLC, Me, Phil, Blade, AtPG.

Of those:

YLC has squirmed a bit, but as Sigurd notes, it would seem he has a role, but good/bad is not certain at present.

Phil is a classic semi-lurker and touchy when voted for.

AtPG?

'blade?

[White_eyes:D]

Ichigo and Reenk need to exchange thoughts and PMs. All others are potentially tainted (I haven't been converted, but can offer no definitive proof.

5 Remain: YLC, Me, Phil, Blade, AtPG.

Of those:

YLC has squirmed a bit, but as Sigurd notes, it would seem he has a role, but good/bad is not certain at present.

Phil is a classic semi-lurker and touchy when voted for.

AtPG?

'blade?

I would say bad....as he has no proof that he IS good. He can't claim that he saved Ichigo, he can't claim he has been investigating anyone really(he only voted for Khann once but then toke it back right away)....Plus was Khann not a comm officer or something like that? Makes my, he converted two guys at the start more realistic,since they worked in the same department....

[ULC]

White_Eyes, I suggest you discuss with Sigurd the details of what and who I am, since I sent my role pm to him. I can't specifically help the town, like Reenk has, but if I do open my mouth, then my ability is wasted...plus, CR won't let me quote him.

EDIT: I have actually made it repeatedly clear what my ability is, and it ATPG is aware of it to a degree (I got hotheaded and leaked some information)

[White_eyes:D]

White_Eyes, I suggest you discuss with Sigurd the details of what and who I am, since I sent my role pm to him. I can't specifically help the town, like Reenk has, but if I do open my mouth, then my ability is wasted...plus, CR won't let me quote him.

EDIT: I have actually made it repeatedly clear what my ability is, and it ATPG is aware of it to a degree (I got hotheaded and leaked some information)

and I think that it was fake and edited what was sent.....since your ABILITY has very much failed to save, warn, or even help town in any way....your just trying some last minute bullflop to keep yourself safe. You don't want to be lynched for this round as you have noticed your kill rate has gone down...but on the flip side Reenk can't confirm or deny your Pro-town status since he lost his ability to reveal and you want to seem too valuable to the town to lynch since your Towns only hope.

[Crazed Rabbit]

White_Eyes, I suggest you discuss with Sigurd the details of what and who I am, since I sent my role pm to him. I can't specifically help the town, like Reenk has, but if I do open my mouth, then my ability is wasted...plus, CR won't let me quote him.

EDIT: I have actually made it repeatedly clear what my ability is, and it ATPG is aware of it to a degree (I got hotheaded and leaked some information)

You can quote me.

CR

[Reenk Roink]

White_Eyes, I suggest you discuss with Sigurd the details of what and who I am, since I sent my role pm to him. I can't specifically help the town, like Reenk has, but if I do open my mouth, then my ability is wasted...plus, CR won't let me quote him.

EDIT: I have actually made it repeatedly clear what my ability is, and it ATPG is aware of it to a degree (I got hotheaded and leaked some information)

Now this intrigues me. I have been slightly suspicious of you but placed you lower in scale to others. The argument by Chaotix27 gave some good reasons why, but then again, I admit that White_eyes:D hounding and ramblings make your guilt seem less plausible.

But what is the role? When did you send it to Sigurd (he was lynched very early and it is against the rules to communicate through PM with him after his lynch and it seems unlikely that you would confide in him in the first 3 rounds)? Why not tell us now? And why would CR not let you quote him? This is what he says on the first post:

Quoting posts and PMs (even mine) is allowed.

That is suspicious, then again, given what has happened so far, it's not unlikely that CR changed the dynamics in your case too. Plus my gut tells me you are a good guy for whatever reason.

You are an enigma to me.

EDIT: Ok, spill the beans.

[Chaotix]

I figured white_eyes' insane rantings on YLC were actually making everyone less suspicious of him, so that's why I made my post to show that there actually was some sense behind his words. I still think YLC is the best lynch, right now.

We can probably rule out twilightblade as mafia for the reason that he hasn't been here- so unless CR was randomly assigning his kills, which he should tell us if he would do something like that- he couldn't have killed anyone.

[Sigurd]

But what is the role? When did you send it to Sigurd (he was lynched very early and it is against the rules to communicate through PM with him after his lynch and it seems unlikely that you would confide in him in the first 3 rounds)? Why not tell us now? And why would CR not let you quote him? This is what he says on the first post:

No rules were broken. CR stated no communication by the dead outside the game thread.
I have of course not communicated with YLC other that quoting the rules when he sent me a pm.

Again I feel Peasant Phil is the most likely suspect this round should I be naive enough to believe YLC and his role description.
Alexander helped lynch both Pizzaguy and seireikhaan so I put him in the innocent box. Which leaves Seamus, Twilight and Phil.
Seamus was investigated and Twilight got a WoG warning. PP shoud be our lynch candidate this round.
If it turns out bad, there is still time to rethink the possibilities and lynch the last treehugger.

[White_eyes:D]

Now this intrigues me. I have been slightly suspicious of you but placed you lower in scale to others. The argument by Chaotix27 gave some good reasons why, but then again, I admit that White_eyes:D hounding and ramblings make your guilt seem less plausible.

But what is the role? When did you send it to Sigurd (he was lynched very early and it is against the rules to communicate through PM with him after his lynch and it seems unlikely that you would confide in him in the first 3 rounds)? Why not tell us now? And why would CR not let you quote him? This is what he says on the first post:



That is suspicious, then again, given what has happened so far, it's not unlikely that CR changed the dynamics in your case too. Plus my gut tells me you are a good guy for whatever reason.

You are an enigma to me.

EDIT: Ok, spill the beans.

Ok, that sucks........well I guess I could just not bring up anything since it seems I draw more suspicion on others then THE GUY who is GUILTY...and Reenk I really dislike you now....

Edit:AND I am the one who brought up half of the reasons of YLC's guilt and you didn't even read it, yet you instantly believe Chaotix?
(I was lynched in a game where I was the detective because Chaotix turned half the town against me by giving a fake pm...)

[Reenk Roink]

No rules were broken. CR stated no communication by the dead outside the game thread.
I have of course not communicated with YLC other that quoting the rules when he sent me a pm.

Are you a lawyer?

But I want to see the YLC role PM very badly. Peasant Phill is my #1 but YLC is #1b and with him hiding something vote: YLC.

Pressure tactics attributed to Seamus.

Also, don't dislike me White_eyes:D, I like you, I just don't like the way you hounded YLC, it seems like me and my List.

[White_eyes:D]

Are you a lawyer?

But I want to see the YLC role PM very badly. Peasant Phill is my #1 but YLC is #1b and with him hiding something vote: YLC.

Pressure tactics attributed to Seamus.

Also, don't dislike me White_eyes:D, I like you, I just don't like the way you hounded YLC, it seems like me and my List.

Well come on, You guys are basically saying I am insane and can't be trusted because of it....
but I guess I could go with that saying "don't mistake my insanity for stupidity"

[ULC]

I am terribly sorry! I falsely believed that I couldn't quote CR, I'm just so used to not being able too .

I am only concerned about making my ability useless, that's all. If Reenk wants too, I can send it (forwarded of course) to him, or if the town truly demands it, then I will reveal publicly. of course, I expect White Eyes to strike the drums and round up supporters for another crusade

Whether the town actually believes my role or not, is up to you guys.

[White_eyes:D]

Whether the town actually believes my role or not, is up to you guys.

You see Reenk, this is the reason I most suspect him(many others but because he reminds me of a certain Pizza Guy)....he sounds similar to Pizza Guy and Khaan with these kind of statements.....and no it's not crazy you Reenk seen how Khaan and Pizza Guy had a Certain 'Mafia playing style' when voted for and I think this is YLC's...

[ULC]

And thus your suggesting that the mafia fall within this specific spectrum within the game of how one acts? or that I am in fact Pizzaguy and Khaan? Which statements make me sound similar, since I don;t see what your talking about. And you know my playing style White_Eyes, and it's not Khaans or Pizzaguys.

[Reenk Roink]

Unvote: YLC

Look, the fact is given the slow kill rates of Mafia, we have some time to really make sure. Let's not condemn YLC or Peasant Phill. I have asked him for his PM.

[Twilightblade]

ummm... hi guys

I'm content to see whether YLC has an actual pm (mostly due to me absence)

[White_eyes:D]

I knew it.....once you all believe the sudden role PM he gives you, he well become an almost unlynchable target.....

[ULC]

I knew it.....once you all believe the sudden role PM he gives you, he well become an almost unlynchable target.....

*sighs* Reenk hasn't even weighed in on it, please wait before we start up again .

[Chaotix]

White Eyes, the more ya whine about it, the less people are going to take you seriously.

I think all the evidence we have against YLC has been presented, and for the most part, everyone else believes it is plausible, but are still unsure. Im on your side of the argument, but I doubt anything further that you say is going to convince Reenk or the others any more.



As for YLC: you will be caught, one way or another...

[White_eyes:D]

White Eyes, the more ya whine about it, the less people are going to take you seriously.

I think all the evidence we have against YLC has been presented, and for the most part, everyone else believes it is plausible, but are still unsure. Im on your side of the argument, but I doubt anything further that you say is going to convince Reenk or the others any more.



As for YLC: you will be caught, one way or another...

True, but if you recall you lynched me in one game(kinda off-topic)BECAUSE I was not active enough in presenting evidence I will not make the same mistake twice.....and the wizard is useless since I was already killed by Khaan.... anyone have any theories WHY he killed me?(because everyone thinks I am crazy)