Pirate Ship Mafia [Concluded]

[scotchedpommes]

Seems to me like Grizz was attacked by the Brits or the Maven crew as well as a vig group. The solo protector could block one, but not both, so Grizz was killed. Doesn't seem to me that Grizz had any ability to protect himself.

Could easily have been another body from the same group, I'd have thought. Grizz and his mate wouldn't have had much of a chance against those numbers, would they? Course, Sasaki could let us know how many he took with him to get the job done, for the sake of clarity.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

Could easily have been another body from the same group, I'd have thought. Grizz and his mate wouldn't have had much of a chance against those numbers, would they? Course, Sasaki could let us know how many he took with him to get the job done, for the sake of clarity.

There were 5 of us.

It's possible the doctor tried to protect grizz on CR's orders and failed. That might explain CR's odd request that we pursue the vigilantes rather than the mafia.

[Louis VI the Fat]

I would like to know what Yaropolk and Diana were up to last night.

[woad&fangs]

Just remembering rule #1 Sasaki.
Sqwuak!

[Reenk Roink]

Vote: abstain, courteously

[Louis VI the Fat]

Vote: abstain, courteously

That be a limey if ever I seen one!

[Crazed Rabbit]

There were 5 of us.

It's possible the doctor tried to protect grizz on CR's orders and failed. That might explain CR's odd request that we pursue the vigilantes rather than the mafia.

The vigilantes are the only ones who have killed anyone so far, Sasaki. A mafioso could be in your group. Killing LG and getting gold for themselves would have furthered their goals.

Vote: abstain, courteously

New Yoooooooorrrk!

(if this doesn't make sense, watch the movie 1776 (made in 1972))

CR

[Askthepizzaguy]

I would like to know what Yaropolk and Diana were up to last night.

Yarrrrr, I'd be askin' the Captain, our Captain
If ye be curious as to what be happenin'
Regarding old Itchy Lou and Smilin' Sam
We had ourselves a group and went with the plan.
The Cap'n was informed and knows of our group.
And if'n ye be needing me, I'll be swabbin' the poop...
Deck that is. Back of the ship. High as can be.
Well the first thing you know Lou's got gold to spare
Kinfolk said to Lou "scrub your derriere"
Said the Presence is the place you ought to be
So they loaded up the ship and pirated the sea...

Yo ho ho! I be votin' fer the next man what don't talk like a Pirate!

[pevergreen]

The vigilantes are the only ones who have killed anyone so far, Sasaki. A mafioso could be in your group. Killing LG and getting gold for themselves would have furthered their goals. CR

Look at pever the green's vote.

[woad&fangs]

vote: Yaropolk
http://smileys.sur-la-toile.com/repo...x/perruche.gif

[Crazed Rabbit]

The pizzaman be talkin' true. Both of those be sworn for by others that they be involved in groups.

CR

[Askthepizzaguy]

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Yarrr... put [IMG] tags around that and it should work.

[A1_Unit]

Vote: abstain I don't know who is who and I don't want to lynch any innocents yet. :P

[woad&fangs]

Yarr, I wish I could edit posts with votes in them.

[GeneralHankerchief]

Yarr, I wish I could edit posts with votes in them.

You're good, woad. I know what it is.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Vote: A1_Unit

You don't sound like a pirate, mate. And I'm not even referrin' to yer woeful lack of sailor talk. I can't account fer what ye be up to last night, and the way ye be playin' the game smells of havin' a yeller streak runnin' down yer back. What are you hidin', you landlubber? Afear'd to lynch the innocent, yes, that's what all good turncoats say. I don't buy the nice guy routine. We're CUTTHROAT, BLOODTHIRSTY PIRATES, LADDIE!!! Were it up to me, yarrr would already be walkin' the plank.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

The vigilantes are the only ones who have killed anyone so far, Sasaki. A mafioso could be in your group. Killing LG and getting gold for themselves would have furthered their goals.

Yah, this is like what disgruntled goat says but your conclusion still doesn't make sense. The mafia could be in the vig group, but there is no reason to assume they were. Not vigging LG so that he'd get lynched this round instead of them and killing someone else at night would have suited the mafia's goals just fine.

************

I suggest you be voting for w&f, cap'n.

and if ya'll think that tone is overly mutinous, ye should watch more pirate movies

[Sasaki Kojiro]

The pizzaman be talkin' true. Both of those be sworn for by others that they be involved in groups.

CR

Inconsequential. No way to confirm their participation. Participation in a prot group should not be used as evidence in anyone's favor.

Vote: A1_Unit

You don't sound like a pirate, mate. And I'm not even referrin' to yer woeful lack of sailor talk. I can't account fer what ye be up to last night, and the way ye be playin' the game smells of havin' a yeller streak runnin' down yer back. What are you hidin', you landlubber? Afear'd to lynch the innocent, yes, that's what all good turncoats say. I don't buy the nice guy routine. We're CUTTHROAT, BLOODTHIRSTY PIRATES, LADDIE!!! Were it up to me, yarrr would already be walkin' the plank.

Why act like your just roleplaying a pirate in the thread, when at night you're organizing groups? That's disingenuous.

[A Very Super Market]

Arrr, pirates arrrrren't allowed to get drunk and make decisions they be regrettin' in the morning?

[Askthepizzaguy]

Inconsequential. No way to confirm their participation. Participation in a prot group should not be used as evidence in anyone's favor.

Why act like your just roleplaying a pirate in the thread, when at night you're organizing groups? That's disingenuous.

Are you callin' me a liar, you yellow-bellied, mutinous sea dog? Ye be lucky the Cap'n finds you amusing enough to keep around, mate. Yarrr... I might be a black-hearted, murderous pirate, a thief and a killer, but thar be one thing I don't do, and that's lie to me cap'n.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

Are you callin' me a liar, you yellow-bellied, mutinous sea dog? Ye be lucky the Cap'n finds you amusing enough to keep around, mate. Yarrr... I might be a black-hearted, murderous pirate, a thief and a killer, but thar be one thing I don't do, and that's lie to me cap'n.

If you were a real pirate you'd know that pirate captains aren't put on a pedestal. They're like an nfl quarterback. One of the guys, nominal leader, they play well then great, but if they throw 5 interceptions then you toss him out unless you're the panthers.

And yes, there's a mismatch between taking serious night actions and just playing in the thread. Disingenuous.

[Lord Winter]

Why would Woad make such an obvious connection to a suspicious person if he was scum?

[Askthepizzaguy]

If you were a real pirate you'd know that pirate captains aren't put on a pedestal. They're like an nfl quarterback. One of the guys, nominal leader, they play well then great, but if they throw 5 interceptions then you toss him out unless you're the panthers.

And yes, there's a mismatch between taking serious night actions and just playing in the thread. Disingenuous.

Yarrr will be forgivin' me if I don't sit around on a barrel of ale with a thumb in me buttocks while good men I be workin' with fer years die at the hands of traitors, laddie. But there's no law that says I can't have fun while I'm doing it. Not that I'd listen to such a law anyway. Being a pirate is more than just plunder, it's also enjoying the act of plunderin'.

[miotas]

Arrr. This sasaki be talkin to much, an afer all that rum las' night I be gettin a 'eadache.

Vote: Sasaki Kojiro
To shut the blighter up.

Now... a bit of the hair o' dog to clear up this 'ere 'eadache...

[Sasaki Kojiro]

Why would Woad make such an obvious connection to a suspicious person if he was scum?

He sent that before LG came under big suspicion. And I'm hoping LG was the british special officer, but then again I'm an optimist

[Crazed Rabbit]

Yah, this is like what disgruntled goat says but your conclusion still doesn't make sense. The mafia could be in the vig group, but there is no reason to assume they were. Not vigging LG so that he'd get lynched this round instead of them and killing someone else at night would have suited the mafia's goals just fine.

And how did those who be in ye group contact ye? Did they come forward after ye asked for men to help ye kill LG? Or did ye go to them?

Inconsequential. No way to confirm their participation. Participation in a prot group should not be used as evidence in anyone's favor.

A wise captain I be, and takin' into account all factors when deciding whom to trust and whom not to trust.

CR

[Tratorix]

The mafia didn't kill, true, but there were 2 of what seem to be mafia attempts: solo attacks. Doubtless there are more than 2 mafia in this game, but I'm fairly certain woad wasn't attacking anyone.

To be fair, my result PM doesn't mention anything about the members of the protection group, only that CB survived and I got 100 gold.

Whether or not he is guilty is a different story... and your PMs certainly throw suspicion onto him.

I do think we need more evidence or for him to show up personally and defend himself, before I decide to lynch my protection partner off the bat.

Nvm.

[TinCow]

Given the lack of any kill that is identifiable as mafia (even the solos could have been vigilantes), participation in any group last night is proof of absolutely nothing. Since they weren't killing, some of the mafioso could easily have been legitimately joining in groups.

However, I am not overly concerned about the vig kill on LG. LG was a likely candidate for the lynch today, so his loss is acceptable under the circumstances. In addition, vigilante kills don't change a townie into a scumbag like they do in Capo, so simply participating in a vig kill isn't something worth lynching someone over IMO.

To be fair, my result PM doesn't mention anything about the members of the protection group, only that CB survived and I got 100 gold.

Vote: Chaotix

How did you get 100 gold, when a successful protection only awards a total of 30, which is then divided up amongst all the protectors?

30: Amount awarded for successfully protecting an individual, divided up evenly among protectors (if treasure is left over, the remainder goes to those who sent in orders earlier)

[Sasaki Kojiro]

A successful protection in a group nets you 15 gold. Chaotix is lying. Vote: Chaotix

No, it gets 30 divided among the participants. I take chaotix's post to be a typo (should be 10). If you got 15 then someone skipped out of your group?

And how did those who be in ye group contact ye? Did they come forward after ye asked for men to help ye kill LG? Or did ye go to them?

Both. Also, I was going to be part a group started by someone else attacking a protected target, but we went for LG instead.

[Tratorix]

No, it gets 30 divided among the participants. I take chaotix's post to be a typo (should be 10). If you got 15 then someone skipped out of your group?

Or he could have just read how much gold he had. Oops.