Asterix and the Gauls [Concluded]

[Yaropolk]

FOS: Yaropolk Its curious you say on Night 1 that since I was willing to help (I could have said I was already working with someone else, no?), I was trustworthy and you wouldn't vote for me and now on Day 2, you are already voting for me with a bandwagon formed, despite having clearly explained everything. Ok, that makes sense.

You are absolutely right - I pmed some people on N1 to see who would be willing to investigate with me. This was done to get a response out of people to see who is not commited to some other dastardly night action. Jolt was one of the people who replied that he's willing to work with me, and I put him in my townie column. I did not check my notes before voting, I withdraw my lynch vote. I have no other suspects at this time.

unvote: Jolt
vote: abstain

edit: stupid spoil tags look just like bold, had to edit them out

[Jolt]

It is my time to ask questions. In this Phrase

Jolt was sitting down to a private supper. The day had progressed well, apart from angry interjections from hardliners. But all in all, it looked promising that an agreement could be reached.

Just as he was finishing his meal, two guards approached him. “Sir, there’s some men outside who wish to speak to you.”

Jolt sighed as he told them to tell the men to come back to him in the morning. He was tired, and the last thing he wanted to do was entertain visitors.

A few minutes later, a large disturbance was heard coming from outside. Rushing to his feet, Jolt saw his two guards fighting furiously against a couple of men, armed with clubs. Drawing his weapon, he quickly went to their aid and the assailants were driven off.

I wonder how the voters on me can explain this:

Jolt was sitting down to a private supper. The day had progressed well, apart from angry interjections from hardliners. But all in all, it looked promising that an agreement could be reached.

And I ask especially to taka, who has been so proeminent in going from two guards into a Mafia conspiracy where I'm automatically protected.

Let me give my voters a hint: Mafia famillies don't want an agreement.

[Askthepizzaguy]

I would again call for people to leave Jolt alone this round. Thank you.

[Jolt]

Good. Now the number of prospective Mafia taking advantage of the bandwagon is reduced. I'm still waiting for some answers of the people who thought it was nice to vote for me.

[atheotes]

well... Jolt seems to be a power role. whether mafia or pro-town we are not sure. since the game is based on rubicon and that had pro-town roles with protection abilities i am not convinced he is mafia...Not sure what he can do to get out this.

Vote: Abstain for now.

[Marshal Murat]

Unvote:Beefy
Vote:Abstain

I'm having chicken tonight. Meh.

What I want to know is how trustworthy Yarolpolks list is. I was honestly suspicious of any gladhanding by anyone (it's a mafia game right?). Is it a list of people who responded "yeah I'll help" and then were put into groups or just people who responded "yeah I'll help"?

[Jolt]

Obviously, since I am quite proven to be innocent, the orators of this game can save me by Vote Switching to navarro (Who apparently hasn't made a post yet.)

[Quintus.JC]

Unvote: Beefy
Vote: Navarro

[Jolt]

Or that. Thank you Quintus.

Unvote: johnhughthom Vote: navarro

[johnhughthom]

Unvote: Jolt Vote:Navarro

Read through again and it's not as clear as I had thought.

[Iskander 3.1]

This is giving me a headache. I don't think that Jolt's the one to blame though. What's the argument on Navarro?

[A Very Super Market]

He's lurking really badly. That's about it.

[Yaropolk]

Premeditated lurking in the 1st degree

[Iskander 3.1]

Ah. He did that in Rubicon and turned out to be mafia there, too.
Vote: Navarro

[atheotes]

he has posted elsewhere this afternoon...
unvote; Vote: Navarro

[A Very Super Market]

Right boys, he deserves to be insulted.

Vote: Navarro

[Quintus.JC]

There really isn't much of a case against Navarro, lurkers poses little problem during the early stages but could become quite problematic as the game goes on, best to elimate them early. Personally I don't think Navarro is scum, but I think Jolt deserves to live at least another round.

[seireikhaan]

Vote: Quintus

Very neutral statement.

[Beefy187]

Unvote:Beefy
Vote:Abstain

I'm having chicken tonight. Meh.

What I want to know is how trustworthy Yarolpolks list is. I was honestly suspicious of any gladhanding by anyone (it's a mafia game right?). Is it a list of people who responded "yeah I'll help" and then were put into groups or just people who responded "yeah I'll help"?

I am going to defend that chicken!

Vote: Marshal Murat

As for Cronos... Your going to have fun tonight

[Tratorix]

Unvote:Jolt He makes some good points, and some bad points, but I'll back off for now.

There really isn't much of a case against Navarro, lurkers poses little problem during the early stages but could become quite problematic as the game goes on, best to elimate them early. Personally I don't think Navarro is scum, but I think Jolt deserves to live at least another round.

See, this is my style of mafia playing! Don't let anyone knock you off that fence, JC! Can't look suspicious if you don't give an opinion.

Unvote: Jolt Vote:Navarro

Read through again and it's not as clear as I had thought.

You just made a flying leap from one bandwagon to another. I'm impressed. Vote: Johnhugthom

[Cultured Drizzt fan]

God people, this is really all over the place. Alright, I have finals so I really don't have time for this, suffice to say I don't believe any of the cases you guys have are even half way convincing. My vote stays.
dont take this as critical, I just really hate first round lynches.

[LittleGrizzly]

Errm, im voting abstain...

Edit: Vote Abstain

Don't think Jolt should be lynched...

[Chaotix]

Looking more closely at the write-up, it would seem there are some parts which would make Jolt look innocent. However, he is in no way "proved" innocent, so we shouldn't take it that way.

I still think it's particularly scummy that he first made a WIFOM claim to be mafia, and is now claiming that he is a proven innocent because of a few words in the write-up and the fact that he had guards. That said, I suppose he deserves another chance, if he'll stop acting so scummy.

Unvote: Jolt

That said, there is no case against navarro. Remember, this is still the very first voting round. Technically, he can't be lurking yet, because there hasn't been a full day for him to lurk through yet. And, if I recall correctly from the few games he's played in the past, it seems to be his general style of play anyway.

Right now, I'm going to vote: AVSM because he's being unusually useless, while trying to seem helpful.

[Jolt]

I still think it's particularly scummy that he first made a WIFOM claim to be mafia, and is now claiming that he is a proven innocent because of a few words in the write-up and the fact that he had guards.

Yeah, I'm innocent. In fact, I'm one of the orators.

[Greyblades]

Ugh I never knew coming up with role PM's was so time consuming.
Vote: Abstain
Just checking in just so noone thinks I dont care about this game.

[Death is yonder]

Jolt's story looks like it checks out pretty well, but I'm wondering at the coincidence.

If the game is going to be quite similar to Rubicon, it would mean that the mafia can protect their "godfather" so to speak. And there are precisely 2 henchmen, maybe it just fits too nicely...

Quite suspicious about Marshal Murat's and Johnhughtom's reasons for jumping on the bandwagon, multiple bandwagon's in fact.

[johnhughthom]

I jumped on one bandwagon actually, I read the write up, then Jolt's reply and thought he was suspicous so voted for him. Then I read Jolt's argument, reread the write up and thought I might be wrong. Then I jumped on a bandwagon.

[Beefy187]

Jolt's story looks like it checks out pretty well, but I'm wondering at the coincidence.

If the game is going to be quite similar to Rubicon, it would mean that the mafia can protect their "godfather" so to speak. And there are precisely 2 henchmen, maybe it just fits too nicely...

Quite suspicious about Marshal Murat's and Johnhughtom's reasons for jumping on the bandwagon, multiple bandwagon's in fact.

Unvote, Vote: Death is Yonder

For making that horrible face!
You Gauls are already ugly and smelly enough.
Smile for once! It makes you so much more cheerful and beutiful

[Chaotix]

Yeah, I'm innocent. In fact, I'm one of the orators.

Prove it.

[Death is yonder]

Jolt was sitting down to a private supper. The day had progressed well, apart from angry interjections from hardliners. But all in all, it looked promising that an agreement could be reached.

Just as he was finishing his meal, two guards approached him. “Sir, there’s some men outside who wish to speak to you.”

Jolt sighed as he told them to tell the men to come back to him in the morning. He was tired, and the last thing he wanted to do was entertain visitors.

A few minutes later, a large disturbance was heard coming from outside. Rushing to his feet, Jolt saw his two guards fighting furiously against a couple of men, armed with clubs. Drawing his weapon, he quickly went to their aid and the assailants were driven off.

You see Chaotix, the following are evidence that Jolt is... well, innocent? (Highly Likely)

If the day had progressed well, as an agreement looked like it was about to be made, would it not be possible to infer that Jolt is on the non mafia side, as the mafia don't want an agreement.

Just giving some thoughts, I would put him off my suspicious list, at least for now.

@Beefy:

Vote:Marshal Murat

After some re-reading and deliberation I think your voting is very odd. You vote beefy on the pretext that you are eating beef for your next meal. Following that, you change your vote off him saying you are eating chicken...