The fight for Inishmore [Concluded]

[Ituralde]

I'm just curious to the extent of Seamus role. I don't suggest to lynch him right away, just wanted to apply some pressure to get him to talk some more. He's already known to have a role and he has a protector. How much worse can it get for him if he reveals his role? So until he answers my vote stays. It's the only piece of information I've got so I'm going for it.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Fair enough. I would just like to point out that since he's declined to reveal, your pressure will be ineffective, especially if there is no bandwagon. And I do not advocate a bandwagon on Seamus at this time.

[Alexander the Pretty Good]

[Reenk Roink]

Vote: Askthepizzaguy

I refuse to answer your fascist questions. No I'm not nervous, just irritated.

[A Very Super Market]

Wait, has no one noticed the "Three Blind Mice" to "Two Blind Mice" clue? I mean, it seems rather obvious, but I don't see any other reason to change it. Either Jolt or Reenk was mafia.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Uh... Reenk is still alive. He's kind of voting for me. In fact, I am almost sure he is.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

While I voted Reenk on day 2, I think it was for his 'usual'?? antics I shall now vote: Askthepizzaguy. - reason: gut instinct.

Ach - ok so you DID offer yourself up for the lynch I remember now actually mentioning it in a Psychomafia PM as well that you were trying to get lynched again...

My vote for you was based on the activity over the last few pages. Looking at it again, maybe I was swayed by the apparent conflict between you and Reenk...?

Well, what can I say but: I am town - plain and simple no-role boudica

I guess in one respect that I am not such a bad lynch option given that my contribution to this game has been slight and I can't see it getting much deeper. However I am an awful lynch option given my innocence, but you'll just have to either take me at my word, or wait for the write-up to confirm it.

With town's best interest in mind, I shall not unvote yet - but stand aside in order that perhaps more worthy lynch candidates might come centre stage.

Vote:Boudica

The second post is after two votes on her, and yet she's already baling on any sort of normal defense and going for "I'm just a townie you can lynch me it's ok but if you do the writeup will show etc".

Now the reason for votes were:

Low activity
Thin reasoning
Saying pizza didn't offer himself up for lynch

Which are reasonable suspicions but not overwhelming. Mafia are usually over paranoid about who suspects them, worried about casual comments that no one else in the town really even notices, and boudica fits that profile to a T.

[FactionHeir]

AVSM:
Or someone wants you to think that this is the case. pevergreen did mention that kills are written by the killers.

Sasaki does make sense, what's your defense boudica?

[Sasaki Kojiro]

Wait, has no one noticed the "Three Blind Mice" to "Two Blind Mice" clue? I mean, it seems rather obvious, but I don't see any other reason to change it. Either Jolt or Reenk was mafia.

I wonder if the hadn't read pever's plots carefully and were trying to claim padraic as one of their own in order to appear weaker.

[Askthepizzaguy]

I am looking at the murder write-ups, but I hardly consider them viable clues. Misleading clues written by the mafia have been used in the Godfather game, and in Scourge of Ephesus. If we base our play off of stuff that came straight from the mafia's own hand, we are playing into theirs.

Still, it appears they were written by the same people, and in the same style. That's about all I can glean from them without delving into unreasonable speculation.

[A Very Super Market]

Feh, forgot about the kills being written by mafia. Never mind me, then. Or just WIFOM endlessly

[Askthepizzaguy]

Weren't you a serial killer that was anti-town? Or did I misinterpret. I don't mind your participation, I just wonder what your objectives are.

[ULC]

Vote: Seamus

[seireikhaan]

VOTE: SASAKI

[Askthepizzaguy]

I find this discussion staggeringly useful.

[ULC]

VOTE: SASAKI

VOTE: SEAMUS

My colors are prettier...

[A Very Super Market]

I was anti-everyone, but my goal is completely unaccomplishable (Unless the last two people are IRA and English and just kill each other) I might as well try and help out.

Simply put, I'm kinda bored.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Very well, and since I am bored as well, I'll talk to you. Are any of the current suspects being voted for good ones in your opinon? Do you have any suspects of your own to offer.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

Khaan is trying to imply something, that's clear enough. Starts out bold, becomes lavender, then rainbow? Is there a character in the play who starts out straight, becomes gay, then becomes a gay activist?

[Askthepizzaguy]

There are a couple more realistic probabilities.

I see that he could be employing a pro-town strategy of dropping hints.
Or, he's just employing a basic townie strategy of trying to get the mafia to murder him, and not explaining his votes to generate controversy, which is frankly brilliant.
Or he could be mafia attempting to mislead us.

So many possibilities, but there is no way of knowing. I doubt he'd reveal so early, and I won't be manipulated so easily. I need a case, not a hint.

[FactionHeir]

I thought in mafia games it was always about "If in doubt, lynch"?

[Askthepizzaguy]

Being predictable gets us killed, too. Even if I would offer benefit of the doubt in one game over a reasonless vote, I may not do so in another game, because the mafia could pick up on that as a viable strategy for manipulating the town.

I'll look at Sasaki more closely, but that's about all I can do when I've been given nothing to work with.

[FactionHeir]

You mean like your Day 1 lynchthepizzaguy?

[Askthepizzaguy]

You mean like your Day 1 lynchthepizzaguy?

That is awesome. I am seriously considering changing my name to lynchthepizzaguy.

[shlin28]

Vote: ATPG

Your potential future name told me to do it.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

Vote: ATPG

Your potential future name told me to do it.

You just put pizza ahead of boudica by my count...

I told you guys pizza should have been lynched day 1.

[Lord Winter]

Sorry everyone, I fell behind in my mafia reading.

Anyway, I don't see any point in lynching AtPG again. He's done nothing out of character and deserves to live through the first half of a game for once.

I agree with Saski, Boucida is truely acting out of character. I can't remember her doing the lynch me if you want thing before.

Vote: Boucida

[Askthepizzaguy]

If I don't produce a mafia by the mid-point of the game, you can go ahead and lynch me for my failure. I'd prefer you lynched me sooner rather than later, though, as in later rounds we might actually have viable suspects and every lynch counts.

[GeneralHankerchief]

khaan's behavior is startlingly similar to GF3 when he was Detective and dropping hints as to who (he thought) the mafia was. However, he knows how much of a failure that strategy was.

Need to look into boudica more before I make a decision.

[Askthepizzaguy]

khaan's behavior is startlingly similar to GF3 when he was Detective and dropping hints as to who (he thought) the mafia was. However, he knows how much of a failure that strategy was.

I am hesitant to vote for him again because of that. However, if we don't get a detective reveal or an explanation at some point, I absolutely will vote for him. There's only so much benefit of the doubt people can be allowed.