The fight for Inishmore [Concluded]

[Askthepizzaguy]

It was a good case. The writing style is nearly identical to yours, the tone is "upturned nose", the content, vocabulary, and literary references are those easily found by someone of your caliber.

The sad part is, I can actually pay you a compliment Reenk, and you still find ways to belittle my efforts. I consider that in-game, though, so I of course forgive you and shrug it off as best I can. But I see now how you were able to make it through Prometheus by yourself. You are indestructible.

[Reenk Roink]

You are merely repeating the points that have been refuted.

The tone is certainly not "upturned nose" rather it is taunting the Mafia to a greater degree (because it was me, usually I would not go as far as I did).

The writing style is nearly identical to MANY players, not just me. Every stylistic point you brought up is a characteristic of several players styles.

The entire point of content has been savaged earlier in my post about how any one familiar with the language could do the same.

Literary references is the worst point. I already said I don't like Shakespeare.

Vocabulatry? Already replied to in content.
Again, not a good case at all. You frankly did better in the GF3.

[Lord Winter]

Vote: YLC

Your last posts come off as too agressive.


@AtPG/Reenk

The only part that links the kill to Reenk is the clear Weenx imitation. That is all it is though an imitatioin. Look at the finer points it is missing the characteristic Wanax commentary that would Reenk put in on the Wenex kills. I'm not buying the match.

[ULC]

Vote: YLC

Your last posts come off as too agressive.

How about this as agressive - I AM ING DEAD! Pay attention to the game more!

[Lord Winter]

Sorry didn't look at the status list.

Unvote: YLC

[Andres]

Checked the thread, Sasaki started his case against LittleGrizzly before GH asked us to vote Ituralde.

Unvote : Sasaki

[LittleGrizzly]

and funnily enough that invalidates my reason not to vote for him...

Vote sasaki

[Andres]

I have a disagreement with your reasoning; in this game, the mafia families seem to be only killing once per night. A henchman dies, it is no big deal. If Sasaki and LittleGrizzly exposed themselves trying to save a henchman, it would make little sense. However, mafia games rarely make sense, so I suppose even though I disagree, anyone's opinion is valid here.


And White_Eyes, the writing style itself is completely different, as is the tone, in your examples.

This doesn't sound like the usual ATPG to me.

Also, basing votes on the write-ups is usually not a good idea. And you're a more than decent writer yourself, ATPG.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

You are merely repeating the points that have been refuted.

The tone is certainly not "upturned nose" rather it is taunting the Mafia to a greater degree (because it was me, usually I would not go as far as I did).

The writing style is nearly identical to MANY players, not just me. Every stylistic point you brought up is a characteristic of several players styles.

The entire point of content has been savaged earlier in my post about how any one familiar with the language could do the same.

Literary references is the worst point. I already said I don't like Shakespeare.

Vocabulatry? Already replied to in content.
Again, not a good case at all. You frankly did better in the GF3.

Oooo "savaged" nice. No "upturned nose" there.

You can say you don't like Shakespeare all you like; I believe you're pulling off a very ballsy tactic, which is again not uncommon for you. The point is that very few people here would bother trying to imitate you, and very few people could pull off such a stunning fake.

I'll even humor you. Which player's styles are you referring to? Give me names.

[Seamus Fermanagh]

Winter:

Lurk much?

Both you and Diana need to be more active at this point or you should be slain out of hand.

[Askthepizzaguy]

@Seamus-

She worked last night and she's working tonight. When she gets out of the shower, I'll prod her to contribute more here.

[Lord Winter]

Winter:

Lurk much?

Both you and Diana need to be more active at this point or you should be slain out of hand.

I know, I got behind in my reading here and I'm trying to catch up. To be honest I don't have a complete idea of what's going on.

[seireikhaan]

Vote: Diana Abnoba

Lurking is bad.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

Vote: Diana Abnoba

Lurking is bad.

[Reenk Roink]

[QUOTE=Askthepizzaguy;2189816]

Oooo "savaged" nice. No "upturned nose" there.

Um, Ok...

You can say you don't like Shakespeare all you like; I believe you're pulling off a very ballsy tactic, which is again not uncommon for you. The point is that very few people here would bother trying to imitate you, and very few people could pull off such a stunning fake.

I'll even humor you. Which player's styles are you referring to? Give me names.

TinCow, YLC, seireikhaan, General Hankerchief, Silver Rusher, Kommodus, Pannonian, Lord Winter, Caius, Jolt, boudica, Ichigo, Proletariat, Husar, Leet Erikson, disco, Ice, Crazed Rabbit, Xiahou, Seamus Fermanagh, pevergreen, Andres, Sasaki Kojiro, Yoyoma, CountArach, Askthepizzaguy, taka, Beefy.

Only really Aries and White eyes have distinct styles from what I see, and White eyes was EASILY able to mask his.

The fact is, the evidence you have given that this write up is mine is based off non write up posts from one game and a non Mafia game context.

One of your major points in analysis (the use of parentheses) was not even present.

[Diana Abnoba]

I am a nurse(pool and on call, at several hospitals) and I usually work 12 plus hours on the night shift. I can get called last minute to go into work, so I haven't been able to participate as much as I would like.

Vote: Yoyoma

I tend to believe that Yoyoma could be mafia, as pizza suggests. By the way, I appreciate the compliment but I can't type at all, haven't used a computer since 1995. If I sent such a kill, someone else would have wrote it. I was at work, I could not send the kill.

[FactionHeir]

ATPG could have written/sent it for you, seeing how you live together it seems.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

[QUOTE=Reenk Roink;2189949]

Um, Ok...



TinCow, YLC, seireikhaan, General Hankerchief, Silver Rusher, Kommodus, Pannonian, Lord Winter, Caius, Jolt, boudica, Ichigo, Proletariat, Husar, Leet Erikson, disco, Ice, Crazed Rabbit, Xiahou, Seamus Fermanagh, pevergreen, Andres, Sasaki Kojiro, Yoyoma, CountArach, Askthepizzaguy, taka, Beefy.

Only really Aries and White eyes have distinct styles from what I see, and White eyes was EASILY able to mask his.

The fact is, the evidence you have given that this write up is mine is based off non write up posts from one game and a non Mafia game context.

One of your major points in analysis (the use of parentheses) was not even present.

1. You've been playing head games all game, but not really going after suspects.
2. WIFOM, WIFOM, WIFOM all game.
3. The players you mention aren't in this game, and your case is exceedingly weak that some of those players could have or would have written it.
4. If you were a townie, you wouldn't be so single-mindedly focused on just a couple people, myself included.
5. Pick a stance; I am guilty or innocent. First you defend me, then you accuse me, then you seem to think I am innocent, then you OMGUS vote. Frankly, it's inconsistent play. I won't argue with you Reenk, because no one besides me will ever vote for you anyway.

Why not drop your vote against me, seeing as it is useless, and do something constructive or productive with it?

[Reenk Roink]

Seamus, Yoyoma, it seems that Yoyoma is about to get the axe. Let us have revenge on one of those who voted for him.

I will send you a kill shortly where The Wanax will appear and summon the 1975 Philadelphia Flyers to kill whoever. Bobby Clarke will start things off with a two handed chop to the ankle and then Bernie Parent will go between the legs with his goalie stick for a hard blow to the groin. Dave Schultz will finish the victim off with a hammer. Of course Bill Barber will be diving the entire time.

[Askthepizzaguy]

ATPG could have written/sent it for you, seeing how you live together it seems.

You're suggesting she is Oswald, the henchman? You believe the Godfather picked her AND ME as henchmen. So that if one of us dies and is guilty, the other is a suspect.

I've already accused you of being less than a townie, FactionHeir, and you seem to be going for the easy targets. I don't think you care if we lynch townies at all, so long as it's not you.

[Reenk Roink]

1. You've been playing head games all game, but not really going after suspects.
2. WIFOM, WIFOM, WIFOM all game.
3. The players you mention aren't in this game, and your case is exceedingly weak that some of those players could have or would have written it.
4. If you were a townie, you wouldn't be so single-mindedly focused on just a couple people, myself included.
5. Pick a stance; I am guilty or innocent. First you defend me, then you accuse me, then you seem to think I am innocent, then you OMGUS vote. Frankly, it's inconsistent play. I won't argue with you Reenk, because no one besides me will ever vote for you anyway.

Why not drop your vote against me, seeing as it is useless, and do something constructive or productive with it?

1) So?
2) WIFOM is a myth.
3) Most of the players mentioned are in the game, the case is 1000000x stronger than yours.
4) Says who? How can you define townie behavior?
5) I'm not going to be constricted by how you want the game to be played. People don't vote for me because there is no reason, this shtick is kinda getting annoying to be honest.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Sorry I annoyed you, Reenk.

But since I'm provoking an emotional response where there should be none, as a townie you should be laughing at my ineptitude, instead you're getting defensive again... I'll drop it. I think you're a henchman, and there will be no bandwagon on you, and so I am looking for your Godfather.

That's all. Pleasant day.

[Reenk Roink]

Sorry I annoyed you, Reenk.

But since I'm provoking an emotional response where there should be none, as a townie you should be laughing at my ineptitude, instead you're getting defensive again... I'll drop it. I think you're a henchman, and there will be no bandwagon on you, and so I am looking for your Godfather.

That's all. Pleasant day.

I don't mind the accusations of WIFOM, the writeup analysis, or being called a henchman, but it's really unfair to repeatedly say that "the other players don't vote for me" when it's false. Like it's my fault people aren't thinking I'm guilty or believing your case.

[Askthepizzaguy]

It's not, but I am allowed to point out that you do get away with things that others would not. That's not a criticism of you, it's a compliment, and a scolding of the town. Which, I feel is deserved, but I doubt that they would agree.

I'm still entitled to my opinion and I don't really feel like arguing with anyone anymore about it.

[FactionHeir]

You're suggesting she is Oswald, the henchman? You believe the Godfather picked her AND ME as henchmen. So that if one of us dies and is guilty, the other is a suspect.

I've already accused you of being less than a townie, FactionHeir, and you seem to be going for the easy targets. I don't think you care if we lynch townies at all, so long as it's not you.

What I am saying is that RL is not a good excuse. Ever.

[Askthepizzaguy]

LOL

Ah, but it's not a good excuse only in cases where it suits you, FactionHeir. Sigurd has gotten a total pass this game even though he's posting elsewhere. But let the WOGs commence on that. Looking at the lurker chart,

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Askthepizzaguy 211
Sasaki Kojiro 73
pevergreen 56
Greyblades 53
Beefy187 44
Reenk Roink 44
YLC 42
GeneralHankerchief 40
LittleGrizzly 38
A Very Super Market 37
White_eyes:D 34
Seamus Fermanagh 30
FactionHeir 26
777Ares777 24
Andres 23
F.C is the bees knees 23
Ituralde 18
taka 18
boudica 16
Yoyoma1910 16
El Diablo 13
Captain Blackadder 12
Diana Abnoba 12
Shinseikhaan 11
Lord Winter 8
gaelic cowboy 7
Jolt 7
shlin28 6
Alexander the Pretty Good 3
CountArach 3
Psychonaut 3
Polemists 2
Sigurd 2

I see Sigurd, I see Lord Winter, I see Shinseikhaan. One of them has given a real life excuse. Wait, Lord Winter said he's got a lot of catching up to do. So that's two. I haven't heard much from Diana, but I know why, even though I shouldn't know why, I do, and perhaps thats why we shouldn't play games together, and yoyoma is intentionally avoiding the game as well. Boudica's posts aren't up to snuff, she's gone after me on bogus reasoning and also now Diana for suspect reasoning. Andres has been out of town for a while, but he's also done not a whole lot due to what? Real life excuses.

The list goes on. Cheers though. That writeup did not come from me, and I know it didn't come from her. And contrary to Reenks increasingly suspect opinion, not everyone here is capable of writing that Oswald kill. The few people who would be crazy enough to try it include him, and some other brilliant players. But the tone... the boldness... the psychology behind it... sounds so much like Reenk that I will be embarrassed if I am wrong. And if I am wrong, that will narrow down who Oswald is even further.

[Reenk Roink]

It's not, but I am allowed to point out that you do get away with things that others would not. That's not a criticism of you, it's a compliment, and a scolding of the town. Which, I feel is deserved, but I doubt that they would agree.

I'm still entitled to my opinion and I don't really feel like arguing with anyone anymore about it.

*points to the many times Reenk has been so very close to being lynched in both games where you brought this "observation" up*

[Askthepizzaguy]

close to being lynched is not the same as being lynched. I was close to being lynched round one; didn't mean squat. I got away with calling for my own head. That's a fact. You escaped the lynch too; near the mark is still off the mark.

Listen Reenk, I like you and respect you, even when we disagree. Since town isn't going to lynch you this round, and I'm done arguing with you, can we drop it amicably?

[Sasaki Kojiro]

I don't get why grizz is getting a free pass here. Boudica either with her continued poor reasoning.

Yoyoma, I noted earlier, was suspicious of AVSM, who got killed by oswald. I dropped that because he followed up the next day bragging about how he'd known avsm was a bad guy, which seemed to bold for mafia. He's a better choice for reenk if you must lynch based on the writeup. But frankly the I don't see why it's been the focus of this round.

edit: Here's the case I made on Grizz yesterday.

[Seamus Fermanagh]

I'm after thinking that we need a duel function in this game too.....Reenk v Pizza at 10 paces. Do you choose crossbows shooting rubber chickens or slingshots and grapes?