The Godfather, Part 3 [Concluded]

**Beefy187** · 02-15-2009, 11:58

Fact that no one counter claimed it shows that either the real detective is already dead or Tevash is for real.

Since there is no one counter claiming, only option we got is give Tevash a day or two before he gets up on the chopping board again.

**ULC** · 02-15-2009, 12:05

Believe, not believe? Does it even matter? I am truly apathetic to the town's situation as of right now, and as far as I care, every last one of you can take a long walk on a short pier. Right now, I am getting really sick of mafia games, the main reason is being called a liar - I am one of those people who take it very personally when they are called a liar, and the last few days have done nothing to improve my ability to handle that.

I refuse to read through this thread, which is filled with slander, anger, downright depressing amounts of antagonism. I refuse to help the town anymore in anyway shape or form. I refuse to vote one way or the on any matter, and I honestly hope the mafia win at this point, it would serve every last one of you right.

In short, I ask that I suicide before I continue on and say something that will not only ban me from the gameroom, but the Org as a whole, if I have not already.

**Askthepizzaguy** · 02-15-2009, 12:18

Originally Posted by YLC

In short, I ask that I suicide before I continue on and say something that will not only ban me from the gameroom, but the Org as a whole, if I have no already.

Shhh... be nice, it is just a game. Please. You're my friend, don't do that.

**Askthepizzaguy** · 02-15-2009, 12:11

Spoiler Alert, click show to read:

**Seamus Fermanagh** · 02-15-2009, 15:40

Originally Posted by Beefy187

Fact that no one counter claimed it shows that either the real detective is already dead or Tevash is for real.

Since there is no one counter claiming, only option we got is give Tevash a day or two before he gets up on the chopping board again.

Not necessarily. Were I the detective and NOT involved in the runoff, I would not have counter-claimed during a runoff. While most false detective claims are mafia playing an angle, it has been done by generic townies just to toss

in the game.

Moreover, a false detective will always trip themselves up within a few rounds, so a Mafioso who has done so with this many rounds remaining is not gonna make it -- its too reflexive by the town to kill both sides of a "I'm the detective -- no you're not you're mafia" pairing, just to be safe. Tev will ALWAYS be a litle suspect -- and scrutinized -- from this point forward. EDIT note Tincow's post just above both in support of what I am saying here AND as a good idea with Tev if he doesn't respond.

Again, I caution all NOT to assume we have taken down a mafioso. I am certainly cagey enough to take the first truly contentious vote and start single-killing after it to hide my numbers, even if it takes 4-5 rounds to "convince" the town they got one. The devastating impact of renewed double murders in the last couple of go-arounds would be worth it -- panicking the town into making quick and possibly under-evaluated choices. Since I am hardly the brightest person in the Gameroom, I have to assume the mafia may be employing such a tactic.

Again, were I the detective and had 1 ID'd, I would want to take a round or two (since it's still mid-game by the numbers) to try to get the 2nd mafioso if I could, while townie numbers indicated it was not necessary to reveal and make a 1-to-1 trade.