The Scourge of Ephesus [Concluded]

[Ibn-Khaldun]

GH.. since YOU did not received this pm then YOU can not decide whether it is real or not. You can only speculate.

I think he forwarded this message to ALL the townies so I would like someone else who were townie to confirm this.

Edit: And it is quoted twice only because I couldn't quote the title of that pm.

[GeneralHankerchief]

It's not the message I'm interested in, it's the fact that you have Andres and, bizarrely, "The Scourge of Ephesus" misspelled in the title.

"The Scourge of Ephesus" was in the subject line for the PMs, not the title. It boggles my mind how it got in a title.

[Ibn-Khaldun]

It's not the message I'm interested in, it's the fact that you have Andres and, bizarrely, "The Scourge of Ephesus" misspelled in the title.

"The Scourge of Ephesus" was in the subject line for the PMs, not the title. It boggles my mind how it got in a title.

So??

You got pm that was meant personally for you. I got message that was for all townies(at least I think so because it makes no sense to write the same old message to more than 25 people!)

[Askthepizzaguy]

I also find it interesting that you're online during this night phase, not contributing positively, and invisible.

Not proof, but definitley odd.

[GeneralHankerchief]

And how do you explain Andres's misspelled name?

It's not like he changed his username to "Andrres", sent out the PM, and then changed it back.

[Askthepizzaguy]

I only have two suspects, really. There's Beefy, who is supposedly not here, and Ibn-Khaldun, who is nearly 100% mafia and is here, active but unhelpful as usual, and posting BAD defenses. Then there is lord winter, who, due to the clues, should actually be our number two suspect.


Ibn-Khaldun
187Beefyz
Lord Winter


But dont you think someone trying to finger Lord Winter would put such obvious clues in after him?

[White_eyes:D]

So??

You got pm that was meant personally for you. I got message that was for all townies(at least I think so because it makes no sense to write the same old message to more than 25 people!)

I must say....you just messed up if you tried to fake it misspelling the hosts name and the title of the game....Andres doesn't make mistakes like that.....your own Fake reveal is your downfall

[Ibn-Khaldun]

Ibn, in most of these games now, the host provides a mafia with the townie PM so they can do what you just did.

And I should know this because... ???

In how many mafia games I have been?? This is second one.

In your Simpson mafia game I was a townie. Did I participate there a lot?? Can't remember that I did.
And when was it?? Quite awhile ago!!

And this is my second one and suddenly I should know ALL the things that have been done in the previous mafia games??? Gah!!

If that makes me a bad mafia game player because I don't read ALL those previous game threads then.. I really don't know why I joined this one!
Wait .. now I remember why I joined.. Andres promised cookies!!

Edit: White_eyes:D .. so you did not get that message??? Anyway.. that is the original message that I got.

[GeneralHankerchief]

*notes that IK has once again ignored the "Andrres" question*

[Ibn-Khaldun]

*notes that IK has once again ignored the "Andrres" question*

Should I give you my password so you could check that PM out???

4. To have fun?

Most likely.

You lose, Ibn. Please do not vote.

Since vigilante killed you then you must of been more scummier than me.
Actually, no wonder you were killed if you go after people without any evidence!

[GeneralHankerchief]

Nice, you still didn't answer me.

So you claim that what you quoted is EXACTLY how the PM was sent? Andres's misspelled name and all?

[Askthepizzaguy]

And I should know this because... ???

1. In how many mafia games I have been?? This is second one.

2. In your Simpson mafia game I was a townie. Did I participate there a lot?? Can't remember that I did.
And when was it?? Quite awhile ago!!

3. And this is my second one and suddenly I should know ALL the things that have been done in the previous mafia games??? Gah!!

4. If that makes me a bad mafia game player because I don't read ALL those previous game threads then.. I really don't know why I joined this one!
Wait .. now I remember why I joined.. Andres promised cookies!!

1. Why is this a defense?

2. Why is this a defense?

3. Your noobishness is actually why your bad townie/blatant mafia behavior is so easy to read. Veteran players would read more like 75% mafia or lower if they are really good.

4. To have fun?




You lose, Ibn. Please do not vote.

EDIT: actually go ahead and vote. I want to see who you want dead.

[Askthepizzaguy]

GH.. since YOU did not received this pm then YOU can not decide whether it is real or not. You can only speculate.

I think he forwarded this message to ALL the townies so I would like someone else who were townie to confirm this.

Ibn, in most of these games now, the host provides a mafia with the townie PM so they can do what you just did.

And I am guessing it was revealed earlier somewhere, too, but I am burnt out and I cant be bothered to go look.


Your reveal proves nothing, your votes and actions and reasoning speaks VOLUMES.