The Godfather, Part 3 [Concluded]

[White_eyes:D]

Yeah.....it was a townie victory..........GH did they really have song clues in the previous Godfather?......anyway GG I loved being the grunt....and I loved screwing with town more......

[Askthepizzaguy]

STOP MESSING WITH MY BRAAAAIIIINNNN!!!!!!!!

Will ya quit it! It was funny the first time, already!

Well, now I don't feel so bad about TevashSzat, and GOOD CALL townies on White_Eyes.

I had to keep my vote on Reenk Roink out of fairness, because the game was basically over but Beefy refused to say he was innocent to me all game, and Reenk Roink did, over and over again, even past the point of no return.

Well done, White_Eyes for avoiding the wrath of SkyNet. TevashSzat wasn't so lucky. I made a good guess about seireikhaan being either the detective or a mason, and when it was too late, I figured Ares was the Nudicyclist, but he had basically done everything legal he could do to explain he had a role.

What I want to know is, why did Seireikhaan post all those clues and stuff? And why was Ares so sure it was Sasaki as a henchman? That threw me off a lot, it didn't help me. Any explanations?

Yay! SkyNet got ONE of them!

Now I get to hear Pizza guy scream in agony

Why would I do that? I already said you TOTALLY fooled me, Beefster. And I don't feel bad now, because I WAS actually useful this game after all, not a total jackass.

To be honest, I am surprised by the result, and I really wish SkyNet would STOP FINGERING THE PROTOWN ROLES!!!

[GeneralHankerchief]

Oh GH, double fakeout! Love it. Suppose I should have realized that the lack of song and explanation for juggler dude meant something was up.

Well, you'll notice when I said this:

The fake ending was a one-time thing.

I said nothing about fake endings.

-edit- oh no, please don't wait for my commentary to post anything. I'm going to be locked in a room with a computer for a week working on that thing.

[White_eyes:D]

OH.....Khaan.....you died because of Random.org......Yeah I know....lucky break in the early going for us....

Edit:for three nights in a row we went without killing two people......then Tevash went MIA....then in the end game my internet service went down for about 4 days..... I was totally pissed.....I couldn't even give Beefy a proper write-up....

[Seamus Fermanagh]

My response has been edited into my previous post. GRRRRRRRR.

[seireikhaan]

Wow, I gotta say...

UNBELIEVABLE game. Incredibly well done. Good writeups from the mafia and our CoP's, good role selection, EVERYTHING. Granted, it got heated for a while, and for that, I apologize. It was mostly my fault; I'll explain in detail tomorrow perhaps, but I just got so frustrated at being a dead detective. Either way, my behavior for most of the game was unhelful and, at times, borderline vulgar. Sorry.

However, I think this game will give Capo III a run for its money come HoF time, assuming Capo runs on schedule and comes this year. Wonderful game, wonderful job all around.

[Reenk Roink]

Seriously... the ???

So Beefy "revealed" to me that he was the Godfather and told me White eyes was his grunt. I asked who his other grunt was, and well, Beefy wouldn't get back to me. That coupled with taka's earlier post got me wondering. I still thought Beefy was the main Mafia, but had second doubts about both Andres and taka.

When GH posted the taka victory, it made sense it retrospect. taka for some reason sent me a congrats PM right after the tie vote. I had thought crap, this guy did it, he played us all, but then Beefy soon after revealed to me so I ignored taka for the bit.

GH, you are an evil, evil man...

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Thank you for using my kill method

[GeneralHankerchief]

My response has been edited into my previous post. GRRRRRRRR.

That made me guffaw in real life. My roommates would probably appreciate your efforts.

[seireikhaan]

Congratulations seireikhaan, you are the Detective!

I think you know how this works.

One investigation a night, the Godfather comes up innocent, and no private reveals of any kind. I'll need your first investigation within 24 hours. Best of luck!

GH

PS: BTW, in a little bit of trivia that may help you to determine whether you hate random.org or not, your number was actually the third one. The first two, interestingly enough, were the Godfather's two mafia grunts.

OH.....Khaan.....you died because of Random.org......Yeah I know....lucky break in the early going for us....

Well, GH, I think we have our answer to that last bit...

[GeneralHankerchief]

Yeah, that was really weird. Random.org's first two picks for Detective were Tevash and White_eyes. And then it goes and gives the mafia khaan.

I wonder if I should be relying on it for the Battle of Edessa in the Throne Room...

[Reenk Roink]

You know what, I'm still pissed! You never let us do this in Mafia V!

[Sasaki Kojiro]

OH.....Khaan.....you died because of Random.org......Yeah I know....lucky break in the early going for us....

Edit:for three nights in a row we went without killing two people......then Tevash went MIA....then in the end game my internet service went down for about 4 days..... I was totally pissed.....I couldn't even give Beefy a proper write-up....

What was the plan behind skipping the kills btw? I guess you didn't actually brazenly vote for your buddy and your godfather lol

btw, the fake ending just goes to show what I was saying earlier. It's so easy to read that and go "I can see how taka was the GF all along!"

[Askthepizzaguy]

Seireikhaan, I'd love to know what was up with your clues?
And Ares, why were you so sure Sasaki was evil? I thought he was too, admittedly.

Reenk, quick, change your title back! Quick, quick!

...do you guys forgive me now? And GH, you best not be lying.

[taka]

for everyone that congrats me, i think the congrats should go to the town. and a big well play'd to beefy, i personally NEVER thought he was the GF until i had to ask him just before his fate was sealed.

When GH posted the taka victory, it made sense it retrospect. taka for some reason sent me a congrats PM right after the tie vote. I had thought crap, this guy did it, he played us all, but then Beefy soon after revealed to me so I ignored taka for the bit.

i thought u knew that beefy was the GF before i sent you the pm? i sent the pm because i knew u had nailed beefy

as for everyone talking about lurkers....

PLEASE LEAVE US ALONE!..... sometimes we're busy in REAL LIFE........

and congrats to the townies who saw through beefy and voted for him, i personally thought wrong and voted reenk

[Reenk Roink]

Damn, Tevash really seemed innocent to me too. I will wear the badge of humiliation for a bit.

[White_eyes:D]

I really thought it was over when Beefy was the Godfather..... but we almost did it.....had are other Mafia buddy been around for those last couple of nights......it might have been different... but anyway.....this was my PM between me and Beefy, when he choose me as his grunt.....

your the Godfather Beefy????
Tevash we need to VERY careful about our targets, A LOT of vets are playing this and I can't help but feel the odds are stacked against us.....none the less....

Beefy= godfather=.... alright lets give up

Yea pretty much
Well seeing as you White_eyes built up a reputation of being innocent and Tevash is a good silent killer I thought the combination of you two works brilliantly rather then hiring the veterans. I have to say.. Ichigo+ Sasaki combo would've been deadly..

Your right White_eyes. We have a lot of vets. I think rather then trying what Sigurd and Boudica did, killing suspects, I think its a lot better to stick to basic and kill those who are seemingly innocent if we have any chance of victory.

The analyzers are better to be lynched. Thats those like ATPG, GH and LittleGrizzly.

good luck crew. Let the bloody show begin

you need to admit.....my write-ups REALLY screwed with you guys

[Askthepizzaguy]

PLEASE LEAVE US ALONE!..... sometimes we're busy in REAL LIFE........

NO!!! Sorry, in the early game, lurkers must die. I'm sorry, but those are the rules. You understand?

1. Early lynches will NEVER kill mafia, unless they are OK with a henchman dying to protect the others. Therefore, lynch people who volunteer (no protown role) or the lurkers, preferably.

2. Don't feel bad, Reenk. Seriously, I feel bad for going after YOU and thinking Beefy was innocent. I'm wearing the "Defender of Beefy" badge to remind me of my shame.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

The analyzers are better to be lynched. Thats those like ATPG, GH and LittleGrizzly.

So your plan was to lynch the host? heh

Did you guys have a quicktopic?

And Ares, why were you so sure Sasaki was evil? I thought he was too, admittedly.

I guess that juggling ball bit was put in their by GH, seemed weird that the mafia would choose to put it in.

[GeneralHankerchief]

Mafia Quicktopic:

http://www.quicktopic.com/42/H/GvCSFhMJF6JEk

I must say, it was great for fast host/mafia communication. I think all future hosts should request access to all in-game Quicktopics to make things run smoother.

[Reenk Roink]

But if I may give a request, please leave Sasaki and Ichigo alone for a time being. I don't want to welcome them back with Round 1/ Round 2 kill.

This is why I love Beefy and wanted him to win. What a great guy.

[Askthepizzaguy]

@The Mafia:

Missing the murder after Lord Winter's death was a sly gambit, but I don't think it worked very effectively. The town assumed that he might be guilty, but they also assumed he could be innocent. And Lord Winter did a good deed by mostly refraining from posting so as not to confuse us.

May have been better to murder twice every round, but by all means, mafia keep trying that gambit.
Was it a gambit, though? Or did one of you forget to murder? TevashSzat's death = 1 less mafia vote, 1 less mafia murder. Not bad, even if that's the only thing SkyNet was able to do POSITIVELY this game.

SkyNet is still dead, though. I have an announcement I'd like to make:


MIDAS is coming.

[White_eyes:D]

So your plan was to lynch the host? heh

Did you guys have a quicktopic?



I guess that juggling ball bit was put in their by GH, seemed weird that the mafia would choose to put it in.

Yes we did maybe Beefy could tell you it.......and I thought Rythmic was the Vigilante if you look in my kill write-up I said he had a identity.....heck you guys missed a lot of clues in my write-ups.....TinCow having "BEEFED" craved into his head.....

[White_eyes:D]

MIDAS is coming.

What in the world is that???

[taka]

a weapon of mafia destruction i assume

[Askthepizzaguy]

Heck you guys missed a lot of clues in my write-ups.....TinCow having "BEEFED" craved into his head.....

WIFOM, and Beefy is always the scapegoat. Had to ignore that, I didn't miss it at all, but I refused to believe clues that came FROM the mafia.

Ballsy, but those kinds of clues will remain in-jokes for the mafia, because it's too hit-and-miss. Lots of people were falsely implicated by the writeups.

What in the world is that???

MIDAS is to SkyNet what warp drive is to the horse and buggy. And I'm not revealing who might be helping. Someone here knows who it is, please remain silent.

[White_eyes:D]

a weapon of mafia destruction i assume

oh.....taka you have not lost as a Mafia yet.....weird.....but I am sure your rep in the small games well get you lynched at some point....

Edit: I am still keeping the SIG I love that comment by TinCow....and me+Skynet and a few vets made it happen.....

[TinCow]

Whew, I'm pleased with the fake-out. I had just about given up on ever being able to spot ANY mafioso when playing as a townie, since I was so convinced about Beefy at the end. After all the dead ends I pursued in this game, the idea of a taka win nearly melted my brain since he didn't appear on my mafia radar at all. Good to know I'm only mostly hopeless as a townie, and not totally.

MIDAS is to SkyNet what warp drive is to the horse and buggy.

Is it too much to hope that it has improved levels of brevity?

[White_eyes:D]

Is it too much to hope that it has improved levels of brevity?

It is too much to hope it will keep ATPG's post count down?

[Askthepizzaguy]

Everyone who played this game:

I want you to know I have taken your friendly and helpful advice to heart.

1. I will be spoilering my longer posts
2. I will be talking a lot less, especially in the earlier stages
3. There will be no MIDAS report to read. Everything is secret. You either trust the advice or not.
4. If you demand a specific argument for a certain person, I'll keep it brief and to the point.
5. I'll need your help in refining my style in this manner. Be patient and you will get the results you want out of me: Helpful, yet bearable.

I hope I redeemed myself even a little, and please, do NOT be afraid to offer me your advice and tell me if I am getting annoying. I do care, I am not so much of a jerk as to ignore all my friends.

[taka]

oh.....taka you have not lost as a Mafia yet.....weird.....but I am sure your rep in the small games well get you lynched at some point....

Eeek!