Swords in the Moon [Concluded]

[TinCow]

It appears we missed the mark again.

I wouldn't count on a smoking gun in the lynch write-up even if we were accurate. Andres' hints are very, very subtle, and are often difficult to detect except in hindsight. For PP's lynch, the thing that stands out is the "mat." Does anyone with greater knowledge into the time period know whether the ninja had some time of special (training?) connection to sitting on a mat for extended periods? More so than samurai?

[Gregoshi]

TinCow, the thoughts of the condemed are extremely serene for a killer. The thoughts of "love and tears", the mat, comfort, the "nice and friendly" vendor and the repeated emphasis on "clean" stand out to me.

However, just to drive myself crazy, perhaps you are right. Perhaps it is a bit too serene. Take Sasaki's post about Privateerkev in the Trapped in Taormina game:

Night 3:
Privateerkev wasn't in his room when you investigated it. You found his belongings. Nothing out of the ordinary. Privateerkev seems to be a boring townie.

And Privateerkev was mafia.

I don't see how you guys play this all the time and maintain your sanity.

[FactionHeir]

I'm trying to figure out if the bird thing might be any hint.
Problem is, not every day has a bird appearing during lynch time (the hour of which also differs).

The only time the bird was very different was when QJC was lynched - a crow. So maybe its only 1 confirmed guilty lynched.

[Reenk Roink]

Amazing how fast someone can be condemned in this game!

[Husar]

Amazing how fast someone can be condemned in this game!

So do you have a detailed analysis on all 65 or so people or should we just wait another 5 rounds and see if anything substantial comes up?
I mean yes, in some cases it all feels rushed etc. but when discussion levels are low, experienced players quiet, others lie etc. that's sometimes the only hints you have...

[Andres]

40 minutes until deadline.

[Yoyoma1910]

My theory on the nature of last nights write up:

Hour of Boar:
Ninja Master

Hour of Rat:
Ninja (With log from fire. Did someone loose their weapon at some point?)

Hour of Rat:
Ninja

Hour of Tiger:
Special Ninja Event



Currently I believe we have two ninja and their master.


We had two Wannabes die in one evening early on. As previously stated, I believe one of them was likely one of the traitors. After that, I'm not sure.

[seireikhaan]

I don't see how you guys play this all the time and maintain your sanity.

Maintain our what?

[Crazed Rabbit]

I don't see how you guys play this all the time and maintain your sanity.

Well it's actually quite easy when you've got the bears in your attic doing the soundtrack for your homework.

CR

[glyphz]

I wouldn't count on a smoking gun in the lynch write-up even if we were accurate. Andres' hints are very, very subtle, and are often difficult to detect except in hindsight. For PP's lynch, the thing that stands out is the "mat." Does anyone with greater knowledge into the time period know whether the ninja had some time of special (training?) connection to sitting on a mat for extended periods? More so than samurai?

The mat?
My first impression of the lynch write-up, including that of the mat, was that of someone who was very much inactive during the course of the game ...which would fit PeasantPhil's activity this game (5 posts by the end of Day 7, not including sign-up post), and the reason behind his lynch.



:edit: Time spent on the mat, compare it to say time spent on duty, contributing to the discussion (w/ Andres making use of a person's behavior to make the write-ups unique).

[Gregoshi]

The mat?
My first impression of the lynch write-up, including that of the mat, is that of someone who was very much inactive during the course of the game ...which would fit PeasantPhil's activity this game (5 posts by the end of Day 7, not including sign-up post), and the reason behind his lynch.

Good observation glyphz.

[TinCow]

The mat?
My first impression of the lynch write-up, including that of the mat, was that of someone who was very much inactive during the course of the game ...which would fit PeasantPhil's activity this game (5 posts by the end of Day 7, not including sign-up post), and the reason behind his lynch.



:edit: Time spent on the mat, compare it to say time spent on duty, contributing to the discussion (w/ Andres making use of a person's behavior to make the write-ups unique).

This makes a lot of sense and I am inclined to agree with it.

Turn the pressure back up on Seamus.

[CountArach]

I have had six shocking days straight... couldn't have been at a worse time... SORRY EVERYONE.

First off, I can confirm two things:
1) Everyone has sent me their duel ratings.
2) Sasaki is indeed telling the truth. I am merely his Kagemusha who takes his place in public.

Ummm... I don't think there's much more I really need to say at this point, except to apologise again to everyone and to say that I will answer any questions asked of me.

[Yaropolk]

1) Everyone has sent me their duel ratings.

Rhyfelwyr - sorry I've been trying to lynch you for 3 days due to not sending in rating, nothing personal.

[FactionHeir]

If you are his Kgemusha, who is Kagemusha then?
(oh yes, using this smiley guarantees a GH vote )

In any case, I am rather confused why you would admit to this publically, thus helping the mafia?

[Haudegen]

If you are his Kgemusha, who is Kagemusha then?
(oh yes, using this smiley guarantees a GH vote )

In any case, I am rather confused why you would admit to this publically, thus helping the mafia?

That´s what I was thinking. But on the positive side: the mafia probably finds this very confusing too.

[Gregoshi]

In any case, I am rather confused why you would admit to this publically, thus helping the mafia?

Like you and Haudegen, that was my first reaction, but getting into the mindset of this game, is that so? Or have things got more confusing for the ninja? With one swordmaster left, "Shingen"'s life was on the line. The Kagemusha Gambit opened up the possibilities that Shingen could be any of the townies. I say "any of the townies" because offering up a sacrifice (in this case Sasaki) seems to be a common tactic in these games. Am I thinking right or am I off the mark?

The lack of being able to obtain any physical evidence is maddening about this game - even then you can't trust the gatherer. I feel my soul corrupting day by day.

[Yaropolk]

Rhyfelwyr - sorry I've been trying to lynch you for 3 days due to not sending in rating, nothing personal.

In light of the fact that CA was likely not a pro town role, my FOS Rhyfelwyr still stands. He was the only one who was saved from a duel by a night killing.

[woad&fangs]

vote: Rhyfelwyr
challenge Rhyfelwyr

I think factionheir is another good one to go after today.

[shlin28]

I suppose it would be the ultimate twist if the guy we were suppose to protect is in fact the bad guy... seems like the trend in the Gameroom nowadays.

Perhaps that's why he got me lynched for my high duel score?

I'm not too sure on the FH thing, he normally is pretty neutral too. Analytical but not so accusative is how I would describe his playstyle.

Quintus' behaviour is off a bit though - too few posts in comparison with other games, I suppose it could be because of exams, but you never know...

I will post more of my thoughts tomorrow.

PS: Just caught up on the thread

[Peasant Phill]

I wouldn't count on a smoking gun in the lynch write-up even if we were accurate. Andres' hints are very, very subtle, and are often difficult to detect except in hindsight. For PP's lynch, the thing that stands out is the "mat." Does anyone with greater knowledge into the time period know whether the ninja had some time of special (training?) connection to sitting on a mat for extended periods? More so than samurai?

He opened his white kimono. It was also clean. For this occasion, this moment of a noble death, the clean white, cushions, sheets, kimono, snow, were fitting.

I think this says it all. Subtle but persisting hints.

Probably good catch on the use of the mat in the write-up. Laying low is a tactic of mine.

[Gregoshi]

Laying low is a tactic of mine.

Is six feet under low enough? I should talk - I'm a rottin' geisha.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

Is six feet under low enough?

Burn!!

[glyphz]

LOL

(though my current position, in game, isn't any better either. Can't keep my head on, while trying to come to my comrade's aid. How lame...)

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Your continued presence, 'postmortem,' is much appreciated, Gregoshi.
Here's hoping to see you in future mafia games.