Pirate Ship Mafia [Concluded]

[Sasaki Kojiro]

CDF has more posts than a lot of people. CDF, why do you think they think you led to their deaths?

[Cultured Drizzt fan]

Its only natural. We have been working together all game and they both end up killed in 2 night phases, in a row.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

Its only natural. We have been working together all game and they both end up killed in 2 night phases, in a row.

Don't give in so easy, remember org mini mafia

If you were just three townies working together, then there is no case against you. Atheotes was killed by two men, and tratorix was killed by a solo killer. In addition, there is no real motivation for a mafioso to murder their group.

Maybe tratorix's case is more than that, but without knowing what it is I'm not inclined to trust it.

[Askthepizzaguy]

I'd prefer simply blocking CDF and moving on to other suspects. There wasn't a whole heck of a lot of pressure on him and he seems to be ready to die. Let's get some people talking with pressure votes or something.

[Yaropolk]

Fine unvote: CDF vote: Scottishranger. I'm adding ATPG's vote to put pressure on the guy. Please make sure CDF is blocked as right now he is still my #1 suspicion. Those who have voted for ATPG and not unvoted yet, please do so.

[Beskar]

Oh, I fully support ATPG being a Quartermaster, as he has decided to go with a lot of record keeping, and people seem to just throwing him random information, and in hands of the mafia, he would be very vunerable, thus, I suggest him being QM which makes him immune, incase he is suspectible in some way.

Edit: How many pages is this beast? I just returned, I can't even find out if Reenk Roink responded to me yet, what is all this ATPG drama.

[Tratorix]

Its only natural. We have been working together all game and they both end up killed in 2 night phases, in a row.

Then perhaps you could offer up a theory as to who is responsible? I really don't believe this was just a coincidence.

[Beskar]

Why do you keep getting the name wrong?

Personal defect with myself, I am really really bad with names and it just one of those names.. Marvin, Marques, Maran, I think I called it everything.


Edit: Identity of an Investigator

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Louis VI the Fat

[Cultured Drizzt fan]

If you want I could post everyone who knew the protection group was you me and atheotes.

but that might not be the best Idea. Suffice to say I doubt any of them are guilty.



Sometimes when bad luck rains it pours. Like I said if lynching me will prove my innocence then go ahead, I am fine with it.

[TinCow]

Then perhaps you could offer up a theory as to who is responsible? I really don't believe this was just a coincidence.

Is your only reason for suspecting CDF because of these two consecutive deaths from your group?

[Louis VI the Fat]

My frustration was that I feared this game would turn into a "follow orders without asking questions" game; as in town organising itself, putting data in an excel sheet and lynching the factors that seem off.

Excel? What on earth are you on about? Don't be silly. We be pirates. We get drunk and then shout names in this thread.

Also, being a piraty pirate does not mean running your own ship into the ground. It means sailing your loot home, that you may get to enjoy some booty on a rum and wench infested tropical paradise.

You don't need to act erratic as a pirate. Eccentricity is for limeys. We 'honest' pirate crew know just how to have ourselves a jolly good time. Here you go:



Iskander is the latest victim of a private buccaneering group. This group is on a killing spree, possibly because they are in it for booty and some pirating fun.

So here's my offer:

I promise ten gold for every name of this group. That's a whopping thirty for all three of your partners's names. Plus I promise full secrecy and immunity to the person who PM's me with these names. (Yes, pirate's code of honour, to which I am bound)
Of the three names, I shall randomly kill one. The other two walk, so neither they nor anybody else will ever know who took up the offer to help himself to a little extra booty on the side.

Odds are, that you killed for the loot, for the pirating fun of it, and for personal enrichment. Well thirty gold is but one PM away...

It is just business. You know it is the pirating thing to do to help yourself to all of this:

[Louis VI the Fat]

GH confirmed there was a single killer. It wasn't me.

A serial killer then? Hmm...



I need to vote, but I am still going through some PM's and stuff.

I will vote: Jolt

He's a pirate with a four letter name, yet it isn't an obscenity. Very unpiraty. What pirate knows four letter words that don't make all the priests from here to Recife fall on their knees and pray God for forgiveness for mankind's many sins?

[GeneralHankerchief]

Ten gold max for a single transaction, Louis.

[White_eyes:D]

I just figured I would point out that Travoix was sleeping in the write-up....which contradicts what CDF said earlier...

"Psst... wake up." Tratorix didn't move.

"Wake up," the voice said a bit louder, jostling Tratorix a bit harder.

"Mmm... mmph!" he muttered as the voice's owner jostled him harder still. "Okay, okay, I'm awake! What is it?"

Can you explain why? I am kind of pressed for time right now soooo.......

What I want to know is how I am scum when we have both been in the same protection group the entire game. Especially considering we got the protection money for last night, so it was successful.


edit: OhhHHH Tratorix is dead?

ugghhhh. not a good day.

He is scum people....Lynch away

[Cultured Drizzt fan]

Let me just respond with my common sentiment, I get to say I told you so.

[White_eyes:D]

Let me just respond with my common sentiment, I get to say I told you so.

So you LIED to town??

Or is my interpretation of GH's write-up off....

[Tratorix]

I just figured I would point out that Travoix was sleeping in the write-up....which contradicts what CDF said earlier...

1. You misspelled my name.
2. While I like the attempt to get CDF lynched, you're wrong.

[White_eyes:D]

Well that sucks....thought the write-ups would indict actions that they were doing....(should not have said anything if you wanted him lynched...) Unvote:CDF Vote:abstain till I cleanse my shame

[GeneralHankerchief]

The writeups can and should be scrutinized for clairty, but don't take too much out of what a person was doing at the start of their "scene" at night. Otherwise it severely limits the possibilities of what I as a writer can do, and seeing as how there are going to be several dozen "scenes" over the course of the game... I need all the possibilities I can get.

[Jolt]

GH confirmed there was a single killer. It wasn't me.

A serial killer then? Hmm...



I need to vote, but I am still going through some PM's and stuff.

I will vote: Jolt

He's a pirate with a four letter name, yet it isn't an obscenity. Very unpiraty. What pirate knows four letter words that don't make all the priests from here to Recife fall on their knees and pray God for forgiveness for mankind's many sins?

I dislike pirates from Tortuga.

Unvote, Vote: Louis IV

[Askthepizzaguy]

unvote, vote: Jolt


Yarrrr.... I have Jolt telling me privately that he wishes to become a british or a Maven, that he refuses to do protection groups, and that he would rather kill anyone I point my finger at. This smells of a traitorous townie, serial killer, or mafia, to me. I request that we make him walk the plank.

[Tratorix]

unvote, vote: Jolt


Yarrrr.... I have Jolt telling me privately that he wishes to become a british or a Maven, that he refuses to do protection groups, and that he would rather kill anyone I point my finger at. This smells of a traitorous townie, serial killer, or mafia, to me. I request that we make him walk the plank.

Why in the heck would Jolt tell you this? I've never understood why everyone thinks revealing things to you is a good idea.

[shlin28]

unvote, vote: Jolt


Yarrrr.... I have Jolt telling me privately that he wishes to become a british or a Maven, that he refuses to do protection groups, and that he would rather kill anyone I point my finger at. This smells of a traitorous townie, serial killer, or mafia, to me. I request that we make him walk the plank.

What? When did this occur? Why would he tell you this when you stated in the threat that you are town would rather die than turn scum...?

[DisgruntledGoat]

Why in the heck would Jolt tell you this? I've never understood why everyone thinks revealing things to you is a good idea.

Neither do I it was mind blowing to learn that people revealed whole families to others in Capo right off the bat.

I trust ATPG's motivations so Vote: Jolt

[Askthepizzaguy]

I haven't the foggiest idea what Jolt is up to. Admitting you'd rather become maven or British to the investigated about-to-be quartermaster is the same as requesting to be lynched. In the absence of better suspects, we might as well get rid of an uncooperative and admittedly traitorous player.

I'm working through my mind what Jolt could be. It's possible he's a joker/bomb role but I believe we've all agreed on how lame those roles are, and I think GeneralHankerchief spent a lot of time on this game, too much to risk everyone dying within a round or two. And if he's not a suicide role, then he's either disinterested in the game or he has a death wish.

Granted.

[Subotan]

Unvote, Abstain;Vote:Jolt

If we're going to bandwagon on someone, it may as well be on someone who at least smells guilty.

[Joooray]

Sorry guys, I don't have any time to read the thread, from what I could see, there has been long back and forth and I don't just want to abstain, so I will join the last few votes and Vote: Jolt.

[Centurion1]

Sasaki, I hope you admit you were wrong about little grizzly. Dead wrong, but my gut says your innocent, so i trust you.

ATPG is now a guaranteed safety spot, which i apologize in advance makes you an excellent conduit for organization. Louis is also clear so he is good for organization. I request that all organization goes through our officers as their are confirmed incorruptible townies now that they are officers.

CDF is denfinetly innocent, while i understand tratorixs anger, it is misplaced. ATPG how about you ask these two watchstanders you know to investigate cdf and then we will know about him for sure.

Andres, i didn't think that normal townies can jump ship, thought it was only maven.............. and why leave so early if maven, your cap'n would be angry....

for now Vote: Abstain

Can i see a tally?

[Tratorix]

CDF is denfinetly innocent, while i understand tratorixs anger, it is misplaced. ATPG how about you ask these two watchstanders you know to investigate cdf and then we will know about him for sure.

I'm not angry. I'm cool.

So, CDF is definitely innocent, but should be investigated? Not sure I follow that.

[Centurion1]

Tratorix i mean i suspect innocence but a formal result would be ice. no offense i think your reasoning is weak. How is the fact he plans your protections dirty, even if you die it is not likely he has anything to do with it