The fight for Inishmore [Concluded]

[LittleGrizzly]

missing my death diana vote...

BTW next time im jumping straight on the pizza bandwagon... have made me look like complete scum!

[Askthepizzaguy]

I would hope that next time, I get a fresh start and am treated like every other player, as is my policy for all of you.

Don't carry grudges from one game to another, please.

[LittleGrizzly]

Ok i have a great way to prove my innocence and Sasaki's guilt at the same time!!

If diana is telling the truth about being the godfather then pizza will die because hes a henchman (con someone confirm this part for me ?) thus proving... combined with my innocent result that i am not the godfather or scum at all! at least not irish godfather anyway... which is the accusation sasaki has been throwing on me all game!

With me proven innocent we can lynch sasaki who has been off most of the game and is quite probably scum...

Unvote ATPG
Vote Sasaki

In the interests of disclosure ATPG pm'd this to me

Hey, please vote for Boudica. I die when Diana dies, trust me.


You get boudica, Diana, and you get me and Sasaki in one fell swoop. Throw me a bone, and you win.

Im unsure Boudica is mafia... im more sure on sasaki, aslong as ATPG is truthful about dieing when his gdfather dies, the plan seems fool proof... im sure some of the more scummier players may have issue with it*


*that is unless we cant confirm atpg dies, in which case my plan is flawed...

Edit: ATPG i was joking... i will be more hesitant to defend you in future though... due to you big shiny diamond ones...

[Askthepizzaguy]

Sasaki or boudica is fine.

Either way.



edit: I am a henchman... because most of the people in the game have been cleared of being henchman by investigation or murder attempts, all except me, Diana, Sasaki, and Lord Winter.

I claim Brendan, Diana claims Christy. Sasaki claims to be "innocent" and Lord Winter tried to suicide.

[LittleGrizzly]

Does that beyond all doubt (once your confirmed by write up) mean all IRA charaters are dead ?

And why the hell was Andres accussing me of being the godfather ?!

[El Diablo]

It did say in the rules at the start that henchmen die when the godfather is killed.

also

Diana - death

Not sure if mine was counted.

[LittleGrizzly]

It did say in the rules at the start that henchmen die when the godfather is killed.

There you go people a clear way to prove im not the irish godfather without killing me... what excuse is there not to take it ?

Apart of course from being english mafia and wanting the town to waste a lynch on an innocent!

[Reenk Roink]

We need to tread very carefully to pull this off. Of course, there is plenty of good info in Atpg's posts, but reflecting on it, I believe he has twisted, added, or omitted some info to give his team a shot.

Tie up on Sasaki and boudica, hopefully they both are lynched. Obv Diana needs to go. Now what to do about Atpg? And what of LG and GH?

God this is a tricky situation...

I certainly hope that Atpg is right about Sasaki, but in case he isn't, we are pretty much boned.

edit: Atpg, why not vote Sasaki and make it a 4 way tie?

edit, edit: Read Diana's post, sorry if I misunderstood your situation Atpg. I still don't understand the gloating, but I don't think you were throwing away the game. Just the last page was REALLY confusing and tough to swallow for a bit.

[LittleGrizzly]

Now what to do about Atpg?

The way i see it... if ATPG survives because diana is not godfather we wont let him survive another round anyway... it is hard to see how they could sacrifice two players and win... is Andres confirmed IRA ?

If andres is confirmed IRA then there can only be two IRA left and i don't see why a non ira would confess to being one... thus atpg and diana must be the remaing IRA (assuming they can't recruit) so i dont see why they would reveal and lie about diana being the godfathermother

Im wary of GH but i find him very hard to read... doesn't seem to give off much signals...

[boudica]

At this point I wish I'd served town better. Meh - and again I say Meh! Meh! I say!. Despite my poor and somewhat confused/confusing play - You all deserve whatever's coming to you. Unvote: ATPG vote: Sasaki You know I would have drunken myself to death in an earlier round if I'd been allowed.

[seireikhaan]

However, due to the inspiration this game comes from, as well as the epic games of Silver Rusher and Seamus, this game also uses the Godfather mechanic. If the "Godfather" is lynched or killed that "mafia family" will cease to exist, the remaining players, if any, attempt to flee the island and drown.

Looks like there's going to be some soggy pizza.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Guys.


I want the confusion of the past pages to disappear. I am exposed, admitted scum. Listen to me objectively for one moment.



1. I admitted my guilt. Only a mafia would do that.
2. Diana admitted hers. We are Irish mafia. Period.
3. That means ONLY Sasaki or Lord Winter are Oswald, assuming you weren't lying to us, town, about your investigations.
4. Look at Sasaki's behavior all game, and his lack of defense that he's Oswald. He just wants us to die.
5. Boudica is not herself, and boudica lurks and plays innocent all game, and then at the end all of a sudden knows who to vote for. It was all an act.
6. Diana dies, I die. Or you lynch me as the "Godfather" next round, which I am so NOT.
7. Kill Sasaki.
8. Kill Sasaki.
9. Kill Sasaki.
10. LG can die next round if I am lying about who I am or who Diana is. We aren't.
11. Sasaki's death will prove that he is Oswald, or Lord Winter is.
12. Boudica can be easily lynched at any time, too. You outnumber them.



I gave you everything you need to solve the case. Throw me one bone and lynch Sasaki or boudica this round. I offer mine and Diana's vote on anyone in the game; you pick. But I choose Sasaki or Boudica. Lynch Boudica. Or Lynch Sasaki.



Now, think about it, I am scum yes, but myself and Diana admitted it, and Andres was our third. LittleGrizzly is NOT Irish mafia. LG could only be English mafia, and Sasaki or Boudica's death should prove which.

[El Diablo]

The only thing that I can think that ATPG maybe trying to do is that HE is the godfather and Diana is the henchwoman.

Either way he dies next after the lynch right?

As for tieing things up our host may not want to lynch either of them and then we may run out of time.

As I see it now...

Boudica: 4 (Shinseikhaan, Askthepizzaguy, Diana Abnoba, El Diablo)
LittleGrizzly: 2 (GH, Sasaki)
Sasaki: 2 (LG, boudica)

Life: 1 (Pizza)
Death: 6 (Shinseikhaan, Sasaki, GH, boudica, LG, El Diablo)

I belive that Diana and ATPG are the remains of the IRA. They will hopefully be destroyed with the death of Diana.

The remaining votes are for Sasaki, LG and Boudica.
The IRA are after Boudica, with Shinseikhaan.
Sasaki and LG are claiming that the other is the godfather.
Boudica has the sole vote on ATPG.

Are we assuming that the English mafia have two henchmen and the gf left?
Could this be Boudica, GF with LG and Sasaki as henchmen?
Thus I say we take out Diana - hopefully killing the IRA off - if not then ATPG will have to kill the english to even hope to win. the ones wanting the English mafia the most would the IRA and so...

Unvote Sasaki vote Boudica

[Diana Abnoba]

Guys, I understand why you don't trust pizza, but I have never lied to you. I am Godfather and when I die so does pizza. So kill me and take out Sasaki or boudica all in this round. I am almost certain that Sasaki is mafia but not sure he is Godfather. Boudica was investigated, so this means she could be Godfather or town. I don't think LG is mafia or GH is either, but could be wrong. I will change my vote to anyone you pick, or we can make another tie(just make sure that it is one of us (me or pizza) that makes the last vote). You don't need another death vote tomorrow.

[El Diablo]

ATPG why are you voting on boudica rather than sasaki then?

[boudica]

Guys, I understand why you don't trust pizza, but I have never lied to you. I am Godfather and when I die so does pizza. So kill me and take out Sasaki or boudica all in this round. I am almost certain that Sasaki is mafia but not sure he is Godfather. Boudica was investigated, so this means she could be Godfather or town. I don't think LG is mafia or GH is either, but could be wrong. I will change my vote to anyone you pick, or we can make another tie(just make sure that it is one of us (me or pizza) that makes the last vote). You don't need another death vote tomorrow.

Hey Diana - you're not too sure about too much there are ya? believe me I know how you feel - this game is nasty

[Askthepizzaguy]

Tally.... according to mine and El Diablo's:

Boudica: 4 (Shinseikhaan, Askthepizzaguy, Diana Abnoba, El Diablo)
LittleGrizzly: 2 (GH, Sasaki)
ATPG: 1 (boudica)
Sasaki: 1 (LG)

Life: 1 (Pizza)
Death: 6 (Shinseikhaan, Sasaki, GH, boudica, LG, El Diablo)

@El Diablo

I believe that Oswald is the henchman, Sasaki.

I'll vote Sasaki and Diana will as well, just say the word. Throw me a bone and trust me on Sasaki being henchman... FIND THE GODFATHER. Boudica is my top pick, LittleGrizzly maybe next, but doubtful.

[LittleGrizzly]

I would just like to remind everyone i also have a innocent result on me and thus can only be the godfather if i am scum

EL Diablo this blows your me boudica and sasaki theory out the water... but trust me i wouldn't campign so damn hard for my henchmans lynching... i could have easily given up a few rounds ago and have solid proof that i went for sasaki consistently... why would i keep trying so hard round after round ?

Boudica could be Sasaki's godfather... perhaps with GH ?

Im worried about tieing sasaki with boudica... perhaps we should have sasaki in the lead to ensure his buddies cant save him ?

[boudica]

Tally.... according to mine and El Diablo's:






@El Diablo

I believe that Oswald is the henchman, Sasaki.

I'll vote Sasaki and Diana will as well, just say the word. Throw me a bone and trust me on Sasaki being henchman... FIND THE GODFATHER. Boudica is my top pick, LittleGrizzly maybe next, but doubtful.

your tallys is incorrect - I voted Sasaki. Pevergreen - you've got your work cut out with this one

[Askthepizzaguy]

Diana Abnoba: Irish Godfather/Christy
Andres: Joey (Henchman)
Askthepizzaguy: Brendan (Henchman)

Seamus: Donney (Investigator)
FactionHeir: Davey (Roleblocker?)
Reenk Roink: Mairead (Defender)

Shinseikhaan: Heilyn (Neutral)
A Very Super Market: Padraic (Serial Killer)

Boudica: Suspected English Godfather/Unknown name
Ituralde: Mike Fingers (Henchman)
Sasaki Kojiro or Lord Winter: Oswald (Henchman)

For reference. Sasaki is 90% certain, Boudica is a judgment call. She's not townie boudica, IMO.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

your tallys is incorrect - I voted Sasaki. Pevergreen - you've got your work cut out with this one

Boudica: 4 (Shinseikhaan, Askthepizzaguy, Diana Abnoba, El Diablo)
LittleGrizzly: 2 (GH, Sasaki)
Sasaki: 2 (LG, Boudica)

Life: 1 (Pizza)
Death: 6 (Shinseikhaan, Sasaki, GH, boudica, LG, El Diablo)

If people besides me would do tallies, (thanks El Diablo and Seamus, for example) then we wouldn't have this problem. But I thank you for re-checking my tally as I asked. Maybe that was the reason I murdered everyone.... do some more tallies, people.

[boudica]

For reference. Sasaki is 90% certain, Boudica is a judgment call. She's not townie boudica, IMO.

How long must I listen to the deluded rantings of a mafia ? Get those bits of cashew and milk from out your teeth and take a chance on the bet that you're wrong.

[Yoyoma1910]

your tallys is incorrect - I voted Sasaki. Pevergreen - you've got your work cut out with this one

Mon dieu seigneur! Boudica, what has happened to your perfectly-super-fantastic grammar!

[El Diablo]

LG - lets use the IRA to our advantage then their votes wont change and the English wont have enough numbers to dump on another victum.
Vote Boudica and if she is only a henchwoman we will look futher.
Sakasi or LW next round?

[boudica]

Mon dieu seigneur! Boudica, what has happened to your perfectly-super-fantastic grammar!

I is drunked

[Askthepizzaguy]

Boudica CANNOT be a henchwoman, she was investigated.

[boudica]

Boudica CANNOT be a henchwoman, she was investigated.

I'm town you admitted mafia fool. Please just someone lynch me while I sleep. You won't have to hear from me (in this thread :P)again.

[LittleGrizzly]

Boudica cannot be henchwoman she has innocent result.. shes godmother or innocent...

I have 2 problems with tieing it up

1) sasaki's buddy(ies) could come on and change the tie...
2) we cannot now what happens in a tie... if pever decides to release them all the english mafia get a night to kill without a lynch possibly happening to them... if he is doing it in turns then it is the no lynch turn this time... (unless theres a third option like random choice)

Also im not entirely convinced on Boudica... alot of here reasoning made sense to me and even some of it was understandable... i too was distracted by another game until i died in that game and wasn't paying a great deal of attention to this game...

though of course it could be lies i don't personally suspect her...

Edit: i would like to point out that despite going tor boudica meaning im further away from the lynch i would rather risk myself and vote for who i think is most likely mafia...

[Diana Abnoba]

I is drunked

I think I will join you for a drink myself, after all this.

[Askthepizzaguy]

How sweet it would be for town if 4 mafioso died tonight... and if you only get 3.... just one left to catch! The IRA are your humble servants. When we signed up for this job, we knew it could end in our deaths. Our two votes are your two votes, and rest assured.... we will get them scumbags.




And English guys: One last round before we all die?

We have the voting power, right here right now, to stop Diana's death, and yours. But you never reached out to us... and that is why you must die. If we go down, you come with us. That is the way of evil criminals. We betray one another... and that is why the civilized world will go on.