The Scourge of Ephesus [Concluded]

[TinCow]

How do your previous statements AT ALL imply the bolded part?

My previous statements don't, but I'll be happy to explain my line of thought. First, we know GH can role block because it has been confirmed by many people, too many for them all to be mafia. Second, role blocking is not an ability that is likely to be given to mafia. Third, the descriptions of the old man in the write-ups appear anything but scummy.

As I specifically stated, this does not mean GH absolutely is pro-town. This is an Andres mafia game, so it's certainly possible he could be mafia or neutral. However, the evidence I see points strongly to pro-town at this point in time. If evidence appears that disputes GH's allegiance to the town, I will reassess the situation then.

[Reenk Roink]

My previous statements don't, but I'll be happy to explain my line of thought. First, we know GH can role block because it has been confirmed by many people, too many for them all to be mafia. Second, role blocking is not an ability that is likely to be given to mafia. Third, the descriptions of the old man in the write-ups appear anything but scummy.

Thanks for explaining. I still think it's quite plausible for a Mafia group to have a roleblocker, but the third case is quite a good one I didn't think of. The old man really just wanted to tell me stories.

GH, since your role is quite well known now, might you at least quote some parts of your PM to us? I understand if you snip certain things out for security reasons. Just put my mind to ease.

[GeneralHankerchief]

My most recent feedback PM?

[Reenk Roink]

The Role PM please

[GeneralHankerchief]

Already posted it defending myself against ATPG. It should be the first one in the series. Let me check back and see if I can find it.

-edit- Here we are. My role PM is the first quoted bit.

[Reenk Roink]

Already posted it defending myself against ATPG. It should be the first one in the series. Let me check back and see if I can find it.

-edit- Here we are. My role PM is the first quoted bit.

Ah, thanks, I missed it. Except for one bit about an old man that doesn't appear to relate in the initial story or in your PM, things check out and while I can't quote PM's anymore, the secret hiding place mentioned in mine correlates strongly with your PM.

I too now have come around and have a strong feeling that GH is neutral at worst. I suggest the doctor protect him every night and hope that his choices ring true.

PS: Don't block the doctor!

[shlin28]

Gah, didn't get back in time to change my vote

Oh well, whats done is done.

To Ibn Khaldun: You are not explaination why you make such short posts + votes without any explainations. Your recent post is nothing but supersition I prefer concrete evidence or at least an adimittance that your suspicions of Yoyoma is just a hunch.