Pirate Ship Mafia [Concluded]

[White_eyes:D]

Yeah well....I knew abandoning ship was a bad idea for because the lynch write-ups seemed to imply this...."no Islands around.." Now we are near an Island......If anyone wants to jump ship....now would be the best time...

And a serial killer is around right, when I decide to leave the group....just lovely..

[Sasaki Kojiro]

I don't see why it would be suspicious for someone to abandon a protection group that's privy to information that needs to be edited out. Mafia would generally stick with that group...

[DisgruntledGoat]

You think we should go along with a double lynch??

No I'm not too sure what to do with this situation at this point. I'm just trying to figure things out. To me it looks like two townies that are suspicious of each other. I wanted to know who ATPG would suggest for his co-lynchee.

[Askthepizzaguy]

To be honest I have no real leads. I was trying to get White Eyes to explain his behavior by abandoning a pt group for no reason whatsoever. Didn't know he was going to do what he did.

You guys choose. I don't want to be responsible for another townie death besides my own.

[DisgruntledGoat]

o_O that last statement seems awfully atypical for ATPG.

[Askthepizzaguy]

o_O that last statement seems awfully atypical for ATPG.

Then I must be scum. Lynch me.

[Andres]

How about Sasaki?

Ah, mister Pizza, but lynching Sasaki would not be a good idea:

1) He always gets investigated at the beginning of the game, if he were guilty, we would have seen evidence already, certainly after 3 nights;
2) The mafia will not recruit Sasaki, because:
a) Sasaki is opposed to winning the game by organising (or should I say "locking") everybody in groups, so no useful intel;
b) nobody trusts Sasaki and he probably ends up lynched sooner or later.

However, those in the middle of the town organisation, are more likely to be recruited (if you aren't scum already): CR, Louis and ATPG.

That's why we simply must have a mutiny at a certain point in the game. And no better candidate to take the position of captain than Sasaki (and myself as his highest ranking officer, of course).

[Sasaki Kojiro]

Unvote:pevergreen, Vote:DisgruntledGoat

Seems to be thinking of how he can benefit from the pizza-white eyes quarrel.

[Yaropolk]

vote Andres. I think he's innocent

Brilliant reasoning for your vote.

Really, this belongs in the category of "most funny mafia quotes"

You can quote it if you want then! The reasoning is purely preventive - if we kill all attempted deserters, the other rats will think twice about leaving the ship!

[Askthepizzaguy]

However, those in the middle of the town organisation, are more likely to be recruited (if you aren't scum already): CR, Louis and ATPG.

Good point. better lynch me to make sure.

[White_eyes:D]

I don't see why it would be suspicious for someone to abandon a protection group that's privy to information that needs to be edited out. Mafia would generally stick with that group...

Your right....If I was Mafia, I would have stayed with the group and not been ing myself over wither ATPG is mafia or not..If I was SK, I also would have to avoid suspicion....and I also wouldn't have cared...I just would have kill him...

Why didn't you PM me first ATPG?? You could have made a case depending on my response rather then trying to force me to come out with sensitive information(Or rather private stuff if you will but the only way to prove I am innocent) like that

[Askthepizzaguy]

Your right....If I was Mafia, I would have stayed with the group and not been ing myself over wither ATPG is mafia or not..If I was SK, I also would have to avoid suspicion....and I also wouldn't have cared...I just would have kill him...

Why didn't you PM me first ATPG?? You could have made a case depending on my response rather then trying to force me to come out with sensitive information(Or rather private stuff if you will but the only way to prove I am innocent) like that

Yes, yes, revealing who we were protecting and that I knew very sensitive information was necessary to defend yourself, and all my fault.

[White_eyes:D]

No I'm not too sure what to do with this situation at this point. I'm just trying to figure things out. To me it looks like two townies that are suspicious of each other. I wanted to know who ATPG would suggest for his co-lynchee.

are you acting scummy for talking like that....If you think they are two townies.....why lynch any of them? Unvote:CDF Vote:DisgruntledGoat

[Andres]

Good point. better lynch me to make sure.

Too early.

I think Joooray and Pevergreen are better candidates.

And we need to hear more from Tratorix who accused CDF.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Perhaps I am not making myself clear.

I'll reveal two watchstanders, a roleblocker, and a doctor if you don't lynch me this round. Also who has been organizing and who they've been protecting. You want to risk me being recruited tonight, be my guest.

[pevergreen]

I will seriously leave this game if the Pevergreen thing keeps going.


Yes, if you must know, it really does me off a lot. No, I don't know why.

TinCow, sending a PM to GH to ask why, CC'ing you.

[TinCow]

I'll reveal two watchstanders, a roleblocker, and a doctor if you don't lynch me this round. Also who has been organizing and who they've been protecting. You want to risk me being recruited tonight, be my guest.

Who gave you this information, and why? It seems odd to me that you always end up at the center of every town group.

[DisgruntledGoat]

are you acting scummy for talking like that....If you think they are two townies.....why lynch any of them? Unvote:CDF Vote:DisgruntledGoat

You are twisting my words. ATPG has suggested HIMSELF to be lynched. I said I want to know who he wants to go with him. I.E. to see if there were any motives that might surface, not that ATPG would do anything that silly and reveal himself through that but I thought it worth the try. Obviously he was smart enough to suggest Sasaki for his co-lynchee and basically revealed nothing. No where did I say I would go along with the double lynch, in fact in that post you quoted I clearly show my opposition for a double lynch and in fact lynching ATPG at all. This sort of thing doesn't seem above board at all. ATPG schemes, it's what he does best and I'm trying to understand this scheme he's got going now.

[Yaropolk]

Ok this is not normal. Either ATPG is bluffing and is mafia, in which case we should lynch him, or he is truly a conerned townie, and I will trust his instinct (and we should lynch him).

unvote: Andres vote: ATPG

I would suggest the doubly lynch to be put on CDF to pressure him into revealing why Tratorix is accusing him. Tratorix is dead so I doubt he can tell us much.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

Who gave you this information, and why? It seems odd to me that you always end up at the center of every town group.

I don't see why multiple power roles would be revealed to someone recruitable...especially an obvious recruiting target.

[pevergreen]

I buggered up.

My apologies TinCow.

I retract my earlier notice.

edit: above post (sasaki)

People automatically trust ATPG. A lot of the newer players.

[White_eyes:D]

Ok...but I am keeping my eye on you

But everyone knows Pizzaguy is at the center of every townie group....why he thinks this time would be any different is beyond me...(It might have something to do with that PM I posted earlier..)

But why didn't you send me a PM of your suspicions ATPG? you knew I knew ALOT about you....(Or at least some statements...) instead you just went off and accused me in-thread without even hearing me out....and now everyone knows, whatever it is that's bothering you

I don't know if we well be hearing from Tratviox, on why CDF is scummy....It was a protect group, right? where is the third guy?

[TinCow]

I don't see why multiple power roles would be revealed to someone recruitable...especially an obvious recruiting target.

The only way this could be known is if ATPG has been investigated. Since he's already putting himself out in the limelight, I think these results should be posted or conveyed to us in some manner. ATPG's statements are pretty blatantly asking for recruitment. Since he's not in a position that prevents him from being recruited, this is of concern to me. If he's been investigated and found to be non-scum and non-recruitable, great... but we need to know that.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Who gave you this information, and why? It seems odd to me that you always end up at the center of every town group.

two blabbed to me immediately. One did last night. The other was spread by the person's own protection group to me. I must have a really trustworthy face.

That's a really, really bad move if you didn't make me an officer. Just plain not thinking ahead. It's not secure in the slightest. I noted my concerns about this to the Captain, who if anyone was going to blindly trust, should have been that guy. Or deeply investigate one of the officers and trust that person. Don't blab to Askthepizzaguy. I can't just forget that information if I get recruited.

You know I just wanted to roleplay this time too.

[Askthepizzaguy]

The only way this could be known is if ATPG has been investigated. Since he's already putting himself out in the limelight, I think these results should be posted or conveyed to us in some manner. ATPG's statements are pretty blatantly asking for recruitment. Since he's not in a position that prevents him from being recruited, this is of concern to me. If he's been investigated and found to be non-scum and non-recruitable, great... but we need to know that.

I have been already fully investigated as recruitable and non-scum.

Predictable.

[TinCow]

I have been already fully investigated as recruitable and non-scum.

Predictable.

You do realize you're making a very strong argument for your own lynching. Why are you doing this?

[White_eyes:D]

Isn't there an obvious write-up when someone gets recruited??

[Askthepizzaguy]

You do realize you're making a very strong argument for your own lynching. Why are you doing this?

So the town doesn't LOSE!

look, I want to win the game, right? I'm a townie. I win if the town wins. I want the town to win.

White Eyes blabs that I know sensitive information, enough such that I'm thinking of abandoning ship so you don't have to waste a lynch on me, since I can't become an officer (all slots are filled)

Now, I have to die. Or else the mafia recruits me. And then what?

I want to win the game, right? I blab all my info and pray they can win. You have to kill me.

[Andres]

You do realize you're making a very strong argument for your own lynching. Why are you doing this?

How about who ever pulls the strings behind the scenes stops sending information on recruitable townies? And those with pro-town roles, please do not reveal yourselves to recruitable townies!

I understand that ATPG is recruitable and knows the names of people with a pro-town role.

Not much of a choice left


Unvote ; Vote : ATPG

Unvote : Mutiny

[Askthepizzaguy]

At least don't waste the round though. Double lynch me with another suspect.

I'll put the finishing vote on myself to make sure it's a double.